Alright, this definitely isn't the version I know from Glenn Miller. I'd urge anyone to look up a different version of this song. The ACTUAL Glenn Miller version. watch?v=gfigZBtAIjs
This is a good song. I don't care what the under lying meaning is because it's not why I listen to this song. The only criticism I have is that the t. Sax solo is to square
The song has lost its meaning here... a song about suffering and struggle turned into something like this? Oh well... they should've used another song as template.
@merl0c Yeah, I kinda agree. I like jazz and swing but for some reason I feel like playing The Song of the Volga Boatmen like this is a little, I don't know, disrespectful.
@robmoney i don't see how you can say that a song is tasteless i mean the glenn miller orchestra was the best in it's time and just because you don't have a taste for a particular kind of music doesn't make it any less good i mean i'm not a real big fan of that screamo stuff but if you are that's okay cuz you're open to your opinion and let all the people who like this be open to theirs too no reason to call a great band's music tasteless
@robmoney i'd hate to see an argument between you and and an adult since you have to result to calling a 16 year a fucking moron, i mean, that is really kinda sad don't you think
@robmoney i'd hate to see an argument between you and and an adult since you have to result to calling a 16 year a fucking moron, i mean, that is really kinda sad don't you think
@robmoney i'd hate to see an argument between you and and an adult since you have to result to calling a 16 year a fucking moron, i mean, that is really kinda sad don't you think
I remember seeing (and hearing) this being performed in an old film. It was neither a Glenn Miller nor a big band performance. Anyone know the name of the film?
The song predates the Battle of Stalingrad by about a hundred years, at least.
And given that Mr. Glenn Miller recorded this rendition a year before the actual battle took place, I hardly think that its fair to say that "a mockery" is being made.
@lokaiz as if after the end of tzarism Russia became heaven on earth! You read this on Wikipedia, and "tzarist" is tottaly random in that context! Tzarism is often put as the source of all eavil in Russia, to justify the revolution and all the death and destruction it brought along! I don't say that the Tzars were good governors, not at all, but Russian people was miserable, and kept miserable after the revolution, and marxists love to put all the blame on tzarism to cover their own incompetence
This was my late father-in-law's, a retired WO4 from the USMC, survivor of Iwo JIma, favorite Glenn Miller song. He always refered to it as "The Vulgar Boatman".
Glenn Miller will always be one of the greatest artists of all time- the way he can take tunes (of any style or country) and turn them into something that swings is really spectacular.
Always wondered why we always sing Russian communist songs and never ever, never ever any song of Russians who believed communism was a dictatorship and faught against it. Why? Is it maybe that our governments are actually a form of communism?
Gosh, I grew up listening to his music (not during time period, but when I was growing up) Great song. I always loved his style his music. It's been a while I've heared any of his songs.
Surprised no one mentioned the arranger of this, Bill Finegan. The arrangers are the true un-sung heroes of this music. Note the fugue at 1:54. . . .brilliant.
The US, UK and USSR had a common enemy at this time. Musicians, film-makers etc were encouraged by the government to emphasise how much we had in common with all the allies - so this might be part of that. I think that taking a slave song from one culture, and orchestrating it so that for a general US audience it would evoke the sound of American traditional slave music, is a wonderful achievement.
But I'm sure there would be plenty of Americans complaining similarly if a Russian musician made a tribute to- for example- Star Spangled Banner (though I'm aware the Red Army Choir once preformed "Battle Hymn to the Republic"- you can imagine the looks on the faces from either country. ;) )
I listened to a posting of the original version, it was a strong, lovely piece of music. Glenn Miller's version has great rhythm. See? They both have their appeal. Personally, I prefer GM's version, b/c I'm a fan of big band- but that doesn't mean one is better than the other. It's all a matter of opinion!
I bet Now that an american who redid it gets the royalties for it.... aaaah sweeet capitalism. And how dare u rate down my comment. My god its my opinion, u dont see me doing that.Damn it thats an insult. And the english thing is because im too lazy to scroll down and i see u like to pick up on every detail, hav u alot of spare time? Here: Slava bogu chto takih idiotov kak ti netu v Rossie ato tebya uje davno mordu izbili i otbidarasili na polnoi programme. good luck translating.
This is shit. "barges on river volga" is a song about when russian labour was still cheap enough to use while the technology already existed(tug boats) it supposed to represent the strength of russian spirit in times harshness and unforgiven misery. This "interpretation" completely misses the point. Trust it to americans to fuck it up.lol
You don't know who created "Volga Boatmen" or how it was originally performed by it's author! No one living does.
EVERY composer will give it (or any art) his own spin and interpretation, JUST AS YOU HAVE.... but Glenn Miller took the song to #1 in the US charts and entertained millions with it during hard times in the US.
Efimovich Repin (1844-1930) - Volga Boatmen. is the artist. And just for the record this is one of the national songs in my country so i should know hw its performed. And the interpretation is wrong because you cannot recreate this song in the spirit this guy did because it has no soul like the original does.... so in my opinion he fucked it up.... royally. See the original thats hw it should be done. this is just a cheap knock off with no singing and no meaning.
The song was collected and published by composer and musical ethnographer Mily Balakirev in his 1866 book "Collection of Russian Folksongs" compiled between 1861 and 1865.
The painting "Burlaks on the Volga" by Ilia Efimovich Repin has been said to have inspired the "Song of the Volga Boatmen" but painted 1870-1873 (after 1866).
As far as I know, the "original" composer remains unknown. First issued in sheet music in Moscow about 1886.
this is a Russian FOLK song. it is one of Russian famous creations and its original style only belongs to Russia. It is art and history of my nation. and like with art you cannot recreate it and warp it into something that makes no relevance to iits origin, especially in this case where the "style" destroyes the deep meaning.
Please people this was in the 2nd world war . He was arranging music for people to dance to and to forget the war for a time. Most of them would'nt have known what the music was about , they just wanted to listen to good music and have a good time.- they might be dead tomorrow. His arrangements for that time were way before the average band for that time.
I love Glenn Miller, but I honestly have to say it's no comparison to the original. Now, he does make it sound very good, but again, I feel that the original held more of the pain in it. As the song refers to the suffering lives of the boatmen. Great copy though~!
This is the Miller Air Corps band playing this song that was a big hit for his civilian band. The stunning arrangement was by Bill Finegan, one of his civilian band arrangers
Thank you *very* much indeed for putting this up! One of my all-time favorite Glenn Miller tunes...and I'm no child of the Swing Era (except in mind!).
Jazz/swing is a great genera of music that is overlooked in today's music world. I know I particularly like Dixieland jazz - one of my favorite subgenera's. =D
Volga runs through the cool side of town.
DoctorPencilK 1 month ago
this should have been the theme of perry mason
youpon1000 1 month ago
Alright, this definitely isn't the version I know from Glenn Miller. I'd urge anyone to look up a different version of this song. The ACTUAL Glenn Miller version. watch?v=gfigZBtAIjs
SnowBlind853 1 month ago
Weird, this sounds nothing like the version I have on my computer from Glenn Miller. This isn't quite as good, you sure this is Glenn Miller?
SnowBlind853 1 month ago
Comment removed
vitalyspacewalk29 2 months ago
Comment removed
vitalyspacewalk29 2 months ago 2
@vitalyspacewalk29 Anyone who invented Vodka can't be all bad.
someonespadre 2 months ago
Comment removed
Piece0fDust 3 months ago
gramatik swing of justice
grovidas 3 months ago
This is a good song. I don't care what the under lying meaning is because it's not why I listen to this song. The only criticism I have is that the t. Sax solo is to square
GuysWithHats 4 months ago
Agh, too bouncy! Mel Brooks could make a musical about the Dancing Volga Boatmen with this version.
Lamashtar 5 months ago
Ochen horrorshow! My father-in-laws favorite song, and he lived through Iwo.
KlezmerGolem 6 months ago
Does this count as the first *remix*? This was one of the first tunes I learnt to play on the piano, I did not sound anything like this, LOL.
trct633 6 months ago
He butchered it.
MrMervyn 6 months ago
The most upbeat Russian song ever.
maxman1602 6 months ago
Excelente!!!!!!
Astaroth639718 6 months ago
El arreglo de GM es una lección de cómo quitar el dramatismo ruso y dejar el gozo de la música.
MonttVaras 6 months ago
yep, vulgar
tabananje 7 months ago
Come sing vith me!
whowantsabighug 9 months ago 2
The song has lost its meaning here... a song about suffering and struggle turned into something like this? Oh well... they should've used another song as template.
merl0c 9 months ago
@merl0c really, it's just the first half minute. The rest feels like "dancing in the volga"
badpeq 9 months ago
@merl0c Yeah, I kinda agree. I like jazz and swing but for some reason I feel like playing The Song of the Volga Boatmen like this is a little, I don't know, disrespectful.
Wierdoinc 7 months ago 3
This version is trite compared to an authentic Russian version, like the Red Army Choir version, no soul to it at all.
DawnOfTheDead991 10 months ago
This is like making a big band version of Strange Fruit, fucking tasteless.
robmoney 10 months ago
@robmoney i don't see how you can say that a song is tasteless i mean the glenn miller orchestra was the best in it's time and just because you don't have a taste for a particular kind of music doesn't make it any less good i mean i'm not a real big fan of that screamo stuff but if you are that's okay cuz you're open to your opinion and let all the people who like this be open to theirs too no reason to call a great band's music tasteless
dyshilton 10 months ago
@dyshilton
Do you know what this song is about? that's why I equated it to Strange Fruit.
robmoney 10 months ago
@robmoney it's not an issue about what's it's about it's about you calling it tasteless
dyshilton 10 months ago
@dyshilton
I called it tasteless because of what the song is about. fucking moron.
robmoney 10 months ago
@robmoney there is no need to be calling names now
dyshilton 10 months ago
@robmoney i'd hate to see an argument between you and and an adult since you have to result to calling a 16 year a fucking moron, i mean, that is really kinda sad don't you think
dyshilton 10 months ago
@robmoney i'd hate to see an argument between you and and an adult since you have to result to calling a 16 year a fucking moron, i mean, that is really kinda sad don't you think
dyshilton 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@robmoney i'd hate to see an argument between you and and an adult since you have to result to calling a 16 year a fucking moron, i mean, that is really kinda sad don't you think
dyshilton 10 months ago
Comment removed
robmoney 10 months ago
10 persons went sailing on the Volga river when it's frozen
WAMEDJO 10 months ago
@WAMEDJO Sadly, there are 11 people sailing the frozen Volga.
MaxCruise73 10 months ago
weary gud song
lolita19711 1 year ago
i'm Russian...and this guy is awesome, i love american songs from 30's and 40's...fuck politician....lets play music:)
Shumaev 1 year ago 30
I remember seeing (and hearing) this being performed in an old film. It was neither a Glenn Miller nor a big band performance. Anyone know the name of the film?
Strawberry7Lynn 1 year ago
@Strawberry7Lynn The Glenn Miller Story?
historygenius 1 year ago
the original is way better than this.
Telamon8 1 year ago 2
Way better than the original
P1anoYC 1 year ago
this song is dedicated to the 10,000 heroes who crossed the volga in the battle of stalin grad. and he made a mockery of it.
scids225 1 year ago
@scids225 Mockery in which way?
TowersJens 1 year ago
The song predates the Battle of Stalingrad by about a hundred years, at least.
And given that Mr. Glenn Miller recorded this rendition a year before the actual battle took place, I hardly think that its fair to say that "a mockery" is being made.
DBEnterprises 1 year ago
@scids225
Except for the fact that this song has nothing to do with the Battle of Stalingrad. It's a song sung by burlaks hauling barges on the volga river.
boshlonavish 1 year ago 2
@boshlonavish it was also about the suffering of the russian people and the misery of tsarist russia
lokaiz 1 year ago
@lokaiz as if after the end of tzarism Russia became heaven on earth! You read this on Wikipedia, and "tzarist" is tottaly random in that context! Tzarism is often put as the source of all eavil in Russia, to justify the revolution and all the death and destruction it brought along! I don't say that the Tzars were good governors, not at all, but Russian people was miserable, and kept miserable after the revolution, and marxists love to put all the blame on tzarism to cover their own incompetence
gabrieow 1 year ago
@gabrieow One can say, no matter who ruled them, Russians were born to suffer.
DawnOfTheDead991 10 months ago
This was my late father-in-law's, a retired WO4 from the USMC, survivor of Iwo JIma, favorite Glenn Miller song. He always refered to it as "The Vulgar Boatman".
MorganPolander 1 year ago
I know where Jamaica got there Ska from
1988acid 1 year ago
@1988acid The Blues. They heard it over the radio and tried to do it while mixing local shit with it. Ska has nothing to do with Big Band.
robmoney 10 months ago
Thank you very much :)
hexionn 1 year ago
Glenn Miller will always be one of the greatest artists of all time- the way he can take tunes (of any style or country) and turn them into something that swings is really spectacular.
92elrtv2 1 year ago
how old is this
MegaBillyboy12345 1 year ago
Always wondered why we always sing Russian communist songs and never ever, never ever any song of Russians who believed communism was a dictatorship and faught against it. Why? Is it maybe that our governments are actually a form of communism?
SonsOfGod 1 year ago
What is this I don't even.
*Clicks like*
yutzwagon2 1 year ago
Gosh, I grew up listening to his music (not during time period, but when I was growing up) Great song. I always loved his style his music. It's been a while I've heared any of his songs.
aldrickbarber35 1 year ago
@aldrickbarber35 how old r u
MegaBillyboy12345 1 year ago
@MegaBillyboy12345 14. When I was 9, my dad played the CDs in the car...
aldrickbarber35 1 year ago
Surprised no one mentioned the arranger of this, Bill Finegan. The arrangers are the true un-sung heroes of this music. Note the fugue at 1:54. . . .brilliant.
melodistman 1 year ago 9
Whap-pa-pow-pa...LOVE this song!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Alexus7373 1 year ago
I WAS SOME FUN.SURF MUSIC /MAN OR ASTROMAN
supperbowl43 1 year ago
Glenn Miller was an artist -- screw Artie Shaw!
Kinemacolour 1 year ago
it needs a banjo medley
ilikezappa 1 year ago
Such a sad song. It's cool how they made it happy!
Taterzoid 1 year ago
Hope this didn't label Glenn Miller as a "pinko" during the Red Scare.
CrownRadio 1 year ago
He died in late 1944 over the English channel. They never found his plane.
kountk 1 year ago
He got a bronze star right?
PetjePetjePaard 1 year ago
The US, UK and USSR had a common enemy at this time. Musicians, film-makers etc were encouraged by the government to emphasise how much we had in common with all the allies - so this might be part of that. I think that taking a slave song from one culture, and orchestrating it so that for a general US audience it would evoke the sound of American traditional slave music, is a wonderful achievement.
timsvengali 1 year ago 2
@timsvengali
good point, but I meant in later years, even though he had died, I wondered if this song was blacklisted in certain areas.
CrownRadio 1 year ago
niceeeee one xbabsie hugs
blondiebabs 2 years ago
I have always thought of thi song like a Russian Version of Ole Man River!
ArizonaKnightWolf 2 years ago
Nice tribute, but I like the original more. Miller's version seems a bit too uppity for a song about laboring slaves.
Csp499 2 years ago 3
Miller did a good job of writing a jazz version of this Russian patriotic song.
TashkentFox 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This butchers the very soul of the Volga boatman song.
eksadiss 2 years ago
It's just a tribute, Eksadiss.
But I'm sure there would be plenty of Americans complaining similarly if a Russian musician made a tribute to- for example- Star Spangled Banner (though I'm aware the Red Army Choir once preformed "Battle Hymn to the Republic"- you can imagine the looks on the faces from either country. ;) )
Csp499 2 years ago
On my page theres a video of the Red Army Choir singing our canadian anthem.
eksadiss 2 years ago
way too happy sounding for my taste lol
cartoonsfut 2 years ago
I listened to a posting of the original version, it was a strong, lovely piece of music. Glenn Miller's version has great rhythm. See? They both have their appeal. Personally, I prefer GM's version, b/c I'm a fan of big band- but that doesn't mean one is better than the other. It's all a matter of opinion!
whenimsixty4 2 years ago
I bet Now that an american who redid it gets the royalties for it.... aaaah sweeet capitalism. And how dare u rate down my comment. My god its my opinion, u dont see me doing that.Damn it thats an insult. And the english thing is because im too lazy to scroll down and i see u like to pick up on every detail, hav u alot of spare time? Here: Slava bogu chto takih idiotov kak ti netu v Rossie ato tebya uje davno mordu izbili i otbidarasili na polnoi programme. good luck translating.
qaziomo91 2 years ago
well... a thumbs up/down is also an opinion is it not? just sayin
cartoonsfut 2 years ago
SHAAAAAAAAAAAAZZZZOOOO!!!
qaziomo91 2 years ago
Comment removed
Bushyfoxy 2 years ago
This is shit. "barges on river volga" is a song about when russian labour was still cheap enough to use while the technology already existed(tug boats) it supposed to represent the strength of russian spirit in times harshness and unforgiven misery. This "interpretation" completely misses the point. Trust it to americans to fuck it up.lol
qaziomo91 2 years ago
Oh, give it a break qaziomo.
You don't know who created "Volga Boatmen" or how it was originally performed by it's author! No one living does.
EVERY composer will give it (or any art) his own spin and interpretation, JUST AS YOU HAVE.... but Glenn Miller took the song to #1 in the US charts and entertained millions with it during hard times in the US.
2Fathom 2 years ago
What have you done for the people qaziomo, but whine and bitch, and put-down a culture and hundreds of millions of people with your spite.
2Fathom 2 years ago
Efimovich Repin (1844-1930) - Volga Boatmen. is the artist. And just for the record this is one of the national songs in my country so i should know hw its performed. And the interpretation is wrong because you cannot recreate this song in the spirit this guy did because it has no soul like the original does.... so in my opinion he fucked it up.... royally. See the original thats hw it should be done. this is just a cheap knock off with no singing and no meaning.
qaziomo91 2 years ago
For the record:
The artist here is Glenn Miller
The song was collected and published by composer and musical ethnographer Mily Balakirev in his 1866 book "Collection of Russian Folksongs" compiled between 1861 and 1865.
The painting "Burlaks on the Volga" by Ilia Efimovich Repin has been said to have inspired the "Song of the Volga Boatmen" but painted 1870-1873 (after 1866).
As far as I know, the "original" composer remains unknown. First issued in sheet music in Moscow about 1886.
2Fathom 2 years ago
@2Fathom This is not the original version by Glenn Miller and his orchestra.
4205lr 1 year ago
Efimovich Repin is one of my favorite painter/sculpters but he was no musician/composer. Repin did paint music composers including Modest Mussorgsky.
"Song of the Volga Boatmen" may have inspired Repin to paint the "burlaks" but it is unlikely.
2Fathom 2 years ago
"this is one of the national songs in my country"
Strange, I notice that you claim in your YouTube profile that "United Kingdom" is your country!
Since Glenn Miller's composition was #1 on the charts here, it could be said to be "one of the national songs in my country".
2Fathom 2 years ago
this is a Russian FOLK song. it is one of Russian famous creations and its original style only belongs to Russia. It is art and history of my nation. and like with art you cannot recreate it and warp it into something that makes no relevance to iits origin, especially in this case where the "style" destroyes the deep meaning.
qaziomo91 2 years ago
@qaziomo91 So glenn Miller wrote a different arrangangement of the song of the volga boatmen... give him a break& LET HIM REST IN PEACE!
Freyja1133 2 years ago
Please people this was in the 2nd world war . He was arranging music for people to dance to and to forget the war for a time. Most of them would'nt have known what the music was about , they just wanted to listen to good music and have a good time.- they might be dead tomorrow. His arrangements for that time were way before the average band for that time.
ossy3154 2 years ago
Comparez au coeur de l'armée rouge, c'est de la daube...
Djrome1 2 years ago
I love Glenn Miller, but I honestly have to say it's no comparison to the original. Now, he does make it sound very good, but again, I feel that the original held more of the pain in it. As the song refers to the suffering lives of the boatmen. Great copy though~!
shinseichieien 2 years ago 7
I agree with you. Original is better.
In original you can feel Great Russian soul.
13131313Paulo 2 years ago 2
Very cool!! I never new Glenn Miller interpreted stuff like this!
monoceros1222 2 years ago
american version with stile
theunbearableman 2 years ago
The cadalac of the big bands
tenorismo 2 years ago
This is the Miller Air Corps band playing this song that was a big hit for his civilian band. The stunning arrangement was by Bill Finegan, one of his civilian band arrangers
snuffy39 2 years ago
Fascinating! The way he takes this extremely slow yet powerful Russian bass folk song and turns it into outright Swing is amazing!
eethove 2 years ago
If you're looking more stuff like this try looking up Kenny Ball and his Jazzmen...midnight in moscow, dark eyes etc.
c14h20o4 2 years ago
Forgot to mention another great, Artie Shaw... look for his song nightmare.. surreal!
c14h20o4 2 years ago
Good copy of the original!
4205lr 2 years ago
Gotta love this.
mrcoolgenius 2 years ago
just fucking awesome
5* for this one
R.I.P. glenn
long live the soviet union
SteilAmSeil 3 years ago 17
The Soviet Union no longer exists my friend.
molanlabexm15 2 years ago
Thank you *very* much indeed for putting this up! One of my all-time favorite Glenn Miller tunes...and I'm no child of the Swing Era (except in mind!).
Mahanfan 3 years ago 30
@Mahanfan SEARCH " JELLYBASS - VULGAR " FOR AN ALTERNATIVE INTEPRETATION
danhaw18 1 year ago
I love that slow crescendo starting at around 1:55...awesome! Definitely a fave! 5 stars :)
StarvinArtistSue 3 years ago 7
oh, me too!
vanityfair713 2 years ago
this was a 4.5 star video!!!! How is that? Who is the piece(s) of crap who rated this less than a 5?
cris1234567890tilghm 3 years ago 5
By chance are you willing to e-mail me the MP3 of this song? I cannot find it ANYWHERE on the internet. D=
cylaisawesome 3 years ago 2
look for youtube converter ;-)
nelle69 3 years ago 2
Ahh, thank you!
cylaisawesome 3 years ago
According to US Copyright Law, songs are not public domain until 70 years until after the artist's death.
I wonder if t'll be okay for this, though, seing as the expiration date for this of 2014's just around the corner...
HYAAALP 2 years ago
The song is public domain, it's been around for longer than Glenn miller has, but this arrangement is still under copyright
stuckinaboxhere 2 years ago
I was just introduced to swing music today, and I love it already. This song is incredibly catchy yet somewhat elegant.
UltrasonicMailman 3 years ago 2
Jazz/swing is a great genera of music that is overlooked in today's music world. I know I particularly like Dixieland jazz - one of my favorite subgenera's. =D
cylaisawesome 3 years ago 2
Great!
PhillipsVanguard 3 years ago