@trueblue1634 they are ,....but the video is saying monarchy and dictatorship does not TRULY exist ;) ,....it is a group of poeple,...they ahve their own council or group of people to help him to lead teh country ,.they not leading alone, there is a group behind them
O MAY GOD!!!! STOP PUTTING THIS THING AROUND YOUTUBE! THIS! THIS VIDEO IS JUST LYING, IT'S SAYING THE FUCKING WRONG INFORMATION!!!!! If you want the actually true type of politics click what the video's responding to, or GO ON ANYTHING ELSE THAN THIS PIECE OF SHIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@getgot1 lol believe what you want i dont mind ,... but telling me what to do is exactly what i hate from political systems ,...so ,....live your life, and let other live their life,... you dont wanan beleive what this video is saying,..Good ! up to you ,....but dont tell me how to think and what to do, cuz telling me such things is against my liberty , and im FREE to live like i want, as long as it doesnt affect YOUR liberty ,...so stfu with youre capital letters
It's worth nothing that using the limited scale in this video, most anarchists are closer to people who want democracy, while anarcho-capitalists want a republic (though not necessarily a traditional american one).
Chaos is the better term for "anarchy," and chaos happens whenever any group (anarchists, religious exteremists, or even those wanting a republic) tries to quickly and violently overthrow the current system. Chaos is the result of drastic change, not the ideology.
paleoton is only partially current about left and right. Left were the anti-statist, the liberal(not the same term as today) and right wanted to return to the old way with oligarch. A REPUBLIC just means representative government(indirect democracy). Anarchy, without government . Most Anarchist are non-violent and wish to set up voluntary societies. Government = Force, Anarchy = Peace. If the founders were right government would not be so large today.
@MrBlakskwrl people and government must live a philosophy to make this world work goo d,..and the philosophy to adopt to be equal with everyone, is the philosophy of liberty , you can watch it on youtube by the way ,...and the sprectrum of having all the poweron left and 0 power on the right sounds good to me,..you can say if you want 0 power on left and full power on right , i dont mind, the idea still the same. What is mainly important is , the Philosophy of Liberty to make humanity better
If you want to talk about a philosophy of liberty you should read Rothbard's "For a New Liberty." It is the blueprint for a stateless society. Voluntarism, the non-aggression principle that's philosophy and it should be applied to the state as well as the individual.
@MrBlakskwrl The founders weren't wrong the American people were sold out by Woodrow Wilson when he allowed the FED the difference being are founders had this thing called balls they would call are government out on the bullshit they pull nowadays first with words than with force.
That's the point! It's impossible to keep government small. Wilson was bad but the start of the betrayal of the individual was with Hamilton immediately following the revolution. Starting with Lincoln everything was down hill- he snowballed into the progressive movement(Wilson). Even before Lincoln the era of big government was dawning(check out Jackson and the Force Bill). Government is always as big as it can be.
@MrBlakskwrl No see my point was yes all types government are corruptible but the attitude of the people is what led the US to where it is today Hamilton wanted a central bank yes ? and what happen to him he was shot dead by aaron burr, Lincoln was a tyrant and the people of the south revolted because their voice wasn't being herd yes they lost the civil war but at least they did something about their rights were be violated.
Thats exactly why I am saying it can not work. There has never been a good government. Gang rape is democracy in action. Sorry for the graphic metaphor. The spontaneous order of Market Anarchy is what we need, not to reform this monopoly of force.
@MrBlakskwrl Yes but all anarchy becomes is small democracy groups of people or survival of the fittest the video it self gives the best example of this the ancient Greek city states Anarchy can never truly exist simply because people who have arms of vast amounts of resources food gold fresh water etc have power.
Lol, Okay That's exactly what we have now, we just call that small group of people the government. Really this is one doozy of a question that I am not about to try and answer on youtube. You may have to pick up a book. I highly recommend Rothbard's "For a New Liberty." Stephan over at freedomain radio(search on youtube) has some very informative stuff up. Check out his "Statism is Dead." A republic IS a representative democracy.
@MrBlakskwrl and i forgot to add with you're gang rape example YES the founders agree with you thats why they made a Democratic republic not a democracy.
This guy doesn´t know anything about forms of goverment. Oligarchy means the rule of the rich. Right wing and left wing has nothing to do with how big the goverment is, it came from the french revolution. After the revolution, to debate the future of the country, they separated those who represented the rich in the right and those who represented the poor on the left, thus right wing, means for the rich, left wing, for the poor. There wasn´t communism back then.
@paleoton ok i answer to you paleoton ,....it is simple to know that you are wrong ,.... you say on righ tis rich on left is poor lol ,...i answer you , in my country we are socialist, on left , so we are poor , we the government is rich ? why all the politicians that are at teh head of the country is rich ? any party, they are rich ,..why ? why does all the leaders (in the government) are always all rich ? ,....et vlan dans les dents
your view of anarchy is full of falsehoods and red herrings because you were never taught the thought of anarchy so all you points are in valid. also because u can have communism and anarchy there mutually exclusive but nazism and facism are mutually exclusive of anarchy. Also you have no idea of the difference of socialism and communism or conservatism. socialism is the governments control of natural resources communism is control of all resources conservatism is well just read upon ed burke
The end-product of Communism is a stateless society. So it can't be on the same side as Fascism. Also, Socialism and Communism don't require government.
The point is 'collective ownership', that doesn't have to mean 'State ownership'.
How this collective ownership is implemented is a national decicion and also one reason why the Left wing is so very fragmented today (at least in Europe).
@IiiERT lol ,.yes collective ownership ,...you put someone at the head of that collectivity , what happens ? .....
in other word, what happen when you have too much power, when you have control on what others worked for ? what happen when you can spend the money of another ? ....CORRUPTION !!!!
if you want communism because you think eveyone is equal with communism,...lol ,...why dont you want everyone to have equal power ? heh ,... youre funny
What the fuck are you saying? "Head of the collectivity"?
"in other word, what happen when you have too much power, when you have control on what others worked for ? what happen when you can spend the money of another ? ....CORRUPTION !!!!"
Whaaaat? Corruption? Yes that is corruption. How is it related to what I said? I don't know.
"Power, corruption, money communism equality corruption power power powerpowerpowerpowerpower."
@IiiERT i dont agree with you liiERT , i duno where you learned what you think but,...you wont be able to change my mind on this way .
Communism is controlled by a government ,...just like faschism and and and if anrchy is at teh far right , it doesnt match with communism ,... ever seen a communiste country with no government ? ,...i dont think so.
what you have to understand is very simple, the more we centralise power the more we on left. , on far right everyone have a lil of the power
@IiiERT during any revolution come s ashort time there is no government ,....think about United States ,...they were british before ,...you think they change from british to american ? ,....if you look and analyse step by step, youll see you change from british goivernment , to no government , and then to an american government ,....
something similar happened in germany when hitler took the power.
@IiiERT and power is money ,.. and you need money to get ressources ( in this society) and you need theses resource to work and live ( feed yourself, housing, dressing, etc ) and that money, i live in canada and i can tell you i give more than half of my pay to others ,...
watch that 'creed of freedom' type it on google youll probably learn new stuff ;), analyse it
when a revolution is made, the 'leaders' of the revolution, or simplily the survivors, have to make something like the Bill of Rights, ,...and the survivors have to agree with it, or put some changes,...there goes the start of the laws, that at this moment, tahts teh people decide on how the country is goign to work and serve teh people.
plus ,...if you want, ..to make sure we dont make stupid laws,.....for each laws and rules, we ahve to wait a year at a specific date where we vote for leaders, and laws ! :D ,...all laws,...make complex laws, like non-understandable laws and people wont understand wont vote for ;) so things can stay simple.
@ari1234a and,..before the governemnt become the leader of laws,..is was the laws department, judge and such taht were making laws,...not anymore, not it is the government.
@ari1234a the poeple made it and government jsut have to make teh rules in the lines of what teh people gave them ,....like the original American COnstitution, not teh one they changing and modifiying and destroying ,... which regress our rights and liberties
Notice that our schools do not teach that the U.S. is a Republic. Nor do you hear anyone in government speaking of the Republic, regaurdless of party.
correct me if im wrong, but i thought that north korea was an all out dictatorship and saudi arabia was still a monarchy
trueblue1634 5 months ago
@trueblue1634 they are ,....but the video is saying monarchy and dictatorship does not TRULY exist ;) ,....it is a group of poeple,...they ahve their own council or group of people to help him to lead teh country ,.they not leading alone, there is a group behind them
ragnarush 5 months ago
anarchy is based on choosing your associations
and the state is a mafia so we are in a anarchy with one gang in power.
death9719 7 months ago
many crimes all crimes come from the state
society in the state kills our spirit of revolt
we are brainwashed by all the brainwashed around us.
death9719 7 months ago
do you know anything about communism
social democracy is in the middle.
death9719 7 months ago
besides socialism is a form of egalitarian anarchism
death9719 7 months ago
all republics are oligarchies.
death9719 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
O MAY GOD!!!! STOP PUTTING THIS THING AROUND YOUTUBE! THIS! THIS VIDEO IS JUST LYING, IT'S SAYING THE FUCKING WRONG INFORMATION!!!!! If you want the actually true type of politics click what the video's responding to, or GO ON ANYTHING ELSE THAN THIS PIECE OF SHIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!
getgot1 10 months ago
Comment removed
getgot1 10 months ago
@getgot1 lol believe what you want i dont mind ,... but telling me what to do is exactly what i hate from political systems ,...so ,....live your life, and let other live their life,... you dont wanan beleive what this video is saying,..Good ! up to you ,....but dont tell me how to think and what to do, cuz telling me such things is against my liberty , and im FREE to live like i want, as long as it doesnt affect YOUR liberty ,...so stfu with youre capital letters
ragnarush 10 months ago
Interesting.
It's worth nothing that using the limited scale in this video, most anarchists are closer to people who want democracy, while anarcho-capitalists want a republic (though not necessarily a traditional american one).
Chaos is the better term for "anarchy," and chaos happens whenever any group (anarchists, religious exteremists, or even those wanting a republic) tries to quickly and violently overthrow the current system. Chaos is the result of drastic change, not the ideology.
TombaFanatic 11 months ago
the only democratie we have, is that we vote at every four years ,..
ragnarush 1 year ago
paleoton is only partially current about left and right. Left were the anti-statist, the liberal(not the same term as today) and right wanted to return to the old way with oligarch. A REPUBLIC just means representative government(indirect democracy). Anarchy, without government . Most Anarchist are non-violent and wish to set up voluntary societies. Government = Force, Anarchy = Peace. If the founders were right government would not be so large today.
MrBlakskwrl 1 year ago
@MrBlakskwrl people and government must live a philosophy to make this world work goo d,..and the philosophy to adopt to be equal with everyone, is the philosophy of liberty , you can watch it on youtube by the way ,...and the sprectrum of having all the poweron left and 0 power on the right sounds good to me,..you can say if you want 0 power on left and full power on right , i dont mind, the idea still the same. What is mainly important is , the Philosophy of Liberty to make humanity better
ragnarush 1 year ago
@ragnarush
If you want to talk about a philosophy of liberty you should read Rothbard's "For a New Liberty." It is the blueprint for a stateless society. Voluntarism, the non-aggression principle that's philosophy and it should be applied to the state as well as the individual.
MrBlakskwrl 1 year ago
@MrBlakskwrl The founders weren't wrong the American people were sold out by Woodrow Wilson when he allowed the FED the difference being are founders had this thing called balls they would call are government out on the bullshit they pull nowadays first with words than with force.
jsbobo36 1 year ago
@jsbobo36 i agree with that ( if i understand well , im not english btw )
ragnarush 1 year ago
@jsbobo36
That's the point! It's impossible to keep government small. Wilson was bad but the start of the betrayal of the individual was with Hamilton immediately following the revolution. Starting with Lincoln everything was down hill- he snowballed into the progressive movement(Wilson). Even before Lincoln the era of big government was dawning(check out Jackson and the Force Bill). Government is always as big as it can be.
MrBlakskwrl 1 year ago
@MrBlakskwrl No see my point was yes all types government are corruptible but the attitude of the people is what led the US to where it is today Hamilton wanted a central bank yes ? and what happen to him he was shot dead by aaron burr, Lincoln was a tyrant and the people of the south revolted because their voice wasn't being herd yes they lost the civil war but at least they did something about their rights were be violated.
jsbobo36 1 year ago
@jsbobo36
Thats exactly why I am saying it can not work. There has never been a good government. Gang rape is democracy in action. Sorry for the graphic metaphor. The spontaneous order of Market Anarchy is what we need, not to reform this monopoly of force.
MrBlakskwrl 1 year ago
@MrBlakskwrl Yes but all anarchy becomes is small democracy groups of people or survival of the fittest the video it self gives the best example of this the ancient Greek city states Anarchy can never truly exist simply because people who have arms of vast amounts of resources food gold fresh water etc have power.
jsbobo36 1 year ago
@jsbobo36
Lol, Okay That's exactly what we have now, we just call that small group of people the government. Really this is one doozy of a question that I am not about to try and answer on youtube. You may have to pick up a book. I highly recommend Rothbard's "For a New Liberty." Stephan over at freedomain radio(search on youtube) has some very informative stuff up. Check out his "Statism is Dead." A republic IS a representative democracy.
MrBlakskwrl 1 year ago
@MrBlakskwrl and i forgot to add with you're gang rape example YES the founders agree with you thats why they made a Democratic republic not a democracy.
jsbobo36 1 year ago
This guy doesn´t know anything about forms of goverment. Oligarchy means the rule of the rich. Right wing and left wing has nothing to do with how big the goverment is, it came from the french revolution. After the revolution, to debate the future of the country, they separated those who represented the rich in the right and those who represented the poor on the left, thus right wing, means for the rich, left wing, for the poor. There wasn´t communism back then.
paleoton 1 year ago
@paleoton ok i answer to you paleoton ,....it is simple to know that you are wrong ,.... you say on righ tis rich on left is poor lol ,...i answer you , in my country we are socialist, on left , so we are poor , we the government is rich ? why all the politicians that are at teh head of the country is rich ? any party, they are rich ,..why ? why does all the leaders (in the government) are always all rich ? ,....et vlan dans les dents
ragnarush 1 year ago
America For the Win!! You socialists aren't taking from me, anymore!
AroundSun 1 year ago
your view of anarchy is full of falsehoods and red herrings because you were never taught the thought of anarchy so all you points are in valid. also because u can have communism and anarchy there mutually exclusive but nazism and facism are mutually exclusive of anarchy. Also you have no idea of the difference of socialism and communism or conservatism. socialism is the governments control of natural resources communism is control of all resources conservatism is well just read upon ed burke
6nich 1 year ago
"At the extreme right, there is no government"?
So Communism is a right wing ideology?
And Nazi Germany was an extremist left-wing state?
How confusing.
IiiERT 1 year ago
@IiiERT re watch teh video my friend .....nazism and communism are all on teh left side
on left is 100% power to teh government,...on far right is no government anarchy and 100% power to teh individual which is what i think chaos ,...
so communism socialism and nazism etc are all on the left side
ragnarush 1 year ago
The end-product of Communism is a stateless society. So it can't be on the same side as Fascism. Also, Socialism and Communism don't require government.
The point is 'collective ownership', that doesn't have to mean 'State ownership'.
How this collective ownership is implemented is a national decicion and also one reason why the Left wing is so very fragmented today (at least in Europe).
IiiERT 1 year ago
@IiiERT lol ,.yes collective ownership ,...you put someone at the head of that collectivity , what happens ? .....
in other word, what happen when you have too much power, when you have control on what others worked for ? what happen when you can spend the money of another ? ....CORRUPTION !!!!
if you want communism because you think eveyone is equal with communism,...lol ,...why dont you want everyone to have equal power ? heh ,... youre funny
ragnarush 1 year ago
What the fuck are you saying? "Head of the collectivity"?
"in other word, what happen when you have too much power, when you have control on what others worked for ? what happen when you can spend the money of another ? ....CORRUPTION !!!!"
Whaaaat? Corruption? Yes that is corruption. How is it related to what I said? I don't know.
"Power, corruption, money communism equality corruption power power powerpowerpowerpowerpower."
"heh ,... youre funny"
Well you're not, I'm not amused.
IiiERT 1 year ago
@IiiERT i dont agree with you liiERT , i duno where you learned what you think but,...you wont be able to change my mind on this way .
Communism is controlled by a government ,...just like faschism and and and if anrchy is at teh far right , it doesnt match with communism ,... ever seen a communiste country with no government ? ,...i dont think so.
what you have to understand is very simple, the more we centralise power the more we on left. , on far right everyone have a lil of the power
ragnarush 1 year ago
I have to say that I have never seen A country without a government.
IiiERT 1 year ago
@IiiERT during any revolution come s ashort time there is no government ,....think about United States ,...they were british before ,...you think they change from british to american ? ,....if you look and analyse step by step, youll see you change from british goivernment , to no government , and then to an american government ,....
something similar happened in germany when hitler took the power.
ragnarush 1 year ago
Temporary.
IiiERT 1 year ago
@IiiERT and power is money ,.. and you need money to get ressources ( in this society) and you need theses resource to work and live ( feed yourself, housing, dressing, etc ) and that money, i live in canada and i can tell you i give more than half of my pay to others ,...
watch that 'creed of freedom' type it on google youll probably learn new stuff ;), analyse it
ragnarush 1 year ago
There's some kind of Europe-America ideology gap going on here.
IiiERT 1 year ago
what about british government? 400 years of stable democratic rule
lankplank123 1 year ago
@lankplank123 the only democratie you have is that you vote each 4 years
ragnarush 1 year ago
complete shit
lankplank123 1 year ago
Complete propaganda!
Electguitar 1 year ago
@Electguitar yeah bill of rights is propagandha ? right ? lol ....
ragnarush 1 year ago
This is just propaganda from the American imperialists.
PersianPaladin 1 year ago
@PersianPaladin idiot
emaleroland 1 year ago
@PersianPaladin imperialist ? lol ,.. americans never had monarchy , so wtf ? i dont get what you say
ragnarush 1 year ago
@PersianPaladin lol imperialist ,.....and american in the same sentence ehhe ,....thats funny bro
ragnarush 1 year ago
Question : Who, then makes these laws that the people, who live in Republic states, has to obey ?
ari1234a 2 years ago
when a revolution is made, the 'leaders' of the revolution, or simplily the survivors, have to make something like the Bill of Rights, ,...and the survivors have to agree with it, or put some changes,...there goes the start of the laws, that at this moment, tahts teh people decide on how the country is goign to work and serve teh people.
ragnarush 2 years ago
plus ,...if you want, ..to make sure we dont make stupid laws,.....for each laws and rules, we ahve to wait a year at a specific date where we vote for leaders, and laws ! :D ,...all laws,...make complex laws, like non-understandable laws and people wont understand wont vote for ;) so things can stay simple.
ragnarush 2 years ago
@ari1234a and,..before the governemnt become the leader of laws,..is was the laws department, judge and such taht were making laws,...not anymore, not it is the government.
ragnarush 1 year ago
@ari1234a the poeple made it and government jsut have to make teh rules in the lines of what teh people gave them ,....like the original American COnstitution, not teh one they changing and modifiying and destroying ,... which regress our rights and liberties
ragnarush 1 year ago
Notice that our schools do not teach that the U.S. is a Republic. Nor do you hear anyone in government speaking of the Republic, regaurdless of party.
Bill1405 2 years ago
i agree,...they teach NWO !!! bro
ask the teens
ragnarush 2 years ago
Comment removed
Bill1405 2 years ago
Well put.
Cwal 2 years ago