I'm a bassist and have't played violin in ages, but the lady plucking at 5:23 has gotta be my favorite thing. Just kinda slapping the strings hahahahahah
Hands down my favorite movement from this symphony. Although the second movement could very well be the same whilst listening to it. I just love tchaikovsky!
I saw the LSO playing this very music in april this year in London, also on the bill Sarah Chang performing the Bruch Violin Concerto. Just mindblowing evening, nothing better than seeing it played live and watching the 'Divine' Sarah play, best evening entertainment ever !! Bravo to Classical music and the Musicians who perform it !!
I went to the Royal festival hall 21st April 2011 mainly to hear Sarah Chang play the Bruch violin concerto No 1, Sarah was unbelievable, so much emotion in her playing, the audience went crazy at the end of her performance, she is so wonderful. Also on the programme was Respighi Fountains of Rome No 1 and the Tchaikovsky Symphony No 4 , Orchestra was the Royal Philharmonic. What a feast of music it was,
I loved this movement, live its fantastic to hear it, a wonderful night !
@lindabindaboo Saw the Hopkins Symphony Orchestra perform this live earlier and this scherzo: pizzicato ostinato part was amazing. Windwood and brass instruments have a field day in this symphony. I especially enjoyed the piccolo parts, Tchaikovsky truly knew how to compose.
Such a score card audience. It's the music stupid. Being played by imperfect humans. Sit back and enjoy the genius of Tchaikovsky, for Christ sake. Can any of you play this any better. If you can are you in on of the top 5? or does it make you feel superior pointing out flaws. Ever had a bad day? Maybe they are. It happens. Watch sports? Ever see one of your superstars have a bad game. Well wake up, It also happens in perfomances. I know!!! I'm a pro horn player and have seen it .
it's amazing how the conductor can just stand there barely showing a beat and still they're perfectly together. It's like all he's needed for is portraying emotions
@quasimojo8 Most of the conductor's important work is putting the piece together to his liking and his interpretive imagination through many rehearsal sessions. In truth, by the time the orchestra performs the piece on stage, a conductor's job has already been done, and the orchestra can, in most cases (depending on the piece) play without a conductor. Several solists even prefer playing without a conductor.
Always loved movement no. 3 of this very epic symphony. The plucking strings always remind me of a chase scene in a suspense film- some kind of big adventure coming to en end- and the end is the 4th movement finale.
Tchaikovsky IS NOT always about happyness. The reason he wrote this symphony was fate during the troubled times in his life, when he dumped his wife. He wrote this movement during his visit with the russian peasantry. The pizzicato and woodwind features are used to represent Belalikas, Flutes, And Viols. In fact, this entire symphony is about sadness, and the fourth movement practicaly proclaims revolution.
Barenboim's Tchaikovsky's Fourth Symphony is very interesting, but only during the first and the second movements. In this pizzicato ostinato, Barenboim makes the same mistake that almost all conductors do: THEY FORGET THAT TCHAIKOVSKY'S MUSIC IS ABOUT HAPPINESS! Where is the orgasm in this movement? At 5:15? That's not orgasm when the subject is Tchaikovsky!
2:33-3:10 is so amazing and pretty! The CSO brass NEVER dissapoints!!! THE WHOLE MOVEMENT IS AMAZING. Barenboim can get alot out of them without waving his hands like an idiot. Very impressive.
@TheKevinV08: The tuba is silent throughout both this and the preceding (2nd) movement - we catch the tubist at the end preparing his instrument for the 'tutti' launch of the 4th movement. Until then, what's left for him to do, given his part being silent?
Amazing dynamics! Playing with that level of dynamic while using pizzicato and not making a metalic twang requires an enormous amount of patience and control over plucking hand.
@lilly763 All the notes are there, but to me it sounds quite out of tune. I love the Chicago Symphony like most other people, but I feel like that piccolo soli isn't really up to par with the rest of the orchestra. I will admit though... at least the notes were there! It's not easy to sit tacet for two full movements and then play something like that!! And the solo at 2:46 is right on it!
I love this movement, probably one of my favorite Tchaikovsky pieces. However, I think they play it a little too fast for my taste, and the woodwind and brass sections don't play their notes quite as staccato as necessary to match the strings' style.
anyone have any tips for a beginer piccoloist??? i'm changing over from flute soon and would like some tips and what to expect type things THANK YOU!!!
despite being one of the greatest composers ever lived, i think tchaikovsky was being very mean by telling the piccolo to tacet mvt.1 and mvt 2, and then 161 measures of rests, and then come in with the giant solo =p
never do i hear this 3rd mvmnt, that i don't admire the genius to have interjected a most compelling showcase for any orchestra's string-section.. it never becomes mundane, far from it, and it's conclusion is, pure delight. for all music lovers.. bdfd joe, bedford, mass.
The ending of this movement is so surreal, my mouth drops in awe at the end every single time I listen to it. And that is aided by this absolutely stellar performance!
you could be right, because this is such a great and professional orchestra, but i think Barenboim has had a long and fruitful association with the CSO and is on the whole a worthy successor to Rodzinski, Reiner, Kubelik, Solti et al... anyway this is a great performance I think, and surely Barenboim can take some credit for it...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i know that barenboim was and still is a great figure in the music world. however, i feel that his conducting doesn't portray his interpretation of this music properly. i think that in this case, he could be absent, and the orchestra would still play this way. he doesn't seem to have much of an influence on the orchestra or the audience.
I think everyone should remember who we are talking about before you go making your... rather unprofessional/immature comments. These are the people who have help pave the way so to speak for us... Why don't you enjoy it for what it's worth versus attacking every note. And word to the wise... make sure your performance is perfect before trying to go against one of the best in the biz... (Sagarflute)
I absolutely love his conducting of the brass entrance! How beautiful the brass play here: even though they are playing 16th notes, it seems as if there is a simultaneous legato and lightness to the brass passage that is difficult to acheive. Bravo Chicago Symphony Orchestra!
Tchaikovsky had a great sense of humour! Here, and the third movement of the Pathétique, we have a great drunken excess and play. I love this movement.
Interesting take. I always found it interesting that in the full statement of the march (of the 6th), the melody is in the strings and not the brass -- sometimes the beats of the horns and the timpani all but overpower the melody. A unique march, indeed. Is it triumphant, though? In isolation, one might think so, but what follows exsanguinates any triumphalism from its strident beats, I think. Embedded in the Pathétique, the III mvt is manic irony.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Alternating between fatigue and boredom. Like this movement and Barenboims interpretation. There is no much more to this symphony than just mere notes.
Looks like the principal second violinist was using his middle finger to pluck, unlike everyone else using their pointers. :P It's much easier that way though.
The piccolo player really struggled a bit when he had the melody after the clarinet solo. I mean, yeah...dotted 8th notes his hard on a flute, but he was also a little bit late.
@AdioBlackMentality: If those D-flat passages had been written in D-flat major, perhaps it might have helped?
Otherwise, what's so difficult about that fife passage you flautists/fifists are so upset about (from a keyboardist)? The speed of those notes (notably the 32nds)? Tessitura? Breathing?
The Clarinet solo at 2:45 makes me think of Diagon Alley o.0 wonderful piece!
bubblytar 4 weeks ago
Bleh. SFS did it better.
collindotlloyd 4 weeks ago
I'm a bassist and have't played violin in ages, but the lady plucking at 5:23 has gotta be my favorite thing. Just kinda slapping the strings hahahahahah
CCasey325 1 month ago in playlist Tchai 4
Comment removed
VioLynn0803 2 months ago
You just know every oboe player loves to be the douche bag who plays the oboe blare at 1:49. :D
VioLynn0803 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The flutes sound like one. Pretty good :)
Bettyloutime 3 months ago in playlist audition excerpts
Stunning!!!
jwbeauch 3 months ago
Pizz !!!!! I like !!!
Yuliviolinista 3 months ago
Hands down my favorite movement from this symphony. Although the second movement could very well be the same whilst listening to it. I just love tchaikovsky!
chopinvalseop42 3 months ago
@chopinvalseop42
I saw the LSO playing this very music in april this year in London, also on the bill Sarah Chang performing the Bruch Violin Concerto. Just mindblowing evening, nothing better than seeing it played live and watching the 'Divine' Sarah play, best evening entertainment ever !! Bravo to Classical music and the Musicians who perform it !!
lovemetu 2 months ago
It's incredible how a small difference in tempo makes this a completely different piece... still like it faster, though...
fernandofariajunior 3 months ago
This the Fun movement of all time.
dickdona 4 months ago
This series of videos has got to be the best thing on youtube. hands down.
Diatommy554 4 months ago
KUJALA!!
katbtmn 4 months ago in playlist tchaikovsky 4 - CSO - Barenboim
Everyone- I like to request your prayers. I have to play the piccolo part. Just got the music tonight. ;)
kapoczka 5 months ago 4
@kapoczka Lol! I have similar feelings about the 1st Clarinet part in Borodin's Polovtsian Dances :(!
hennimore1 4 months ago
Tchaikovsky, the master of the pizzicato...
goodchessactor 5 months ago 21
@goodchessactor Tchaikovsky: the master of everything!
hennimore1 4 months ago
The paradyme of our times.do you young Turks get this?
TheTherese3 6 months ago
toquei esse movimento ! meus dedos ficaram com bolhas... ashuahsuah'
AmandaCbx 6 months ago
Really, hearing this music is fantastic. Hearing it live is INCREDIBLE! :)
...But performing it yourself.... wow, just wow. The feeling is indescribable!! :)
Support your local art programs!
lindabindaboo 7 months ago 17
@lindabindaboo
I went to the Royal festival hall 21st April 2011 mainly to hear Sarah Chang play the Bruch violin concerto No 1, Sarah was unbelievable, so much emotion in her playing, the audience went crazy at the end of her performance, she is so wonderful. Also on the programme was Respighi Fountains of Rome No 1 and the Tchaikovsky Symphony No 4 , Orchestra was the Royal Philharmonic. What a feast of music it was,
I loved this movement, live its fantastic to hear it, a wonderful night !
lovemetu 7 months ago 2
@lindabindaboo Saw the Hopkins Symphony Orchestra perform this live earlier and this scherzo: pizzicato ostinato part was amazing. Windwood and brass instruments have a field day in this symphony. I especially enjoyed the piccolo parts, Tchaikovsky truly knew how to compose.
benomind 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm playing this symphony in college next school year....my fingers are going to hurt so much after playing all of that pizzicato!
kaleidoscopeheart91 7 months ago
Comment removed
kaleidoscopeheart91 7 months ago
Go Walfrid Kujala!
eamflutes 9 months ago 4
i listened to this video in 2008 and i still listen to it in 2011. btw nice horn angle mulcahy
mobile507 9 months ago
Comment removed
WinnieTehPooh 10 months ago
Awesome!
rrvtjd 10 months ago
most inventive scherzo ever! my favorite one with bruckner's one in his 9th symphony
1bateleur 10 months ago
Si la magia tuviera un sonido sin dudar seria este.
cristian0693 10 months ago
Such a score card audience. It's the music stupid. Being played by imperfect humans. Sit back and enjoy the genius of Tchaikovsky, for Christ sake. Can any of you play this any better. If you can are you in on of the top 5? or does it make you feel superior pointing out flaws. Ever had a bad day? Maybe they are. It happens. Watch sports? Ever see one of your superstars have a bad game. Well wake up, It also happens in perfomances. I know!!! I'm a pro horn player and have seen it .
geosulli 11 months ago
I love during the piccolo solos all it shows it the hands on the player! Like it's trying to say "Look how hard this part is!!" I love it!! GO CSO!!!
StarWarsChick27 1 year ago
it's amazing how the conductor can just stand there barely showing a beat and still they're perfectly together. It's like all he's needed for is portraying emotions
quasimojo8 1 year ago
@quasimojo8 Exactly.......tht's what orchestral conductors are supposed to do; "portyaying emotions" nothing more, and certainly nothing less.
XEA6L 1 year ago
@quasimojo8 Most of the conductor's important work is putting the piece together to his liking and his interpretive imagination through many rehearsal sessions. In truth, by the time the orchestra performs the piece on stage, a conductor's job has already been done, and the orchestra can, in most cases (depending on the piece) play without a conductor. Several solists even prefer playing without a conductor.
veloqis 11 months ago
Mmmm, the Land of Chocolate....
yorgomtl 1 year ago
The oboe entered like a severe case of PE.
0GL 1 year ago
the sound of the oboe is sooooooooooooooo sharp, i really don't like it
c4exclusive 1 year ago
@c4exclusive
No he's not..
nottravis28 1 year ago
ok, compared to the sound of the german,dutch and french oboist it is. Maybe it is normal in america, i don't know
c4exclusive 1 year ago
@c4exclusive Europeans tune to a different A than AMericans
SHdrummerguy08 1 year ago
2:38 The tuba player looks bored.
nottravis28 1 year ago
Love his face @2:48 :)
PiccoloFlute2010 1 year ago 3
Gran Sinfonía, y que buena interpretación, Grande baremboim
jonatanliv 1 year ago
Always loved movement no. 3 of this very epic symphony. The plucking strings always remind me of a chase scene in a suspense film- some kind of big adventure coming to en end- and the end is the 4th movement finale.
mca1218 1 year ago
Tchaikovsky IS NOT always about happyness. The reason he wrote this symphony was fate during the troubled times in his life, when he dumped his wife. He wrote this movement during his visit with the russian peasantry. The pizzicato and woodwind features are used to represent Belalikas, Flutes, And Viols. In fact, this entire symphony is about sadness, and the fourth movement practicaly proclaims revolution.
BeowulfVids 1 year ago
One of the best (if not the best) pizzicato movements EVER!!! Epic!!!
peppersax 1 year ago
Barenboim's Tchaikovsky's Fourth Symphony is very interesting, but only during the first and the second movements. In this pizzicato ostinato, Barenboim makes the same mistake that almost all conductors do: THEY FORGET THAT TCHAIKOVSKY'S MUSIC IS ABOUT HAPPINESS! Where is the orgasm in this movement? At 5:15? That's not orgasm when the subject is Tchaikovsky!
BrasilioGonzalez 1 year ago
This piece is a real pick me up.
RelaxationMediaVideo 1 year ago
2:33-3:10 is so amazing and pretty! The CSO brass NEVER dissapoints!!! THE WHOLE MOVEMENT IS AMAZING. Barenboim can get alot out of them without waving his hands like an idiot. Very impressive.
classicalmusic6 1 year ago
A bit of a boo boo at 2:24 by the flutes, and Barenboim heard too!
Gozaburo1 1 year ago
LOL the tuba player at 2:38 is just twiddling his thumbs...
TheKevinV08 1 year ago 4
@TheKevinV08 ROFL That was the highlight of my day!
Nomm098 1 year ago
@TheKevinV08: The tuba is silent throughout both this and the preceding (2nd) movement - we catch the tubist at the end preparing his instrument for the 'tutti' launch of the 4th movement. Until then, what's left for him to do, given his part being silent?
LJBSasha 1 year ago
Barenboim makes a great conductor as well
jasonextreme 1 year ago
is the principal violist peter slowick?
Violanerd6 1 year ago
@Violanerd6 The Principal viola is Charlie Pikler. Peter Slowik never served as principal.
classicalmusic6 1 year ago
I love that little smile he gives at 2:23!
samdajellybeenie14 1 year ago
Woodwinds made a little mess there. They got too emotional and fucked up few notes. That is why he smiled :))
dmitryflute 1 year ago
Amazing dynamics! Playing with that level of dynamic while using pizzicato and not making a metalic twang requires an enormous amount of patience and control over plucking hand.
PositiveHalo 1 year ago
2:45 the best part
RyaZila24 1 year ago
2:50
priceless
iamemod 1 year ago 4
@iamemod
lmao!!!
RyaZila24 1 year ago
Comment removed
ApprendistaBandista 2 years ago
Comment removed
ApprendistaBandista 2 years ago
pizzicato ftw
UnshavenStatue 2 years ago
wow...everyone has a different style of pizzicato.....i am also learning this symphony and watching each style i now also have my own style
violinamateurBX 2 years ago
very good version of Tshaikovsky
and so incredible symphony
mozartu 2 years ago
I love the 3.part
i just heard it yesterday evening in the Philharmonie Dortmund with the Symphony Orchester.
It was wonderful
Fuenuenuenuenue 2 years ago 4
This could be one more piece in the nutcracker :D
adalguzm 2 years ago 7
the violinist at 5:24 just made my day
plop292 2 years ago 19
Comment removed
tom94212 2 years ago
plop292, at 2:04 you get a first impressions of the lady hahah, just in front of the flutes
c4exclusive 2 years ago
lol, everyone seems to have their own unique pizzicato! And I must say, watching the bass strings vibrate is quite satisfying!
azzai45 2 years ago 11
i love the flute and piccolo in this movement!
cookiebella512 2 years ago 11
I love watching the low brass in this video
at 2:37 you can see the tuba player start twiddling his thumbs lol.
Why is Charlie Vernon using all the alternate positions? And whats the deal with the 2nd trombone player pointing his bell up there.
zanxquantum 2 years ago 8
Who's playing piccolo in this video?
violinistx100 2 years ago
Walfrid Kujala
lantora84 2 years ago 7
My dad always said you could never snap a string plucking. Then he played this movement, got excited and snapped his E string plucking.
Fun music.
FinaleFantasy 2 years ago 6
on subject of the piece, awesome job CSO/Barenboim :)
cl427x 2 years ago
clearly someone doesn't know how to play a stringed instrument.
V
cl427x 2 years ago 2
When you do pizzicato on a string instrument, there only a certain dynamic you can go to without popping the string off. it sucks. haha.
AdioBlackMentality 2 years ago
....u know how wrong you are?
iWyke2 2 years ago
how?
AdioBlackMentality 2 years ago
Absolutely superb - the whole symphony is great tho`.
Faircrowd1 2 years ago
May be this and the finale movement are my favorites
holamen12 2 years ago
Yes i do
headshotfanatic 2 years ago
iF YOU NOTICE THE DIRECTOR IS DIRESCTING AT DIFFERENT SPEEDS SOMETIMES AND THE BAND IS KEEPING UP WITH HIM THAT SHOW THEY WATCH HIM GOOD
headshotfanatic 2 years ago
If by band, you mean the Chicago Symphony =P
lilly763 2 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they don't look at him at all:D
zimnyleszek 2 years ago
What, you haven't heard of peripheral vision?
zenrarity 2 years ago 8
@headshotfanatic
Illiterate much?
nottravis28 1 year ago
Yay for the piccolo player! Not many people can play that part...
lilly763 2 years ago 70
I saw a documentary on the 4th symphony and the piccolo player player said something like "a lifetime of study for 4 seconds of terror!"
goodchessactor 2 years ago 114
Is this movement diffucult for the bass, because of the pizz?
holamen12 2 years ago
No, It's quit common for the bass(and all others) I've seen it a lot and it's fairly common and a few friends said it's not difficult on the bass.
violinistx100 2 years ago
@goodchessactor hey, i totally saw that too! i saw it like 2 years ago and it was about the san francisco symphony performing this :)
pianoman9763 1 year ago
@goodchessactor i know exactly what you're talking about! i saw it about 2 years ago. it was about the san francisco symphony performing this :)
pianoman9763 1 year ago
@goodchessactor lol yeah i was thinking about that same one :)
pinkfloyddwc 10 months ago
@lilly763 yeah, this picc part is the bane of my existence right now.
ScaldingHotSoup 2 years ago
@lilly763 In tune. lol.
1upMusician 1 year ago
Comment removed
heshoopman 9 months ago
@lilly763 All the notes are there, but to me it sounds quite out of tune. I love the Chicago Symphony like most other people, but I feel like that piccolo soli isn't really up to par with the rest of the orchestra. I will admit though... at least the notes were there! It's not easy to sit tacet for two full movements and then play something like that!! And the solo at 2:46 is right on it!
heshoopman 9 months ago
I love this movement, probably one of my favorite Tchaikovsky pieces. However, I think they play it a little too fast for my taste, and the woodwind and brass sections don't play their notes quite as staccato as necessary to match the strings' style.
MaestroKyle2009 2 years ago
i think it's a little bit too slow.....maybe personal taste lol
iwanabana 2 years ago 2
whoa, violinist at 5:24, crazy cat lady hah
skitzo429 2 years ago 4
Here you can see different schools of pizzicato playing, index finger while grasping the violin, middle finger in the air and others.
goodchessactor 2 years ago 3
anyone have any tips for a beginer piccoloist??? i'm changing over from flute soon and would like some tips and what to expect type things THANK YOU!!!
violinistx100 2 years ago
Practice.
voicesinurhead01 2 years ago 4
um....thanks, but that really wasn't helpfull
violinistx100 2 years ago
Sorry, but there's only so much one can give for advice on a Youtube comment.
voicesinurhead01 2 years ago
lol 5:25 the violinist looks like a cat batting at a ball of yarn.
BRAVO! this is one of the most challenging, yet innovative movements of any symphony.
calman125 2 years ago 5
despite being one of the greatest composers ever lived, i think tchaikovsky was being very mean by telling the piccolo to tacet mvt.1 and mvt 2, and then 161 measures of rests, and then come in with the giant solo =p
FungoBoy 2 years ago 9
haha so true
nickysaxpiccolo 2 years ago
Yes, this is Tchaikovsky how I know him in The Nutcracker or Swan Lake :) Nice
parelaca 3 years ago
woohooo kujala!!!
evasflute 3 years ago 4
never do i hear this 3rd mvmnt, that i don't admire the genius to have interjected a most compelling showcase for any orchestra's string-section.. it never becomes mundane, far from it, and it's conclusion is, pure delight. for all music lovers.. bdfd joe, bedford, mass.
BDFDJOE 3 years ago
2:57 Amazing!!!!
pizzaboy456783 3 years ago
The piccolo is unbelievable...That part is insane...
akm10293 3 years ago 5
Alex Klein, is, and will always be my hero!
Rock on oboes!
ElenoreDinosaur 3 years ago 3
The ending of this movement is so surreal, my mouth drops in awe at the end every single time I listen to it. And that is aided by this absolutely stellar performance!
goorioles747 3 years ago
when this symphony was premiered in 1878, the audience demanded an encore of this 3rd movement. it is still a tour de force!
ictusbk 3 years ago 2
Damn Kujala. He makes the most impossible things look like child's play. I honestly do not know of a wind section better than this one. Stellar!
fliboi78 3 years ago 6
ps i think tchaikovsky would have absolutely lost his mind to hear such a virtuosic performance
kiracore84 3 years ago 5
you could be right, because this is such a great and professional orchestra, but i think Barenboim has had a long and fruitful association with the CSO and is on the whole a worthy successor to Rodzinski, Reiner, Kubelik, Solti et al... anyway this is a great performance I think, and surely Barenboim can take some credit for it...
kiracore84 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i know that barenboim was and still is a great figure in the music world. however, i feel that his conducting doesn't portray his interpretation of this music properly. i think that in this case, he could be absent, and the orchestra would still play this way. he doesn't seem to have much of an influence on the orchestra or the audience.
musickrazy43 3 years ago
OMG WOW
NoodlePowa 3 years ago 2
Stellar clarinet playing
overlord1294 3 years ago 4
Kujala isn't playing along with the flutes between 2:24 and 2:33 just to warm up before the big solo...that part is actually in the score
ndosg15 3 years ago
Don't worry too much about the quality... it's still a lot better than most YouTube videos.
TurnoutBurnout 3 years ago 5
yeah no duh
levnest15 3 years ago
Does anyone know if David McGill's Bassoon has the gentlemen's cut?
Lovethieve1 3 years ago
i know i'm talking about a professional orchestra, but the dynamics during the pizzacato sections are just incredible
LittleCellist1 3 years ago
the pizz could be as fast u can....
elias1015 3 years ago
I think everyone should remember who we are talking about before you go making your... rather unprofessional/immature comments. These are the people who have help pave the way so to speak for us... Why don't you enjoy it for what it's worth versus attacking every note. And word to the wise... make sure your performance is perfect before trying to go against one of the best in the biz... (Sagarflute)
aflute4u 3 years ago
how fast the violin pizz could be?
Q1770 3 years ago
i love the pizzacato part.so magical.
akikofan 3 years ago 2
ah man I love this piece. I just played it in a summer conservatory and that Clarinet solo is veryyyy hard.
czechprince2010 3 years ago
Donald Peck is The Man.
barryc86 3 years ago 2
Which instrument?
ThaSchwab 3 years ago
Principal Flute
WAKeele 3 years ago
Best opening oboe solo ive ever heard from this Symphony
loofascraper 3 years ago
I absolutely love his conducting of the brass entrance! How beautiful the brass play here: even though they are playing 16th notes, it seems as if there is a simultaneous legato and lightness to the brass passage that is difficult to acheive. Bravo Chicago Symphony Orchestra!
maestrojeremy 3 years ago 5
2:53 to 2:59 - - best pic solo I've ever heard on this symphony. Bravo!
edcassells 3 years ago 5
Got to disagree, after the slur the tongued notes were then late/not with the trumpets and then the last note split. Hardly a perfect performance
sagarflute 3 years ago
I disagree for a different reason: the solos of a CSO performance of a Mahler symphony are much better. :) ...in my opinion, it's all good.
Rachman1337 3 years ago
Sounds like Kujala plays along with the flutes to warm up before the piccolo solo.
PacoLevy 4 years ago
When? When the flutes first come in or 2:24?
ThaSchwab 3 years ago
Hmmmm...I wonder. It's a really REALLY good idea, regardless!
powellpicc1985 2 years ago
i love the beginning
iWyke2 4 years ago 2
i play bass and this movement is fun but a challenge to play.
AdioBlackMentality 4 years ago
Tchaikovsky had a great sense of humour! Here, and the third movement of the Pathétique, we have a great drunken excess and play. I love this movement.
darkprose 4 years ago 2
I would agree that they are quite boisterous. Though I liken the 3rd movement of the 6th Symphony to a march of Roman knights!
eristaviserbia 3 years ago
Interesting take. I always found it interesting that in the full statement of the march (of the 6th), the melody is in the strings and not the brass -- sometimes the beats of the horns and the timpani all but overpower the melody. A unique march, indeed. Is it triumphant, though? In isolation, one might think so, but what follows exsanguinates any triumphalism from its strident beats, I think. Embedded in the Pathétique, the III mvt is manic irony.
darkprose 3 years ago
Comment removed
LJBSasha 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Alternating between fatigue and boredom. Like this movement and Barenboims interpretation. There is no much more to this symphony than just mere notes.
DaddyofT 4 years ago
How did u get this video? is it on a dvd i can buy? if so were did u get it? i really want it.
AgentJohnson1 4 years ago
Lol, just watch it one here. :)
ThaSchwab 4 years ago
yea but i want high quality dvd sound and video.
AgentJohnson1 4 years ago
Sorry, this is from my own recording of the live PBS broadcast back in 1997 (that's also why not of the best quality--no digital TV back then!)
medpiano 4 years ago
Looks like the principal second violinist was using his middle finger to pluck, unlike everyone else using their pointers. :P It's much easier that way though.
ThaSchwab 4 years ago
I often alternated between 1 and 2, just to avoid fatigue (and boredom)
medpiano 4 years ago
The piccolo player really struggled a bit when he had the melody after the clarinet solo. I mean, yeah...dotted 8th notes his hard on a flute, but he was also a little bit late.
ThaSchwab 4 years ago
You're right but that piccolo solo is the hardest to play in all of classical music. Piccolo players hate Tchais fourth!
goodchessactor 4 years ago
Sorry ... meant sixteenth, not eighth notes. :)
ThaSchwab 4 years ago
Maybe you do, but I always have fun with these excerpts. Especially Tchaik 4th!
dasteufelhund 4 years ago
Incredible picc playing, Wally Kujala!
dasteufelhund 4 years ago 4
it has a whole bunch of accidentals to.
AdioBlackMentality 4 years ago
@AdioBlackMentality: If those D-flat passages had been written in D-flat major, perhaps it might have helped?
Otherwise, what's so difficult about that fife passage you flautists/fifists are so upset about (from a keyboardist)? The speed of those notes (notably the 32nds)? Tessitura? Breathing?
LJBSasha 1 year ago
That brass section is really good!
JLwaldhorn 4 years ago 2
oh yes, they were excellent
cellocraze 4 years ago <