No one can explain trinity because its all made up.... Man says Jesus is God and God is God and the Holy Spirit is God...... but you know what the Bible Says...When Jesus was Baptized voice from heaven this is my son.....the beloved.... whom I have approved......Matthew 3:16,17 Jesus asked his disciples who they thought he was and they said you are the christ the son of the living God and Jesus said they answered correctly.. Believe Mans Trinity Or The Bibles clear teaching mattehew 16:16,17..
this is insane why god need a son?jesus christ was a prophet not son of god.i remember a clever explanation about holy trinity a christian scientist come to abdelhamid kechk and said to him about holy trinity then kechk said : is that like a finger who is composed from 3 parts but is one finger .then the scientest said yes so kechk said the finger is simple or composed ?the scientist answered composed absolutely.then kechk said so who compose god and he's the first and the last.
did any of you guys notice eric idle laughs before the board falls on robbie coltrane? bad editing there, I wonder how on earth could that have escaped them...
God is love and God is an expressive God. Now, the relationship of the father and the son is like heat to a flame. God is the flame and God's expression or his Word, is the heat. And this fire has been burning forever because God has always been saying something. Now, God is of such a nature that when He does something it becomes truly real and this begets his Son ( from all eternity). The father and Son have a mutual relationship to one another and like having the spirit of a family
or the spirit of a group where you have essentially a communal person, you have that same thing in the relationship between the Father and the Son but as with God the relationship between the Father and the Son produces an actual Person, known as the Holy Spirit. We believe in one God, the Father and creator of all things that are seen and unseen. We believe in the Son, eternally begotten of the Father begotten not made, through whom all things were made.
Brian Hope/Sister Euphemia: Does the Trinity make any sense to you?
Charlie McManus: Oh, no. No, it makes no sense to anyone. That's why you have to believe it. That's why you have to have faith. If it made sense, it wouldn't have to be a religion, would it?
[a Trinity board on the wall falls on Charlie's head]
Brian Hope: Let me try and summarize this: God is his son. And his son is God. But his son moonlights as a holy ghost, a holy spirit, and a dove. And they all send each other, even though they're all one and the same thing.
Charlie M: You've got it. You really could be a nun!
From IMDB: Charlie McManus: You've got the Father, the Son and the holy ghost. But the three are one - like a shamrock, my old priest used to say. "Three leaves, but one leaf." Now, the father sent down the son, who was love, and then when he went away, he sent down the holy spirit, who came down in the form of a...
Was Eric Idel a JW at sometime in his life? I like the way he challenges the conventional church thinkings and has many times used God's name Jehovah in his comedy for years......Just wondering.....
What peolpe loose sight of is GOD can do whatever however He wants to do it. He wanted to baffle the religious so he came in a way noone could fathem. As a BABY? Just that is mind boogling. He could of come in the clouds with all the angels of heaven. IF HE wanted to.But once you accept JESUS the blinders come off and you understand.. GOD is all powerful and HE came to save the world for us! And all the questions and doubts disappear because HE fills your heart with LOVE, JOY AND PEACE!
Did God or the Bible say anything about this scheme to baffle the religious, or did you just pull this out of the air ? Seems like a petty thing for the God of the universe to come up with. Playing tricks.What about all the Buddhists who don't accept Jesus but are filled with LOVE JOY etc. When people are good and kind they are said to be showing Christian virtues. What about the good people in the world who never heard of Christ or don't believe in him? Christians can be quite presumptuous.
So if God sent his son to die for our sins and God and his Son are the same person....was it a suicide? If God was dead when Jesus died , who raised Jesus back to life? When Jesus prayed to God while on earth...was he praying to himself ? I"m just asking...not that any of it matters anyway.
Well it does matter because many people dismiss Christianity so quickly because it doesn't make sense to there logic. The bible says the natural man is not able to take in the things of the Spirit of God: for they seem foolish NEITHER CAN HE KNOW THEM BECAUSE THEY ARE SPIRITUALLY DISCERNED. CORINTHIANS 2:14. So without the Holy Spirit it is foolishness to our human minds. We need the Holy Spirit to fully understand the Bible.However NO Jesus did not commit suicide.
If natural man cannot understand the things of God then why is your understanding of God and his word correct? Where in the Bible is the work Trininty mentioned? Check into pagan history a little and see where the idea of a Triune God came from and was later introduced into Christianity...just like Christmas etc.
What's UNEXPLAINABLE is why God would leave heaven come to earth in human form (phillipians2) die a HORRIFIC death on a cross,overcome sin hell and the grave SIMPLY BECAUSE HE LOVES! John 3:16. In Isiah it says HIS flesh fell like ribbons HE was beyond human recognition. I was raised a Jehovah's Witness and didn't believe in the trinity either. Then I met JESUS in a REAL way. HE has radically changed my life and He WANTS TO DO THE SAME FOR YOU. SAY JESUS I'M SORRY, FORGIVE ME, COME IN MY HEART!
I've seen contradictions in the bible. And I've seen scriptures for and against the trinity. So, maybe we're suppose to all get along despite our difference in opinions on translations and interpretations? Funny thing is, we don't all agree to disagree. Can't we all just get along?
The Creator of the Universe wanted humans to understand clearly who he is and what he stands for. This includes the identity of his Son. So, since the bible speaks in lengthy detail on the subject of "who is God, and who is Jesus" is is a monumental cop-out to say the Trinity doctrine is "incomprehensible". It simply isn't in the bible. Even Eric Idle understands that.
No one has nor will ever properly explain trinity. i have asked over 50 christians, read books on it.The great christian scholars have never been able to explain it. You say ice/water/gas or the york/egg white/egg shell as a paradox of the trinity. the word trinity is Not even mentioned in the bible. The idea of trinity was started by a man called paul who NEVER met jesus. it is the biggest hoax ever. BLIND FAITH
do you mean paul from the bible because that paul actually said that jesus was the son of god but of many different words in greek that cannot be translated they just put their thoughts and didn't let the bible speak for itself. the holy trinity is blasphemy!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
As a Christian I will like to explain the trinity to you. Yes the word is'nt in the bible but the Father, Son and Spirit are one. In Revelation 22 Jesus says "I am the Alpha and the Omega the begining and the end." Think about that. If a child was named after his father who was named after his father they would be the I, II and the III. Would the III say "I am the FIRST " or would the II SAY " I AM THE THIRD" ? NO! Because they are seperate . But Jesus did. HE WAS explainig HE was GOD.
The belief that a cosmic Jewish zombie can make you live forever if you symbolically eat his flesh and telepathically tell him you accept him as your master, so he can remove an evil force from your soul that is present in humanity because a rib-woman was convinced by a talking snake to eat from a magic tree.
Three Persons comprising one Godhead. An incredible, infinite, and difficult to understand God who manifests Trinitarian structures throughout creation. If you can understand the god you are following, I'd start looking for a bigger God.
No one can explain trinity because its all made up.... Man says Jesus is God and God is God and the Holy Spirit is God...... but you know what the Bible Says...When Jesus was Baptized voice from heaven this is my son.....the beloved.... whom I have approved......Matthew 3:16,17 Jesus asked his disciples who they thought he was and they said you are the christ the son of the living God and Jesus said they answered correctly.. Believe Mans Trinity Or The Bibles clear teaching mattehew 16:16,17..
Dixie1914 1 year ago
this is insane why god need a son?jesus christ was a prophet not son of god.i remember a clever explanation about holy trinity a christian scientist come to abdelhamid kechk and said to him about holy trinity then kechk said : is that like a finger who is composed from 3 parts but is one finger .then the scientest said yes so kechk said the finger is simple or composed ?the scientist answered composed absolutely.then kechk said so who compose god and he's the first and the last.
alisaffah 1 year ago
Absolute genius! One of my favourite films of all time. Coltrane and Idle work great together.
stoffershorty 1 year ago
I mean AFTER the trinity falls on robbie, sorry.
moseva 1 year ago
did any of you guys notice eric idle laughs before the board falls on robbie coltrane? bad editing there, I wonder how on earth could that have escaped them...
moseva 1 year ago
God is love and God is an expressive God. Now, the relationship of the father and the son is like heat to a flame. God is the flame and God's expression or his Word, is the heat. And this fire has been burning forever because God has always been saying something. Now, God is of such a nature that when He does something it becomes truly real and this begets his Son ( from all eternity). The father and Son have a mutual relationship to one another and like having the spirit of a family
PistisIasis 1 year ago
or the spirit of a group where you have essentially a communal person, you have that same thing in the relationship between the Father and the Son but as with God the relationship between the Father and the Son produces an actual Person, known as the Holy Spirit. We believe in one God, the Father and creator of all things that are seen and unseen. We believe in the Son, eternally begotten of the Father begotten not made, through whom all things were made.
PistisIasis 1 year ago
One in being with the father. We believe in the Holy Spirit, the Lord the Giver of life who proceeds eternally from the Father and the Son.
PistisIasis 1 year ago
LMAO
rockerstarblack 1 year ago
cont:
Brian Hope/Sister Euphemia: Does the Trinity make any sense to you?
Charlie McManus: Oh, no. No, it makes no sense to anyone. That's why you have to believe it. That's why you have to have faith. If it made sense, it wouldn't have to be a religion, would it?
[a Trinity board on the wall falls on Charlie's head]
ASL8306 1 year ago
Cont...
Charlie McManus: No, the ghost was a dove.
Brian Hope: Let me try and summarize this: God is his son. And his son is God. But his son moonlights as a holy ghost, a holy spirit, and a dove. And they all send each other, even though they're all one and the same thing.
Charlie M: You've got it. You really could be a nun!
ASL8306 1 year ago
From IMDB: Charlie McManus: You've got the Father, the Son and the holy ghost. But the three are one - like a shamrock, my old priest used to say. "Three leaves, but one leaf." Now, the father sent down the son, who was love, and then when he went away, he sent down the holy spirit, who came down in the form of a...
Brian Hope: You told me already - a ghost.
Charlie McManus: No, a dove.
Brian Hope: The dove was a ghost?
ASL8306 1 year ago
It is a Bit of a Buggar... Isn't it.
wwwTheBookbaggs 1 year ago
Was Eric Idel a JW at sometime in his life? I like the way he challenges the conventional church thinkings and has many times used God's name Jehovah in his comedy for years......Just wondering.....
wwwTheBookbaggs 1 year ago
GOD IS ONE . Jesus is the messengr of God , the holy spirit is the angel gabrial . peace
TheCoolmuslim 2 years ago
prove it! that the bible says that?
enerG99 1 year ago
I don't get it! I am Deaf does it have Closed Captions?
By the way .... I don't believe in trinity.
spiderman13ful 2 years ago 2
I made comments with what they are saying, but also send a message to the owner of the video to put CC or subtitles in.
ASL8306 1 year ago
Haha, I LOVE it!
ASL8306 2 years ago
HAHAHHAHAHA, rly funny video.
raginggenocide 2 years ago
What peolpe loose sight of is GOD can do whatever however He wants to do it. He wanted to baffle the religious so he came in a way noone could fathem. As a BABY? Just that is mind boogling. He could of come in the clouds with all the angels of heaven. IF HE wanted to.But once you accept JESUS the blinders come off and you understand.. GOD is all powerful and HE came to save the world for us! And all the questions and doubts disappear because HE fills your heart with LOVE, JOY AND PEACE!
jmegj5 2 years ago
Did God or the Bible say anything about this scheme to baffle the religious, or did you just pull this out of the air ? Seems like a petty thing for the God of the universe to come up with. Playing tricks.What about all the Buddhists who don't accept Jesus but are filled with LOVE JOY etc. When people are good and kind they are said to be showing Christian virtues. What about the good people in the world who never heard of Christ or don't believe in him? Christians can be quite presumptuous.
rookaponz 2 years ago
So if God sent his son to die for our sins and God and his Son are the same person....was it a suicide? If God was dead when Jesus died , who raised Jesus back to life? When Jesus prayed to God while on earth...was he praying to himself ? I"m just asking...not that any of it matters anyway.
rookaponz 2 years ago 3
Well it does matter because many people dismiss Christianity so quickly because it doesn't make sense to there logic. The bible says the natural man is not able to take in the things of the Spirit of God: for they seem foolish NEITHER CAN HE KNOW THEM BECAUSE THEY ARE SPIRITUALLY DISCERNED. CORINTHIANS 2:14. So without the Holy Spirit it is foolishness to our human minds. We need the Holy Spirit to fully understand the Bible.However NO Jesus did not commit suicide.
jmegj5 2 years ago
If natural man cannot understand the things of God then why is your understanding of God and his word correct? Where in the Bible is the work Trininty mentioned? Check into pagan history a little and see where the idea of a Triune God came from and was later introduced into Christianity...just like Christmas etc.
rookaponz 2 years ago 13
@rookaponz No doubt. Trinity originated with Babylon and Egyptian religions.
SilentMonument 2 years ago 8
suicide!! lol halarious.... ya who exactly was he praying to.......
enerG99 2 years ago
What's UNEXPLAINABLE is why God would leave heaven come to earth in human form (phillipians2) die a HORRIFIC death on a cross,overcome sin hell and the grave SIMPLY BECAUSE HE LOVES! John 3:16. In Isiah it says HIS flesh fell like ribbons HE was beyond human recognition. I was raised a Jehovah's Witness and didn't believe in the trinity either. Then I met JESUS in a REAL way. HE has radically changed my life and He WANTS TO DO THE SAME FOR YOU. SAY JESUS I'M SORRY, FORGIVE ME, COME IN MY HEART!
jmegj5 2 years ago
so you're not one of Jehovah's Witnesses then, just "raised" that way??
ASL8306 2 years ago
NO! I "was" a commited Jehovah's Witness, I said "raised" to prove I was one from birth until I was 19!
jmegj5 2 years ago
huuuh,,,, you dont make sense.... please read carefully at what you wrote.....
enerG99 2 years ago
The only 'mystery' of the Trinity is...
HOW CAN ANYONE BELIEVE IT??!!
ROFLMBO!
CanCry 2 years ago 4
look up origins of the trinity in the catholic encyclopedia.... its a manmade theory .... one scripture in the bible doesnt prove the trinity....
enerG99 2 years ago 2
I've seen contradictions in the bible. And I've seen scriptures for and against the trinity. So, maybe we're suppose to all get along despite our difference in opinions on translations and interpretations? Funny thing is, we don't all agree to disagree. Can't we all just get along?
thudson99 2 years ago
please post scriptures on what you say are and are not for the trinity????
enerG99 2 years ago
Just read The Emperor's New Clothes by Hans Christian Anderson. It explains allot!
Pookadeezer 2 years ago
I bought the DVD - the movie was ROFL
Nastralife 2 years ago
love it when the pic hits his head....he he he..
ConnaughtVaughan 2 years ago 3
Does anyone know where I can find the english or portuguese subtitles for this movie? I looked everywhere.
LGEM1982 2 years ago
Light on the biggest hoax in the Christian faith! Good show!!
estudiantedelaBiblia 2 years ago 4
The biggest hoax is running head to head with Hellfire and the immortal soul. It's really a three way tie.
boogiemaam 2 years ago 4
I won't argue with that!
estudiantedelaBiblia 2 years ago
when the picture fell on charlie that wasn't actually supposed to happen. look at brian whe it falls on him. 1:25.
SwearingMonster 2 years ago 2
great movie!!! cant stop watchin it and laugh to die!!! ;)
daluv12 2 years ago
sister euphemia of five wounds
daluv12 2 years ago 2
Let's see... just because you cannot comprehend the incomprehensible, you dismiss it. Interesting.
So, show me "dark matter".... oh.. something about the lightbulb, eh?
Well, then, why doesn't light keep speeding up? Oh... BLIND FAITH is it? Well, that explains it.
cfell 2 years ago
The Creator of the Universe wanted humans to understand clearly who he is and what he stands for. This includes the identity of his Son. So, since the bible speaks in lengthy detail on the subject of "who is God, and who is Jesus" is is a monumental cop-out to say the Trinity doctrine is "incomprehensible". It simply isn't in the bible. Even Eric Idle understands that.
boogiemaam 2 years ago
No one has nor will ever properly explain trinity. i have asked over 50 christians, read books on it.The great christian scholars have never been able to explain it. You say ice/water/gas or the york/egg white/egg shell as a paradox of the trinity. the word trinity is Not even mentioned in the bible. The idea of trinity was started by a man called paul who NEVER met jesus. it is the biggest hoax ever. BLIND FAITH
onesinsomnia 2 years ago 2
do you mean paul from the bible because that paul actually said that jesus was the son of god but of many different words in greek that cannot be translated they just put their thoughts and didn't let the bible speak for itself. the holy trinity is blasphemy!
SuperTeriyakiMaster 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
As a Christian I will like to explain the trinity to you. Yes the word is'nt in the bible but the Father, Son and Spirit are one. In Revelation 22 Jesus says "I am the Alpha and the Omega the begining and the end." Think about that. If a child was named after his father who was named after his father they would be the I, II and the III. Would the III say "I am the FIRST " or would the II SAY " I AM THE THIRD" ? NO! Because they are seperate . But Jesus did. HE WAS explainig HE was GOD.
jmegj5 2 years ago
love this film(:
zeinab911 2 years ago
Hillarious and true. What a combo.
Josiahvidz 3 years ago
The definition of Christianity
The belief that a cosmic Jewish zombie can make you live forever if you symbolically eat his flesh and telepathically tell him you accept him as your master, so he can remove an evil force from your soul that is present in humanity because a rib-woman was convinced by a talking snake to eat from a magic tree.
BrosaJarlen 2 years ago 3
Love this film it's one of my favourites and particularly love this scene. Robbie looks great in that skirt!
oceanofemeralds 3 years ago
5 out of 5 and the best explanantion of a rubbish principle I ever heard.
bob2006ty 3 years ago 2
Yep. Makes about as much (or in fact more) sense than the official explanation.
jamesjohnking 3 years ago 3
Brilliant lol
leinstergirl 3 years ago 2
five wounds, for short.
Philosophobia 3 years ago 2
This is one of my all time favorite movie scenes. Thanks for posting it.
colibriverde 3 years ago 3
The trinity is unscriptural. It's not found at all in the Bible, but is rather, a pagan doctrine formulated by apostate 4th-century christendom!!
JWinCT 3 years ago
Three Persons comprising one Godhead. An incredible, infinite, and difficult to understand God who manifests Trinitarian structures throughout creation. If you can understand the god you are following, I'd start looking for a bigger God.
keruzate 3 years ago 3
Great scene. :)
Tromminator 3 years ago