Added: 2 years ago
From: AstuteClass
Views: 43,197
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (248)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • this scared the crap out of me when I played it as a kid, this scene in particular!

  • Lisa was my favorite character in the game when she died i cried. i thought " No why Lisa ." Still very good game

  • @appo47 Most say that since she was the nurse who took care of Alessa, she was somehow resistant to the effects of the Otherworld. While saying that all of the monsters used to be people, or Alessa made some of them is up to speculation, it's known that some humans were made into the fleshbags. Think kind of like you don't notice you don't belong until you realize what you are.

  • Great theme. I don't understand why the soundtrack lacks this version of the song. Not Tomorrow almost sounds like a demo compared to this,

  • Why everybody thinks she died? she was just bleeding and walking creepy... Can hqppen to anyone :D

  • Yes, she's already dead. This is her soul finally giving up. Harry's interjection into Silent Hill made her realize what she had become.

  • are you happy now? now, i want to play silent hill again!

  • This is probally the third most sad moments in a game that I have seen.

  • holy shit Lisa'd been dead before that scene, why does everybody keep thinking you saw her die?

  • @Appo47 It's more of her mentally dying in this scene. She basically becomes a monster, and she herself is fully dead, but not her body. It's quite complicated.

  • Can you think of a film that has evoked emotion like this scene? I couldn't think of one, truly sad.

  • @EminemsGurl101 she is kept alive, only as the same reason as all the other demon nurses were. Her bleeding represents Alessa, who was burnt in a fire. Lisa mentions in a videotape the blood and puss ooz through, so the bleeding represents Lisa's time changing the blood bandages. It also is a connection to her death 7 years before the game. Getting hit in the head with a suitcase. (P.S, Kaufmann is the hospital administrator)

  • I cried so much at this wen i watched a walkthrough by pyschadelicsnake..............

  • @EminemsGurl101 well, we can't prove what REALLY happened to her. A good theory was that she was killed by Kaufmann after quitting at the hospital, but Alessa kept her alive as a kind woman caring for her. As the flauros, ( a little structure thing) wiped Alessa's powers away, she couldn't keep Lisa alive. so a cutscene called evil Lisa shows her right are, and left eye twitching, showing her sense of changing. She runs away from Harry, saying you don't understand. She finally understands why s

  • What was wrong with her? I've never played the games so I don't understand anything

  • lisa didn't died she become same like the killer nurses

  • This is one of the saddest things I have ever seen. :(

  • Lisa is overreacting cuz harry didnt even pushed her xD

  • did someone slip a wet fart at 1:52 ?

  • Not sure why... But I find the silent hill series scarier than dead space 2 o.O

  • @milderg As much as i love dead space, you can't compare it to silent hill. its like comparing oranges with eyeballs.

  • @milderg Because Dead Space is not scary?

  • @GIChiyo True.

  • Her left bang moves so much and it's still neatly straight!

  • awesome!

  • wait why is she bleeding i'm asking cause i never played tis game before

  • @MrBlackops7108 THEN PLAY THE GAME. its a really awesome game :D

  • @CaptianApe I never play the game cuz it's scaryyyyyyy!!

  • @TheGreengary but you'd be missing out on a wonderful story line, well only 1-3 silent hills have a good story line. if u want non scary the other silent hills you can play.but they don't hold up to 1-3. or u can play during the day time :D

  • @CaptianApe thanks for the advice!

  • @TheGreengary Your welcome :3

  • I wish I knew the name of that song she dies to.

  • @SuperApril34 Not Tomorrow 1

  • @lavahornet2 Thank you. Especially for replying so quickly.

  • hey guys check out my silent hill blood tears short film, it's based on the scene of lisa's death, and I also have a short film for the second game, restless dreams!

  • @rasielussuria that's exactly what I told my friend when she showed me this, it's sad that he pushed her away :\

  • This scene made me want to curl up in a little ball of concentrated emotion and stay that way... one of the most beautiful videogame scenes I have ever seen.

  • this was the first time a game ever made me sad lol playing alone middle of the night with the lights off and the volume way up haha

  • Where did she go?

  • I know it sounds kinda unlikely, but I would have hugged her, AT LEAST, you know, make her last moments worth it.

  • So she randomly starts to bleed? ._.

  • i dont get it why did harry not help her and why did he walk away why was she not there when he opened the door? sorry for all the questions lol

  • @Jonbjn

    Harry didn't help her cause he was scared, and he knew what Lisa would do. She was a monster, she would in the end kill him, stop him from saving his daughter. Harry did something that was extremely difficult to do. He left a friend to save someone he loved. Plus, after the hell he has been put through, i don't think he could believe that this happened.

  • @MasterCheif248 dont you mean tried? cuz i was controllin' harry and i wanted him to help her id of killed her if she did try kill me

  • Please Remake The Game "SILENT HILL" ON PS3 or XBOX 360 to View High quality Scene Like Lisa's death

  • @222Moviemaker

    and redo the voice acting! I wouldn't mind that.

  • I'll always love you, Lisa. :'(

  • I played this game through with my friend for the very first time two weeks ago, allthough I have own this game for years (PlayStation). When we played this game, this is the only scene I really remember afterwards. I came to Youtube looking for this song and this scene. The scene is so dramatic, and I think I fell In love with Lisa. It was sad seeing her die. She reminds me of my ex. Sad scene. :/

  • Few people realize that Harry's not comforting her is a way whoever wrote the story of SIlent Hill found to depict Harry's humanity, "regular guy-ness".

    He is afraid, like a human being. He is trying to find his daughter, not trying to be heroic.

    If you guys sensed danger on hugging that girl after so much had happened, wouldn't you be at least doubtful - and therefore fearful - of embracing her?

  • @arsnakehert Even if I didn't go through anything,I would seriously run away.

  • @arsnakehert no i find him to be a selfish man he wants everyone to help him and they try but when the shoes on the other foot he runs like a coward id easily kill that bitch if she'd of tried somefin' but no he ran and locked the door on her after shes helped him over more than one occasion i mean hes took on worse than puppet nurses so whats one more ? nothing thats what

  • @Blaze187Killa but that's what I'm talking about, people are selfish just like that! ^^

    I find your seeming unselfishness lovely, though. x)

  • @arsnakehert hahaha dont get me wrong i would probably do the same as him but for ppl who try help me and they turn like lisa id put a bullet in her head to save her the pain of bein' that thing haha prefer james over harry tbh tho

  • @arsnakehert

    You can be selfless and still experience fear.

  • @arsnakehert But she was so......arrggg *HUG*

    Although I have to agree with you, but then again it's a game.

  • I love how bad the Graphics are. It brings back memories. I love this scene. So moving~!

  • If that was me... I would hold her... I would comfort her. Harry, I'm sorry but in this scene you're such an asshole >:C

  • @RaveXanaike

    She's becoming a MONSTER and likely would have killed Harry.

  • I'm sooo glad I never got to this scene when I was a kid.

  • Lisa was the best character in Silent Hill.

  • this was the illest game ever

  • THIS IS THE FUCKING GOD DAMN VIDEO GAME!!!!! WHERE'S THE MOVIE VERSION?!!!!

  • @sorenguardian101 WOO CAPS LOCK. But seriously, who cares about the movie.

  • @rwesterh i do bitch

  • @sorenguardian101 there is a movie to it

  • @Left4DeadLOVER101 i know

  • YOU'RE TEARING ME APART, LISA!

  • If I was stranded in a creepy town fighting for my life against demonic creatures only to come this far to hear "I'm the same as them"I would have pointed my gun at her head and said "Oh hell to the fuckin no!Bitch get get away from me! "

  • So what happened to Lisa???

  • @theprettynice3000 @theprettynice3000 She realised she was already dead, so she ceased to exist. She realised that the only reason she was still "living" was the same reason all the other nurses were still there. She remained human because she didn't realize what had happened to her, as soon as she did, she became like the others, a monster. As for why she is gone if Harry goes back, that's not explained. Maybe she was spared, she only had to die, instead of dying and continuing to suffer.

  • @philbateman1989 Ohhhhh!!! Thanks for telling me. I get it now.....Really I owe you one because I never knew what happened to her.

  • ;^; Liiiiisa noooooo

  • i got a pyramid head on my arm tattooed

  • Hauntingly beautiful.

  • how did she die?

  • @sarahmostr Many people think she was killed by Dr. Michael Kaufmann.

  • Harry did what probably everyone would do. It's a dark side of yourself, but think of everything Harry's gone through. He just wants to find his daughter...

    Do you blame him?

  • @1ApertureRealist

    Feeling fear does not make one dark/evil.

  • Man I'm already confused. I don't know if she was turning into a puppet nurse or just dying. Harry might have also been wondering the same thing.

  • sum1 know who that is at 0:01 the left girl?

  • @TheLeong31 Look up "raiden metal gear solid 4: guns of the patriots" on google images. Btw, it's not a girl.

  • @TheLeong31 that actually dude, Raiden from Metal Gears Solid

  • poooor lisa awesome movie now i get it bout the nurse

  • what part is this in the game ?? :P

  • im confused so when she is asking him to stay by her she is already like ... dead ...but looks alive ??? or is she alive then randomly ..yea

  • And I was scared by this shit when I was a child? xDDDDDDDDDDDD

  • in the remake i dont like her so much... wouldnt it be great if they have had the original model and voice foor the remake... sorry, reimagination

  • Now I see why they killed her off, she was the only GOOD VA in the game, games couldn't tolerate that back then. Lisa was the only believable character for me in SH 1, I was almost in tears when I saw the blood coming down her face, her transforming into what she always was, but didn't realize until then, her cries were so real, it was believably sad.

  • This scene made me so sad back than :(

  • ill save YOU LISA....*Chik CHik**Loads 2 bullets in gun* *BAMMMMM SHES DEAD!!!!*

  • im confused how did she die?

  • @87thiare She actually one of them, that scene is when she actually realise she's part of monster

  • one of the saddest scene in the game, would never ever forget it :(

  • LMFAO. That guy said there might be pizza.

    I'm kinda. Eh.. Stoic about Lisa's death.. She whined a lot.. :/ And couldn't control herself with those drugs. :(

  • lisa luv.....

  • oooh, is that what happens when you dont use tampons?

    wait...I HEAR KNOCKING ON THE DOOR, OPEN UP, IT MIGHT BE DA PIZZAH DUUUDE

  • this is one of those games where you have to have played it to feel sad, i only feel a little bit sad, but if i had played the whole game there might have been tears from my eyes

  • this scene is one of few in gaming history that really affected me (most ARE from SH, though). SO utterly disturbing...you gotta love it! 

  • how did lisa die anyway?

  • Uh, Lisa? You got a little something... now it's ... nevermind.

  • One of the most saddest scenes in the series.

  • I'm surprised they haven't remade this game yet. =O!

  • @FunkyMonkeybb

    ... they did.

    It's called 'Shattered Memories'

  • @espeonfreak Shattered Memories is FAR from a remake. >_>

  • @FunkyMonkeybb

    Didn't say it was any good.

    It still counts even though it's more of an re-imagining .

  • @FunkyMonkeybb yea its a re-imagining, basically taking place in this time, not 1996 where the original is based.

  • I'm SO cosplaying as her :D

  • This is the Scariest and Saddest part of all.^_^ its Sad to be Hated

  • They so underused Lisa in the movie, she was a great character and this scene should of made it to the movie.

  • a true survivor horror class=SILENT HILL

  • It is amazing how sad you can feel for someone who is not even real, It's like you almost wish she was real, just so you could save her.

  • The first time I played this part, I just kinda put the controller down and sat there for a couple minutes, collecting my thoughts. Poor Lisa.

  • How would you feel if your partner happens this?

    :( if it happened to my girlfriend, i gone cry and embrace she

  • sorry i know everyone is branding this as the greatest scene in game history but i have never played silent hill can someone tell me why this is emotional. and the events leading up to this scene

  • @halo3e2w1q Not nearly the same effect unless you play the game yourself, but... this scene is sad and poignant for two big reasons. 1) Lisa's not dying, only changing. It is worse than death. She's becoming one of "them" - not alive, not dead - condemned to the nightmare world. To Hell. Lisa knows exactly what's happening and what it means. 2) Harry cannot save her. He never could. You realize now that her fate was sealed long before you met her, full of hope, hours before this scene occurs...

  • @GAMMATRON5000 ah thank you i am going to see a walkthrough to grasp the events leading up to this i know its not the same effect as playing it but i just need to know. i seem to understand the basis... so you were harry gone into silent hill then meet a girl named lisa.... then she learns she may be one of them... then you try to save her, then you think you have saved her until this scene... suppose im way off

  • @halo3e2w1q Yes and no. Easiest thing for you to do if you're not gonna play the game is go to a channel on here - username is Fungo. That person has every cutscene from Silent Hill on a playlist, so you can watch them straight through in order. There is SO much more to the experience than that though. Just watching cutscenes is like trying to understand what sex feels like by watching pr0ns. But... if you're never going to play the game, it'll give you a better idea of the plot and story.

  • Lisa got what she deserved. In Silent Hill: Origins, it's revealed that she helped create the evil in Silent Hill.

  • YokoFactor sent me here

  • Harry is an all around awesome character, BESIDES THIS BULLSHIT.

    She's not a zombie you know. Seriously, what the hell Harry? Worried about getting blood on your clothes? Fuck you.

  • @LamentOfInnocence1 wait, so why didn't he help her??

  • @pussylumpessru Imagine you are Harry,a guy who has seen and fought countless scary shit monsters and ran almost endlessly through Nightmare places. Then one of your allies suddenly freaks out about her true identity in front of you and starts bleeding everywhere and have trouble walking. You cant really blame the poor guy for leaving her,considering all the heavy shit hes been through.....

  • @Kadaj158 Oh. It's funny when she attacks kauffman in one of the endings

  • @Kadaj158

    AGREED!

  • @LamentOfInnocence1 Well Harry has to SURVIVE to find his daughter and with all the demonic stuff thats happening he had no choice but to run

  • @LamentOfInnocence1 She's dead idiot.No one normally bleeds like that normally.After going all through that shit,you expect Harry to hug and help Lisa?Dude, I bet you would definitely do the same thing so yeah fuck you instead.

  • @LamentOfInnocence1 she might of been on her period dude if i was harry i wouldernt wana givbe her a rainbow kiss tbh

  • It should be on the floor, when Harry comes in the room again

  • Where's diary?

    "Asked the Doctor to let me quit being in charge of that patient.

    It's too weird. Still alive,but with wounds that won't heal.

    Told the doctor I quit. Won't work at that Hospital anymore.The room is filled with insects.

    Even with the doors and windows shut,they get in to spite me.

    To the Hospital... Feeling bad. Need to throw up. But nothing comes out.

    Vomiting only bile. Blood and pus flow from the bathroom faucet. I try to stop it,but it won't turn off.

    Need drug. Help me..."

  • @Amfluter Is the drug she needs the White Claudia or is it that red liquid you get to save Cybil with?

  • @TheQueenofMars White Claudia, exaclty. Right before Harry enters the code "ALERT" and comes in the room to start the dialog at this video,there was many boxes "Psycho TV" to the left of him. Its a name of the drug, that made of White Claudia plant. By the way, in the far corner of the room in video these boxes are also possible to see.

  • @TheQueenofMars One more thing. Lisa appears only in NIGHTMARE Alchemilla in all the game, that points at her deep drug addiction. She couldn't percept ordinary world even short while.

    But the red liquid is Aglaophotis, something like anti-demon stuff, that you can find in smashed vessel in the Alchemilla's Hospital (to save Cybil for "+" ending) and near the bike in the bottle at the far part of the town (to save Alessa/Cheryl for "Good" ending). Liquid of Destiny )

  • @TheQueenofMars the drug shes adicted to is called PTV

  • Its just tragic. Screw you damn monsters. I fuck up every last one of ya! DIE! In all games! WAHAHA!

  • when I played it and saw this disturbing scene. I knew for the fact that Lisa's was damned for eternity. I used to have the game

  • I understand why you guys feel bad for her when he wouldnt hug her...but thats what makes it more sad, that he ignores her. So thing about that.

  • Old memories....sad memories.....

    Greatt game!!!!

  • Wow, just thinking bout this now, very easy to find on youtube. Played this when I was 14 before it came out in the UK and the "copy" I had was in black & white for some reason but this game just made me soak up every single little detail, it was difficult as hell cause I was used to playing super mario- not this shit! But I was so captured by it I didn't want to give up, and I remember being like 'I gotta help that chick' then this scene happened and my heart sunk, like, I couldn't save her.

  • My all time best video game moment. Never thought you could be sad playing a video game until this.

  • PEOPLE OUT THERE READ THIS ................. This Scene Is Really Fucked Uhp ....... 1. at 045 harry shud of stayed by her and at 0:59 The Dum Cock Suckker Pushed Her So Fucking HARD iNTO tHE wALL aND hurt her .. HEY SILENT HILL FANS PLAY SH3 HOMCOMING TO WATCH HARRY DIE ...... HHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

  • @DarthVader323610 Your a real asshole so you enjoy watching the man who saved the world die! At least he acted classy and didn't do what you did. And she didn't die from a demon she died because she was already dead and alessa power was weariing out so her so her soul went away!

  • @SocietyBreaker No Your THe Ashole Who Leaves These Shitty Ass Comments On Youtube To Try To Act Cool Infront Of Your Mom SO u Can GO Fuck Her U Fagget GO FUCK UR MOM GO SUCK UR DADS DICK Pussyyy

  • @DarthVader323610 No I am not try to act cool if you say "Hey everyone do you like seeing this person dying" yeah alot of people will be pissed of

  • This is the sadest thing in game history

  • without a doubt, the most moving part of gaming history in its time

  • It really is heartbreaking. Makes me sad just watching it now, the music does it share to heighten the emotional side of it. Poor poor Lisa...

  • This scene left a big impression on me. I remember playing that part of the game 11 years ago. I love this song btw.

  • i dont get what happened... can someone tell me. i have never played this game before or heard of it, so i dont know whats going on. so can you help me out? thanx to much!

  • @TheAmazingLauren She doesn't know that she is one of the Undead nurses, that's why she is the only one "alive".

  • @TheAmazingLauren

    Lisa Garland was a nurse who was charged to nurse alessa.

    in the games she is mostly seen in "the otherworld" when the whole towns starts to decay and turn evil. By the end of the game she is driven to the conclusion that she is in fact dead. Shortly after telling harry this, blood trickles from various wounds in a manifestation of that conclusion. She begs Harry to save her, stumbling towards him, but Harry flees the room and bars her exit from behind a closed door.

  • 1:09 to 1:32 Tragic :(

  • This scene affected me a lot when i first played this and still does, it deserves an oscar of some sort, kinda felt sad she died, usually in a game you don't care but this i did, ALMOST cried ;)

  • in the begginging i saw master chief hey do u know when reach ish coming out

  • @AstuteClass Me, too.

    ^_^

  • This scene was sad.

  • I got "save me from them" tattooed on my back because this moment affected me so much when I first played this game...over ten years ago now.

    Lisa is my favorite game character ever.

  • My favorite character from this game.

  • Um...... Why was lisa bleeding randomly? DId he push her to the wall too hard? If not, how was she one of them?

  • @CupNoodles991

    if you were following the story you would understand why she bleeds.....

  • @CupNoodles991 >.> It's part of the story. She's one of them the whole time; she never was a human. She was just a monster that was fabricated to appear as the friendly nurse the little girl who's imagining her remembers her to be.

  • this is how games should be great story line and great gameplay who gives a fuck about graphics

  • Dose she really die or does she turn in to one of them?

    this is so sad..I haven't played the game but this is just so sad i hardly know anything about Silent Hill but i just love this scene I am playing origins now though

  • @xlilxcreepyxgirlx Lisa "dies" in a sense that she's most certainly no longer human. She mutates and is just a monster, never really being alive in the first place.

  • disgusting way to die...poor lisa :'(

  • Great game ^-^

  • can someone explain this to me please? i havent played the game and i cannot be bothered to play it just to work this out

  • When I watch this video, It reminds me of my cousin's friend..He did the same thing in this video and Both of them made it as a parody...it was very funny!!!