Added: 4 years ago
From: IKA3003
Views: 686,459
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (282)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • werewolf

  • asemanare fantastica intre vocile lor...superb...

  • una cagada el tema de depeche".... semejante banda podria haber hecho un mejor cover!!! una decepcion!!!!

  • obra prima è essa música

  • obra prima é essa música

  • best song ever

    @dublinbarterclub: if they didn't, they would have mentioned the co-writers for sure

  • They did not write this song alone.

  • You did a good job here.

  • I would have played "AlI want is you"!

  • One name everyone should be aware of -- Builderburgs

  • @icebergbart216  I think it's Bilderbergs

  • joshhh hotttt

  • the best part in this song is between 3:29-4:00

  • el amor es como una cadena alimenticia!!!

  • I luv this song 

  • awesome quality 8)

  • U2 will probably not play this song live again - i believe the quote was something like this "if we did we would probably all have to go see a therapist" ;D

  • saudades chel...que saudades

  • q saudades chel

  • quando eu ganhei o Achtung Baby que tem a musica da trilha sonora da minha vida One..veio tbm de brinde essa musica eeh,eu ouvia o album todos os dias quando eu voltava do colegio e estava só em casa..pensava no meu amor e no nosso futuro hj eu sei como é... eu vivo esse futuro .. 1 presente eterno que ja dura 11 anos te amo pretinho...

  • Maybe the best U2 song of all time???

  • Brilliantly done my friend....

  • I was so pissed at Alex for keeping them apart but then I realized I could have done the same cruel thing being so madly in love.. they say love makes you do crazy things... I hope I'm lucky enough to experience true love and passion....

    great combination of the movie and the song! thank you!

  • really good job!

  • this album had so many hidden gems they should release it again

  • @assfacerz its the greatest album/cd ever.....

  • Comment removed

  • The movie is too heavy, but is beautifull.. I love it.. :)

  • @peacelovemusiclivity .....and you need her like a drug.......

  • Best U2 song ever ... & probably the most underrated also.

    Wow! St MOF-ing Bono

  • wonderful

  • love this movie

  • the music blends so well with the video...special movie, special song

  • simply love this song... sweetheart your so..cruel.......

  • Love from Italy...

  • the best group, best song, best, best... all the time!!!!!!!!!!

  • I just saw the movie. You did such a good work!

  • Balad from U2's greatest album

    

  • I feel bad for the chick that wants to be noticed. It sucks to be there in front of someone that you desire and they don't even notice you. You would do anything to get their attention. Needing them like a drug is a curse that can only be lifted if the person accepts you. I have this addiction for someone that doesn't deserve it. This person could care less but this emotion of desire we as humans can't control. I stay away from this person but my mind brings her back against my wishes!???

  • @95589 Guess most of us go through something like this at some point in our lives. Seems that we all want what we can't have. One of my sisters once told me that wanting was the key to unhappiness. Don't we all want something? :\

  • @FroggyHope

    She is right when we want we are asking for more than we have and must accept the consequences of our wants. But it still sucks not being able to control our desires and the people we desire.

  • There's sooo many passssssion in this song!

  • .....awesome!!!!.......

  • Never seen the film but the video was perfect for the song. Bravo.

  • Bono is credited as the sole lyricist.[46] In contrast to U2's previous records, which frequently made political and social statements, Achtung Baby is more personal and introspective, examining love, sexuality, spirituality, faith, and betrayal.[62][63][64] The lyrics are darker in tone, describing troubled personal relationships and exuding feelings of confusion, loneliness, and inadequacy.

  • And again I fall in love with this prerect connrction of dound and picture....

    beautiful music and movie...

    greetings from warsaw ;-)

  • @przemalcz13

    thx from Tbilisi :))

  • @przemalcz13

    Trust me, I've been an editor for 15yrs, haven't seen the movie and think you have done a wonderful job. I don't have the actual movie moments clouding my view(s) on the scenes you selected so to me the emotion of your picks are spot on!

    Great Job

  • Greetings from Warsaw, 2 every U2 fan in the whole world, all over the Milky Way ;)

  • best song of u2

  • what kind of movie maker you use? I did a video on wicker park too but the audio sucks :(

  • @imparadoxical

    I used simple, crappy windows movie maker :)

  • @IKA3003 REALLY?HOW DO YOU DOWNLOAD THE MOVIE???,I BEEN TRYING OVER AND OVER ,AND NOTHING,IT DOES NOT ALLOW TO DO IT,CAN YOU EXPLAIN ME REALLY QUICK HOW?PLEASE!THANK YOU.

  • Best U2 song ever pure class...love to see them perform this live

  • of all the movies in the entire world...this one? really?

  • great lyrics to this song

  • You did a pretty good job there!

  • The real spirit of U2 is best felt in 2 of their songs: "So Cruel" is one of them. The other one is "One".

  • This is by far the most underrated U2 song ever! Wish they play it on their next tour.

  • @towar222

    I totally agree with you, this is my one of the favourites song of U2, and I'm sad they haven't played it in such quality that it deserves. Wish they palyed it in their next gigs. Pity on me, I guess won't be there :(((

  • @IKA3003 Why you won't be there? :S

  • @towar222 I meant gigs that will be in nearest future, like Istanbul (also nearest City from my country), but I have another plans and honestly I'm in a huge financial crisis to afford that trip :(

  • @towar222 wish they played that song (So Cruel) and Acrobat; most underrated songs of all time of U2, on any of stages!!! please prepare them on any of nearest gigs folks!!!

  • @towar222 i agree with you !

  • thanks for this sweet moment. good job!

  • Me encantó la película, me encantó el actor tiene unos ojos para enamorarse, no encontrar un par de ojos como los suyos que me hagan pensar que el amor en realidad existe

  • congratulations! the end is absolutely BEAUTIFUL and fiting in an amazing way with the song! AWESOME JOB!

  • i love this song !! :)

  • This song always makes me cry, the beauty of it is undefined.

  • 5:00 don't cry :(

  • @1:08 she looks really beautiful

  • great, unbelievably great !

  • I've watched this movie only once and it instantly became one of my favourites. I was mesmerized by it. Oh, and I love this song too. It's pretty awesome.

  • uwielbiam tego słuchać i oglądać...

    przepiękne...

  • Comment removed

  • best resume for this movie. Coldplay has the best song for this, though

  • Coldplay?? U2!!!

  • Read again, mate. I was refering to the resume of the movie. Why post if you cannot read ?

  • well try to express in a different and more complete way your opinion...because your words are misleadingly!!!

  • It is pretty clear, mate ! Try to translate it into your language and you`ll see. Take care !

  • It is what I usually do... -_-' bye bye :)

  • well done vid!

  • muy bueno lomejor de u2

  • this is brilliant! awesome movie too!

  • Weren't both of these girls in "Troy" with Brad Pitt???

  • i think so

  • Temaso de un gran disco

  • @extreme67 how sad is your life its funny you never have a bad word to say about the actual sons were you post comments u2 take that as a compliment. this songhas more depth than you have intellectual depravity.....

  • i love this guy

  • ACHTUNG BABY EL MEJOR DISCO

    de U2 YEAHHHHHHHHH MY FAVORITE BAND

    u2 is the best band of the world

    THE BEST ALBUM IS ACHTUNG BABY of all times

    TODOS SUS ALBUNES DE U2 SON LOS MEJORES yeahhh

  • uoooorrr die bläst bestimmt geil. i think she's quite a cocksucker :D

  • does anybody know what`s the name of the dance she do during the movie? I want to start taking classes of that type of dancing but I don`t know the name. If anybody can help me I will be very grateful for.

  • aww awesome I make sure I listen to this at least once a week , I havent seen the movie But looks kinda sad , like she loves him but he loves someone else and I get all emotional...But u2 and the songs can do that to me as well..wow true love its so amazing to discover and have.

  • its not like that. watch the movie. its awesome, and u l b satisfied that u watched a very good movie. its very romantic.

    the way he is loving her, i wish some day, some boy does that for me.

  • Yes it sucks to need someone like a drug that in the end is poisonous. I know it's bad for me but i would do it in a heartbeat just for the memory and satisfaction of the desire.

  • Very, very beautiful....and moreover I love this U2's song, and I was sad that there are no video clip for it. It' done now !!!

  • To tell the truth, this clip is my favorite one on you tube...because of the resons...So cruel is in my oppinion one of the best in achtung baby record...and I liked so much the movie wicker park... perfect connection...of sound and picture...

    greetings for all u2 fans...from a former one ;-)

  • love it! Well done!

  • that video and music.... no need to say more. just one word.... magnificient !!

  • am I weird for wanting the girl that kept them apart to get the man in the end? there is something so tragic about her.......

  • no, you're realistic, just in the movie, love wins the cruelty, real life isn't this way.... real life is..." shits happens".... I like the end of the movie, the middle and the beginning, a beautiful movie... given hope to us, miserable humans..

  • Well done! This song is haunting and the video fits perfectly! Great job to IKA3003. This brings me back to high school and the romances and love we had - thinking that you would never recover from losing your true love!

  • U2 and Josh Hartnett...all in one... what more could you ask of life? :)

  • @AngelOfHarlem1704 omg you're so right! i love love josh he's my ideal man!

  • jpanson,thank's for your commentary , your right ....that's so many elena's around and you never know,when and how you fined one...

    But when you really love..is hard to forget it just like that...

    She's not on my live,but she is on my heart...for little wile.

  • Great vid...especially considering that this is probably the most amazing song EVER.  If you have or have not been in a place where this meant something out of the ordinary to you... well... sorry... this is an amazing piece of music!!!

  • Hi 95589...

    She is cruel cuz i love her so much and i try to talk to her ;and she don't wanna talk to me ..not even wanna let me see her ;and that hurt me so bad

    I let her know that i love her and i need her ,but she don't care at all..i was at time when she love me but ,i don't know how she stop fell that for me ..

  • hoe079, I feel your stuff.. but believe me, there are so many more "elena's" that you don't understand where you are or what is in store for you, just hang in there

  • hey! When you will find a solution for ur story, tell me please, ok?

    we have the same situation...

    May God help you

  • HI..walid12manutd.

    I will tell u when i fined the solution for my situation...Maybe the only solution will be only the time ..

  • A story of love and cruelty..like you Elena..you are so cruel..

  • why is she cruel?

  • Hello 95589,I know that she didn't care what she did and I am pretty sure that she realized the consecuences of her actions,but I wan to tell you that, you can be 100% sure that I will not be one of those fools,we will never have the opportunity of seeing each other again,I left the state where she lives,I decided not to see her again and I will never ,ever,try to think about a come back,end of a story,I don't love her anymore

  • you may not feel love but deep inside there's something you can't ever erase? we are cruel in nature and we only notice pain when we hurt.people leave imprints on our souls whether good or bad!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Hey Korlandito, ok you're over her. You've made the transition that many never make. Many people are either held prisoners by love or they hold others prisoners. Not everyone can break away like you did. At least you loved and hopefully you felt love in return.

  • ..and leaving a treasure behind for someone else to find it and keep it,once she realize what she did ,it would be late,'cause in her rush for a new passion, she forgot where she put away those keys to get into my life again,sad story,but such it is life,take care friend,Orlando

  • korlandito,did she realize what she did? did she even care? people like that rarely see themselves the way they really are. they expect that people will come running to them when they show up again. how many of us fools let them in?????

  • ..wings,now,if she ever decides to come back to me,I will be gone,my heart will never mend,but my mind got stronger enough to endure the moments of pain that will always knock on my heart's doors,it's not pride,it's that she never valued my being,so what is left to me for doing is to remember that I loved and gave the best of me,I feel O.K with myself for having done that,and about her,she will always remember that to love someone else ,she hurt deeply someone else,so she left ,closing doors...

  • jpanson,thanks,when I say what I put down here in words it's 'cause I went through this painful experience ,I felt it,yes, and I will feel this pain 'till the end of my days,I loved, like nobody will ever do, to that person,I put all my energies into that relationship,all my life was given to her,but there are persons who don't believe that a love so big can be real and they fear and doubt about it,really weird human behavior,so my bird flew away to another nest and I was left with my broken ...

  • you're welcome 95589,good luck and be strong

  • korlandito, you seem to be the keeper of this song and video... bless you. This is no doubt the most beautiful and moving song ever written... and if you haven't ever felt this and think you are in love... well you haven't... you haven't felt IT until you have literally LET IT GO and then had to turn it down when it came back... GB U2 forever!!!!

  • ..they act by instincts and inner impulses,sad but true,that's why is so complicated to keep a relationship with a woman going,the only way to do so it is to use an ilogical behavior,give them what they don't look in their ideals but what make them feel subdue,force, once in a while,you got take the risk,if you don't wanna see your bird fly away,it's my opinion ,maybe I am wrong,good luck

  • korlandito you have good instincts. i think the bird needs to be let go. Eventhough this bird haunts my heart i know that we can never fly together. I can lie to myself but the gratification doesn't last long. reality sits in and i must look at myself in the mirror. i know that the claws are are deep and as i pull them out they take a part of me. how can you fly with someone when you don't trust them?? thanx Koralindo!!!

  • sorry for miss spelling your name Korlandito!!!!

  • 95589,I totally agree with you,I don't know whether you are male or female ,but whatever you are ,there's something about what you say that makes me feel that you are a man,because the behavior you explain correspond to a woman,they are after ideals and when they get to reach what they searched for ,they don't know what to do with what they caught,just the thrill of the chase satisfied their ego,then ,they offered themselves to the bad one,'cause women,most of them don't reason......

  • one of the best U 2 songs from the album ;;achtung baby;;

    very nice song

    ty.. u2

  • I love this movie u_u

  • this moving vid fits so well with such great song,excellent!

  • Sometimes you give someone all of you and it's not enough. They choose to give their hear to someone who hurts them.You sit there waiting for them to see you but they are blinded by their pride. It sucks to see someone you love want someone who doesn't love them but only hurts them. How do you get the hooks out and let it go and let them hurt in someones arms? It's hard to stay away and not answer when they call. You answer knowing they are only using you but you take the chance.

  • it matters to me

  • Thanks for reminding me of this nice movie. And I can't even put in words what I feel about "So Cruel". God bless U2 for making music that touches our heart.

  • This song says it for anybody that was in love and was hurt, including myself, you hang on thinking that they will come to there senses but they don't, it hurts like hell. You think they still love you but they use you as a pawn to get what they want. Beautiful song that I think everybody can relate to

  • Comment removed

  • It's also the way Bono sings it. Very emotive, heartbraking. Plus the heartbeat that goes on in hole song. One of the best of one of U2's best albuns.

  • One of the best U2 songs, very underrated

  • underrated.... or over looked?

  • Very Beautiful. This song is extremely intense. Paying attention to percusion, reminds me the heart beat. Seems that everything in it was deeply planned to exposure the meaning of love, that in most of cases, is unrequited.

  • 2:24 is one of the most heartbreaking couple of seconds you can see, you can see her heart break in the next 2 seconds.

  • veryyyyyyyyyy well done......

  • Good job IKA3003!

  • beautiful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • love this song!<3

    nice work. kudos (Y)

  • Great work dude

  • wonderful, i love this song so much ! Very underrated, one of the best U2 songs

  • beautiful ..

  • great lyrics, just busting up with someone today after 2 years and this song is so apt!! shes told me to down load pussy cat dolls and listen to that, ive told her listen to this!! sad & beautiful at athe same time" i put my lips to her lips to stop the lies" amazing

  • nadie la ha trducido??????? ni modo, lo tendre que hacer yo, some day......very close.......

  • te quedo bien ,felicidades ,is achtung baby ! album.

  • I read where Bono wrote the words to this song after Adam's break-up with Naomi Campbell.

  • this film is wicked.

  • those who have not seen this movie(wicker park) a must see!!! Hated the begaining, but at about the middle of the movie it starts to make sense, and an awnsome ending.

  • this is the best u2 song going. love it.

  • One of U2's best.

  • Best band to come out of Dublin............

  • Love this song, U2-BEST BAND EVER!

  • Amazing song for U2... Great video...

  • Love the video! Great Job! This song is amazing.... U2 was able to look inside our hearts and minds and create an amazing song to describe what they saw.

  • from all of U2's great songs this is my favourite! nothing describes a sad love better than a song! and this one describes all there is in love...i think!

  • great song, good choice of visuals

  • it's a great movie. at least I think it is. it has a good story:)

  • it's the deffinition of perfection:) and the movie is really really great!!!!

  • Thank you for your nice words!

  • I love this movie, and this song it's almost like pleasant obsession to me....so using both it's just....perfect. and you did pick the right scenes. good job:P

  • "I gave you everything you ever wanted...

    It wasn't what you wanted"

    For the people wiht broken heart.

    Sweetheart,

    You're so cruel!

  • the entire album ACHTUNG, BABY! is magic! I LOVE U2!

  • Es excelente este video....sobre todo por la cancion...y la mejor banda del mundo!!

  • excellent job

  • thanx

  • wat album is this song frum

    some 1 tell me pleazz

  • This is from U2's Achtung Baby.

  • Really nice job. However, I do think it can use a little editing to tighten it up. Love the part where the girl powdered her face.

  • iit's "Wicker Park"

  • whereabouts is this film set ??

  • Beautiful song

  • Junto con "with or without you", "all I want is you" y "stay", son a mi juicio las canciones + románticas de la banda. Qué hermosa es Rose Byrne, no he visto el filme, pero élla me encanta, debieran darle un rol protagónico.

  • Achtung Baby was the best U2 album ever with Joshua Tree a close second.

  • The Best off

  • beautiful!!

  • i was seeing a girl called bexky for 2months we got on so well thn she told me she still love her ex!! love is so cruel