"in the pines, in the pines where the sun never shines, and you shiver and shake as the cold wind blows. Well the longest train that I ever did see was a hundred coaches long.
This is a splendid version of this song. Bravo both on your performance and your arrangement. What hurts it though is the audio quality: it's a little tinny and there's some minor clipping (unless you did that intentionally to make it sound like an old recording). Please consider re-recording and reposting with better audio so we can all better enjoy your great playing.
Might I suggest back off everything. You are playing too hard and singing to hard this creates a harmonic distortion that is quite unpleasant (sometimes called blare).
@andocrates Possibly, but might it also be a product of poor sound quality in the recording technique, sometimes that can happen based mostly on the recording device/setup, correct?
@DealTurtle I was speaking as a sound engineer not a music critic, it usually costs 125 an hour to get my caustic critiques. But it's sage advice, everything is there but it's all at full tilt boogy which leaves you no high point to accent the work. Watch how different tenors sing Danny Boy - it has a show boating note that tenors tend to overkill but the great tenors sing it soft.
That's not "In the Pines." Supposedly, "In the Pines" is completely unrelated to "Where Did You Sleep Last Night." Damned if I didn't think someone was robbing someone...
The chords are Em, Am, G, B. It doesn't appear that you were doing those chords, so you must have done it in a key to suit your voice.
Yeah, I just like playing it like that. I guess thats one nice thing about folk music, and what ever you call it, I got the lyrics from on old Leadbelly recording.
Really well done; strong, emphatic guitar style and great, rough-twang bluegrass voice. I can't decide if I would have preferred a slightly slower tempo, but still think it was excellent!
congrats I put you on my top 100 acoustic songs. (no particular order). Go to my site if your looking for ideas. great cover. Please send any new stuff or additions to the list.
I love your songs. They are very powerful and you really know how to do a song. Please give us some more songs. I know them all and would like to hear more from you.
i listen to you singing most every day keep up the great work,shaz
49sharyn 1 year ago
very well done,would like to see you do more songs, brilliant young man
49sharyn 1 year ago
I think this is brilliant. Well done, man.
HelloHolaCiao 1 year ago
The other In the pines goes
"in the pines, in the pines where the sun never shines, and you shiver and shake as the cold wind blows. Well the longest train that I ever did see was a hundred coaches long.
andocrates 1 year ago
Love this version,
bulbheadmyass 2 years ago
can i get the chords please =)
Immigrant312 2 years ago
good stuff :)
bialyser 2 years ago
wonderful sounds kinda like leadbelly.
bunburyZ 2 years ago
This is a splendid version of this song. Bravo both on your performance and your arrangement. What hurts it though is the audio quality: it's a little tinny and there's some minor clipping (unless you did that intentionally to make it sound like an old recording). Please consider re-recording and reposting with better audio so we can all better enjoy your great playing.
PopeInnocentXIV 2 years ago
I like this. Very nice.
I also like to play the mellow version by Nirvana, with the walks.
saligonth 2 years ago
Sweet dude. Rock on.
devinescence 2 years ago
Too Cool!! My Dad used to sing and play this on his guitar. He is gone now. thank you so much!!
iggydoll 2 years ago
Sounds good...actually, this song is by Dolly Parton...
hugatree2 3 years ago
no its not its a very old american folk song....way older than Dolly Parton
lukeg34 3 years ago
yes, it is way before dolly's time, and she only did a version of it.
HillJackChels 3 years ago
awesome)))
falluen123 3 years ago
Fantastic!!!!
joepopawheely 3 years ago
I like it! Would you check out my version and let me know what you think? Thanks!
jaredtye 3 years ago
Might I suggest back off everything. You are playing too hard and singing to hard this creates a harmonic distortion that is quite unpleasant (sometimes called blare).
andocrates 3 years ago
Thank you for the free advice.
BillWolfe 3 years ago
@andocrates Possibly, but might it also be a product of poor sound quality in the recording technique, sometimes that can happen based mostly on the recording device/setup, correct?
DealTurtle 1 year ago
@DealTurtle I was speaking as a sound engineer not a music critic, it usually costs 125 an hour to get my caustic critiques. But it's sage advice, everything is there but it's all at full tilt boogy which leaves you no high point to accent the work. Watch how different tenors sing Danny Boy - it has a show boating note that tenors tend to overkill but the great tenors sing it soft.
andocrates 1 year ago
That's not "In the Pines." Supposedly, "In the Pines" is completely unrelated to "Where Did You Sleep Last Night." Damned if I didn't think someone was robbing someone...
The chords are Em, Am, G, B. It doesn't appear that you were doing those chords, so you must have done it in a key to suit your voice.
roofermike2007 3 years ago
Yeah, I just like playing it like that. I guess thats one nice thing about folk music, and what ever you call it, I got the lyrics from on old Leadbelly recording.
BillWolfe 3 years ago
hey man can i get those chords
hippie1022 3 years ago
Dude Rocks
bitrot66 3 years ago
great job man.
IntoleranceRecords 3 years ago
hey nirvana covered this lol
colbdawg 3 years ago
nice. f in solid
fpeotrowski 3 years ago
Really well done; strong, emphatic guitar style and great, rough-twang bluegrass voice. I can't decide if I would have preferred a slightly slower tempo, but still think it was excellent!
walkingfern 3 years ago
PS I also like the way that you just sit down and play; no preamble, no apologies, etc. necessary. Refreshing. Looking forward to hearing more.
walkingfern 3 years ago
Thank you so much, i prefer a slower tempo as well but my camera only allowed 3 minutes of video so I had to step it up a notch.
BillWolfe 3 years ago
LOL Such is often the way.
Unfortunately for me, the more I'm pressed for time, the slower some things seem to go. ;-D
walkingfern 3 years ago
Wow! 'powerful' has been said more than once and I like the contrast to Leadbelly & Kurt's versions which (although I love) were laidback & dissolute
marcusmuck 3 years ago
Powerful!
tjoris51 3 years ago
I like it.
Really oldschool.
I've never heard a version outside of nirvana, and this is a lot more bluegrassy.
Primo.
OliverAB 4 years ago
look for the original (search for "leadbelly where did you sleep last night?")
thestrugglewithin 3 years ago
cool!
gtarz38 4 years ago
You are great!
Knockdownbanjo 4 years ago
That's the best version I ever heard, great!
Did Woody sing this song, too?
JohnnyBazooka 4 years ago
what a balalaika you have there!
bezmolvie 4 years ago
Wow a powerful version, really great!
only2jane 4 years ago
Shout it out Billy boy!
40gms 4 years ago
quality mon
themojohadeen 4 years ago
you have a peculiar way for playing guitar.. (sorry for my english)
juliMathers 4 years ago
good stuff:) loved it check out my stuff tell me what ya think as we both like the same stuff.
anadrolking 4 years ago
Wow. Thats all I can say. Dude you did it. Great job covering this song. You have my respect.
vander47 4 years ago
congrats I put you on my top 100 acoustic songs. (no particular order). Go to my site if your looking for ideas. great cover. Please send any new stuff or additions to the list.
mcfun61 4 years ago
Great guitar playing, loved it. Also the voice sounds amazingly like leadbelly himself =D
GeoFly 4 years ago
Great job! I have always loved this song. You nailed it perfectly. Way to go!
Poguette 5 years ago
Great! One of my favorite tunes. Good job.
deldred 5 years ago
Shit son, that was very entertaining. One of my all time favorites and executed very nicely.
tholcx 5 years ago
That's great man.
itkindaworks 5 years ago
F*cking incredible... wow. I'm pretty much speechless.
nefariousintent 5 years ago
the song is called "black girl" or most ppl know as "my girl"
sicNIRVANAjunkie 5 years ago
Well Leadbelly sang both. I've heard him sing "black girl" and "my girl". I figured I could get away with "my girl" a little easier.
BillWolfe 5 years ago
No the song is called in the pines
j2thev12 5 years ago
I love your songs. They are very powerful and you really know how to do a song. Please give us some more songs. I know them all and would like to hear more from you.
JohnnyBazooka 5 years ago
That was pretty awesome. Your voice is even a lot like leadbelly's. Good Job!
Korodesu 5 years ago