What an absolutely amazing song, there are songs put down as classics but this one should be in that catergory for the depth of its lyrics and the meaning of them to, one more thing i can't believe someone put a dislike on this obviously no music taste at all
How could we europeans, supposed "first world", "civilized", start such a terrible episode in history. It makes me feel so sad when I walk on places where I know people fought to death against their equals. We forget too soon the meaning of war. I live in Spain, the place where Europe made the "training" before WW2. We did not go to WW2 because our country was previosly devastated on a war of brothers were germans, italians, british, etc practiced with their bombs. Never more. Love btwn nations
Thanks for pointing me towards the Black Swan theory.. whoa heavy stuff, but still none the wiser as to the conection with Arnhem.. maybe be I can"t see the woods for the trees as they say, but cheers all the same.
Good performance
Antdog5 1 month ago
What an absolutely amazing song, there are songs put down as classics but this one should be in that catergory for the depth of its lyrics and the meaning of them to, one more thing i can't believe someone put a dislike on this obviously no music taste at all
daguitarmon64 2 months ago
Had me in tears mate and i dont cry much
YourMumJC 4 months ago
im lucky to have Athlete Discography.
MrPibbs100 9 months ago
amazing! i'm learning this on my guitar, you have inspired me joel :)
iloveathletexxxxx 1 year ago
How could we europeans, supposed "first world", "civilized", start such a terrible episode in history. It makes me feel so sad when I walk on places where I know people fought to death against their equals. We forget too soon the meaning of war. I live in Spain, the place where Europe made the "training" before WW2. We did not go to WW2 because our country was previosly devastated on a war of brothers were germans, italians, british, etc practiced with their bombs. Never more. Love btwn nations
martindeserdio 1 year ago
he's so sexy
kenkenka 1 year ago
amazing Joel :)
Kris58Letang 1 year ago
today november 14 th rememberance day and this song says it all i say no more just listen ?
karlohull 1 year ago
Amazing song, the video to this song (actual video) is really moving, amazing voice too (:
hannahmrforan 1 year ago
Amazing to see an artist who sounds just as wonderful without the studio tools. Thank you, Athlete. You truly are something.
hation100 1 year ago 3
A fantastic song, a fantastic story and a fantastic performance.
I like athlete a lot, seen em 3 times so far and hope to see them in Newcastle upon Tyne again soon.
DavidParkinPhoto57 1 year ago
every time i listen to this song i'm amazed again at how absolutely gorgeous it is... one of my favorites.
drummaboi19 1 year ago
i really like this version, raw but very real.
fraxinnelle 1 year ago
Thanks BBQPeanut :) Joel does have a great voice eh!
did you see the doc film, Black Swan Story, on youtube - watch?v=aTHwri9Rn4Q
or shorter 11min version on vimeo 7289822
richardedkins 1 year ago
This is so amazing, when I saw them in concert I was like, wow, his voice actually is the same unedited, it's just that fucking spectacular.
BBQPeanut 1 year ago
not quite as good as thom yorke's black swan song!!
DoAPooAndThenGambole 1 year ago
incredibly touching.. like dying of thirst and being given water.
One of the best songs ever
spacemonkeygod 1 year ago
I as I listen, I am weeping!
tearsofmars 1 year ago 2
One of the best bands out there. Just beautiful music.
soundcanal 2 years ago 2
this is such a quality song! its better than the recorded version, just amazing! brings me close to tears
hubert97 2 years ago
Amazing.....
mce161 2 years ago 2
This video is amazin. Joel has a quality voice. (2 the men who fought) Well done lads and good luck 2 our boys in Afghan!
12cabbageman 2 years ago 5
thanks cabbage man
the full doc film is now at
richardedkins(dot)co(dot)uk
richardedkins 2 years ago
great better than recorded sound this is top dog
tigercat1966 2 years ago
ahw, r.i.p to your grandpa.
pretty song.
ImTakingYouWithMe 2 years ago
Thanks for pointing me towards the Black Swan theory.. whoa heavy stuff, but still none the wiser as to the conection with Arnhem.. maybe be I can"t see the woods for the trees as they say, but cheers all the same.
signpo890 2 years ago
Brilliant performance brilliant song, but can i ask, why is it called black swan song?
signpo890 2 years ago
I think Joel took inspiration from Nassim Nicholas Taleb's book The Black Swan and The Black Swan Theory
read more at their site athlete(dot)mu(slash)band
richardedkins 2 years ago
ur grandpa will be very proud!! RIP ur grand dad and all who fought with him!!!! athlete rule !!!! ;-)
wolfieuk2000uk 2 years ago
Documentary film about the story behind the song can be watched at vimeo (dot) com /7289822
richardedkins 2 years ago
thanks that was very intresting:)
thereverendreeves 2 years ago
Love this song gonna order it now hope you do too as all monies are donated to the royal british legion
karlohull 2 years ago
Your grandpa will be proud (:
Cant wait to buy my copy on 9th of November :)
'Lest we forget.'
x
tcthatsme007 2 years ago
Love this song..........R.I.P to your Grandfather
jumpman19900 2 years ago
beautiful.....
rhysdad 2 years ago
this is absolutely fantastic - hopefully now Athlete will get the recognition they deserve.
11/11/1918 - We will always remember - thank you for your sacrifice - RIP
ryansaffery 2 years ago 7
Song of the year, amazing.. this is my fav version to
NwMagic 2 years ago 2
This is amazing.
talkemotome 2 years ago
i love athlete
08003004 2 years ago
You have the most beautiful voice. It made me cry listening to you sing this song. Really great. Thank you.
ailime1000 2 years ago
love it totally awesome
WOM8ATSZZZZZZZZZZZZZ 2 years ago
Please show your support for The Royal British Legion by subscribing to our channel!
Thank you
royalbritishlegion 2 years ago
Just read his story from WW2, what a soldier! All credit to you for this tribute.
trebor6153 2 years ago 2
Thanks for putting this up absolutely brilliant.
MD20066 2 years ago
Incredible song what a great tribute to his grandpa!
bergjagger 2 years ago
wow this is beautiful :D
mallyt2001 2 years ago 2