프리스타일 (Freestyle) - Y (Please tell me why)

[Eq339]

0:07 Bruce Lee

[nulovely5555]

กาลครั้งหนึ่งที่เราเคยฟังร่วมก­ัล ที่เราเคยมีความสุขด้วยกัล ช้านไม่เคยลืมเลือนเลย

[likeag666]

Cool.I've never seen something like this vid...cool thing with pictures:d

[coolmonkey934]

Yes, people this is the ORIGINAL and I cant believe there are people still saying stuff like the Chinese and Vietnamese versions are "copied". There is such a thing as Copyright, both the Chinese and Vietnamese singers have bought their rights to remake the song, they're not illegally "copying" Freestyle's song. Also, re-makes are a good thing, it shows that the original was so good that people pay to re-make it in different languages.

Peace. Enjoy good music without arguing over petty things.

[MimieuxMimieux]

What? this wasn't an unpopular song. People who don't know shit about Korea think it was unpopular, but it was popular and hit the charts when it came out.

I even remember watching it live on TV. "2004년 7월에 3집 Free style3을 내고 'Y'라는 곡으로 대한민국에 발라드 힙합이라는 장르로 대한민국 가요계에 큰 충격을 주었고" DAH!

[Kann275]

Am I the only person just know this song ? Never heard of Bu de Bu ai before ' '

[leethedster]

lol.. people arguing in horrible english. there is no way that one company can completely reproduce another song without getting permission first -__- so there is no 'illegal copying' songs are translated into different languages all the time. can't say that either them are better, except commercially one of them is. but we all know that doesn't mean that a song is better--it was just more in trend at that time.

[fanthor]

@leethedster orly? just translate an unpopular(but good) song, find a company brave enough to publish it in the other side of the world, there you have it, illegal copying

[leethedster]

@fanthor you didnt address what i meant by saying that they probably had permission, hence purchased the rights. how is that illegal?

[fanthor]

@leethedster no they didn't, freestyle sued wilber

[hanebahyunbin]

I never heard this song before. The original one is from Korea, so just accept it. no matter which country it is, what we should do, just enjoy this beautiful song. we listen to the same song, and be friend with each other, okay ;D enjoy together ^^

[AnnieIuno]

every country copy from another one its a true fact so get over it. Even Americans copy shit frm other countries most likely so stop making a big deal out of who the hell was the original artist even if u guys say who was the original artist will it make a difference? im pretty sure not but hell as long as u guys no who the original artist is well then isnt that good enough? becuz you no the TRUE facts and did ur research while others didnt. So there is no point in arguing becuz its ridiculous

[jonboy123]

Just a really random fact: Korean people, are in fact, originated from the Chinese breed dating back into milleniums.

[kim4738]

@jonboy123 just to let you know, genetically no you are incorrect Koreans are more related to Mongolians and Turkish, fool get your science correct and if you want to go further back everyone is from Africa fool

[jonboy123]

Alright, alright, Chinese people are copy cats, and it's a shame for us to illegally take your OG korean version. I'm sorry on behalf of the chinese that we tend to have more listeners with our version. But since you guys care so much about the copyrights and the jazz involved, you should protest in the media on regards of this issue instead of arguing on Youtube. Truth is, nobody gives a shit which version came out first. Please, we all live under the same sky, breathing the same air. Love?

[Suckto1]

@jonboy123 i dont agree wid u m8 i dont think chinese version is popular than korean. I 1st heard this song in korean and it was way back than nd ya i am not korean. I am Neapli nd we people love watchin/lisnin Korean Movie nd song its quite populars among us nodayz nd ya worldwide wise This song is more popular in Korean and world knows it by Korean song I came to know today that there is chinease version of this song too sounds weird but its nice but i disagree wid u*

[k24boy123]

tired of this hate...both versions are good.

[pigkkk2]

Wilber Pan copied like... tons of korean songs... Not an artist. He's just a cover artist. actually, he's not worthy as a singer.

[dahame]

i disagree. any korean knows this song.. i think this was more of a hit then bu de bu ai its just Old so it faded away.. but its helluva popular song

[hgvietquang]

@dahame its simple. the chinese version is more popular because chinese population is 1,4b

[jimbo4588]

no offence. But Taiwanese version sounds SO MUCH BETTER @_@

[Xchungsta94x]

@jimbo4588 uhh no

[kurifu]

korean version sounds better anyway. probably cause it's the original.

[JsLStyle]

just enjoy the music no racial comments needed

[mrkjsmarine]

에효.... 돈주고 사가서 1위먹던가 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 이제 뽀록나는구나 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

모 차이나 버전이고 뭐고간에.. 차이나 버전이란건존재하지않는다 법적으론..

이곡의 저작권은 한국에 존재한다는걸 알아두길..

[Whiteprince531993]

lol chinese ftw, always copy from others

[jonboy123]

Fuck, who gives a shit about this song whether its chinese or korean. 4 months ago I liked it, 4 months later I hate it ;] Chill the fuck out homies.

[jonboy123]

Why do people always argue that korean made it first. Even though it is, isn't it a shame that the chinese version is more popular? =)

[koolaiem]

True, the chinese version is more popular.

[pakmano7]

@koolaiem lol duh. there are way more of you jjangke than of us.

[koolaiem]

okay i tried to be neutral about this matter but shit like you just cant let everyone enjoy this song. 야 이 십새꺄 닌가 뭔대 남이 올린 비디오에다가 그런 답을 남기냐 어?  what do you mean for "than us" who the hell are "you"? 난 한국 사람이야 임마 근대 너 같이 싸가지 없고 외국분들을 욕하고 다니지는 않아 이 썩을놈아

[okmjyna]

@koolaiem 욕하지마 개갞끼야. don't swear you son of biyatch.

[GisSlicknSmooth]

@koolaiem ahh shibal wae yokk ha go ji Lall eeh yah? aishhibal jamji gattun saekki

[heyhye96]

@pakmano7 니같은 애새끼들때매 한국인들이 욕쳐먹는다 새꺄 ㅉㅉ

[orenji196]

but that doesnt necessarily make it better either.

[ggang112]

@jonboy123

Some chinese insist that this song is a copy of "Bu De Bu Ai ".

fuck dirty chinese t(^-^*)t

[howyar110]

@ggang112 motherfucker

[Xchungsta94x]

@jonboy123 well isnt only because that chinese guy is more famous than freestyle?

and that freestyle is underated? and the chinese guy is allll mainstream and is homo?

[bluebluerealheaven]

@jonboy123 Chinese people had copied this song without permission,

This song made​their first claims, and

They are South Koreans claim to have copies of their songs, and

China's court trial related to the copyrights of this song, when obviously their own copy, but they ruled Korea singer because there is no reason to compensate.

I think they are really brutal audacity.

[supersnsd3006]

such a wonderful melody ..=)

[minmeanmin]

korean version rocks

[Draytonvalley]

@minmeanmin its not a version, its the original.

[misakichii]

thanks for sharing!!

[doobshop]

Original Song

Singer - Freestyle(Korean)

Title - Y (Please Tell Me Why)

Album released at 2004-07-16

Copy Song

Singer - Wilber Pan(chinese)

Title - 不得不愛 Bu De Bu Ai (Have To Love)

Album released at 2005-07-08

[sakuritax0001]

i love this song ^^

[shwehtike]

no.. this version is original..

bu de bu ai is copied..

[Mystic4magic]

Haha I heard this song at KFC when I was at vietnam haha :D The vietnamese versions by Bao Thy :]

[TonyBleach]

Yea the Korean made the song, Chinese ..i copied ( will pan ) but the Chinese version is much more popular in America.. so =( but i'm viet so why do i care =P well my GF is korean xD

[Maplefreak4ever]

wow, so wilber actually copied this song?

I heard he got sued after a month.

[aznjdiddy]

try limewire

[hellenistic]

Do you by any chance have an MP3 of this song? I've been trying to find the Korean version everywhere, and it's completely impossible.