Some of these "ghost stories" were made up by the good Captain himself ... I said some, however, not all.i believe Key West is very haunted! The headstone story about Reba is true.
Interesting, but some of the facts you state aren't entirely accurate. The Bottles in the wall are actually filled with Holy Water to keep the hauntings down.
The Grave under the Hanging Tree "Reba" was actually the head stone to a woman that had been cheating on her husband with the infamous Capt Tony. When Reba died, her husband and a friend of his retrieved her head stone and placed it in the bar so she could be with Capt Tony for all Eternity.
Cool video! Big Buffett Fan here, I've visited Tony's, and I love that creepy old escene it presents with all its rich history. I love the stories, and the eerie pirate cove feel it offers. It truly is the most intresting and favorite bar I've ever visited. Thanks for the post. Got any others like it, or do ya know where I can find additional videos about the bar?
Some of these "ghost stories" were made up by the good Captain himself ... I said some, however, not all.i believe Key West is very haunted! The headstone story about Reba is true.
brotherpowell55 4 months ago
The name on the grave is elvira not reba
juggalette7272 4 months ago
Interesting, but some of the facts you state aren't entirely accurate. The Bottles in the wall are actually filled with Holy Water to keep the hauntings down.
The Grave under the Hanging Tree "Reba" was actually the head stone to a woman that had been cheating on her husband with the infamous Capt Tony. When Reba died, her husband and a friend of his retrieved her head stone and placed it in the bar so she could be with Capt Tony for all Eternity.
There is so much more to say!
morrigue333 5 months ago
I visit Captain Tony's 2-3 times a week and have NEVER seen or heard any 'ghosts'. Great info on the history though.
thegaylicious1 1 year ago
Great story! I was just there a few days ago....did not know the "hanging tree" story.
Seabee644 1 year ago
what a creepy story, I grew up in a house that was haunted.
terrilorah 1 year ago
drinking at ed geins again?
key west has some crazy shit going on
TheSaralysette 2 years ago
Cool video! Big Buffett Fan here, I've visited Tony's, and I love that creepy old escene it presents with all its rich history. I love the stories, and the eerie pirate cove feel it offers. It truly is the most intresting and favorite bar I've ever visited. Thanks for the post. Got any others like it, or do ya know where I can find additional videos about the bar?
SECgatorFAN 3 years ago