Life is fragile and those people suffered ill fate. Words don't easily express how to feel about women and children being massacred in such a fashion. Just be captured by the music.
only criticism of this song is.. it should be longer, the amount of times i've started the song again to satisfy myself on how fucking amazing this song is.
@OneManAndHisToaster well it was almost perfect, thom made a mistake on the guitar lol, perhaps it was the only thing in that performance keeping him a human being, and not an immortal god lol (which he is pretty damn close to)
As amazing as Perfect!!!!! Hail Tom Yorke I will Lay me down In a bunker Underground I wont let this happen to my children Meet the real world coming out of your shell With white elephants Sitting ducks I will Rise up Little babies eyes, eyes, eyes, eyes Little babies eyes, eyes, eyes, eyes Little babies eyes, eyes, eyes
@km1735 the song is based off of a Hemingway story wherein a couple debates over a casual cocktail as to whether or not the woman will get an abortion for her unwanted pregnancy. the "hills like white elephants" are a visual symbolism. the hills look like white elephants in the spanish countryside where the story is set. and the image curiously conjures up also the image of a fetus. thom is talking about not "letting this happen to his children," refering to the white elephants themselves
@truthslap i think he is trying to tell you those babies in the bunker were killed like they were never born. which is why white elephants is from that story. it's an allegory, he says. it can be that it is exactly the truth. or it can be that it is just in the meaning of the idiom. who are you to say? a nobody. it's not your song. therefore you are not an authority on it.
Comment ne pas sextasier devant cette voix dange, accompagnée de ces quelques accords légers, le tout pour donner ce petit chef dœuvre classique Merci de mavoir donner ce plaisir...RESPECT
I hate it when Radiohead fanboys thumb down negative comments about Radiohead. This version is quite obviously worse. Anyone with half a brain can see this.
Are you joking? How hypocritical can you be? I was defending someone who stated their OPINION and was thumbed down seven times by moronic fanboys who seem to think every opinion THEY have is correct.
i was saying that he made an irrational statement that said "this version was obviously worse." was a very opinionated statement, expecially with his wiseass followup.
ive said like many others that this song is super great but...anyone knows why Thom plays this song either with Jonnys or Eds guitar? I mean I think there has to be a reason or a meaning behind that, cuz Thom has his own guitars right? (gibson sg, jaguar... or something...accoustics)
Prrrooobably just because it's a hollow body. Hollow body guitar's produce a more acoustic sound then normal electric guitars like Fender Squire's or whatever. I don't think there's some hidden meaning behind it or anything...
I don't know if you've ever noticed how many guitars some professional musicians own. Some have quite a few, AND, some guitar companies make more than one copy of each model. If you take these things into account, it could mean that he has his own guitar, and this is it. Albeit maybe the same as one of the other members' instruments.
dude that really scares me, and i think you completely misunderstand this music... its full of despair but its not meant to make you end your life, its much deeper than that
nada es mas importante en la vida que amar, compartir y perdonar aun con aquellos a quienes odias... no puede rebasarte tu depresion porque la depresion solo es parte de la vida no lo es todo.
Nothing is more important in life than love, sharing and forgiving those you hate... surpass your depression because its just a part of life, not everything.
I couldnt agree more with the Spaniard :) (or spanish speaking person)
well i dont agree with those who told you "dude that really scares me...and i think you completely misunderstand this music"...because, they are not perfect and...there is no right meaning for a song, as long as you feel it...BUT...your comment and your youtube account name seem like "im a poor emo and i want to kill myself because no one understands me" drop it...you just make us laugh hahahaahahahaha
yeah? i like both, but i prefer the HTTT version more. it really captures the message, with the solo guitar and thom harmonizing in two different pitches.... to me, it's really something special, tapping into my soul heh
Thom has the VOICE of an Angel. God using his creations to give messages to his people.
Worship the creator and not creature - for his servants are not to be worshipped as God - But worship God himself, whom sits in heaven and is blessed for ever and ever.
I think the live version lost alot of power. The thing that drew me to it was the haunting choir-like vocals. Thom is a good musician and all but I give more credit to Jonny Greenwood, that guy adds such a unique sound to Radiohead. Personally I like it better with the multiple voice parts.
Life is fragile and those people suffered ill fate. Words don't easily express how to feel about women and children being massacred in such a fashion. Just be captured by the music.
prevailingcaused 3 days ago
that was goog ...
samthepspuser 2 months ago
@robbiek77 thom's nonreligious.
Inrxz 3 months ago 6
I love the studio version for this: he sings low, out of his natural range...against THIS. Amazingly beautiful.
gunandapackofsndwchs 5 months ago
This is SO GOOD!! Also, this wasn't even the correct song I was looking for :D
thoughtsrmisgivings 9 months ago
there is nothing more chilling than this song.. nothing more moving. it's a portrait of a massacre, there is nothing more horrifying than reality.
truthslap 9 months ago 3
I want this floor/carpet in my bedroom....now
jjysoserious 1 year ago 2
lol @ voice crack
what13521 1 year ago
only criticism of this song is.. it should be longer, the amount of times i've started the song again to satisfy myself on how fucking amazing this song is.
juschiazza10 1 year ago 4
@juschiazza10
I agree. But still everytime I play it i get goosebumps from my tooths till my nech
Zeejv87 1 year ago
wow.... wow wow wow wow wow...such a smooth, pure and powerful voice
samirrh05 1 year ago 2
very good this song around the atmosphere is good and no one with whom I have the joy of music
GeanCarlos1233 1 year ago
California dreaming slow version... lol
bujuluv1 1 year ago
i like this version but cut the crap, the reservoir version is far better, i can even say it's perfect!
OneManAndHisToaster 1 year ago
@OneManAndHisToaster well it was almost perfect, thom made a mistake on the guitar lol, perhaps it was the only thing in that performance keeping him a human being, and not an immortal god lol (which he is pretty damn close to)
coruptgovt 1 year ago
To the one person that put a thumbs down to this video, you just don't have a clue? This is absolutely breath taking.
flaperise 1 year ago 2
can't be coping with this
roblowefan1 1 year ago 2
it's just different
wonderandwhisper 1 year ago
panranguari 1 year ago 2
what the hell one guitar one voice,,,, so strong
GRJNPKSN 1 year ago 12
0:01 look like lisa loeb :)
ghaibboy 1 year ago
Omg, he's good
asbani991 2 years ago 2
awesome he sings the high parts
nameless12345 2 years ago 6
No comment....
anninasilver 2 years ago 2
technically you just commented by saying this.
adamframe 2 years ago 5
Wow, this man is genius.
White elephants refers to war that a country cannot sustain.
Sitting ducks most probably refers to Iraq/Afghanistan.
km1735 2 years ago 2
Its also an allusion to Hemmingway's "Hills like white elephants."
complespyr0 2 years ago
@km1735 the song is based off of a Hemingway story wherein a couple debates over a casual cocktail as to whether or not the woman will get an abortion for her unwanted pregnancy. the "hills like white elephants" are a visual symbolism. the hills look like white elephants in the spanish countryside where the story is set. and the image curiously conjures up also the image of a fetus. thom is talking about not "letting this happen to his children," refering to the white elephants themselves
franzferdinand345 2 years ago
Well what you're saying is rite, but I'm sure Thom refers to the current war situation and not a couple.
km1735 2 years ago
Comment removed
truthslap 9 months ago
@truthslap i think he is trying to tell you those babies in the bunker were killed like they were never born. which is why white elephants is from that story. it's an allegory, he says. it can be that it is exactly the truth. or it can be that it is just in the meaning of the idiom. who are you to say? a nobody. it's not your song. therefore you are not an authority on it.
ourscienceisasham 6 months ago
@ourscienceisasham why am I still getting comments for this? find something better to do.
truthslap 6 months ago
@km1735
It's based on a book by hemmingway..
lufc550 1 year ago
made me cry...
emoxmasochist 2 years ago
AMAZING!!!
21474933433 2 years ago
Comment ne pas sextasier devant cette voix dange, accompagnée de ces quelques accords légers, le tout pour donner ce petit chef dœuvre classique Merci de mavoir donner ce plaisir...RESPECT
tigerorion13 2 years ago
Beautiful
soadfreak8888 2 years ago 10
what guitar is that?
jjkaf2 2 years ago
Looks like a Gibson ES 335. Odd... it's usually Ed that plays those!
cameljockey90 2 years ago
please thom appoligez for the hippocrate like me i know u dont respect,but i just feel so bad when i feel this song and iknow im free....thats it
pullattila 2 years ago
perfect
mgg80 2 years ago
I hate it when Radiohead fanboys thumb down negative comments about Radiohead. This version is quite obviously worse. Anyone with half a brain can see this.
PJGR21 2 years ago
an opinion and a fact are two quite different things. don't think that every opinion you have is correct.
theatomguy11 2 years ago
Are you joking? How hypocritical can you be? I was defending someone who stated their OPINION and was thumbed down seven times by moronic fanboys who seem to think every opinion THEY have is correct.
You're an idiot.
PJGR21 2 years ago
did i thumb him down? no.
i was saying that he made an irrational statement that said "this version was obviously worse." was a very opinionated statement, expecially with his wiseass followup.
stop lurking.
theatomguy11 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my friend can sing this far better, i agree with you
eatpoorpeople 2 years ago
I know, that's why this video has so many negative comments about this performance... this performance isn't terrible.
PJGR21 2 years ago
lol..i meant IS terrible
PJGR21 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this song absolutely sucks without the other 3 voices in the background i thought that the other band members sang them but it seems only thom did.
mersault002 2 years ago
Che voce..mamma mia
15Surprise 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
chcek out my vids. thanks mates.
Hicalmespongebob 3 years ago
his voice can be so haunting at times and i think that's amazing for a singer to do
fruscianteman 3 years ago 4
Hail to the thief
Amnesiac
Pablo Honey
üsd meg tagzikurt elöször tankkal ha nem megy utána gyalogossal ha megy elsöre tankkal akkor ird meg.
egyenlöre ne bonts katonát. de most beállíthatod
70tank 30% toronyra. ahogy ütöttél egyböl irj mert gyorsan fogunk cselekedni.
In rainbows
Kid A
kristianbejb 3 years ago
ive said like many others that this song is super great but...anyone knows why Thom plays this song either with Jonnys or Eds guitar? I mean I think there has to be a reason or a meaning behind that, cuz Thom has his own guitars right? (gibson sg, jaguar... or something...accoustics)
Computerdisplay 3 years ago
You're probably reading too much into it.
ellerbrock24 3 years ago
ok..:(
Computerdisplay 3 years ago
Yeah i've noticed that too. There must be some reason behind it. I wish i knew what it was
Conero08 2 years ago
Maybe he just prefers the specifics of the sound out of theirs :/
ElWeasle 2 years ago
That could well be it. But to be honest, I think it would sound good regardless of the guitar he played it on
Conero08 2 years ago
Prrrooobably just because it's a hollow body. Hollow body guitar's produce a more acoustic sound then normal electric guitars like Fender Squire's or whatever. I don't think there's some hidden meaning behind it or anything...
Shmuhlest 2 years ago
ive said like 5 times now that i was reading too much into it.....this is from months ago, why bother making a comment about it?
Computerdisplay 2 years ago
I don't know if you've ever noticed how many guitars some professional musicians own. Some have quite a few, AND, some guitar companies make more than one copy of each model. If you take these things into account, it could mean that he has his own guitar, and this is it. Albeit maybe the same as one of the other members' instruments.
lukasdatree 2 years ago
GOD, How a man can give so much emotion?
A W E S O M E
EolScofield 3 years ago 6
i dont really like L.A version anymore the le reservoir one is off the chart
billyradiohead 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
when i tried to kill myself, i was listening to this song over and over again..
introvert230 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think when i'm in a plane with my iPod and it would crash, i'll also turn this song on.
Cavensjan 3 years ago
dude that really scares me, and i think you completely misunderstand this music... its full of despair but its not meant to make you end your life, its much deeper than that
adheebghazali 3 years ago 7
translate this greengo:
nada es mas importante en la vida que amar, compartir y perdonar aun con aquellos a quienes odias... no puede rebasarte tu depresion porque la depresion solo es parte de la vida no lo es todo.
jossserigraf 3 years ago
I will have a go...
Nothing is more important in life than love, sharing and forgiving those you hate... surpass your depression because its just a part of life, not everything.
I couldnt agree more with the Spaniard :) (or spanish speaking person)
Ge0rge12345 3 years ago
well i dont agree with those who told you "dude that really scares me...and i think you completely misunderstand this music"...because, they are not perfect and...there is no right meaning for a song, as long as you feel it...BUT...your comment and your youtube account name seem like "im a poor emo and i want to kill myself because no one understands me" drop it...you just make us laugh hahahaahahahaha
Computerdisplay 3 years ago
Dude...WTF
xxxPainKillerX 3 years ago
Has anyone heard the Com lag version? I will (Los Angeles version)
yakuzacruz 3 years ago
yeah I prefer that one
GNRsakuL 3 years ago
yeah? i like both, but i prefer the HTTT version more. it really captures the message, with the solo guitar and thom harmonizing in two different pitches.... to me, it's really something special, tapping into my soul heh
lozengeoflove 3 years ago
Goosebumps and shivers down my spine...
This is the year I finally see Radiohead live. A MUST.
Kveds 4 years ago 3
he has the best voice around
joshk1231 4 years ago 5
Thom always kisses the mic when he's singing,
I want to be his microphone =)
katetay 4 years ago 4
for 2:20,time has stopped!!! Thom is GOD in Earth !!!!!
lucas0908 4 years ago 32
@lucas0908 Don't you mean from 0:00?
katenzcool 1 year ago
@katenzcool He means for 2 minutes 20 seconds, not just that part of the video :)
Tommeh101101 1 year ago
@katenzcool S/he says "for 2:20" not from - meaning that time has stopped for > two minutes.
EUmkl 9 months ago
@lucas0908 And the God of the whole Universe.
Artingence 1 year ago
@lucas0908 If I could rebuke for this comment.
Thom has the VOICE of an Angel. God using his creations to give messages to his people.
Worship the creator and not creature - for his servants are not to be worshipped as God - But worship God himself, whom sits in heaven and is blessed for ever and ever.
God Bless
robbiek77 4 months ago
@robbiek77 God? lol!
aaqaaqaaqaaqaaqaaqaa 4 days ago
coolest guitar ever!
ashleybunbury 4 years ago
I think the live version lost alot of power. The thing that drew me to it was the haunting choir-like vocals. Thom is a good musician and all but I give more credit to Jonny Greenwood, that guy adds such a unique sound to Radiohead. Personally I like it better with the multiple voice parts.
Dustin322 4 years ago
yes but remember that thom did all of the vocals for the choir-like effect on the studio version... and he wrote this song
ViciousGuitarist 4 years ago 22
...and one day, god created thom yorke. there's no way i'd be as passionate about music as I am, if it weren't for radiohead/thom
wurble 4 years ago
God must've been very, very happy the day he created Thom.
neolithics 4 years ago
Radiohead is known to be the best live band, so it's no surprise...I'd kill to see them though
Darkstarskater123 5 years ago
the best falsetto in the businness. amazing
Coldacre 5 years ago 2
you cannot compare the albulm version with this one man! I mean, ion the albulm, there's like 8different vocal tracks by york, plus one by o'brien.
garbette 5 years ago
LIES!!
MonolithFIJI 5 years ago
Actually, Phil also has a part.
Mambuto 5 years ago
i don't think that's true, or at least if it is, it was unnecessary. i have performed this song with one other friend and it seems equally as full
eatpoorpeople 2 years ago
well done!
UAHAHA 5 years ago
Perfect. Even better than the album version.
hijaktaffairs 5 years ago