Added: 3 years ago
From: DavidCookCentral
Views: 238,008
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (321)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • He ruined the song!,he has a good singing voice,but he doesn't sound like Bono! I can't stand it when people take other artist songs and butcher it! That song was good because Bono sang it!

  • @stuozzo23 He does not need to sound like Bono! He is original, he is individual and that is what makes him special

  • This song... always makes me cry

  • Beautiful. Absolutely beautiful. David Cook is great.

  • gonna do a cover myself! Thank you David cook for killin it..in a good way!

  • i have kissed honey lips. felt the healing in my finger tips and it burned like fire, this burning desire... =) THE BEST SONG EVER..

  • shit you know this guys good when simon says phenomenal

  • very nice cover

    but i think he lowered the song by 3 half steps so he can hit the notes easier.

  • @JakobRobert00 the funny part of your statement, while I agree with it, is he has the range to EASILY hit it 3 half steps higher, which if you listen to any of his new songs, becomes obvious. I am convinced that he tried to throw the competition in Top 2 to Archie by being safe and it didn't work!

  • i love this song. original and david cook version. he makes any song "cool."<3

  • Randy: "I'm going to call you DC now, cause we're boys. Right?" *awkward pause*.... David: "...right".

  • I still can't get over the incredible tonality of this haunting performance.

  • My god, he's got a great voice! All of his covers are as good or better than the originals (my opinion) and that just pisses some people off.

  • @u8myapple agreeed, his voice makes every single song ten times better <3

  • Sounds like Ronan Keating covering it LOL

  • this is my 2nd favee cover of this song

    sorry david but i gotta give it to disturbed <3

  • @r0ck3rJadeOnyx3atchu You just made me throw up a little. That cover is alright until they decided to let the guitarist do that break/solo which sounds like it belongs in a different song.

  • calm down david,your voice aint 4 this song,but u can sing and u do it in front of people which is brave 75% of poeple dont want to be on stage,keep on its your ship and u steer it.

  • I'm so glad he kept himself restrained on this song. he kept it simple and let the music speak for itself. but what i love most about this performance was the ease at which he came out on stage and he owned it. didn't look like we were watching a vocal competition at all, looked like he was doing his own concert already. the way he played to the crowd, and fed off their energy, it's rare to see a new performer understand the importance of connecting with the fans, and he did just that. amazing.

  • so good looking

  • i just noticed randy said "duel of 2007", it was 2008... o_0

  • haha i live 2 minutes away from blue springs...way to represent david:)

  • David Cook... ya won the AI Crown. and yOu own it! .yOu are the most versatile singer songwriter and musician ever!

  • stop,please u ruined it,now i need to listen to bono and the group.people stop covering great songs when your in bieber era,young buck.

  • @0458FEO Then don't listen!

  • I DONT LIKE IT WHEN PEOPLE COVER MY FAVORITE SONG

  • the best idol so far.. by a damn mile the best...

  • David Cook wears that American Idol Crown w respect dignity and all the talent it could possibly represent! 3 years + and "Still"!

  • Chuck Norris was in the crowd, and he jizzed in his pants.

  • Still today EVERYTIME I hear Bono sing this on the radio, I hear Davids version on top of the original one. That's how good he is.

  • David you're awesome man, but I'm sorry, nobody will ever cover Bono.

  • Right now it feels ridiculous that Randy even thought to say, "I think you could've done more." He made it his without tearing it to shreds and making it something it's not. I still adore this. David Cook is always. Always. The Man.

  • Didn't Bonny Tyler sing this before U2 sang it? How old is U2?

  • @Addicted2Muzic94 Around 30 years now. They went big in 1980.

  • @EaglesStir OOOOoOoh! Thanks!

  • @EaglesStir Wrong, they went big in '87. Joshua Tree defined them, brother.

  • @Netlocd Well Joshua Tree is probably their biggest album, but they gained recognition in '80.

  • @Addicted2Muzic94 U2 wrote this song, and it was released in 1987

  • @DMcCU2 Ok. Thank you! :D

  • so sexy!!!!

  • at 0:44 if you look at that and the u2 milan version they both look similar

  • Best season and best winner. 

  • 3 U2

    2 Disturbed

    1 DAVID COOK!!!

    i completely forgot he sang this, that was amazing

  • @GreyShadowUchiha almost the same mate

    3 Metalica

    2 Disturbed

    1 David Cook.

  • This is total rubbish. Idol is complete bullshit. The original artist of ISHFWILF, U2, are the real winners. This makes me want to literally puke my guts out. Every last one.

  • @TheFly360 This is a great version of this song. I love U2 and David sang it very well and put his stamp on it!

  • @TheFly360 Oh shut the fuck up. He did a good job covering it, and I'm a huge U2 fan...

  • i am looking for a cover of this song with a raspy soothing deep voice anyone knows one?

  • @VladVolkova yea me,serious i know what your looking for.i got that voice.peace

  • @0458FEO why dont you send it to me pal?

  • The only thing wrong with this is the stupid sounding guitar

  • David cook killed U2...

    

  • @duduvielmo Don't be hatin'

  • better than original!

  • This is the best cover I've EVER heard from him. Its a perfect, soulful fit for him.

  • I've noticed that with David, you ether love what he does or hate it. Cuz he changes the song to be his own rather than follow the original, which personally I think is great! It shows more talent and makes him more original to me, but thats me.

  • @darkestrose2005

    I ahte american idol, but sometimes they put out some really great singers that are unique.  I agree with you on the part about Cook. I mean I think this song is great, but his cover of "The World I Know" by Collective Soul wasn't that great

  • Np One can Beat my DAVID!!!

  • Doesn't have the same emotion of a U2 performance, but it's American Idol which is just one big muzak session anyway. If the guitar had the correct tone it would have made a big improvement.

  • great voice

  • I'd rather watch old Idol clips than watching this year and last year's AI.

  • @swebright

    I totally loved this performance from David!!! I know they keep saying this years talent is best. But I agree I'd rather watch old idol clips especially David Cook's. I am a David Cook fan for life.

  • How did randy not like that performance. I think it was one of my favorites.

  • BARF! passionless performance. 100% showboating. I'm not fooled by your veneer, yo. This sux

  • Replay.. replay.. replay.. haha :-) I can't like this enough times!!!

  • The best cover ever! Love this!

  • I'm a huge U2 fan, and this is the best cover i've heard

  • What a performance.

  • my favorite season ever..although now i love james durbin...but you DAVID COOK u will always be my IDOL..

  • I can't have enough of David Cook even after these years. :)

  • Comment removed

  • i love cook :)

  • i love him! i cant belive this was in 2007! it did not seem that long ago when i was watching this on tv. no other season compared to his. :) he is and always will be the best american idol winner

  • Wow, he is great live! Now I understand why he won :)

  • one of my fav songs i love u2! legends!

  • THIS GUY HAS A GOD GIVIN TALENT AND IT SHOWS TIME AFTER TIME. HE CAN ROCK ANYTHING AND SING THE TELEPHONE BOOK. :) LOVE THE HAIR TOO.!

  • THIS GUY HAS A GOD GIVIN TALENT AND IT SHOWS TIME AFTER TIME. HE CAN ROCK ANYTHING AND SING THE TELEPHONE BOOK. :)

  • Still love it after all this time! David has an amazing voice and is a natural-born performer...love him! He deserved to win, and his post-Idol music proves it!

  • David Cooked and rocked this 4 U2!!

  • This bring back chilling memories

  • the best of american idol 2007...and the best performer DAVID COOK

  • absolutly amazing i love you david cook <3

  • nah the band is always great but you have a awesome singer on top of it and the music just sounds better

  • I have the impression that the quality of the support band has decreased last 3 seasons...

  • i miss dis season. i love David Cook :))

  • Comment removed

  • i suddenly remember why i fell in love with david in the first place. amazing singer. good luck to him

  • pretty sure that's Carl Winslow from Family Matters at :10 sec mark playing guitar.

  • i miss him so much!

  • @GEMFREDD same here ;)

  • my god I never get sick of this.

  • This version is crap...Celtic Thunder version rules

  • He is really good but i prefer Storm Lee!

  • @rachaelwhite1 You really have no taste then.

    Notice he has gone now, and guess what David won..

    what does that tell you..

  • @mjluvx It's my own opinion and fair do's I'm glad he did. Still doesn't make him the best at that song :)

  • This show went downhill after this season.

  • @relonation Adam Lambert's year was sick

  • Best American idol

  • amazing, beautiful voice, i couldn´t ask for more

  • Very credible version

  • the song has been sang by a better singer.. :))

  • david did not just define what american idol was all about. he gave american idol its most defining moment. PHENOMENAL!

  • Well i think he did a bad version of it and u2 wouldnt over been proud it that..

  • favourite AI winner of all time, he'll be a freakin legend in no time at all.......DAVID COOK IS THE MAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • This was the night and the song where I fell for David Cook. Over two years later and I still love the guy. Plus, he can really sing.

  • Epic! My favorite singer singing my favorite band....

  • @9NinS nothing compares to U2

  • I LOVE U2 and I like David Cook a lot. I'm glad he did this one, and wish he'd recorded it as an Idol single. Did he do as good as U2? No! Of course not--it's U2 for goodness sake, but this is a solid performance. The arrangement isn't that great though...it's missing the restrained intensity of the original and sounds more like a hired wedding band is playing it. I don't like the "scoop" at the end, but it works for this situation.

  • Best thing to come out of American Idol, by a mile.

  • @Crittab I'm sorry to tell you but that'd have to be Carrie Underwood. Its a good song and he did it justice but there is no way that he is the best. Carrie is by far the most talented country artist today let alone some music contest.

  • Seal

  • Eifler121: David didn't intend to get all the credit for Billie Jean. Ryan announced it was Cornell's version but I guess the judges didn't hear it nor never heard of Cornell's version. Actually, I thought Cook's version was much, much better than Cornell's version. He didn't do it exactly like Cornell, he changed it up even more.

  • i wish he recorded this one.

  • i love it how he ignores the judges XD

  • This is how American Idols are supposed to be... that was the show's biggest moment.... when David came on and won. :)

  • bono wud havebeen proud but not compareable

  • I LOVE IT!!!!

  • DAVID COOK IS THE BEST AMERICAN IDOL EVERRRRRRRRRR

  • well done!...i always luv u2 and bono...but this david cook can do well in his genre

  • he is the best american idol ever better than the previews and upcoming american idols

  • I love david cook and he is wonderful but ppl saying tht he's the best out of the american idols?!? not even close, he has to pass Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson first

  • I see this and know that he will be doing this for the rest of his life! Love this rendition of U2's classic song!

  • here is an example of a rocker who doesnt need a guitar and stage presence which i lacking big time from season 9

  • He's great, but I think Adam is definitely comparable to him in terms of vocal ability.

  • The best of all the american idol...!!he really is.....

  • That night Cook seemed larger than life to me. He's such a beautiful man, beautiful singer and beautiful performer. Being on stage for him just seems to come so naturally it has to be a God given talent. I love him and always will. No one else compares.

  • gives me chills

  • he is killing me! I LOVE HIM SOO MUCH!!!!!!!!!!!

  • wow a voice he has :D

  • No matter what David sings, he's still one of, if not THE, best singer on American Idol EVER! He's got the voice, the performance, the looks... everything! So glad he won! :D ♥♥♥

  • america you done a great job buy voteing david cook the american idol in 2008 i was sitting on my sofa here in england hopeing david cook would be cowned american idol he got better each week i had to get my cousin who lives in califorina to by his album for me and send it to me and he is the best american idol guy to of won does anyone no what he is up to now is he married got kids getting married would love to no what he is up to now

  • A-M-A-Z-I-N-G!!!!

    One of the best songs ever

    i'm amazed!

  • I love him so much :-) Best ever winner of American Idol.

    Just wonder what happen with the number of viewers? This song reached to a million plus views month after he won. Then now just less than 100k ? Has anyone or YT deleted those high rated videos of David Cook?

  • @SendMeAnAngel09 yeah!!! ur freakin' right dude he's the best winner ever of American iDOl!!!!!

  • His voice sounded pretty fried that night.

  • David is definitely for been the best american idol there has been. He is amazing and he has got a really good voice and he is never boring. He also isnt bornig and bland because he has been the most verstaile singer who has won american idol. He will always be the best american idol ever. True performer. GO DAVID UR GREAT

  • favorite AI performance

  • i think U2 would've been proud of that

  • @ryanmacdaddy1000

    For sure! Awesome Cover

  • Still freaking love this. Last seasin and this season pale in comparison.

  • @7skittlesful This season was by far the best. Lee (before I heard beautiful day), Crystal, Casey, Mike, and Siobhan were all great. If any of them were in a different season they would've won. This season saw the most people who were actually looking to become their own artist. Not wanting to sing other people's songs. I hate that David Cook gets all this credit for being original with his Billie Jean performance. He did it exactly the way Chris Cornell did. He was good, but no artist.

  • @7skittlesful Adam and kris were good.. that's about it. I know they are somewhat rockers but yup, this was my fave season since Daughtry !

  • @tallderektoronto I agree with you 100%.

  • freakin orgasmic. (:

  • this was amazing!

  • After watching American Idol last night and then re-watching David Cook videos again today... Last night they were just awful! Especially compared to him!

  • I think this is by far the weakest season of AI yet. I even resorted to doing homework the last couple weeks instead of watching.

  • love this performance! especially when he does that last note! amazing! love u cookie!

  • I really hope the contestants do more U2 songs on Idol this season. Yes, they're challenging to sing, but they're high quality, which would be great for the show.

  • HIS VOICE MELTS MY HEART. :)

  • i STILL HAVEN'T FOUND WHAT i HAVE BEEN LOOKING FOR SINCE I'VE MET YOU DAVID. i WAS ADDICTED TO THIS SEASON. I KINDA MISSED DAVID ON AI. HIS PERFORMANCES JUST BLOWS ME AWAY. :) LOVE U DAVID!

  • he's truly AMAZING

    so agree with u, sweet !

    love David Cook, what a beautiful voice ?

    but i still wonder why have some people try hate him ? what ugly like monkey & boring voice ? OMG ... cant believe it, they're so blind or jealous !

    I cant see anything ugly terrible in him LOL yes, of course cuz he's great & so cute :))

    he's one of most awesome AI story <3

  • ..YeAh ..America got sense for choosing this man! Uh Oh! David forever!! .fr.Philippines..

  • This is my all-time favorite American Idol performance.

    <3

  • It's just that his voice tone is fashionable now. You cant compare that's to Bono's, those are different times.

  • @AranvalNightshadow exactly correct

  • He is so darn GOOD and when he looks into the camera...oh my! I have always loved this song and I love it even more when David sings it!!! Never gets old!

  • For once america had common sense and voted for the right guy :D

  • This is the AI performance where I fell in love with David Cook. I also love the U2 original version. In general, I have to say I prefer David's voice over Bono's. I prefer U2's earlier records, and this is one of the best.

  • every song he sings he does better than the original artists, and thats from a U2 fan.

  • ur an idiot and baised

  • I like shiny things

  • The guy is amazing. Period.

  • is a period the same as a full stop?

  • @jacko111213

    only if you are sending a telegram...

  • just gonna say: wow. fucking incredible.

  • this was pretty fucking good..awesome voice