Pink Floyd Have a cigar (alternative version)

[RadioUgly]

Funny how Roy Harper was perfect for this song, and it still sounds like Pink Floyd. Thanks.

[perkele0]

Album version is better!

[JanninesPhotos]

I love Roger's vocals on this version. It should have been on the album originally!! :)

[franc097]

@JanninesPhotos yeah, but with that of the guy who is singin in the other version is the manager of Pink they need another guy

[JanninesPhotos]

@franc097 It was Roy Harper, who is a folk singer not manager. Still I love that version too.

[andycoombes]

@JanninesPhotos - And Roy's not a "folk" singer........

Hats off to Roy (Led Zep)

[andycoombes]

@JanninesPhotos - Roger's vocals are pale in comparison to Roy Harper's.....

[iansusky]

Roger Waters is singing?

[boonexy]

hmmm i wonder if he just didnt ever commit a solo to this

[mludeiro]

The coolest Floyd's song!

[jauerbaton89]

yes.i heard it years ago.it was on bootleg.i waited for it in good quality.yesyesyesyesyesyesyesy­esyesyes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[jauerbaton89]

yes this is this version.i'm from poland and in my country we haven't got WYWH immersion box yet,but i heard the album sampler and this is this version.

[webbtastic100]

any chance you have the alternate version of wish you were here thats going to be in this same box set?