she got through to everyone, to Paula, the other judges, her family, the viewers, everyone. even to her dad all the way in heaven smiling down at her.
Not freaky to me. I think that was very brave of her to do that. And just like every father who loves their children, if he was alive, he would've wanted her to go no matter what happened to him.
@tokesx3802 yοu ϲan watϲh tv frοm аll over tհe ԝorld οո yoսr pс јuѕt by dowոloаdinց ѕomе рrogram, іt's gοt tհοuѕandѕ of ϲhаոnels οn it. ϳuѕt ցo tο linevid com (рut a . befοre the com obvіoսѕly, it won't lеt me post lіոkѕ for ѕome rеaѕoո) іt'ѕ ոot exаctly frеe bսt іt'ѕ јսst οոe time раyment аnd іt works rеally ԝell
This was really sad...but i'm confused. If my dad died 2 days ago, I would be curled up in a corner bawling my eyes out. i mean 2 days! how is she doing this?
@RunningWithRum ...well it's like Paula said, "that's where passion comes in." I commend this young lady on her will and strength to go on. WOW is all I can say.
yeah, this was heartbreaking, this girl could sing too... on a lighter note, I thought it was funny how paula wanted to be so emotional but she couldn't cry cuz her face is frozen solid from too much botox.
@KENZeichen she was voted off in top 16, i think. So sad, i thought she should be the one winning. She has an amazing voice and i like her personality as well....
just heard her track called "Outta Time" which uses the Bone Thugs sample "1st of Tha Month" and it's pretty hot! I think there may be some comparisons to other female singers (first one I think of is Keyshia) but Im glad she's trying to keep it going with the music career
Aww this is so heartbreaking... I'm impressed at how she could even sing without completely falling apart. She poured a lot of feeling to that and she really moved me... I think she's a brilliant singer! She should have been in the top 12 instead of Kristy Lee or Ramiele or probably Amanda... and make it to Top 4 or 5 at least!
I really want to begin watching full films and tv shows on youtube, but too bad that is certainly never going to occur. diecoward, that's the reason I am choosing |stream episodes [dot] net| at this moment to be able to watch the tv shows and movies and youtube for everything else!
She just never lived up to the potential of this audition. Whether it was the pressure of the big live shows or whatever, but I really wanted her to do well and she just didn't do what I thought she was capable of.
I don't think I'll ever forget her. Kristy Lee Cook is not a bad singer, but I still did NOT get how she got more votes than Asia'h when they were choosing the top 12. I honestly didn't
Well I only singled out KLC because the choosing came down to the two of them and Seacrest was all "Who do you think will get to the next round between these two?" If it had been Ramielle, though she is also not a bad singer, I would have also singled her out against Asia'h~ I hope she still becomes successful in life.
I honestly don't think that they put her through because of her story (even though I'm very sorry that it happened), but she sang the HELL out of that song, like seriously!!!
@ilovemusic4529 ....I totally agree with you. I got chills from her angelic voice. The young lady was awesome and I know that her father would have been very very proud and was smiling down on her.
One of the most touching,heartbreaking auditions ever in American Idol! Only few people have the courage and inner strength to do what she did here in the most horrible circumstances possible. And she definetely deserved to go further in that year's American Idol 2008! But let's hope that once again those who are truly talented will be blessed in the end of the day,sometimes it may take even years but some day their time will come! So be ready to hear more about her in the future :)
i really like her alot honestly i can relate to her i was suppose to try out august 2009 with my sis buyt she ppassed away months earlier in march...her voice was a bit horse but that was only from her being upset and crying over her dad passing.
@p111067 Thats too bad that you couldn't feel an individuals pain thru her song and actually feel some of her grief. Maybe you didn't understand the song and the context in which she was singing it in.
OMG......that was so sad.......the story about her Dad killed me.......I'm sure he is in heaven smiling down on everything she does........
Paula we love you......Fox better bring you back! I do not like that Kara chick :-( Paula is a consummate professional and I trust her judgement and feedback much more than Kara's
it makes me cry too. it's amazing how she sang so beautifully while going through so much pain. i seriously wish she went way farther in the competition. she was at least top 10 worthy
Asiah you make me so proud every time I hear you sing. I hope everything will work out for you. I love and I can't wait to see you back home sometime!
I WENT THROUGH JOPLIN MISSOURI WHERE SHE IS FROM aND MY COUSIN THAT LIVES THERE SHOWED WAS WHERE HER DAD PASSED BUT ANYWAY SHE CAN SING IW ONDER WAT SHE DOING NOW
she has very good voice and whoah... so brave to do that...i wonder why she didn't even made it to the top six...hmmm... so sad... she's a great singer. i'm sure there's sumthin good out there that's meant for her.
This has been flagged as spam show
wagner sings a cappelle, take a look
waggietoo 3 weeks ago in playlist AMERICAN IDOL BEST
15 people never had a dad and dont know how to sing
williambarkley911 1 month ago
I SAW HER ON EXCUSED!!! Poor girl had to resort to dating shows..
rosaliehalevampire 1 month ago
she got through to everyone, to Paula, the other judges, her family, the viewers, everyone. even to her dad all the way in heaven smiling down at her.
MiladyToxic 2 months ago
this girl is amazing and very talented she will make it far
Brebradl 2 months ago
i no her she is a good friend she sang for my 3rd birthday in 2001
hawtgirlz143 5 months ago
its just freaky that she actually auditioned while his fathers funeral must have been going on :O
MrDoodly999 7 months ago
Not freaky to me. I think that was very brave of her to do that. And just like every father who loves their children, if he was alive, he would've wanted her to go no matter what happened to him.
popups46okay 5 months ago
tears
JamaicanApostolic 7 months ago
Striaght from JOMO(:
i love this girl haha
shes amazing, and fun to be around.
her family is awesome.. her dad was a great guy(:
countrylovinz 7 months ago
shes so beautiful and gorgeous. God bless her.
0680496 8 months ago
i love her i just saw on mediatakeout her ex tried to beat him he can go straight to hell i hope everything goes well for her
mzlautner16 8 months ago
really inspiring... i admire this woman so much
andyelde 8 months ago
im at work crying watching this.....omgee it was beautiful :)
senior09bre 11 months ago
she's amazing
rewelikson 11 months ago
wow shes so strong,id quit if my papa died
Rebealia 11 months ago
shes beautiful, & an amazing singer.
magdagirl241 1 year ago
Aawwww her story was sooo sad. I cried when she left... :(
harryhermionerone1 1 year ago
she can sing nd thtz sooooooooooooooooo sad bout wht happened wit ha daddy im glad she made it
afwatt 1 year ago 2
love ya xoxo
MrRockstarr89 1 year ago
everything in 5th grade sed that i looked like her. bt i didnt think i did
YDD18 1 year ago
everything in 5th grade sed that i looked like her. bt i did bt not anymore
YDD18 1 year ago
Oh my God she is amazing she has so much spirit and passion. I couldn't do that
jess401 1 year ago 3
amazing.
iaaamy 1 year ago
12 people..idk but dey got problems for disin her. she is truly amazing.
5150thornton 1 year ago 3
@tokesx3802 yοu ϲan watϲh tv frοm аll over tհe ԝorld οո yoսr pс јuѕt by dowոloаdinց ѕomе рrogram, іt's gοt tհοuѕandѕ of ϲhаոnels οn it. ϳuѕt ցo tο linevid com (рut a . befοre the com obvіoսѕly, it won't lеt me post lіոkѕ for ѕome rеaѕoո) іt'ѕ ոot exаctly frеe bսt іt'ѕ јսst οոe time раyment аnd іt works rеally ԝell
vcmooseidiot655 1 year ago
aw i love this clip,Paula is so sensitive i love her and
xCharLovesPaulax 1 year ago 6
is the hoarseness just how her voice is? just asking or is it a vocal issue? shes gorgeous
DESYREE1sexysinger 1 year ago
Oh no... what a sad story about her dad... alot people would not have continue on
whataname01 1 year ago
GOD BLESS HER!!!!!!!!I love this girl!!!!!
gtech20 1 year ago
This was really sad...but i'm confused. If my dad died 2 days ago, I would be curled up in a corner bawling my eyes out. i mean 2 days! how is she doing this?
RunningWithRum 1 year ago
@RunningWithRum ...well it's like Paula said, "that's where passion comes in." I commend this young lady on her will and strength to go on. WOW is all I can say.
3789MHArmstrong 10 months ago
Why should America be tortured by this? I guess America enjoys pain in the ears.
Tell me, where is this singer now?
NO WHERE!
Why? Because 99.9 of these contestants are NOT STARS.
Paula Abdul? She is a STAR? Of what?
The rest?
The problem with this show is that no one tells the TRUTH.
JR08620 1 year ago
aawww poor girl she is a beautiful singer though
TheQueenGia 1 year ago 2
yeah, this was heartbreaking, this girl could sing too... on a lighter note, I thought it was funny how paula wanted to be so emotional but she couldn't cry cuz her face is frozen solid from too much botox.
jimbeezy07 1 year ago
sob story!! Paula's beautiful here
blueblond1 1 year ago
ireally like this girl, my favorites were her an jordin <3
imwayy2bomb 1 year ago
CO TAM ROBI MAJKEL DŹEKSON
DjTowotDjWania 1 year ago
brought me to tears..i love her
mpascual5541 1 year ago
LOL, she's in jail right now. Did you all know that? XD. She beat up a girl in a nightclub.
TeaTimewithKyle 1 year ago 4
@TeaTimewithKyle she is my cousin,and if u don't believe me u can go on facebook and ask her.my name is mckenzie.
jepperson2011 1 year ago
@TeaTimewithKyle and she got out a few hours after it,and she did not beat up a girl!GEEZE!!
jepperson2011 1 year ago
she has an outstanding voice... unique... what happend to her? did she win? a very sad story..
KENZeichen 1 year ago
@KENZeichen she was voted off in top 16, i think. So sad, i thought she should be the one winning. She has an amazing voice and i like her personality as well....
tennisfan2808 1 year ago
sad story.
uncoverbrother 1 year ago
I Feel your pain!!!
younggiggas 1 year ago
wow,,that made me cry!
ciaraday02 1 year ago
i love her voice and with the song also made me tear...
Nightlylioness 1 year ago
man i cried!!!
deysweetgirl 1 year ago 2
Damn I got goosebumps..She sounded good..Loved her voice..
UniqueMonique513 1 year ago
You are fantastic! I wish to hear more songs from you!
CJOYBABES 1 year ago
she is beautiful!!! :) Paula's so sweet too :)
OzFreak22 1 year ago
Who are the 11 Jackass' who voted down!?
Paulwhoisvegan 1 year ago 10
just heard her track called "Outta Time" which uses the Bone Thugs sample "1st of Tha Month" and it's pretty hot! I think there may be some comparisons to other female singers (first one I think of is Keyshia) but Im glad she's trying to keep it going with the music career
IBMo615 1 year ago
She got a mixtape cominq out called Deal With It
ST0RMi14 1 year ago
SHE WAS LIKE ONE OF THE GREATEST...VERY TALENTED AND IT WAS VERY EMOTIONAL
VettDaMc 1 year ago
Aww this is so heartbreaking... I'm impressed at how she could even sing without completely falling apart. She poured a lot of feeling to that and she really moved me... I think she's a brilliant singer! She should have been in the top 12 instead of Kristy Lee or Ramiele or probably Amanda... and make it to Top 4 or 5 at least!
elpelozzz 1 year ago
She just signed a deal with mega producer Babyface so things are looking good for her.
Geezyone 1 year ago 2
she's a sweetheart.
jimmmmie 1 year ago
this makes me cry u can feel her pain i cried that shits touching
HHETVSH0W 1 year ago
her voice is so touching
BraBaBe 1 year ago
I really want to begin watching full films and tv shows on youtube, but too bad that is certainly never going to occur. diecoward, that's the reason I am choosing |stream episodes [dot] net| at this moment to be able to watch the tv shows and movies and youtube for everything else!
FOX American Idol 2008- Asia'h Epperson
bobnichols895 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
We dont like the new youtube, and we wanna show youtube that we dont! Copy and paste this on every video you see!
macroevolve 1 year ago
i loved paula.. sad that she's gone.. Girl has an amazing voice
biancadoss11 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
10 performers and nine spots left after tonight. Saw the last show at lastnightstvshows (.) com who will be going home tonight?
crookedlegacy761 1 year ago
Tears!
Marjiii333 1 year ago
Gosh i couldent have done that..shes awsome =D
bigredfromdownsouth 1 year ago 5
She's an incredibly brave young lady. God bless her.
macroevolve 1 year ago 10
She just never lived up to the potential of this audition. Whether it was the pressure of the big live shows or whatever, but I really wanted her to do well and she just didn't do what I thought she was capable of.
cuchelo1 1 year ago
i like her voice, she can sing, but did anybody else notice that kind of voice popping thing she was doing. i didn't like that voice poppin' lol.
jimbeezy07 1 year ago
if you dont cry your not human
EricTheGolfer 1 year ago 4
true
itsmeanthony 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
after watching the show it wasn't hard to see why she was voted off.
notusguy 2 years ago
*sniff* such a sad story......
newmoonfreak000 2 years ago
i really thoght she was going to go far in the competition, she has winner all over her but the stoy was different!!
ronaldguz 2 years ago 3
I don't think I'll ever forget her. Kristy Lee Cook is not a bad singer, but I still did NOT get how she got more votes than Asia'h when they were choosing the top 12. I honestly didn't
FMAGSGB 2 years ago 6
@FMAGSGB I totally agree! Actually Ramielle shouldn't have been in the top 12 at all!
Smileyglo 2 years ago
Well I only singled out KLC because the choosing came down to the two of them and Seacrest was all "Who do you think will get to the next round between these two?" If it had been Ramielle, though she is also not a bad singer, I would have also singled her out against Asia'h~ I hope she still becomes successful in life.
FMAGSGB 2 years ago
she is a good singer thoo
emilia223 2 years ago
I think she is beautiful.
bridgett167 2 years ago 4
I honestly don't think that they put her through because of her story (even though I'm very sorry that it happened), but she sang the HELL out of that song, like seriously!!!
ilovemusic4529 2 years ago 60
@ilovemusic4529 ....I totally agree with you. I got chills from her angelic voice. The young lady was awesome and I know that her father would have been very very proud and was smiling down on her.
3789MHArmstrong 10 months ago
thats my cousinn!!! =)
kiki122094 2 years ago
how could you not tear up while watching? the circumstances were devastating. idk how she did it.
volleydancer1221 2 years ago 3
She had alot of courage to go up there and sing....if it was me I couldn't have done that...
daffytv 2 years ago 4
shes reealllyy good!!
gen11gen 2 years ago
I really hope this girl makes it big someday, she's one of the best there is in my opinion.
rachieskltn 2 years ago 78
@rachieskltn Looks like she's about to do some really big things very soon! Check out the article on Bossip (dot) com posted today(May 10th, 2010).
ubersoul 1 year ago
One of the most touching,heartbreaking auditions ever in American Idol! Only few people have the courage and inner strength to do what she did here in the most horrible circumstances possible. And she definetely deserved to go further in that year's American Idol 2008! But let's hope that once again those who are truly talented will be blessed in the end of the day,sometimes it may take even years but some day their time will come! So be ready to hear more about her in the future :)
JakeSnake7878 2 years ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
uhmmm ... why do they always compliment the ones who make it even before they sang like they just know
ive seen peopple on here who look like their def. gonna make it and end up sucking, but they dont compliment them?
colored12beads 2 years ago
WTF r u talking about?¿
Dallas3212 2 years ago
woow she is a amazing singer and she is so beautiful like to have a girlfriend like her
ni99a4eva 2 years ago 5
lol "a girlfriend like her" it's cause she's light skinned.
Beetwate305 2 years ago
i really like her alot honestly i can relate to her i was suppose to try out august 2009 with my sis buyt she ppassed away months earlier in march...her voice was a bit horse but that was only from her being upset and crying over her dad passing.
bootylicious4u21989 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i dont like her voice and i didnt felt even a bit sad with this :s
p111067 2 years ago
@p111067 Thats too bad that you couldn't feel an individuals pain thru her song and actually feel some of her grief. Maybe you didn't understand the song and the context in which she was singing it in.
melkayla 2 years ago 3
this vide actally made me cry. that is just down right amazing. paula's right. she has sooo much passion. and i'm truly sorry about her dad...
cheerlady2011 2 years ago 10
I like her. =} She seems cool. I don't know what I would do without my dad.
4Blindian4 2 years ago 5
gets me every every time!
eirrac2009loaf 2 years ago 9
What the fuck?... I don't cry very often. That had my crying like a fuckin 2year old. I got mad props for that girl.
basslessb69 2 years ago 4
WOW THIS GAVE ME CHILLS!
vtechflower85 2 years ago 3
wonderful version.
andyelde 2 years ago 3
wow i cry every time i watch this holyy its so crazyy this is an amazing performance no dout!
meawsomerocker 2 years ago 2
She's gorgeous and her voice is amazing. I continue to shed a tear or two whenever I watch this.
MissRedd4Ya 2 years ago 3
i cried reallly badd wen i seen this!!
hatedonmostly2007 2 years ago 4
How many years later and I STILL cry when I see this. She's a much stronger than I .
Cynthsam21 2 years ago 6
She made me cry!! It reminded me of when my dad passed..
LiteReddKutie 2 years ago 6
got damn. that was so sad. first time i shed a tear watching audition shows
tupark82 2 years ago 11
This has been flagged as spam show
Thats weird.. her father just past away, but she talks like nothing happend
isocan68 2 years ago
I would love to hear her record this song
ilovemusic4529 2 years ago 7
her voice is awesome for her age.... i cant believe she sang when her dad just died. at least it made it that much better
kindhappy 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
bitch u fake
madesv6 2 years ago
that was evil madesv6, come on now good and take that back. Or face the wall and think about your behaviour today
masterkudjo 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
fake
MeDappaDonn 2 years ago
OMG....she was so brave to do that...i would not have been able to do anything like that.....love you Asia'h Epperson!!!!!!
Divadoll2010 2 years ago 8
ohmygawwd i cried
Byurtney 2 years ago 5
OMG......that was so sad.......the story about her Dad killed me.......I'm sure he is in heaven smiling down on everything she does........
Paula we love you......Fox better bring you back! I do not like that Kara chick :-( Paula is a consummate professional and I trust her judgement and feedback much more than Kara's
tomblue12sbc 2 years ago 11
SHES SO SWEET :)
albobabiie229 2 years ago 2
Asia'h and Alexandrea Lushington should have stayed and Kristy Lee Cook and Amanda Overmyer should have gone home. I'm still bitter. :D hahhaha
ccf1021 2 years ago 3
she desrved to get farther than she did
kingvsqueen 2 years ago 4
she's a cutie
tanpopotanakose 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
soooob story
sthesailor 2 years ago
I loved her, I wanted her to be in the top 10!!! Most of the contestants that season were boring; Asia'h was interesting...
Paula's so cute; I want to give her a hug :)
STLUCIANIDOL91 2 years ago 4
Alguêm pode me dizer por gentileza qual é o nome desta musica e quem canta agradeço...
escrevão por ventileza nos proximos comentarios grata.
n1a1n1d1a1h 2 years ago
i remember watching this live, it was so sad it made me cry, especially the back story and then picking thius song. she stil did a great job
ScarletintoFire 2 years ago 4
aaaaah paula! :(
JUSTIN2418 2 years ago
god! she has a very good voice.....y she didn't win...
BritneySpearsFans123 2 years ago 3
good singer
nd feel sorry fot her 2
girlflower17 2 years ago
I love her!!!
Because she's got a huskey voice it makes me proud, coz i myself have got a huskey voice too. This always makes me cry.
diarymilk1 2 years ago
i wanted her to win.
wickd658 2 years ago 3
i dont know why, but this video make me cry. thanks asiah for share with us
thehumandancer 2 years ago 4
it makes me cry too. it's amazing how she sang so beautifully while going through so much pain. i seriously wish she went way farther in the competition. she was at least top 10 worthy
xxox0genuine0xoxx 2 years ago 8
3:57 Randy and Simon's voices sound so funny :)
And Asia'h is just incredible, she really should have wom or at least made it further than she did. how far did she go btw? :-*(
JennaCarterQ 2 years ago 3
yes jajjaja XD!
Asiah is amazing
P4n3t0n 2 years ago
Wow i really love this Girl and i fell sad for her ASIA = ROCK
0bigse 2 years ago 5
2:21-2:26 is so incredibly beautiful.
lhschoirboi05 2 years ago 3
I can't stop crying!! I'm happy she made it! she has an incredile voice!!
katsumikg1 2 years ago 4
oh I feel so sorry for her :(
xRhonda 2 years ago 3
OMG if this you can see how fast one of your impotant persones can pased away poor girl
supermarocsara94 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
its called denial
ubbddu 2 years ago
I so cried when I saw this,wow....so sad ,she has a beautiful voice.....
maya221985 2 years ago 6
Bitch you better sang......
225character 2 years ago
made me cry definitely her dad would be proud.
paintedwarriors 2 years ago 6
I CANT BELIEVE SHE DIDNT WIN!!!
justincruse2011 2 years ago 6
her story is maad touching plus when she sings its heartbroken
JtingSpartan 2 years ago 6
Asiah you make me so proud every time I hear you sing. I hope everything will work out for you. I love and I can't wait to see you back home sometime!
-Love your cousin, Mariano
mcdr15 2 years ago 5
i remember this. such a beautifull voice, i cried.
basketballgirly11 2 years ago 6
Comment removed
Lemon3142 2 years ago
Comment removed
Lemon3142 2 years ago
i started crying wen i saw ths
urtecho2626 2 years ago 4
Im a guy and this audtion last year made me almost cry...chills up and down
theRIPPER333 2 years ago 3
oh good lord....
she's amazing.
MonsterMaxxxx 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
a ten w srodku to majkel dźekson????;
DjTowotDjWania 2 years ago
she was amazing!! she shouldve won this thing!!! and this song always makes me cry when she sings it....:(
yluku808 2 years ago 2
OMG i just don't knw how she got the courage to sing like dat wen she just found out dat her dad had passed....i can't do that:(
Divadoll2010 2 years ago 4
I WENT THROUGH JOPLIN MISSOURI WHERE SHE IS FROM aND MY COUSIN THAT LIVES THERE SHOWED WAS WHERE HER DAD PASSED BUT ANYWAY SHE CAN SING IW ONDER WAT SHE DOING NOW
missayanaj08 2 years ago
the tone of her voice is beautiful this song makes me cry******************
liljacbig 2 years ago 4
i cry like a baby every time i see this :(
italia101085 2 years ago 5
blablabla... in american idols they´re talking soooo much
zipponorris 2 years ago
beautiful, she make me cry always. the song is so sad
karithmey 2 years ago 9
a ten w srodku to majkel dźekson???
DjTowotDjWania 2 years ago
asia'h should made it to the top 12!!!
hellohi06 2 years ago 10
PAUL ALWAYS CRIES KMT
ShereneLamin 2 years ago
she made me cry...wish her best...
DarkSiteOfAngel 2 years ago 3
aww thats soo sad. it made me cry ..
lilazngirl20 2 years ago 3
Omg, her grandmother's my coworker at Wal-Mart! Also, one of my former coworkers went to school with her. That's like so weird.
dirrtydozen22 2 years ago
I liked her. She has a great voice. She should have advanced to the Top 12. That was a shocker when she didnt.
sjsubval 2 years ago 3
she has very good voice and whoah... so brave to do that...i wonder why she didn't even made it to the top six...hmmm... so sad... she's a great singer. i'm sure there's sumthin good out there that's meant for her.
ateayeng0713 2 years ago 2
Don't get me wrong but I think she can sing better, her throat was probably very moist cuz she was crying.
F0Xhound009 2 years ago 3
she's so cute &so brave to do that!
it's so sad but i'm happy that she did it!
Sam3girl 2 years ago 2
:'(
jztubedotcom 2 years ago
yeah i dont think i coulda done what she did :'( I teared up watching this. Her voice is different and she is pretty, i wish her the best
xxcuteshoesxx 2 years ago
Yay!!! She kicks ass!!! She's tough!!!
KristinChenoweth1 2 years ago
Woah!! look at paula!
brynne8104245 2 years ago
paula looks like shes about to cry
peaceplease999 2 years ago
...she did cry.
melkayla 2 years ago
I can not do what she just did.....If my dad died i would of just went home....I LUV Asia'h
Divadoll2010 2 years ago
that was sad i was almost in tears she was amazin and i think she deserved it!
SusieQ9545 3 years ago