Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (23)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • That was such a brilliant perfromance from afairly underrated song. In fact, Richard Wright himself was the most underrated member of the band. He also had a very good singing voice. He sang a lot in the early days, and as much as I love Roger Waters, it's a shame that Richard didn't get to sing as much in the later Floyd years when Roger really started to take control of the band.

  • you see his swollen eyes? -- death is so unsayably sad, and you see that gilmour is crying his eyes out in this time, he really strains to contain himself

  • As far as for Poor performace, as people say, He was Mimicking Syd,

    So he could not literally be himself, as it was a Wright/Barret song.

  • As far as for Poor performace, as people say, He was Mimicking Syd,

    So he could not ereally bee himself, as it was a Wright/Barret song.

  • Very tocuhing. I love both Dave and Rick.

  • First of all, if you have ever tried to play a clean slide sound on a Telecaster then you can appreciate how difficult it is. Secondly, "he's no slide player"?? I would encourage you to listen to "One of These Days", "Shine on You Crazy Diamond Parts 6-9" and "Great Gig in the Sky" to hear how much of a slide player David Gilmour is.

  • @HeyYouTribute don't forget "High Hopes"

  • @HeyYouTribute David has long said that he prefers playing the lap steel slide guitar with how the song was structured he couldn't play the lap steel in the performance.

  • So soft spoken and gracious.

  • Syd Barrett played the slide guitar on the original of this song...one of my all time favs as well.

  • he's no slide player

  • @autinspare hes one of the best really.....hes making it more like the original

  • one of my all time Floyd faves

  • Wright could write a good song (no pun intended). It is a shame he was not more forthwright in producing matriel, he prefered to help the others with their music.

  • i'm ok with contemporary show mess, ripoff weak rock, pop experimentations, teen silly stuff, "cold electronica", it's there, it's about evolution. some stuff is good, some is not, some it's pure crap... but all goes out of the window compared to this great man and the history of Pink Floyd. no glamour, hullabaloo, hiss: just the comfortable certainity of having those great guys who made eclectical elegant immense music. the rest is just many steps behind.

  • sorry for the bad english

    Gilmoure gets old... but who cares....

    his lifework will still survival generations !

    thanks !

  • ehhh... painfull an dreadfull old years... wish giilmour good health.. he's seems very old in this video but as always he put all his power in this song and made everything awesome just for his friend wright now we all do know what real masterpiece is :3

  • incredible

    wonderful

    i bet they whole put their 100% to remember HIM

  • recognize*... apologies for the typo

  • Around 4:23 and throughout the entire video you can recodnize the grief thats coursing through Gilmours veins. Tragic loss from my favorite band..

  • If memory serves me right, when this was released, there were 5 members of Pink Floyd who played on the album. Syd was not in good condition then.

  • This song was recorded for the first album, before Gilmour joined, but was left off. They put it on the second instead.

    According to Gilmour 'Set the Control for the Heart of the Sun' is the only song where both Syd & Gilmour can be heard. Syd had recorded his bits before Dave joined.

  • Absolutely WONDERFUL ! Thank you for sharing this with us all.

    I notice Gilmour neglects to mention that it was Syd and not himself who played on this track for "Saucerful Of Secrets"... but it's great to see him doing this song as a tribute to Rick.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more