The thing I don't like about remakes of songs such as this is as Plato said art is flattery and twice as false as reality, but not only are song lyrics usually restrictive they don't explain themselves and yet to take an idea and only change the music seems pointless and requires no intellectual improvement on the idea.
This will sound CRAAAZY but when I bought The Lone Ranger as an import (I live in the states) back in 1998 I remember listening to this song on repeat a grand total of 38 times. Yeah I loved it that much. As much as I love The Beatles and I really dig their version of the tune I gotta go with the Suggs rendition as my favorite. Real heavenly thing he has going with the girls singing in the background. This rendition is catchy as hell.
I remember Suggs talking on TV about this upbeat version of the Lennon tune. Suggs said he intended to cover it at the same tempo as the Beatles track, but Sly Dunbar (of Sly and Robbie fame) who produced The Lone Ranger album, suggested he speed it up and give it some 'oomph' to alter the whole dynamic of the song. After a few run throughs, Suggs was forced to concede that the producers idea was best!
This cover Isn't bad In my opinion, but Its so different than the origional that I personaly dont like it. But its not bad, just doesn't have feel to it that I liked In the beatles version.
It's different yes but good all the same, I much prefer covers like these where it's a stark contrast to the original. Really shows a creative spark in the coverer(not a word but I can't think of a better one :P )
@timlove1 me too. there is something about this version. the bv's are good. if you like this listen to Scritti Politti's version of "She's a Woman" similar radical re working of a Macca song
I like this a cover done and differently..JOHN LENNON wrote this in a lighthearted way anyway. Alot of people view BEATLES songs as some kind of holy grail which can never be touched butlot of the fab four tracks were written in a humerous way and I think LENNON would have liked this version.
Great cover. At least they changed it instead of these bands who basically do the same version of a song only worse. Better than the original? Well...hardly. I wouldn't call this a butcher of it, but I agree there should be some sort of provision in the World Court about butchering Beatle songs.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Ha. Telling people what to listen to and what not to listen to? Keep posting such brilliant statements. You think the World Court statement was a sarcastic joke I made maybe? You're the best sweetie.
How can a yank seriously say that when you actually pay shit rappers and R n B singers to RAPE your National ANTHEM at every major sports event. "aaaand the ho ho ho ho me offff da da beraaaaaaave one time one time can i get a reeewind"!
You dont know shit about SKA jamaican or british.I dont give a shit about you or the Beatles end of the day all the FUCK they were was an early FAGGOT boyband like New Kids on the Block.MADNESS are the dogs bollocks and Suggs is a fucking LEGEND!
Er yeah whys that so hard to work out.The screaming girls the ponsy hai do's just because it happened in the 60's dont mean the term boyband cant be coined.THEY INVENTED ALL THIS FAGGOT SHIT!
dude ur a FUCKING DOUCHE. what do you call this shit then......these guys definately look like a Faggot Boyband to me. oh and by the way nice user name. U R A Fucking WANKER.
I remember this tune it came out in 1995 or 1996..ish didnt it?I just thought it was a fun tune to be honest it wasnt a classice by any means but we are talking about an era that was banging out tunes like Saturday night,Skatman and other crazy party tunes back then.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
doing a ska version of i'm only sleeping is like doing a swing version of strawberry fields forever.. or a metal version of our house for that matter. it just doesn't work, it defies the whole mood and point of the original.
His only havin a laugh.People like Suggs aint got nothing to prove anymore.all the stuff Madness release today is for the FANS.Where as people like saint Paul have people on his payroll telling him that his "still hip with the kids man!" all day long.
But some people do enjoy versions that defy the point of the original.
Mack The Knife is a very popular American lounge music standard, but it was originally written as a serious German opera song about murders in South London.
If the song still retains some integrity or the new style version stands up then yeh, i agree, but ska i'm only sleeping doesn't, it just sounds naff, but each to their own mate.
you do get the impression a lot of people on here are madness fans in denial.. it doesn't make you any less of a fan of madness (which I am) to admit this song is awful.
Like you say, this is TOTALLY down to personal taste so there's not really anything to argue over really. Personally I do genuinely like this version of the song, honestly!
I don't think I'm in denial because I never liked his other solo singles "holiday" and "the tune" which came out at the same time, they always felt like filler to me. It was nice to see him on TOTP again but I wasn't blindly saying all his stuff was good cos it wasn't.
dick head? You dont think thats a bit harsh? I presume it was you who rated the comment negatively, so forgive me if I do the same to you...didn't realise I wasn't allowed to express an opinion
The thing I don't like about remakes of songs such as this is as Plato said art is flattery and twice as false as reality, but not only are song lyrics usually restrictive they don't explain themselves and yet to take an idea and only change the music seems pointless and requires no intellectual improvement on the idea.
drivebyg 4 weeks ago
this version and the video reminds me of Robbie Williams' Tripping, i dont know why ...
rkogts619 6 months ago
Hey that is my name is he an imposter? Enjoyed the tune...
Suggsneaux 8 months ago
Lennon liked Madness, so I think he would have approved.
dominickearney 11 months ago 3
I used to think "Suggs" was rather attractive... I remember this version quite well...
shmuli9 11 months ago
See, I love the beatles, and love when good musicians do good covers of their songs. So, I thank you suggs. This is very fabulous.
latigremusic 1 year ago
The genius that is Suggs
jimgoodmanful 1 year ago
So fucking BADDD. ABOMINATION
funktapus 1 year ago
con lentes se parece a Ben Affleck
tuzoangi 1 year ago
This will sound CRAAAZY but when I bought The Lone Ranger as an import (I live in the states) back in 1998 I remember listening to this song on repeat a grand total of 38 times. Yeah I loved it that much. As much as I love The Beatles and I really dig their version of the tune I gotta go with the Suggs rendition as my favorite. Real heavenly thing he has going with the girls singing in the background. This rendition is catchy as hell.
Mind1973 1 year ago
suggs is so sexy would love to meet him
musicmad65 1 year ago
i like it.. and i like the beatles version too.
HappyNeil 1 year ago
like it .. it fun.
HappyNeil 1 year ago
I remember Suggs talking on TV about this upbeat version of the Lennon tune. Suggs said he intended to cover it at the same tempo as the Beatles track, but Sly Dunbar (of Sly and Robbie fame) who produced The Lone Ranger album, suggested he speed it up and give it some 'oomph' to alter the whole dynamic of the song. After a few run throughs, Suggs was forced to concede that the producers idea was best!
me1onhead 1 year ago
Haha my fav Beatles song, and one of my fav band ( well band singers )
masterofscotland 1 year ago
classic
jobber25v 1 year ago
its good yeah
cajf1970 1 year ago
He's playing the Irish Centre in Birmingham on Thursday, and I'm going, AND I CAN'T WAIT!!!! HE WILL BE AMAZING :D
burkezillar 1 year ago
Who is Suggs the band called Madness??
Calaitafan 1 year ago
@Calaitafan u taking the piss sonny boy
MadnessDixie 1 year ago
i want this song to be played at my funeral everybodys welcome yee haaaa
paullynskey1 1 year ago
This cover Isn't bad In my opinion, but Its so different than the origional that I personaly dont like it. But its not bad, just doesn't have feel to it that I liked In the beatles version.
arkireW 1 year ago
@arkireW maybe the problem is that it's too upbeat for the subject matter. i prefer the lazy, drowsy sound of the original. it's more fitting.
somnomagh 1 year ago
Is the guy in the plaid suit and hat Mike Barson? He was also from Madness.
Godslove66 1 year ago
yes it sure is Monsieur Barzo!
madamebarso7 1 year ago
i don't know what these people are going on about this is great i also like the beatles version but why cant i like both i don't get it ?
simonturner73 1 year ago
brilliant cover, fun song, great vid, especially love that Barzo and Smash are there!
thearchives2009 1 year ago
damn fine cover! but nothing on the original.
lordpenut1 1 year ago
anyone dont like this version, just dont listen to it! simple as that! its a good updated version I reckon.
SonicJCG 1 year ago
Not a very sleepy arrangement. It doesn't make sense as an upbeat song. It's a very laid back subject.
ueberRegenbogen 1 year ago
@ueberRegenbogen
It's different yes but good all the same, I much prefer covers like these where it's a stark contrast to the original. Really shows a creative spark in the coverer(not a word but I can't think of a better one :P )
Aidref 1 year ago
Suggsy,Barso and Smash!! this song is fab i really like it
sazzarooneyjones8 2 years ago 3
Suggs n madness rok but I don't like this for some unknown reason
la4france 2 years ago
suggs owns
greg311kid 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what a disgrace to the beatles.ya music blows these days.
klutz94306 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wtf... poor lennon =/
brunojanoski 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this kinda really sucks
crapolllla 2 years ago
No...you kinda really suck. Asswipe.
Awesome cover.
reivenlocke 2 years ago 2
horrible cover omg who let this happen?
AOCRkid 2 years ago
ahahahahahhahah :S:S:S:
Apuyina 2 years ago
he's a great performer,
fantastic cover.
should have made the top spot.
mistaben2k 2 years ago 4
brave choice of obscuire beatles song ,shoulda been bigegr.
mignonhenne 2 years ago 2
Suggs and the boys have stood the test of time - they are still awesome!!!
BlueGJW 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
suggs sux.
jiayunlim 2 years ago
He sucks at being bad... He's too good
Marshey14 2 years ago
Go for it Suggsy boy.
salvadormarley 2 years ago
shame it only reached 30
bradley2brad2 2 years ago
This was a top 10 single.
badhead 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Goes to show how shitty music is these days.
RodgersRevolution 2 years ago
great cover!
therubbersoul09 2 years ago
i like this its a good cover
lennonfan93 2 years ago 2
John would've loved it.
Detroit1967 2 years ago
I like this one. Maybe the original is better, but I like Madness style too much and here is some of that.
rodrigoraulsuarez 2 years ago
I'm a major Beatles fan and I think this is one of my favorite covers of a Beatles song.
timlove1 2 years ago 6
@timlove1 me too. there is something about this version. the bv's are good. if you like this listen to Scritti Politti's version of "She's a Woman" similar radical re working of a Macca song
chevgr 1 year ago
I like this a cover done and differently..JOHN LENNON wrote this in a lighthearted way anyway. Alot of people view BEATLES songs as some kind of holy grail which can never be touched butlot of the fab four tracks were written in a humerous way and I think LENNON would have liked this version.
allyplumb 2 years ago 18
This comment has received too many negative votes show
well not 100 percent crappy but still its the exact same lyric!
Sheenaliza33 2 years ago
Go blow a goat.
reivenlocke 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this seems like a cheap rip off of the Beetles version (AKA CRAPPY!)
Sheenaliza33 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is shit
oasarse 2 years ago
Excellent version!
killerbehindyou00 2 years ago 8
nice. this came out in '95... long hot summer...
whether you like this version or not, no need to get all biligerant and sweary, just stay in bed, float up stream...
SimonB198207 2 years ago 7
I think this is a great cover of the original.
The mod touch......
gpzb2 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
wow...he's a fucking DOUCHE. and to think he prolly got money for remixing this beatles song. DOUCHE DOUCHE
montyp919 3 years ago
is mike barson at the start of that ??????
MADNESSRULE2K8 3 years ago
Great cover. At least they changed it instead of these bands who basically do the same version of a song only worse. Better than the original? Well...hardly. I wouldn't call this a butcher of it, but I agree there should be some sort of provision in the World Court about butchering Beatle songs.
bea78tles 3 years ago 3
I don't think the Beatles deserve any special treatment. If you don't like covers of their songs, don't listen to them.
weejockpoopongmcplop 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ha. Telling people what to listen to and what not to listen to? Keep posting such brilliant statements. You think the World Court statement was a sarcastic joke I made maybe? You're the best sweetie.
bea78tles 2 years ago
Oh sorry, my mistake. Jokes are usually funny. Keep trying though, I'm sure you'll get there eventually ;)
weejockpoopongmcplop 2 years ago 7
it should be a federal crime to butcher Beatles songs
funktapus 3 years ago
How can a yank seriously say that when you actually pay shit rappers and R n B singers to RAPE your National ANTHEM at every major sports event. "aaaand the ho ho ho ho me offff da da beraaaaaaave one time one time can i get a reeewind"!
WANKERTYWANK 3 years ago
Are you defending this song?
If so, i don't give a shit what you think, go listen to more ska interpretations of formerly good songs.
funktapus 3 years ago
You dont know shit about SKA jamaican or british.I dont give a shit about you or the Beatles end of the day all the FUCK they were was an early FAGGOT boyband like New Kids on the Block.MADNESS are the dogs bollocks and Suggs is a fucking LEGEND!
WANKERTYWANK 3 years ago
Beatles were like New Kids on the Block. Nice comment. You are a very smart person.
bea78tles 3 years ago
Er yeah whys that so hard to work out.The screaming girls the ponsy hai do's just because it happened in the 60's dont mean the term boyband cant be coined.THEY INVENTED ALL THIS FAGGOT SHIT!
WANKERTYWANK 3 years ago
Hahaha.
Calm down buddy.
funktapus 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
dude ur a FUCKING DOUCHE. what do you call this shit then......these guys definately look like a Faggot Boyband to me. oh and by the way nice user name. U R A Fucking WANKER.
montyp919 3 years ago
omg, still liking the original old version from the beatles
kinglizard22 3 years ago
concha i mean cunt people change
avesavia1985 3 years ago
in fact he looks like matt damon!!! lol
tzarguy0 3 years ago
simply amazing
tzarguy0 3 years ago
Better than the original.
peterlorre11 3 years ago
I agree
Pr0bl3ms 2 years ago
one of the best songs of all time
madnessmum 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this sucks
drumsex 3 years ago
thats your opinion!!!i think different my friend
madmacska 3 years ago
horridh says best suggs song ever
horridh 3 years ago 15
a fantastic marriage of singer and cover song.... such an inspired arrangement.....
i'm sure john would have approved....
imo
rusty
rpopstar 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is a fucking slaughter
Is that a Reggae beat?
Shoot me
funktapus 3 years ago
its a ska beat, and im a big beatles fan. this is one of the more origanel covers out there
beano200821 3 years ago 6
Hes singing sense! Let me sleep!!!
dawnofthedeaddead 3 years ago
Breathes new life and rythm into the Beatles classic.
bobgrantsbus 3 years ago 2
love this.... thanx 4 video!!!!!
marienphil 3 years ago
omg i LOVE this Suggs sooooo much. If he wasnt married, I'd marry him! <3
NuttyGirlGeorgie 3 years ago 2
is that Barso playin the piano?
lfbJJCool 3 years ago
yh he is. Carl Smyth is in the vid too!
NuttyGirlGeorgie 3 years ago
I love this track!;)
Much better than the original because of his voice and the Sly and Robbie mix! ;)
Utterly brilliant!
Hotlips4000 3 years ago
I'm a big Madness fan, but to claim this is better than Lennon's original is an obscene claim.
majortony 3 years ago
Why? I've heard both, and prefer Suggs' version, nothing wrong with that, just because it's John Lennon's song doesn't make it untouchable.
ManganeseHawk 3 years ago 3
I remember this tune it came out in 1995 or 1996..ish didnt it?I just thought it was a fun tune to be honest it wasnt a classice by any means but we are talking about an era that was banging out tunes like Saturday night,Skatman and other crazy party tunes back then.
Branewbie 3 years ago
GREAT TUNE SUUGS ROX
petshopboysupporter 3 years ago
The two people in the background, are they Mike Barson and Chas smash?
sirdoccy 3 years ago 2
yh they are
NuttyGirlGeorgie 3 years ago
Suggs is good.
Camgirl73 3 years ago 3
Suggs is cool and i think he sings this song Brilliantly.
alchomy666 3 years ago 2
Marvellous
Shame this misses out the end of the song though.
VeniVidi 3 years ago
People tend to take BEATLES songs too seriously they used toi mock themselves all the time John especially..
allyplumb 3 years ago 4
not many artists can cover the Beatles and cover them well. I think they could have done alot worse than Suggs to cover this one.
djhousefire 4 years ago 4
John Lennon was a fan of early Madness so this cover makes sense in that respect.
PetchCartoons 4 years ago
I think you have to be familiar with the whole Madness sound to get this..GO ON SUGGSY, GIVE IT TO `EM!! :)
plecman 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
doing a ska version of i'm only sleeping is like doing a swing version of strawberry fields forever.. or a metal version of our house for that matter. it just doesn't work, it defies the whole mood and point of the original.
merseybeatle84 4 years ago
His only havin a laugh.People like Suggs aint got nothing to prove anymore.all the stuff Madness release today is for the FANS.Where as people like saint Paul have people on his payroll telling him that his "still hip with the kids man!" all day long.
THESTAFFIECHANNEL 4 years ago
But some people do enjoy versions that defy the point of the original.
Mack The Knife is a very popular American lounge music standard, but it was originally written as a serious German opera song about murders in South London.
tabletschool 4 years ago
If the song still retains some integrity or the new style version stands up then yeh, i agree, but ska i'm only sleeping doesn't, it just sounds naff, but each to their own mate.
you do get the impression a lot of people on here are madness fans in denial.. it doesn't make you any less of a fan of madness (which I am) to admit this song is awful.
merseybeatle84 4 years ago
Like you say, this is TOTALLY down to personal taste so there's not really anything to argue over really. Personally I do genuinely like this version of the song, honestly!
I don't think I'm in denial because I never liked his other solo singles "holiday" and "the tune" which came out at the same time, they always felt like filler to me. It was nice to see him on TOTP again but I wasn't blindly saying all his stuff was good cos it wasn't.
tabletschool 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
its diabolical
griffshanks 4 years ago
griffshanks shut up, it's fab! I'd like to see you do better dick head.
babes11987 3 years ago
dick head? You dont think thats a bit harsh? I presume it was you who rated the comment negatively, so forgive me if I do the same to you...didn't realise I wasn't allowed to express an opinion
griffshanks 3 years ago 2
This is a great cover!!! Think suggs done a hell of a job with it
suggsisking 4 years ago 2
i kinda like it x) but you know the original will always be the best
CircuitxScene 4 years ago
This song should have done better than it did!
poolfarm2 4 years ago 2