ARE YOU GAY???

[Jackijd15]

Sha!

[TheScar2198]

No you said what the buck

[felixlee14]

Love your ending pitch!

[ACWWwhite1]

are you seriously gay?!!?!? i thought you had a wife?

[ruinsofdeath1]

your so gay

[spooksyaboy10]

@ruinsofdeath1 your probably like 6 

[mgeorge92]

This will forever be one of my favorite WTBs. The end gets me everytime :D haha

[blondebtchh]

The gay face? The gay hair? The gay hair flipping where there's no hair? HAHAHA Ohh man I love this guy.

[musicluv461]

he is absolutely positively HILARIOUS!!! luv u buck :)

[gagamjfan13]

LOVED THE SINGING!!!! AND I LOVED THE DUCK PART!!! U R SSOOO EFFIN FUNNY!!! I LOVE DAT UR OPENLY GAY!!! 

[bigbluewhale99]

This is my favorite wtb ever

[KoeHalifax]

HEY I SAY P.S.  o wait...

[2599Cloudstrife]

HE always goes to ... not even him self to other people and the question is about him

[RetroNurdz]

Answering the topic.

Only on thursdays.

[snoopyflick]

I've used PPS before, and I'm not gay. WTF you insensitive prejudice bigot. I'd use the f word, as it's warranted, but want people to see this comment.

[ASEKMusik]

@snoopyflick Obviously it was a FUCKING joke. Get over it.

[pandagirlful]

@snoopyflick chill out....

[ThePorkchiz]

I if walks like a duck... if it talks like a duck... if it flips it's hair like a duck... It's a gay fucking duck.

xD

[Bobbi3Jack1099]

omg i just realized that theres an aouther named michael buckley and he write really good!!!

[cutelilpoodleluver]

Dude. Michael. Are you gay or something? You seem like it.

[xokateandkayxo]

gaygaygaygay

[DaAnimekid]

lmao... fuck david..

[SonAmyFanGurl]

i LOVE micheal Buckley<3

[AmyEtv]

u sound just a little like colfer

[spazzgurl133]

Was that the Stamford mall?

[xokateandkayxo]

FAG

[AmyEtv]

@xokateandkayxo MEAN

[sammolikestoast]

@xokateandkayxo You're a bitch.

[cupcakesrocktheworld]

LOVE.

[parislov1]

"Its a gay fucking duck" lmao :-P

[GetShitOnKid]

@parislov1 HAHA! =-)

[HotCoco456]

wow very orinal thepennestri its not like every other hater calls him. And when are you going to reilze he doesn't care?

[CoralAvshalom]

i love you you are so funny i couldn't stop laghing from this video lol XD

[MyCupcakes941]

I dare

[ThePennestri]

fag



[Killian265]

Lol if it walks like  a duck if it talks like a duck then its a gay fucking duck

[jordandavila88]

shut the buck up

[35Favorites]

It's a gay fucking duck, best line ever!!!

[HypotheticalBeauty]

Oh my God this is by favorite video so far! It's a gay fucking duck

[Territhestrawberry]

"its a gay fucking duck" hahaha oh buck you truly are fantastic x x x

[randomperson889]

i dare to comment! -_- :)

[sprytose]

@WHATTHEBUCKSHOW. Dude, i'm not gay. I like jenette mcurdy cus she is SOO HOT. I mean, Look @ her she is hot.

[blooperbros217]

so.......is that a yes???

[kmasucci]

@ulquiorra2001 NO SHIITT

[verylazboy]

can u please crawl into a hole and stfu?

[poetrytolive]

Love the opening RENT reference.

[ulquiorra2001]

i dont get is he gay?

[missytaterhead]

@ulquiorra2001 ...are you serious

[CathForStew]

"another clue: spontaneous brusture into show tune" LOL

Laughed so hard! This David must simply have no gay-dar what so ever!!! XD

:)

always lots of love!

[Thecrazykielbasa]

This is weird. It's weird. Very weird. Fucking weird. I'm so mad that I don't know what to do. Fighting with microphones, freezing down to my bones and to top it all off I'm with you!

[21Midnight]

omg lol i loooooveee this video. this is my over all favorite video EVER. :] GAY FUCKEN DUCK lol. oh how i love you buck.

[rcangel98]

i love how is very, very, very, very, very, VERY proud to be gay!! <3

U ROCK BUCKLY!!! :D

[SmileTodayPlz]

Hi David thanks for writing comment if you dare!!!<3:)

[corvusoscuro]

love you Micheal

no homo XD

[nimchimpskii]

What's the difference between being gay and being a fag?

[kittahlova206]

i love you but its too bad ur gay... lol

[TheBropro3000]

GAAAAYYYY



[ThePineappleQueen001]

Thumbs up if you realized the song he began to sang at the beginning was

Tango Maureen from Rent!!

LOVE YOU BUCK!!!! -3

[drumguy127]

I don't even know how many times I've rewatched this since it first got posted because it's SO FRAKING HILARIOUS!! :D

[xlshields]

267 ppl are not sexy....

[rblackthornj2]

HELLO DOLLEY! I LUV U MICHAEL!

[pepaminter96]

wow i feel like im on crack now wAoaaah

[Nalom24]

Glee is on at 9pm in the UK...I guess we are all just prudes

[lacidog8]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA UR HILARIOUS

[GuruRawr]

I still love you XD

[kelliferpigg]

Still love this video!



[caffrey1996]

u fuckin faggit

[lexiloo1198]

Everyone was trying to meet Jenette, when they should've been trying to meet you!

[ronpunpanchgul]

soccer-nba com

[megaflyer99]

The funniest sign I've ever seen at an Anti-Gay Rally/Riot was a sign that said "Homosexuals are Gay!" the least he could do was try to make up something original! oh well! what the buck!

[cutytocute]

QESTION:U ONCE SAID U WEREN'T WEARING PANTS DURING A SHOW............DO U EVER WEAR PANTS WHEN UR NOT IN PUBLIC???????????............J­UST CURIOUS

[MSILuverFreak]

Gamergirl48 me too!!!

[artboy98]

I hate gays

[Jaylecialee]

@artboy98 I'm sure they hate you too.

[chooseurlastword]

Gay people are funny and cool, what's wrong with that?

[gamergirl48]

If it walks like a duck, talks like a duck, flips its hair like a duck, it's a gay fucking duck! That is my all time favorite line from this show!

[TheAcidskull]

i hate you ,you fucking faaaaag, you should be ashamed of how you embarrest men everywere

[ThisIsNotAva]

@TheAcidskull

I'm sure they would be more "embarrest" of your spelling than whether or not he is gay.

[TheAcidskull]

@ThisIsNotAva om not american nor english,so it ok for me to spell things wrong.

just a question ,are you gay

[868BooBoo]

@TheAcidskull - OMFG he just explained it through the whole video !!! are you retartedd ????? -____-

[TheAcidskull]

@868BooBoo fuck you

[868BooBoo]

@TheAcidskull - hahahahaha nice comback . :P

[TheAcidskull]

@868BooBoo not trying to start a fight,thats why im making a short comeback

[868BooBoo]

@TheAcidskull - Ha Okaay Bye .

[ThisIsNotAva]

@TheAcidskull

Your nationality doesn't make it okay for you to be a close minded ignorant prick.

My sexuality is none of your concern, it's not relevant.

[TheAcidskull]

@ThisIsNotAva i hate gays and there is nothing i can do about that

[TheAcidskull]

@ThisIsNotAva and what you just said means that you are gay,dont bother replying i wont asnwer

[ThisIsNotAva]

@TheAcidskull

Have you met every single gay person in the world? I really doubt it. Hating a bunch of people just because of something they have no choice over is so ridiculously pathetic. Judge people for their personality if you have no judge them because of something.

Also, I'm pansexual. But it's no relevance.

You don't have to be gay to support equal rights.

[ZADRfangurl]

Thats rude David!!! Thats not exactly something you ask!!!!! That was extremely rude and if you where waltching this vid and laughing, you are retarded because you just got bashed on youtube!!! Fail. But anywayse, I thought the vid was extremely great, and funny. Good job.

[gwapi69]

I think this is my fav episode!!!!

[cme239]

If you were straight and single, who would you date and why?

[SparklyyMegan]

What the fuck? I really don't get the comments that say "even though you're gay I still love you" Like, really? Him being gay should be totally irrelevant to whether or not you like him.

[gwapi69]

rofl I can't stop LAUGHING!!!! hahahaha

[thedevilmonkey13]

yeahhhh i dear!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Celsius2009nc]

IT'S A GAY DUCK ...GOTTA LOVE THE BUCK

[momomoore1623]

Even though your gay I still love you!

[Sophia123273]

OBVIOUS!..............

[Sophia123273]

pregnant with his stork baby lol, oh totally no uniforms!!!

[Sophia123273]

LOL!!!!!!!

[BabeyGurlie69]

not fair my bf is mad b/c i used to do porn...

[LADYGaGaMONSTER1984]

Im not nearly as Femm as him, but hes hilarious! And I don't mind how wild he is! It's so fun. Haha (:

[slurringfingers]

BAHAHAHAHHA. Oh my gosh. I love him. Not romantically meant... obviously... seeing as he's GAY. <3

[Jacklgf]

this is too fruity and boring. I stopped it at 57 seconds.

[FaveAuntPookie]

You're gay?? When did that happen? I had no idea :)) <3

[sk8ordie575]

ur gay

[ImmaMonster01001]

ITS A GAY FUCKING DUCK! haha. omggg I love itt! :DD

Fav wtb everr:DD <3

Loveee youuu:]

[harc520]

@kimmysmilesatyou no, if it were that easy, i would be straight. it would save me a lot of trouble.

[kimmysmilesatyou]

@harc520 oo ok thats kewl i gess! :)

[ZINPaDRaGooN]

Thumbs up for Rent reference and all those out there who started singing the Tango Maureen

[wintersnap1313]

i love u bubk because ppl r ashamed to admit it but u r perfectly ok with it

[bigmommakay]

"flail flail flail, gay gay gay...obvious!" (:

[Mimir0zay]

Now that you sang Tango Maureen i got it stick in my head lol but i effing love you <3 <3 <3

[TheCannykid]

hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhh

[dadaniel1]

Still my favorite WTB!

[geo120ify]

Iron my weave!!!! LOL I LOVE YOU!

[TheBookwormFromMars]

Wait, is he gay? I think I may have missed the part where he mentioned that.

[xxjackie21xx]

GAY FUCKING DUCK!! LOL

I LOVE YOU <333

[NessxQuick]

0:06

RENT! <3 <3  <3

[Deeverdict]

i kinda feel sorry for this David guy now. but good for him, his gaydar will be fully charged-up afer this.

[TheFamilyguylover44]

oh yeah your sexy

[TheBlahBlahNews]

Actually continued singing the Tango Maureen through the video :/

[Hayley81394]

Bahahaha I -3 u buck!!!!!

[preschoolpimpan]

HEY! i liked shakespeare in love!!!! it was great!

[JessiNick97]

Is it weird I have all the symptoms of being gay? ( especially bursting into showtunes)

[lunazulaivarsson]

"Check 1 2 3"

"Anything but that!"

RENT!!!!

[FengZeXiao]

I think Whatthebuck is BI

[AnyaEmber13]

jack: Grace, did you know i was gay?

grace: My dog knew you were gay

^^this video reminded me of the Will and Grace pilot XD

[kathyvelasco20]

I luv u buck ur awsome

[CoastMajor]

WHATTHEBUCK is my favourite gay

[rawryourface69]

Ive seen this a million times and just noticed that you qouted rent xD

[punkranchero312]

much as my butt puckers it is never tight enough for him...

[Doomybiscuit]

Why are all the cute guys gay -__-?

[MaryMouseRawrs]

sooo are you gay? lol jk

[cheary30]

hair flips with no hair are the best kind

[buca100]

Lolz "if I spontaneously burst into showtunes, I'm gay!"

[hollywoodstar380]

I do dare!!!!!!!

[DiorellaDior]

thumbs up for RENT shot out in the intro ...haha "check 123..anything but that! love yaaa

[tailsbarzkar]

you are sexy

[ad00097]

Gay people enlighten my mood, they're always just so energetic :')

[HSMiCarlyforevs]

"Mummy whats a condom??" "ITS WHAT I SHOULD HAVE USED!!!" ROFL!!

[TinyTool12]

"If it walks like a duck, and talks like a duck, flips its hair like a duck...it's a gay fucking duck" LOL

[CondorK92]

"Hags on The View" WIN! :D

[niloufarn]

i admire you for being yourself, and not letting other people's comments stop you. AWESOME VIDEOS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[AriadnaMSaenz]

this is probably one of my favorite videos of yours lmao!!! First the constant David thing was killing me and second RENT and The Sound Of Music in one video? I think I died of happiness

[Mylifeisaspoof]

Hahaha I love that last line! Buck you make my day :) -3

[TheMrguy232]

are you gay cuz it seems like u r

[MudAlways]

FUCK THIS GAY.

[thieugiahongo]

HAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHHAAHAHHAAHAH­HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA­HAAAAAAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAAHHAHH­AHAAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAAHHAHAA­HHAHAAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAAHAHHAHA­HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAH­AHAAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHA­HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA­HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA­HA........ ok im tired

[rachelthommusic]

BAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!! Michael, you are just too much. Hilarious! :D

[dratinifan13]

I dunno, the clues he left are also for heterosexual men as well. Either way the dude's cool.

[BulldozerJack]

After watching this I just punched a wall... with my face.

[Thehighschool8888]

Buck.. I hope you don't care.. but I like commenting on all your american idol videos to share my opinions.. and I am so glad that Paul went home, now stefano and haley should go. My final 3 are probably james, casey and scotty, but scotty FTW :))

[yamum713]

Nice guy , i wonder if his wonderful wife and kids are as nice as him? (:

[SandiVengeance]

Dear dear Deaf Dumb and Blind David :)

[SarvwelitaLovesPaco]

I LOVE YOU!!!!!!! but you know you probably dont love me back because you know ur GAY!!!! haha you are HILARIOUS!!!

[AmeliaVitale]

flail flail flail gay gay gay!

[tppipersa]

check (test) 1, 2, 3 anything but that!! love the rent reference x)

[EVERYBODYelse2008]

loved your rent reference in the beginning :D

[varsityluverr]

iron my weave?

AHAHAHAHA...thanks for that, it made my day

[sledhead250]

yeah man you are a way cooler gay than chris crocker, i respect you man

[Nonmiha]

Wow you gotta lot of air!

[ladybruno87]

Another clue, spontanious breaking out into show tunes.. GAYYYYYYYY! Lmao!

[siemmens1]

how cares if ur gay LOL U R AWESOME DUDE and VERY FUNNY JAJAJAJA

[darklinkwillkill666]

i'm one of those straight acting gay guys. i'm not camp at all, but i have my moments! i like anime, videogames and dubstep/metal/drum n bass etc. but not sports so there's one thing i suppose. when i see gay guys acting camp on tv it kinda annoys me because it generalises us. when someone thinks gay now, (or they do when they are 15/16 like my class) they think high pitched talking about twilight and purses. not just "oh yeah, i like dicks... thats about it." like me. XD

[fartmonkey89]

mmmm RENT!