One thing I find weirdly fascinating is which singers use appoggiaturas and when. Schrott is not exactly a singer known for period-style precision, but he uses quite a few appoggiaturas (like on "e l'usanza"), probably more than the more period-trained Finley.
Of course although appoggiaturas are authentic, they should depend on whether the performer feels comfortable with them (conductors who insist on them all the time aren't any more right than the older ones who banned them entirely).
This part of the second act really demonstrates the difference between an Opera and a play. Imagine trying to have this many people speak at once during a play. It would just become noise. But in Opera, you can have as many people speak as you want. By the end of this act, there are twenty people with different parts on stage singing at once.
@Otaku155 you are so right. mozart's genius was in putting everything together as the musical texture enriched along with the characters coming together to build towards the climax. incredible. I studied and worked on this with singers long ago...and professors told me it is considered one of the most feared sections in all opera to put together . VERY complicated despite what mozart shows effortlessly. my favorite musical section was always the start of this "pt.2 video". beautiful lines
@tedly10027 especially from 0:31 "sir, we ask you..." until the musical line climaxes on "what is delaying marzellina?" what a beautiful line....it always tugs my heart after all these years.
@Otaku155 "The end of the second act for example ... In a play, if more than one person speaks at the same time it's just noise; no one can understand a word, but with opera - with music - with music, you can have twenty individuals all talking at the same time and it's not noise, it's a perfect harmony."
Any similarity between your comment and that quote from Amadeus? There aren't even 20 people here! "Mozart" was just saying you CAN have 20 people all singing at the same time.
I dont think so...here her singing is as always great- but the asthetics of the salzburg prod. are much better for her and her emotion is better in the salz prod.
I find the bland set too distracting (weird, huh). You are going "What the hell are they DOing????" faarrr too much to be enjoying the music. 3 women making out on stage, Barbarina losing her virginity, the use of a high soprano for both Cherubino (sort of ok for me) AND Marcellina (uh uh, no way), and Anna Netrebko (hot)as Susanna, which requires a light voice, not full like Netrebko (still hot), and the WEIRDEST tempo I have EVER heard for some pieces makes it TOO WEIRD to pay attention.
pues a lo mejor tengo algo q te puede interesar (si no lo tienes claro)...Le nozze di Figaro en Aix en Provence con Camilla Tilling Marco Vinco (creo) Laurent Naouri, Magdalena Kozena y....Veronique Gens claro XDD
Es mejor que con Jacobs? Jacobs fa schifo (come se dice en espanol?) come conductor..Si es buena, pues quiero oir dove sono e porgi amor :) Gracias amigo!
schifo? Can you write in English please XD?, well, Dove sono it's great, and Porgi amor too (Veronique it's a great Countess, and the rest of the cast is so good)
It means he is a crappy conductor :) His Figaro is great, and I used to love him for it, but I think now its because of the cast and not him. Horrible Don Giovanni he made...
Well his cosi is the best recording I've heard of it, but just listen to the difference between Gens singing come scoglio in the Mozart cd and in the Jacobs cosi...the Mozart cd just has more life and energy. I've turned around completely on Jacobs.
It could be that Jacobs just gets some Mozart operas more than others... I get the impression he's straining for effect in his Don Giovanni CD and DVD (though I still like both) while his Figaro and Cosi feel more natural. Every conductor has classics that he's really good at and those that he doesn't quite gel with.
On a related note, for example, I think Pappano really seems to connect with FIGARO. The energy and drive and appropriateness he brings to it are not always evident in other works.
Who's playing the Countess? She's fabulous.
Judill 3 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Who else agrees that this is the best production EVER!?
leporello56 3 months ago
orchestra is too loud!!
mouthmouse 4 months ago
Do you know there can be one fundamental "Urtakt" to this entire finale up to the piu allegro after the other trio has entered?
ksmith610 5 months ago
@Otaku155 that's true, but with out a libretto you would have no idea what any of them are saying!
rvaughanwilliams1988 10 months ago
This is sheer bliss and perfection. :28 on. LOVE IT!!! Brava!
darlinglisa7 11 months ago
who is bartolo in this?
leporello56 1 year ago
Great production all around; also answers the question what would it be like if Tony Danza worked for former NY Governor Elliot Spitzer...
cjurakpt 1 year ago 2
hahha Bartolo and Rosina at 9:56
chrizosthemis 2 years ago
@chrizosthemis I don't know any rosina here!
mouthmouse 1 year ago
@mouthmouse Rosina is another name of Countess Almaviva.
chrizosthemis 1 year ago
@chrizosthemis Ah yes I remember! Sorry!
mouthmouse 1 year ago
One thing I find weirdly fascinating is which singers use appoggiaturas and when. Schrott is not exactly a singer known for period-style precision, but he uses quite a few appoggiaturas (like on "e l'usanza"), probably more than the more period-trained Finley.
Of course although appoggiaturas are authentic, they should depend on whether the performer feels comfortable with them (conductors who insist on them all the time aren't any more right than the older ones who banned them entirely).
thesafekind 2 years ago
Thanks a lot for this upload. it looks brilliant. I've never been to an opera, but must go and watch this live.
IanM1984 2 years ago 2
who is the antonio? what a fantastic actor for the opera stage
byertalley 2 years ago 5
@byertalley Jeremy White. He's indeed amazing!!! "I didn't see any horse jump from the window" XD XD
papagena92 1 year ago
Too many notes.
NicosNicosNicosNicos 2 years ago 11
wondeful production. But the orchestra play too loud!
mouthmouse 2 years ago
I agree. It almost sounds like the Orchestra is on mic
Otaku155 2 years ago
And their parts where we don't hear singers ( 08:59 sadly my favorite part of this scene :-) )
mouthmouse 2 years ago
I wish my Count costume was that nice...
jeffro887 3 years ago 2
This part of the second act really demonstrates the difference between an Opera and a play. Imagine trying to have this many people speak at once during a play. It would just become noise. But in Opera, you can have as many people speak as you want. By the end of this act, there are twenty people with different parts on stage singing at once.
Otaku155 3 years ago
Thanks for paraphrasing from amadeus.
elias12186 3 years ago 18
@Otaku155 you are so right. mozart's genius was in putting everything together as the musical texture enriched along with the characters coming together to build towards the climax. incredible. I studied and worked on this with singers long ago...and professors told me it is considered one of the most feared sections in all opera to put together . VERY complicated despite what mozart shows effortlessly. my favorite musical section was always the start of this "pt.2 video". beautiful lines
tedly10027 1 year ago
@tedly10027 especially from 0:31 "sir, we ask you..." until the musical line climaxes on "what is delaying marzellina?" what a beautiful line....it always tugs my heart after all these years.
tedly10027 1 year ago
@Otaku155 "The end of the second act for example ... In a play, if more than one person speaks at the same time it's just noise; no one can understand a word, but with opera - with music - with music, you can have twenty individuals all talking at the same time and it's not noise, it's a perfect harmony."
Any similarity between your comment and that quote from Amadeus? There aren't even 20 people here! "Mozart" was just saying you CAN have 20 people all singing at the same time.
8Ho03EdONl1liL 6 months ago
As much as I LOVE Finley, why on EARTH did he pussy out on the second "ola, silencio" and not do the interpolation?
come on!
lucyliesinashes 3 years ago
Figaro really looks like Joey in "Friends", lol. Great to see Miah Persson, she's lovely.
ElinBagis 3 years ago
Isn't he? I'm thinkin' about it since I know his face :-))
Funny to watch Joey singing like this :-)
terezqa 2 years ago
k*tmuziek
DhrSoulslayer 3 years ago
I absolutely adore this production. Loved the cat fight too. ;)
operaticxingenue 3 years ago
Oh I think, Röschmann sings the Countess on this production very better than in the production of Salzburg!!
aeru9 3 years ago
I dont think so...here her singing is as always great- but the asthetics of the salzburg prod. are much better for her and her emotion is better in the salz prod.
hillevifan 3 years ago
Ok!
aeru9 3 years ago
I find the bland set too distracting (weird, huh). You are going "What the hell are they DOing????" faarrr too much to be enjoying the music. 3 women making out on stage, Barbarina losing her virginity, the use of a high soprano for both Cherubino (sort of ok for me) AND Marcellina (uh uh, no way), and Anna Netrebko (hot)as Susanna, which requires a light voice, not full like Netrebko (still hot), and the WEIRDEST tempo I have EVER heard for some pieces makes it TOO WEIRD to pay attention.
olympicfreak678 3 years ago
is the basilio philip langridge?
hillevifan 3 years ago
Yep
GianniSchicchi73 3 years ago
Thanks!!!!!!! The best Nozze...
leporello89 3 years ago
De nada amigo :)
elias12186 3 years ago
Jeje, in spanish XD Cada vez me gusta mas Roschmann, q Contessa!!!! :)
leporello89 3 years ago
Cuando has escuciado Veronique Gens, no hay otra contessa... :)Deveras es la mejor Gens...e bella!
elias12186 3 years ago
pues a lo mejor tengo algo q te puede interesar (si no lo tienes claro)...Le nozze di Figaro en Aix en Provence con Camilla Tilling Marco Vinco (creo) Laurent Naouri, Magdalena Kozena y....Veronique Gens claro XDD
leporello89 3 years ago
Un video? Pues certo que lo quiero! Donde la encontraste?
elias12186 3 years ago
lo siento, es audio, pero con muy buena calidad, jeje, si aun asi te interesa te lo puedo mandar
leporello89 3 years ago
Es mejor que con Jacobs? Jacobs fa schifo (come se dice en espanol?) come conductor..Si es buena, pues quiero oir dove sono e porgi amor :) Gracias amigo!
elias12186 3 years ago
schifo? Can you write in English please XD?, well, Dove sono it's great, and Porgi amor too (Veronique it's a great Countess, and the rest of the cast is so good)
Colgaré Porgi Amor y Dove sono :)
leporello89 3 years ago
It means he is a crappy conductor :) His Figaro is great, and I used to love him for it, but I think now its because of the cast and not him. Horrible Don Giovanni he made...
elias12186 3 years ago
Well, his Cosi is great, but Don Giovanni...
Alexandrina Pendatchanska it's a great Donna Elvira, but the rest of the cast...:-S
leporello89 3 years ago
Well his cosi is the best recording I've heard of it, but just listen to the difference between Gens singing come scoglio in the Mozart cd and in the Jacobs cosi...the Mozart cd just has more life and energy. I've turned around completely on Jacobs.
elias12186 3 years ago
Well, I've both CD's but I haven't compared Come scoglio...bueno, tendré q hacerlo (lo siento pero mi ingles ahora mismo no da para mas XDD)
leporello89 3 years ago
It could be that Jacobs just gets some Mozart operas more than others... I get the impression he's straining for effect in his Don Giovanni CD and DVD (though I still like both) while his Figaro and Cosi feel more natural. Every conductor has classics that he's really good at and those that he doesn't quite gel with.
On a related note, for example, I think Pappano really seems to connect with FIGARO. The energy and drive and appropriateness he brings to it are not always evident in other works.
thesafekind 2 years ago
Por cierto, Conductor....Minkowski
leporello89 3 years ago
Yes I like Minkowski, but I tend to prefer McGegan's recordings. In Ariodante you get to compare the 2 so well :)
elias12186 3 years ago
No conozco a McGegan...pero lo buscaré :)
leporello89 3 years ago
Do you like Baroque opera? He has a few Handel recordings. I've actually never heard him in anything besides Handel.
elias12186 3 years ago
Si! Me encanta el barroco, pero tengo poco... me tengo q poner al dia con ello XD
leporello89 3 years ago