JESUS CHRIST IS A MEDIATOR BETWEEN US AND GOD THE FATHER AND ST MARY IS MEDIATOR BETWEEN US AND HER SON-CHRIST CONFIRMED BY VISIONARIES FOR 2000 YEARS.
GOD WANTS FAMILY NOT ROBOTS AND ALLOWS ST MARY AND ALL SAINTS AND ANGELS to HELP US!
SHE IS OUR MOTHER IN CHRIST AND BLESSED BY ALL GENERATIONS
"And the dragon was wroth with the woman, and went to make war with the remnant of her seed, which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ." Rev. 12:1-17
BELÍSSIMA E EMOCIONANTE MÚSICA SACRA, A QUAL TIVE A FELICIDADE E O PRIVILÉGIO DE CANTAR, QUANDO ERA ADOLESCENTE E MEMBRO DO CORAL DO COLÉGIO ESTADUAL AUGUSTO MEIRA (CEAM), JUNTAMENTE COM O CORAL DO COLÉGIO GENTIL BITTENCOURT, NA BASÍLICA DE NAZARETH (AO MAGNÍFICO SOM DAQUELE ÓRGÃO) E NA CAPELA DO COLÉGIO GENTIL BITTENCOURT (NUM DIA DO CÍRIO E DA TRANSLADAÇÃO DE NOSSA SENHORA DE NAZARETH). INESQUECÍVEL!!!!!!
I feel sorry for the 11 dislikes. One person hates the video and someone mentioned the word screaming. Jose Carreras speaks and sings in many languages so I doubt that he is singing anything here so incorrectly that it takes anything away from his singing. I am not a Roman Catholic and I am not interested in the Latin or what it means. I just know that this is beautiful music and beautifuly sung as some would say - by the greatest tenor of the 20th and 21st century. I certainly would not argue.
Fascinating to hear and see the change in technique between this video done pre Carreras's illness and how he sang afterwards. His voice is more effortlessly pure here and has a stronger baritone ring. From the late 1980's he dropped his lower jaw in an exaggerted manner with singing A-flat and above. His later tone was far more mask and resonant.
I like his later voice a bit more because it has more drama but he is always a great tenor.
There is no music more beautiful than classical. It is the true essence of music. Although I'm a gospel-rnb singer, I bow to professionally trained opera singers, because they're just in a league of they're own. This song was stunningly done. Moving, powerful, soft and heartfelt.
Zionism is born in Babylon, the Talmud is the destruction of Judaism of Moses, is the betrayal of the Torah; is the greatest crime in history of mankind, is the bank seigniorage: IMF, that created all occult power: satanism freemasonry, etc; is legal and institutional framework of the triumph of Satan on earth; is the real reason for the Shoah, is an advantage of only 300 families criminals NWO
@fritz5109 Jose Carreras pronounces exactly as you corrected…. Perfect Latin for him who studied it in rome and Milan as he did napolitan in Naples… He is by far the best intellectually prepared tenor of the last fifty years…Pavarotti is a brick compared to this man…intellectually I mean….
I never said he doesn't pronounce everything perfectly. However, I would say that's a thin "s" at approx 1:12. My Latin classes were a long time ago and I guess all those booklets that go with cd's have made me even more confused. I have one here in my hand and it reads: "ventris tuis Jesus". I'm glad you learned me the correct spelling again.
I never said he doesn't pronounce everything perfectly. However, I would say that's a thin "s" at approx 1:12. My Latin classes were a long time ago and I guess all those booklets that go with cd's have made me even more confused. I have one here in my hand and it reads: "ventris tuis Jesus". I'm glad you learned me the correct spelling again.
Jose can be proud of his career. Past his prime now, he was a beautiful tenor for a long time. Survived cancer and came back singing nicely. Maybe not in the very top ranks but a beautiful voice. I loved his
rendition of "Chenier" I would have loved a career like his. So BRAVO Mr. Carrreras
If you like JOSÉ CARRERAS check THE 30 TENORS in my playlist SUPER TENOR ARIAS ( including CLAUDIO SOTELO performing ARIA DEL CIRUJANO as a world première ) and tell me which one you prefer !
But, please, dont forget, if you can, to help the JOSÉ CARRERAS LAUKAEMIA FOUNDATION ( Fundación Josep Carreras contra la leucemia ) !
at la scala covent garden the met and hamburg the would dissagree with you but....we all know you know better hahahha...the world was in fact wrong and you are so right.....right???
Both the set and the fact that they made him dubb himself, is in the best European tradition of H O R R I B L E television making. If I were Carreras then, I would have jumped the contract, faked fainting, put on a " I'm not performing in this set, and much less dubbing" routine.
And if i was in bad voice, hey " Check out my singing nephew" line to get out of the situation.
Whatever it was, it's just another one of European television's career destroying, embarrassing moments.
Look Mr. CrapTV Defensor, maybe it's too cold up there in Swede, and your brain is half frozen, but doubt you have any sense of television making, when all you upload is yourself playing with your head cut.
"Jack shit", is your playing.
"Back to school", is that were you learned to "dude" people around, retard?
Plus, who cares about the rest of TV in Europe?
In fact when do people ever mention Sweden?, of course with "creative" people like you...it tells.
So a country up near the Artic, with less than 10 millions people can tell the U.S. how to deal with their own peculiar and complex issues / necessities.
yo soy prufundo admirador de Juan Diego Florez y Pavarotti, pero tengo que aceptar que esta interpretación es impresionantemente bella, que más puedo decir....... sin palabras, felicitaciones maestro Carreras.
En esta epoca su voz era la mas bella del mundo, lo siento Luciano tus medios no eran tan bellos como los de Jose, lamentablemente la voz de Jose no durò tanto.
except...if you look at Carreras' hairline...it looks as if it had already receeded from the chemo therapy treatments he had received when he had cancer. Perhaps, this was an earlier voval recording set to a more recent (1990) video of him. Just food for thought.
Everyone who listens to Carreras and knows his vocal abilities also knows that this aria couldn't have been recorded in 1985. Even four-five years earlier his voice was not clear on high notes, and that was very obvious in 1982/83. So this aria must have been recorded either in 1980. or even a year earlier.
I've loved Carreras since I learned about him in the mid 80's. Ofcourse his recordings back in the 70's he sounds like a God, but yet here I can still hear the beautiful voice that only he has.
Time passes and leaves scars in all human beings. Those looking for perfection in tenors should understand that Gigli in 1925 was not Gigli 1950. Same happened to Pava (Check Pava in his last few years). Same happens to Domingo. And to EVERYBODY. This interpretation is GOOD. Very tender. Very colorful. Very touching. Carreras in his maturity/decline. But CARRERAS. Grande Maestro.
i heard him in 1996 and his voice was really bad on the top notes yet.also on G and A.i'm really surprised to hear him now..in this video his voice is not so bad.
yes i pretty sure this is 95 carreras...he really is still a good tenor, it wasnt until about 2003 that his voice became much weaker in the high notes, and is quite wobbaly now
I fancy myself a good tenor. I'm not sure if I should find this video inspiring or depressing.
I actually am pretty good, but I'm just a big fish in a small pond.
TheAdmiralPancake 2 days ago
what a powerfulllllll voice !!!
ka2shi7 2 weeks ago
AVE MARIA
BEPOLITEFORLIVING 2 weeks ago
Damn. I just can't hit that high note on "hora".
Bitemis 1 month ago
ta muito bom.... adorei
duke1091 2 months ago
just been lisstening to jose carreras singing ave maria.magnificent
ednajoyful 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
JESUS CHRIST IS A MEDIATOR BETWEEN US AND GOD THE FATHER AND ST MARY IS MEDIATOR BETWEEN US AND HER SON-CHRIST CONFIRMED BY VISIONARIES FOR 2000 YEARS.
GOD WANTS FAMILY NOT ROBOTS AND ALLOWS ST MARY AND ALL SAINTS AND ANGELS to HELP US!
SHE IS OUR MOTHER IN CHRIST AND BLESSED BY ALL GENERATIONS
"And the dragon was wroth with the woman, and went to make war with the remnant of her seed, which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ." Rev. 12:1-17
JezusSlave 2 months ago
BELÍSSIMA E EMOCIONANTE MÚSICA SACRA, A QUAL TIVE A FELICIDADE E O PRIVILÉGIO DE CANTAR, QUANDO ERA ADOLESCENTE E MEMBRO DO CORAL DO COLÉGIO ESTADUAL AUGUSTO MEIRA (CEAM), JUNTAMENTE COM O CORAL DO COLÉGIO GENTIL BITTENCOURT, NA BASÍLICA DE NAZARETH (AO MAGNÍFICO SOM DAQUELE ÓRGÃO) E NA CAPELA DO COLÉGIO GENTIL BITTENCOURT (NUM DIA DO CÍRIO E DA TRANSLADAÇÃO DE NOSSA SENHORA DE NAZARETH). INESQUECÍVEL!!!!!!
PAULO BORDALO
JORNALISTA, FOTÓGRAFO E CINEGRAFISTA PROFISSIONAL
(BELÉM DO PARÁ).
paulobord 3 months ago
Better than the version of Pavarotti.
johnchannetshow 3 months ago
the best version yet, he sings the entire ave maria
gangstanikes 3 months ago
Another wonderful rendition of Ave maria - VITAS, the best voice ever
aalexmary 6 months ago
My fav tenor! Lorg live Mr. Carreras
aalexmary 6 months ago
what a beautiful rendition of the Ave Maria this guy truly deserved to be among the first and real three tenors what a great powerful voice.
TheEdmag 6 months ago
I feel sorry for the 11 dislikes. One person hates the video and someone mentioned the word screaming. Jose Carreras speaks and sings in many languages so I doubt that he is singing anything here so incorrectly that it takes anything away from his singing. I am not a Roman Catholic and I am not interested in the Latin or what it means. I just know that this is beautiful music and beautifuly sung as some would say - by the greatest tenor of the 20th and 21st century. I certainly would not argue.
bravocarreras 8 months ago
Fascinating to hear and see the change in technique between this video done pre Carreras's illness and how he sang afterwards. His voice is more effortlessly pure here and has a stronger baritone ring. From the late 1980's he dropped his lower jaw in an exaggerted manner with singing A-flat and above. His later tone was far more mask and resonant.
I like his later voice a bit more because it has more drama but he is always a great tenor.
donaldrose 9 months ago
Maestrazazazo!!!!!
al10506025 9 months ago
IF YOU WANT TO SEE A YOUNG SOPRANO AND STAR OF THE FUTURE PERFORM THIS SONG SEARCH "OKSANA LEPSKA" ON YOUTUBE :)))))
simonbassline 9 months ago
AVE MARIA!!! I repeat the great architect of universe, lucifer is dead!
Krystian Konrad Moreński
kknyz 11 months ago
wish i could sing the song like this @-)
enzoferrarimendoza 1 year ago
Outstanding¡
TheDciTOM 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
* * * VERY NICE !!!! * * *
Bidyyy 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
☆.¸.☆´
¸.☆´¸.☆´¨) ¸.☆*¨)
(¸.☆´ (¸.☆´ (¸.☆´¯`☆...☆-
Lareyl 1 year ago
Fantastic!!!!
SOLE
solounamujer48 1 year ago
Una excelente voz de nuestro tenor,, fantastica interpretacion.
Anna
taracea2010 1 year ago
Perfekt!!!
kkr1030d 1 year ago
Bella musica
DATAMES 1 year ago
heel mooi bedankt ,johanna
johanna794 1 year ago
@johanna794 wow pure beauty!!
cogermax91 1 year ago
Bravissimo Carreras!
zdevol7 1 year ago
JOSE CARRERAS EL GRANDE.
vvvvvv1231 1 year ago
multumesc
lucica687 1 year ago
Boldog Karácsonyt!
1lacci 1 year ago
JOSÉ: YOU ARE THE GREATEST TENOR EVER!!!!!!
fedurosan 1 year ago
There is no music more beautiful than classical. It is the true essence of music. Although I'm a gospel-rnb singer, I bow to professionally trained opera singers, because they're just in a league of they're own. This song was stunningly done. Moving, powerful, soft and heartfelt.
jnsash003 1 year ago
i hate it
relisham 1 year ago
Wonderful!!!
Sissiaraujo 1 year ago
Preciosa canción con la voz de este gran Tenor
macascabel 1 year ago
THIS ONE MAKES ME CRYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
soulfoodmarketing 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out my new symphony on my channel.
LuisCangueiroMusic 1 year ago
1990 more like
CockpumpVideo 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Zionism is born in Babylon, the Talmud is the destruction of Judaism of Moses, is the betrayal of the Torah; is the greatest crime in history of mankind, is the bank seigniorage: IMF, that created all occult power: satanism freemasonry, etc; is legal and institutional framework of the triumph of Satan on earth; is the real reason for the Shoah, is an advantage of only 300 families criminals NWO
ShalomGerusalemme 1 year ago
i too am not sure Josep looked like this in 1980. can´t it be mistake ?
eurydike 1 year ago
Great Jose',I played with him for the Italian television:amazing voice!
synballein70 2 years ago 2
se llama josep no jose
jodercreateyacuenta 2 years ago
Lip sync?
aguacun 2 years ago
@aguacun Yes, this is the same recording from the album. Pity - it would have been nice to see him sing it.
Englishtenor2 2 years ago
thank you!
aguacun 2 years ago
fuckin nygga ! don't speak polsih krystyna .ave maria and shit ass!
djKoDeK1 2 years ago
Some little notes on the text given by this clip.
1. It's not "ventris Cuie tu" it's "ventris tuis Jesus". Although it seems José sings "Jesu".
2. "Santa Maria" should be "Sancta Maria". For this is Latin and Santa is Italian.
3. "Nor et in hora" is "Nunc et in hora".
The last sentence in English would be "Now and in the hour of death."
Merry Christmas! :-)
NLfilmfan 2 years ago
Thank you for your comment an Merry Christmas to you too
fritz5109 2 years ago
You're welcome, Fritz. And thanks for putting this nice clip on YouTube!
NLfilmfan 2 years ago
hi i'm italian and i wanna ask if i must pronounce the in T in sancta
thx
amdnovello 2 years ago
Yes, you should pronounce the T in sancta.
NLfilmfan 2 years ago
@fritz5109 Jose Carreras pronounces exactly as you corrected…. Perfect Latin for him who studied it in rome and Milan as he did napolitan in Naples… He is by far the best intellectually prepared tenor of the last fifty years…Pavarotti is a brick compared to this man…intellectually I mean….
luisjochoa 1 year ago
@NLfilmfan Firstly Carreras pronounces everything perfectly, listen more carefully. Secondly it is "ventris tui Iesus" not "tuis".
croc17 1 year ago
@croc17
I never said he doesn't pronounce everything perfectly. However, I would say that's a thin "s" at approx 1:12. My Latin classes were a long time ago and I guess all those booklets that go with cd's have made me even more confused. I have one here in my hand and it reads: "ventris tuis Jesus". I'm glad you learned me the correct spelling again.
NLfilmfan 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@croc17
I never said he doesn't pronounce everything perfectly. However, I would say that's a thin "s" at approx 1:12. My Latin classes were a long time ago and I guess all those booklets that go with cd's have made me even more confused. I have one here in my hand and it reads: "ventris tuis Jesus". I'm glad you learned me the correct spelling again.
NLfilmfan 1 year ago
@NLfilmfan But Carreras is famous for this.... changing everything cause he just forgot lol
Dont hate him please...lol
RonaldBarone 1 year ago
@NLfilmfan Well, looks like he's too awesome to care about it. The song should care about to suit Carreras :)
paazoe 1 year ago
@NLfilmfan It is "ventris tui", genitive singular masculine, "of your womb". Brush up your latin!
Josep Carreras's performance is impeccable.
Fergananym 9 months ago
nice,bravooo
gvdfans 2 years ago
Bardzo ladne.
krystyna4501 2 years ago
Jose can be proud of his career. Past his prime now, he was a beautiful tenor for a long time. Survived cancer and came back singing nicely. Maybe not in the very top ranks but a beautiful voice. I loved his
rendition of "Chenier" I would have loved a career like his. So BRAVO Mr. Carrreras
joelweisberg 2 years ago 4
great! even though I prefer Domingo...he's just more emotional, but carreras voice is the greatest!
onepiecebestanime 2 years ago
Éste es el Ave María que más me gusta (el de Gounod), y la versión de Carreras es espléndida.
olafdavila 2 years ago 2
Increible !!!! Maravilloso Carreras !!!
tukilala 2 years ago
OMG.... Absolutely breathtaking!!!!
markmichaelwong 2 years ago 3
Vraiment une voix magnifique!
erglesnarf 2 years ago 3
Que voz tan consistente y afinada...grande maestro carreras!!!
tachiniger 2 years ago 3
here he seems to sing like Mario Lanza
TenorBarbilian 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
en mi opinión, la mejor versión y mejor voz, es la de Juan Diego Florez, quien me dejo impresionado con su talento.
jjor2000 2 years ago
..........
pandano42 2 years ago
El hombre mas bello del mundo !!!!!!!
tukilala 2 years ago 12
@tukilala es solo por que no haz visto ni sentido Juan Diego flores.Disculpa.saludos.
luisenriquearagonez 1 year ago
bella voce, ma mai sostenuta da una tecnica adeguata.. poi la fine la sappiamo
Turee85 2 years ago
bravo, fantastico, una voce magnifica !!!!!
temple1201 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
*** VERY NICE ***
mihura666 2 years ago
*** VERY NICE ***
mihura666 2 years ago 3
GOOD
johnchannetshow 2 years ago 3
No está mal, desde luego. Pero podría hacerlo mejor en el registro medio.
stratosferik 2 years ago
in my opinion, one of the best "J.S. Bach-Ave Maria" versions
fedeymini 2 years ago 3
*Beautiful*!!! Incridibile voice!!! Fenomenale!!!
Ivone da Luz.
mafgs 2 years ago 3
maybe no one know it but i've seen a video who showed carreras who sayd a sweargod during the registration of the song!AVE MARIA MA PORCO IDDIO!
vabosalam 2 years ago
ahahah vero l'ho visto anche io e non hanno neanche censurato lollll
il bllo è che lo dice con accento spagnolo e fa ridere!
amdnovello 2 years ago
cazzo dopo 4 mesi una risposta :)
vabosalam 2 years ago
eheh
pensa che l'ho visto su un vecchio laserdisc di un mio amico
amdnovello 2 years ago
If you like JOSÉ CARRERAS check THE 30 TENORS in my playlist SUPER TENOR ARIAS ( including CLAUDIO SOTELO performing ARIA DEL CIRUJANO as a world première ) and tell me which one you prefer !
But, please, dont forget, if you can, to help the JOSÉ CARRERAS LAUKAEMIA FOUNDATION ( Fundación Josep Carreras contra la leucemia ) !
Thank you
upatoia 2 years ago
good but maria callas is way better....
Unilka 2 years ago
He sounds okay! I like him.
smileygoblin 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Making millions of yelling.
This guy was never a singer. He was always, and will always be a yeller.
Also, his acting is about as bad and monotonous as Sarah Brightmans.
neosquid 2 years ago
at la scala covent garden the met and hamburg the would dissagree with you but....we all know you know better hahahha...the world was in fact wrong and you are so right.....right???
tauromaniac 2 years ago
you making zero of envying!!! hahahaa
tauromaniac 2 years ago
hmm ... perhaps a little harsh ... don't shoot me down
000nour000 2 years ago
Both the set and the fact that they made him dubb himself, is in the best European tradition of H O R R I B L E television making. If I were Carreras then, I would have jumped the contract, faked fainting, put on a " I'm not performing in this set, and much less dubbing" routine.
And if i was in bad voice, hey " Check out my singing nephew" line to get out of the situation.
Whatever it was, it's just another one of European television's career destroying, embarrassing moments.
fabrizzzio48 3 years ago
Dude, how do u know if this is dubbed or not? Maybe dubbed for better audio quality.
As for European television u dont seem to know jack-shit.
Italy, Spain, France & Germany only dubb foreign TV. These four contries is not Europe alone. Back to school?
Gerway 3 years ago
Look Mr. CrapTV Defensor, maybe it's too cold up there in Swede, and your brain is half frozen, but doubt you have any sense of television making, when all you upload is yourself playing with your head cut.
"Jack shit", is your playing.
"Back to school", is that were you learned to "dude" people around, retard?
Plus, who cares about the rest of TV in Europe?
In fact when do people ever mention Sweden?, of course with "creative" people like you...it tells.
fabrizzzio48 3 years ago
Haha. Did you get offended when I said you dont know about Eu TV? You need too relax and why this trashtalking of my homecountry?
One person who mention this country is your countrys biggest documentary maker. And he speaks of how good it is and how USA should take after Sweden.
Even if i dont like you, I still choose not to talk crap about USA in fact I love it.
Peace
Gerway 3 years ago
Ofended me? Nah. Not from you.
But your the one "jack-shitting" yourself around.
"biggest documentary maker"
You mean that he is fat and large?
So a country up near the Artic, with less than 10 millions people can tell the U.S. how to deal with their own peculiar and complex issues / necessities.
Go ahead, keep making "sense" ala Swede.
fabrizzzio48 3 years ago
yo soy prufundo admirador de Juan Diego Florez y Pavarotti, pero tengo que aceptar que esta interpretación es impresionantemente bella, que más puedo decir....... sin palabras, felicitaciones maestro Carreras.
jhonny87 3 years ago 4
Excelente!!!!
30martin082007 3 years ago 6
si!!
000nour000 2 years ago
MARAVILLOSO ESPETACULAR
yacoomar 3 years ago 3
lo maximo
chemmasogood 3 years ago
En esta epoca su voz era la mas bella del mundo, lo siento Luciano tus medios no eran tan bellos como los de Jose, lamentablemente la voz de Jose no durò tanto.
acitipo 3 years ago 3
Estrella fugaz... Pavarotti, muerto, aún brilla!
aguacun 3 years ago
QUE BELLISIMA VOZ
Tenochispano 3 years ago 13
Si,es excelente,muy bello
jakehoe 3 years ago 5
Certainly this video is after he got ill in 1987. His voice on this recording belongs to a playback from earlier years.
It is not correct to say this is from 1980...
ngurrytenore 3 years ago
except...if you look at Carreras' hairline...it looks as if it had already receeded from the chemo therapy treatments he had received when he had cancer. Perhaps, this was an earlier voval recording set to a more recent (1990) video of him. Just food for thought.
Tenor5274 3 years ago 4
Everyone who listens to Carreras and knows his vocal abilities also knows that this aria couldn't have been recorded in 1985. Even four-five years earlier his voice was not clear on high notes, and that was very obvious in 1982/83. So this aria must have been recorded either in 1980. or even a year earlier.
Most beautiful voice.
djura3 3 years ago
Wonderful performance...Jose the Best Forever!
alegossen78 3 years ago 7
me encantò como entonò el AVE MARIA.....que por cierto es una mùsica sòlo cantada por los grandes....y èl es uno de ellos.....
gabygoss85 4 years ago 3
I've loved Carreras since I learned about him in the mid 80's. Ofcourse his recordings back in the 70's he sounds like a God, but yet here I can still hear the beautiful voice that only he has.
BRAVO!
donatello1 4 years ago 8
yes this is playback and recording from cca. 1985.This CD with Vienna boyschoir
dudusik 4 years ago
Time passes and leaves scars in all human beings. Those looking for perfection in tenors should understand that Gigli in 1925 was not Gigli 1950. Same happened to Pava (Check Pava in his last few years). Same happens to Domingo. And to EVERYBODY. This interpretation is GOOD. Very tender. Very colorful. Very touching. Carreras in his maturity/decline. But CARRERAS. Grande Maestro.
emiliano52 4 years ago 4
i heard him in 1996 and his voice was really bad on the top notes yet.also on G and A.i'm really surprised to hear him now..in this video his voice is not so bad.
dongio76 4 years ago
No muy bien pero de todas maneras es un gran Maestro.
jamesdeperu 4 years ago
yes i pretty sure this is 95 carreras...he really is still a good tenor, it wasnt until about 2003 that his voice became much weaker in the high notes, and is quite wobbaly now
mcknighty11 4 years ago
pfff its NOT 95 its 85
tauromaniac 2 years ago 2
de verdad que eso lo canta en esa ocasion en el 95?
is this song really sang by carreras in 1995? are you sure? he sounds to good in 95 to be carreras.
tena2 4 years ago
this is the most beautiful music to hear, so peaceful and heavenly...
gheeah 4 years ago 5