Added: 4 years ago
From: purringmeows
Views: 25,927
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,055)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • mcr

  • MCR

  • IT'S SO HARD TO DECIDE! But it has to be MCR cause they were the first band I really fell in love with!

  • And i don't like Panic!'s first album because it is more on sex and drugs. I like their music, lyrics and their genre. I love them no matter what topic is in their album.And I love all of their albums. P!ATD forever!!!

  • @paranic06 Yay!! P!ATD foreveeerrr!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    yes! you're right, I also I like his music, his lyrics and besides I love P! ATD much no matter what anyone says. Panic! At The Disco is my favorite band on my list

  • PANIC! AT THE DISCO FTW!!!!! <3

  • My Chemical Romance com certeza

  • MCR <3333333333333333333333333333

    2:33 *-* sooooooo sweeeet :*

  • Panic at the disco is hell awsome but MCR wins the battle. They have more hits and been around longer plus their lyrics have great meanings

  • how dare you make me choose!?! I just can't do that...

  • Both are amazing, but MCR wins- They were formed years before and have produced more hits ;) BUT, I absolutely adore Panic! At the Disco as well -.-

  • I like Panic, but MCR wins!! :D

  • MCR!!! but there both good...

  • Panic! at the Disco!

  • MMMCCCCCCCCRRRRRRRRRR!!!!!!!!!­!!!!

  • Panic! FTW!!!!!!

  • i love them both so much !! but i think mcr is better.... sry panic

  • My favorite band WAS panic at the disco now it's mcr now I have feelings for panic at the disco so I can't decide

  • My Chemical Romance hands down :P

  • anyone else think when it said mayday parade - three cheers for five years, black parade and three cheers for sweet revenge?

  • @aussiefreddy0077 Hhaha yes!XD

  • MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE!!!!of course!<3:D

    

  • dude its mcr

  • I Love both of them! I can't decide!

  • i cant decide!!!!

  • MY CHEM!!!!

  • PANIC AT THE DISCO <3 i love you guys <3

  • panic AT THE DISCO ALL THE WAY

  • mcr.<3

  • both amazing bands but my heart beats 4 Panic!!!!

  • @BrYOnYWiLliaMs97XD yay!!!!! 

  • I like them both... But I'll side with Panic!. :)

  • I love them both so much, but My Chemical Romance will always have a special place in my heart, and they are like a family I wish I had. <3

  • What is this song?

  • @CheesyBigMac1 Mayday Parade - Three Cheers for Five Years

  • @CheesyBigMac1 Mayday Parade - Three Cheers for Five Years

  • panic at the disco was musically superior than MCR. I know music and I know what I'm saying.

  • @msanm5 I think music is more of an opinion. You can't really know all music. Maybe you know music you like, but you don't know music I like. I like my music. I know what I'm saying.

  • @bridgetalaine7 here's another kid who says good music depends of personal taste. i talk to people who think that way everyday...they're all kids and ignorants is some ways. better or worst musicDOES exists...and its different from personal taste. whatmakes someone a better musican? the innovation, the lyrics meanings, how they play their instruments, how many types of sounds to they have, the originality. before you talk to me grow up, i think that might take years, learn music, then come back.

  • @msanm5 It does. There are great musicians who's music is generic and unappealing. And there can be musicians who have no physical talent, but really put their heart into the music and makes it enjoyable to hear. Innovation and lyrics? Some may think songs about love and sex are better than those about struggles and death. They can both be good. Same goes for originality. Talent and what is 'good' to some people are two totally different things. And I doubt you can learn all music in one life.

  • @bridgetalaine7 some bands just make love songs...other bands write about love, politics, a circus, magical places..thats what make a band better lyrically..also...how they express(words,sentences) what they're saying and how smart is what they're saying. a person who has no ''physical talent'' cant play good music. music are not words. good is good, taste is taste. now you're understanding the difference.

  • @msanm5 I know and understand the difference between good and taste. But how can you compare an orchestra and a rock band who are at the same level of talent? The opinion is going to be biased unless the listener hates all music. Its hard to call two different bands 'good' or 'not good' because MCR and P!ATD both have different sounds and are preferred by different people.

  • @bridgetalaine7 .now you go with a different "strategy''..i can see your opinion changed right now.and no, they're not on the same level of talent( thats impossible in humans). I understand what you want to say...you're saying that they're so good in the type of music they play that it would be only a matter of taste to classify them as better or worst. but its not like that, panic have more innovation musically, better lyrics, better melodies. both can't compare. MCR have the same base sound.

  • @msanm5 see, but better lyrics, better melodies, those are opinions. its a matter of opinion. i totally get that panic might have more talent, and a better voice, but its all personal opinion on which band is better to the listener. and strategy? i'm not over here planning and thinking on how to corner you or something, i'm simply saying what i think about this.

  • @bridgetalaine7 there you're confused again...i'll have to explain it to youlike a baby...you said you understand the diff between good and taste. imagine a 6 year old girl who loves hannah montana, thats her personal taste..but the beatles have more more varitation of lyrics, more variation of melodies,more instruments to play that makes songs sound different so it doesnt get boring. thats what you couldnt understand. better melodies and lyrics are not opinions or individual, personal taste IS.

  • @msanm5 The Beatles are more talented yes, and in many people's opinions, including obviously yours, and mind, they are better. But to that little girl, Hannah Montana is better. To some man out there who is a music nut but hates the Beatles, Hannah Montana is better too. When you take a poll on what music is good, everybody's answer will be different. The Beatle's TALENT is superior to Hannah Montana. I understand the difference. I'll rephrase..I know the difference between talent and opinion

  • @bridgetalaine7 finally you understand me..and what you said there is just what I told you many times.

  • @msanm5 No, I've been saying the same thing the whole time. You said Panic at the Disco being better than MCR was a fact, and I still think its an opinion. But, this conversation was interesting and its hard to find someone to have to have a debate with without getting insulting and overly annoying. And for that, I thank you! :) Its nice that people have opinions, even though I still think I'm right lol

  • @bridgetalaine7 you still think you're right and you think that panic being better musically its just my opinion because you're dont have the capacity to think and analize as me, dont care if you want to believe it or not. I dont want to be hard on you tho. you're just not so talented to understand music and and analize concepts.

  • @msanm5 they might be more TALENTED, but them being better is your opinion. and, you mean analyze with a Y. and I guess not. because i'm just a kid, and apparently just because we're younger we can't understand music. You can think that they ARE better, but I'm still going to stick with what I believe, but how good it is all depends on the listener in my opinion.

  • @bridgetalaine7 english is not my native language. talented and better? as I said...english is not my native language..so ok...better is an opinion..but panic at the disco are more talented musicians then. better depends on the listener, talented doesnt. now you understand.

  • @msanm5 that's what I've been saying this whole time. haha.

  • @bridgetalaine7 nope you didnt...you were fighting the whole conversation because of one word..''better is personal''? jajajajajajja. well take these ms.word...panic is more TALENTED lyricits and musicians. now you cant say its just opinion. see how useless can you be? :D

  • @msanm5 what the hell? okay, well, 'superior' is kind of a synonym for better. superior is an opinion. so if panic at the disco is more talented then okay. 'better' is an opinion. you aren't even making any sense now, and you're kind of acting like a douche, so i'm ending this now.

  • @bridgetalaine7 that's right, panic is more musically talented. good luck in life.

  • I love em both but.... i have loved mcr way longer than P!ATD

  • MCR!

  • is this really a question?i think they both are winners!!:D

  • Both band's music is completely UNIQUE. They can't be put up against each other. They may come under Alternative Rock, but they have their own unique sounds.

    Plus, they're both too good in every category - style, sound, lyrics, meanings, not to mention how nice they all are :)

    My two favourite bands <3

  • I Think it's a tie they both are awesome in their own way. They both have different styles. Panic At The Disco sometimes wears costumes when they perform, but MCR changes their style and look for each album. I say they both win

  • MCR

  • I like both bands because they are both very musically talented bands (I. E. My Chem's ability to make everything fit together and not sound awkward, and Panic!'s multi-instrumentalist members). So I can't pick. I say, both bands. =) Everyone's a winner in my book.

  • mcr no questions asked i mean brendon is good too but gerard is way better then him i like him

  • MCR

  • mcr no questions asked!

  • MCR FTW. All though I really love Panic! (:

  • I love P@TD but....i didnt really care for there last album then there was the wierd break up....it all got complecated...

    MCR is my vote!

  • @fishtankfreak So...you don't care about the one that is coming out on Tuesday? (: Just asking.

  • @DC11961 No i do care for both bands. But i think its a shame that P@TD broke up so soon though. MCR is still going strong..mostly i guess. I just liked P@TD first album more than the 2nd, it was more...sex and drugs lol =)

  • @fishtankfreak Lol I getcha. xD I guess that's why a lot of people loved Panic! in the first place. But then again, they wrote the album when they were 17-18 so I'm not surprised at their choice of topic. xD

  • @fishtankfreak Their new album sounds more like their 1st. It's amazing! :D

  • I love them both... perhaps PANIC! just scrapes by into 1st... :)

  • Me and my friend (we both own this account) think MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE 4 EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3 Mikey, Gerard, !!!FRANKIE!!! and RAY (torosaurus rex xD) but not bob -.- He shouldn't of left. Screw you bob! xD WE LOVE YOU MCR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3

    MCRmy forever :D

  • Comment removed

  • Panic don't need an army, they can be humble;D PANIC FOREVER<3

  • My CHeMIcaL ROmaNcE!

    MCRmy

  • my chemical romance wins no contest bout it

  • i really like panic, but there is no compition that i love MCR way f-ing more!!! so-MCR!

  • I LOVE ALL THREE!!!

    BUT

    MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE = MY LIFE SO YEAH MCR

  • My Chemical Romance. Forever .

  • what's the song called @ 3:48 ?

  • @Crystals246

    the song on the video? Mayday Parade - Three Cheers for Five Years

  • @Crystals246 that isnt my chemical romance. thats AAR.

  • @DaRealLee Oh sorry. I posted that a long time ago.

  • i thought it was vs not easy pick really! mcr! but then again u should have dun afi vs mcr then it would be a hard pick!

  • i would have to say both of them i really cant decide

  • My Chemical Romance FTW!

  • They are my two favourite bands in the world, but I have to say Panic! wins. I really do love both, but I've been a hardcore panic fan for years, and I've gotta be loyal :D

  • MCR rocks. p!atd sucks, but im a metal head so whatever.

    AVENGED SEVENFOLD. :D

  • @foREVerXgray but Avenged isn't really metal. Don't get me wrong, i like them, but it's not the genre i'd put them under.

  • Well at first I had a song for each band, but youtube told me that I couldn't use those songs because of copyright issues.

  • @purringmeows oh yeah i know what you mean. anyway, i was saying that you have a good taste in music either way. :3

  • firs, i find it hilarious how you used mayday instead of either of the battling bands XD

    but ok, this is probably the hardest decision. grr.

    I THINK THEY BOTH WIN. FTW PATDMCR.

  • @xmrsgeewayx

    I originally had a song from each band playing, but youtube blocked it because of copyright issues.

  • both win!

  • MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE! i love panic at the disco, but MCR is so good than panic at the disco!!!

  • MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE!!!

  • panic! all the way :D

  • Sorry, but it has to be My Chemical Romance. I love Panic!, but My Chem are my favourite all the way.

  • I cant decide.......... i love them both!!!!

  • i love p!attd but mcr is da best!

  • Uhmm....they're both great but I'm a huge supporter of the MCRmy so I gotta go with MCR :]

    love em both tho and the song choice was GREAT!

  • Panic! at the Disco 4-evaaa <3

  • Panic! At The Disco

  • MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE IS THE BEST !!

  • I like them both too...:P

  • My Chemical Romance forever

    Although, I am a VERY big fan of Panic!

  • oh yeah, and is fall out boy a choice :P

  • i love them so much equally.. the thought of choosing one over the other makes me cry :'(

  • THEY'RE BOTH GOOOOOD!!!

  • Panic! at the Disco

  • mcr

  • My chemical romance wins in my book *writes it down* Pwnt. book.

  • Don't get me wrong I love patd. But mcr, no contest. :)

  • I love em' both to death! But My Chemical Romance definitely wins!

  • I love them both too much. I would have to put it at a tie.

  • MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE... easy :)

  • MCR totally PWN'D PATD. but they fought a good fight

  • MCR PWNS!!!!!

  • if patd made music like afycso then they would have given mcr a run for their money. but mcr wins

  • MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE TOTALY KICKED THEIR ASS! I mean i like PATD but MCR is better

  • mcr

  • mcr!! without doubt!

    gerard all the way!!!

  • You can't beat MCR. But Panic is/was amazing. =/

  • @jesstheshocker exactly. MCR wins, always.

  • MCR! f*ck yeah!

  • love them both <3

  • PANIC AT THE (freakin!) DISCO ALL THE WAY!

  • I CAN'T CHOOSE!!!!!!

    but GREAT song choice! Old Mayday Parade FTW!

  • @EmoDramaDork thanks!

  • I really like Panic at the Disco but MCR is still the better band :D

  • Yes, Picture sure do help me make a choice. lol jk but really tho.

    The winner is MCR because well, they are MCR.

  • MCR

    frankie <3

  • My Chemical Romance!!!! All the Gerard fucking Mikey Way!!!!

  • no competition they both win

  • @mcr4ever34 I agree, they're both amazinggg:]

  • <3 CHEMICAL ROMANCE WINS! <3

    <3 Panic! At The Disco is great too! <3

  • Panic! At the Disco

    Panic! At the Disco

    Panic! At the Disco

    Panic! At the Disco

    Panic! At the Disco

    Panic! At the Disco

    Panic! At the Disco

  • nah they both are awsome!!!

  • i luv brendan and ryan, but mikey way owns my heart

    go MCR!

  • its brendon.

  • @greenday45654 same Mikey holds my hert forever

  • song name ? playing ?

    in love with this song ...

  • three cheers for five years by mayday parade :)

  • Luuuuuuuv mayday parade :D

  • It's funny how a couple of months ago I probably would've said "Panic! are good but MCR kick ass!!"

    Now I would say "Panic! own!"

    But thats not true... I think the real truth is Panic! at the Disco rock way more before Pretty. Odd. But now, MCR beat them into the ground... Sadly... Now that Ryan and Jon are gone... There's barely any competition member wise... But Oh, Glory was really good [way better than NP] and I think they could be back in the running.

    xx

  • well if you wanted honesty thats all i have to say: MCR!!!!!!!!! All the way!!!! P.S. real MCR fans ROCK! And MCR FTW!

  • Panic..no Mcr..no gah! thats to hard to choose lol both

  • I love them both and their music, but I wanted to see who you guys thought was better. Enjoy! Plz rate! Comment to say who you think is better!!

  • Well.. who do you think? -.- (my name, DUH)

  • Panic! at the Disco. :D

  • nice vid, my chemical romance is better but p!atd is good :)

  • MCR is THE best.. so much better than P!ATD.. for their music..songs..everything..

    and they're not emo as someone could call them.. Gosh.. when will you people get it??!

    They told it also... stop label them as emo band!!...X_x

  • oohh... read the rant in Rocksound...

    Can't remember the name of it but its on one of the first pages. It's about people like you.

    I don't mean this in an offensive way though

  • ???

    people like??

    wtf r u talking about?hmm..

  • It's someones rant about people who go on about how you shouldn't care what labels people give bands and just listen to the music.

    I think you should read it is all

  • okay.. whatever...

    my only point is that I don't like when someone labels..

    anyway.. I just listen some band because of their music.. nothing else..

    and I never offended no one who listens different kind...

    k.

  • MCR

  • Mcr!!!

  • NO CONTEST. MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE!!!!!

  • there really is no "BEST" cos tey both kickass in totaly different genres. for example if it was for class you can undoubtedly say P!ATD cos come on how many other bands like them have you seen wearing a tophat!!! but mcr is more emo with a bit of soloing right its alot heavier... P!atd is more light listenin for metal heads like me... even tho i llike most music its gotta b panic for me cos tbh "they got class"

  • MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE!!!! panic! at the disco sicks!

  • i <3 mcr more,,

    but still love p!atd

  • Comment removed

  • mcr is amazing enough said...

  • MCR!

    they have their own ARMY!!!!!

    MCR-my!!!!

    =D

  • MCR

    i like panic! too but...

    mcr it's just the best!

  • PANIC *.*