20100627 亞洲星光大道 9. 楊麗珊:Falling.flv

[cherry36149944]

哇- -今次扮Alicia Keys= =？

[k060500376]

唱的很好 但是 一開始跟音樂 似乎沒搭好

差半個key似的感覺

[spike378]

as good as her voice is, it is no use copying the style to sing this song without his own style. She even goes as far imitating her voice. She should had used her own ways to sing this

[beck520520]

蒨時的比較像國際級水準 她的是選秀級水準~~兩個都很棒~

[kawingy]

真係超級好聽*V* 楊麗珊最適合唱呢種歌,支持支持=]]

[GamePoster]

鋼琴配樂真的很難聽= =''

[leepl0826]

你叫林欣彤個d拉咪拉到腰到睇下仲有無聲。

[far2crazed]

呢首歌其實最適合佢囉

[GavinChan1993]

@idunnoiii

你咁講法，過於武斷

本來楊麗珊就唔係唱國語歌，大家都係欣賞佢把聲同玩音GE技巧

[casualife]

一個參賽歌手都咁多人講(讚或鬧都係好事). 佢唱得好唔好係聽o既人個人感覺，個人覺得佢起碼比現今本地部份­職業歌手出色；見到d新人有咁o既表現，本地職業歌手真係要努力­啦。例如有位歌星早兩年o係某頒獎會唱到扯晒蝦，唱歌都變成講o­野o既情況以職業歌手係絕對唔可以接受。各位歌星應該比多好多心­機練歌啦。

[sweetandfunny97]

OMG she's amazing. She has very big voice

[14REEVE]

佢唱第一下拉支咪拉到好遠!!!!!!!

[ericaahtiong2]

the key that she sang be4 the intro was not the same as the one that the band played...why din the judges say about it?

[shironeoo]

wow they have beats by dre...

[barryyu07]

講真，我去菲律賓旅行，嗰邊的黑廳，真係再勁d都有。

[stone2rock]

@barryyu07

well those are just Lounge singers with skill but no emotion....Gretchell will be a GREAT SINGER with lot of emotion!!

[jackycheung1000]

若計香港樂壇，以實力計沒有一個香港的女歌手及得上楊麗珊

[eisenlam]

@jackycheung1000 如果你講現今既樂壇就可能係

你真係當甄妮、梅豔芳、葉倩文果d無料到？

btw，楊麗珊雖然唔錯，但佢既低音真係唔夠楊倩蒔穩

（同埋亞視對band好差）

[FungKwong]

@jackycheung1000 唔係呀ma你點聽歌架....同埋你知唔知咩叫唱得好?

[catflower17]

請多小小欣賞他人及感激他人的態度. 實際上我睇過英美西班牙等等類似節目, 佢唱得真系唔錯. 一個非專業歌手, 點可以甘嚴格, 包容下參加比賽既朋友, 有勇氣已經好難得.

[aznboieiji]

way better than most artists of hong kong!

[clsue12]

THE VOICE d平均參賽者水準唔夠今屆星三!!星三既唱得好過佢地~

mag lam係唱得好..但佢得一個style...而且我都覺得gr­etchell先唱得出果種味道~

唔好以為冇人支持gretchell..只係tvb多人睇過at­v,大家先可以棒到mag lam甘高!!

[angiegirl95]

holy!

[fionzzzzzzzzzz]

唔好玩啦佢同gem比 根本無得比= =

佢連maglam都未比得上 得個樣 歌詞係咁唱錯又甩哂

02:59 本身係'in and out of love' 佢唱得太慢跟唔上隊band

變左'in and out of' 之後就立即下一句'with you'

咁成句詞唱出黎有咩意思呢?

技巧 唔係無 但未去到高level果d feeling 作為一個聽眾其實好主觀 我個人唔覺有feel仲覺得有d假

[fionzzzzzzzzzz]

唔好玩啦佢同gem比 根本無得比= =

佢連maglam都未比得上 得個樣 歌詞係咁唱錯又甩哂

02:59 本身係'in and out of love' 佢唱得太慢跟唔上隊band

變左'in and out of' 之後就立即下一句'with you'

咁成句詞唱出黎有咩意思呢?

技巧 唔係無 但未去到高level果d feeling 作為一個聽眾其實好主觀 我個人唔覺有feel仲覺得有d假

[mafsouth]

@almightymflo講開林欣彤，網上有人出標題，將佢同­閻奕格比，我第一個反應就係:what a joke！

[maloe100]

@mafsouth 楊麗珊唱Falling,只有groove,冇pitch,就評­佢係國際級技巧,咪仲好笑,what a terrible gag!!!!!

[zacHan01]

@maloe100 你正一tvb打手~!

成日留意兩台d人...都仲係咁冇批判性思維~

星光d人唔係發明星夢~佢地係真心鍾意唱歌~與你鍾意那些人並不­同

[maloe100]

聲夠大,唱歌冇乜感情,聽完就過～

[almightymflo]

今集錄影可能是用MMO的音樂做配樂,未必是live band,因為當晚要做星光2班總決賽!樂隊無那麼多時間準備!

[emiltsuimunsang]

overrated

and it's not surprised that a Filipino got such a loud voice

[kengch]

開頭果一下好正^^...

之後就...........唉

[adam123166]

技巧性太嚴重....只是一直在大小聲

[pill225]

I think 鍾舒祺's version from super idol is already better than her, not even close to 楊蒨時's version

[FussMz]

入錯key... 2分59秒佢都知自己衰左笑一笑...

handle唔到lee隻 big songs...

3分42根本破左...

3分50反而唱得幾好

4分04都係破啊...

拉到支咪落地下都無用...

有爆發力無細緻音色...

TVB既人水準的確係高小小...

[lpyn24]

@FussMz 入果下好明顯樂隊入快左= =

[futurefighter2008]

@FussMz

TVB? lol. TVB is a joke.

[baddayvbguy]

我有好大一個疑問。。。點解評審完全唔講佢一開始入歌完全走曬音­既呢？？ 而且走得好離譜。。。不過佢有天賦，好好練下，應該會好犀利。

[garylyf]

係喎.. 我當時都唔覺。。你講完我再聽先覺得~ 我淨係覺得佢幾個高音位都唔係太穩陣~哈哈

[KIT7732KIT]

同一隻歌 falling 

個人喜歡楊麗珊唱法多過楊蒨時

兩個都超班 ... "正"

[xoShanniGummyxo]

She is good...

[superclip2u]

好球!

[aw05172001]

楊蒨時的Falling,細膩且殺傷力夠,跟alicia keys有得比,連外國人都開口大讚

楊麗珊的Falling,只是一支有火力的大炮,沒有細膩的感覺­,沒有讓我Falling下去

技巧感情音色都不及前者,但在她有的是天份,有的是進步空間

但贏楊蒨時....大家蒨時雖沒在比賽,但不是沒有進步,楊麗珊­要贏要非常非常大的進步才行

[mafsouth]

打從星光一星光二，巨聲一巨聲二，都未出過這類形的歌手，她絕對­有條件成為港板Alicia Keys

[adidasmichael09]

佢同楊蒨時有無關係? 差唔多樣，又唱同一隻歌....

[sophiachan]

女版澎湃哥......

[greeniemina]

@sophiachan 所以我封拒做澎湃妹!　哈哈!

[maloe100]

@greeniemina ～Cheap精,自己企出嚟解釋吓,你係林欣彤短片上留言宣博楊­麗珊..........,講咗d乜?

[nonokey6]

anyway compare一下ATV同TBB的參賽者

like this lady, 其實都贏到好多無線ge人了

不過佢0個種情感都係差少少, 真係0個少少

之後keep住就真係贏到都唔奇......

至於衣著髮型0個d野.....urgh.

[joechampion]

@nonokey6 我覺得林欣彤勁過佢好多 (林喺之前的比賽連何紫慧, 陳康健都打低埋)!

[whywhy312]

@joechampion

林欣彤邊有得比呀??! 剩係聽佢唱 In love with you 已知佢高音上唔到, 完全沒有黑人騒靈 feel.

[nonokey6]

@joechampion 隨你所想啦

[nonokey6]

唔知點解見到佢....

覺得佢似全美超模cycle10的stacy ann

esp. 佢個self introduction 0個陣好似好似

[Jadehelam]

0:45某樂器-.-

[mlal1027]

she got potential.

[brightclearsky]

What a voice!! So emotional and powerful!! Wow...I am totally speechless!!

[aaaake1]

拎走佢支咪 直接同肥媽鬥中氣 收視升升升XD

而家肥媽做佢老師 真係好期待佢同JAC

[siutakc]

外表同台風有進步空間，除此之外沒甚麼好說了～

[bungadu]

The band blew it...she sings at a higher key..sorry for it

[babyfacedevil]

@bungadu there's no band that day

[Luvladyy]

好好聽真係,估唔到,好西利

[hkkkk]

參賽者得, 但係評判同主持都唔掂......

[eddielee1990]

i love her vocal so much!

hope that she can sing "without you" in the following days..

[ekoweee]

隊BAND 好廢！ 好明顯個KEY 唔岩，都照入

[Leo5fly]

一見到人地有黑婆腔 ,就話超班,美國,菲律賓通街都唱成甘ga laaa,但佢d 高音,拍子,音準,係咪甘穩先?? 見人兩下punch 大力d 加d soulful 腔就近世界級? 周國豐都唔知 up 乜....唔識講小句穩陣laaa,咪呃細路,世界級? 維園一大班 laaa

[futurefighter2008]

@Leo5fly

人地係話 國際級 啊，哥仔！國際級 係指可以摞出手同國際上既歌手競爭。話距 超班 有咩問題？起呢個group入面，距的確係超班。另外，講咩級既­係張佳添周國豐啊，好心你插人之前聼清楚同埋搞清楚邊各講先啦。

[Leo5fly]

@futurefighter2008 冇錯wor...兩個講d野我都係覺得膠, 都係果句,如果甘係近國際級,就維園,同尖東都通街係,而我唔覺­周國豐對音樂或vocal 有太深認知.個人而言,個女仔係唱得唔差,技巧上未穩到算pro­,音準/高音/節奏等,演繹上,首曲係幾blues, 而佢唱得唔幾blues, 抽像d講係小左兩分醉意, 只於點解覺得佢超班? 大概係佢有黑人腔呱, 但成個菲律賓同黑人都係甘唱ga laa,只係廣東腔 效果唔同姐! 佢兩個講d野就只條好似,非洲土著見到外國人甘law.

[Leo5fly]

白痴評判

[steffi920622]

今屆星光真係..........靜係第一集已經贏哂!!贏無線­!! 做得好呀亞視!! =D

[dannyip1229]

個樣似林珊珊溝杜麗莎...=D

[koma615]

@dannyip1229 笑左...........

[leohouse76]

勁野, 技巧勁過楊蒨時, 但黑人態度及感情不及楊蒨時, 不過現在才第一集, 可造之材

[shanyyui]

可造之材!!

[mafsouth]

這位參賽者肯定是星光三的一個亮點！

[yoannasmusic]

我打左好多個冷震, 贏好多個無線既參賽者.. 真係國際級... 好過gem

[joechampion]

@yoannasmusic 好過gem又未至於!

[avxvn]

@joechampion 她有黑人靈魂樂的那種態度,gem系比不上的. 楊倩時同理,他的那種態度不是隨便可以模仿的.

[aaaake1]

@joechampion 濟係個feel都好過gem(我心目中) gem被人捧得太勁 有部分人已經厭左 反而楊新鮮好多

[clsue12]

@aaaake1 同埋我睇返gem d live..佢而家好著重於技巧..

感情既投入愈黎愈少!!聽完就係覺得佢好唱得..但冇咩feel­..

希望gretchell以後唱歌仍然能keep到感情!

[soramonte]

@yoannasmusic

not that 楊麗珊 sang exceptionally well but

please don't compare her with gem, gem is overrated

[EvkaNg]

好過好多香港嘅出碟歌手

[Alan940927]

@EvkaNg 唱功同技巧都贏左.唯獨係無乜感情

[joechampion]

佢味必及得上林欣彤!



[kenlct]

@joechampion

一睇到呢句，即刻呆左 .............

不過唔知你講邊方面 ...........

講樣既話，或者 / 可能真係未必及得上既 (其實都唔係架喇 .....)

但係講唱功就唔駛講，林欣彤根本比唔上 .......

所以只能夠講感情方面，可能佢第一集注重技巧多過感情，

導致出黎既效果係感情有所欠缺，不過楊麗珊只係第一集，

絕對有改善既空間。

[almightymflo]

@joechampion 為何如此說[佢味必及得上林欣彤!],是否林欣彤唱過此曲呢,有­好效果嗎?才可以比較,個人認為林欣彤,聲音沉,唱不出聲,壓在­喉嚨來唱歌,所謂未開聲,咬字不清楚,因此不要拿此林欣彤來與所­有星光1,2,3班的女仔來比,起碼星光女仔咬字清楚好多!也不­要捧此林欣彤那麼高!

[maloe100]

@almightymflo 罪魁禍首係樓下個位greeniemina,我都因為佢先至過嚟­睇,你要評林欣彤歌藝係冇問題,但拿星光咬字同佢比,乜星光d人­會識重視咬字清楚咩?簡直係笑話,男嘅唔講都知,女嘅最新有沈路­易～Laughing You,記注唔好再惡意抽水／

[peterchoi0]

超好聽

[futurefighter2008]

比阿LO笑死

[aman2040]

又靚呀…

[luv520]

when she started singing "I keep on falling.." I got goosebumps

[stevengcake]

kinda cute at 6:16, and again an underrated performance

[syndisin]

那個琴手幹嗎? 怎麽一開始的入音落差那麽大, 幸好楊處變不驚, 否則....又浪費了一把好嗓子.

唉! 真的希望亞視認真處理那隊 BAND, 不要浪費今次這些唱將人才.

[01manv0ca1]

@syndisin

用mmo 的

[dadilala]

if she has more emotion, it would be perfect~~~

[ararka]

佢個樣有d似廖碧兒.....

[kenlct]

佢真係幾似譚小環！不過佢應該要箍一箍牙。

因為論樣貌都真係唔算差，7:17 嗰度合埋咀嗰個樣都 ok 好睇。

講番唱歌，如果佢可以好似周國豐所講咁，做到唱功同感情平衡，

咁就絕對係一流！肯定可以衝出香港先！

始終今次個分輸俾譚焌釗係輸喺感情方面，

同埋開頭同 mmo 夾唔到，甩左 beat。

[evaaaaaaaaaa]

she does look like 譚小環 lolol

such a nice voice!!! filos can usually sing...i want to hear her sing chinese..wonder if it'll have the same rnb feel...she's really good but lacks a bit of soul...this rendition compared to 超偶's Yang Qian Shi is less emotional and impacting

[leafisfalling]

真係似譚小環喎. 個 feel 又似李玫

[garry527]

嘩！好索~~~（由底發出黎個種）

[justinctso]

要執執d牙,,,,就靚女好多

[armao]

@justinctso

哈哈我又覺得佢咁都幾cute ^^

[connidom]

超好聽!!!不過真係需要多d感情, 因為Alicia Keys真係太利害!!!!!

[pocari1985]

佢比d感情就係楊蒨時架喇



[almightymflo]

尚欠經驗,如果多幾ROUND的時間,評判指點技巧與感情,可以­與楊倩時有得揮!她又有台型,COOL牙最要緊!

[YanYanLaw1]

勁揪呀!!

[pepper1105]

holy shit....

[mrtonyto20102]

好明顯楊蒨時唱得好好多啦！不過距再學多d，真繫有可能贏楊架！­@@

[futurefighter2008]

@mrtonyto20102

楊比距感情好，但距好有自己風格，而楊基本上係跟足原唱

[wddcyt]

@futurefighter2008

完全同意

[JAPANSHOP1]

今我諗超台灣超偶楊倩時!!

[171282056]

我怕佢比比下賽，比D唱片公司勾走左炸。

[171282056]

香港終於要出一位國際巨星啦！佢好有潛質啊！樣子又國際。音樂老­師話菲律賓人真係好識唱歌，佢地天生就好鍾意音樂！！

[zescixx]

即刻諗起楊婧時

[futurefighter2008]

隊band咩事啊？

[ScaniaFung]

@futurefighter2008 呢日跟本冇band，播mmo

[futurefighter2008]

@ScaniaFung

哈哈，開頭真係看到我一額汗

[Shining727]

技巧真係超晒班

[Cherish0327]

好好好精采既演出

希望佢唱其他歌都有自己特色啦

但最好先去"cool"下D牙

[wairealmadrid]

今屆終於有個厲害的參賽者, 而且是女生

值得留意. 保持水準, 唱不同語言歌, 作多方面嘗試

一定三甲內

[hohoyun]

今届D参赛者同上一届真係差咗几个级数

[kelvvvvvin]

Cool, not bad at all!!!!

[IMSune]

終於有人講喇! 完全同意張佳添。淨係唱得好咪做幕後代唱囉，要做幕前要上台就要­晌台上有魅力去吸引觀眾。

之前成日晌跌桔見d小朋友開post問xxx係實力派定偶像派。­我諗佢地連咩叫偶像派都唔清楚。偶像派應該係指晌舞台上以個人魅­力、舞台魅力、表演設計等方法去攝人嘅歌手，而唔係指得個樣嘅歌­手。一個真正嘅天王巨星係應該偶像實力兼備，而唔係單純地只有實­力或者才華就得。所以羅力威呀嗄~ 紅不紅根本沒關係呀嗄~

[IMSune]

嘩! 開頭果一下，支咪拉到落肚臍都仲有聲! 肥媽二世呀!!

[garyhonghk]

@IMSune 系呀,好勁的技巧

[dreamaj]

@IMSune 爆笑, 都唔知係收音好定佢真係勁...笑死...好誇張

[soramonte]

I can't stand the band................

[greeniemina]

感情可以更好。　希望以後有自己style

[Kriza8669]

WO* 開頭俾佢嚇一嚇~~ 幾好~

不過都係台灣星光果個女仔勁好多~

[king1413]

@Kriza8669

應該係台灣[超偶3]既楊倩時

[waterlo2003]

翻版楊倩時！