Doesn't the 335 have about the same horsepower? it's around 300 if i'm correct. I mean, It's not that big of a difference. Probably the biggest things that matter here is the weight of the cars and the BMW being rwd and the porsche being awd
@2fight4 that's right, but the weight isn't the same, the understeering isn't the same , the handling of the car, ect.... so it would have been better to do rwd vs rwd, to avoid any discussion of the haters , you know, all theses bmw forever forza guys ;)
@Trystelune yeah, i know what you mean ;) and i totally agree, i thought you were some of these bmw guys, thinking the Porsches 4wd would be an advantage.
If you buy a Porsche (or any other sportcar) whitout a manuel gearbox you probably have a lot of money and just want to show it, for an enthusiast or anyone who likes do drive there is no substitut for a manuel !!!
well i was betting on 335i. The carrera has a 4x4 tranny so it must loose lots of power on high speed but i don't remember if it is a viscous tranny like the old 996 turbo, if it is , then the power will go 100% to the rear wheels on a straight line wich will explain this result.
The 996 has an antique automatic gearbox which costs arround 4 seconds from 0-200 km/h. A handshiftet version would clearly win against a 5 years younger 335. And not to forget: the 996 has 4-Wheeldrive!!! So the "lower-end" Porsches aren't slow at all....
why did you delete my comment???? I just said that the 996 has automatic transmission and this makes the porsche very slow and the 335 not as fast as you tryed to implicate by this vid....
For persons who can't shift the tiptronic will be even faster. Probably this is the reason why you overestimate the potential of the outdated tiptronic of the 996 model. Go ask the owner of M5Board. He will verify my "stupid" comment.
I know what I'm doing with a manual - don't even go there!
The tiptronic tranny on the 996 doesn't make the car 'very slow', it merely adds milliseconds onto acceleration times. Stating that the Tip makes the car 'very slow' is what I was referring to when I said you'd made a stupid comment, because, you said it yourself, the tip is faster for a fair few drivers.
Dude, this is boring. Just face it: The tiptronic of the 996 makes the porsche 4 seconds slower compared to the excellent manual gearbox from 0-200km/h (what is on your roads like 0-125 mp/h). If you would be aware of the technical conditions of this generation of tiptronic (only 5 gears, + 115 pounds, poor response...) you wouldn't even think about merely miliseconds. But I've never said that the 996 tiptronic is a slow car anyhow! Just that the manual is quite faster
@gtbol135qw A 316i is a bottom of the line BMW. Welcome to the rest of the world :-).
inkkkkkkk 6 months ago
Doesn't the 335 have about the same horsepower? it's around 300 if i'm correct. I mean, It's not that big of a difference. Probably the biggest things that matter here is the weight of the cars and the BMW being rwd and the porsche being awd
Dfrogman 1 year ago
result as expected, and it would have been more "fair" to take a 996 2wd, because the 335 i isn't a AWD.....
Trystelune 1 year ago
@Trystelune
the 2wd 911's are faster than the AWD, theres no advantage for the Porsche in this kind of race.
2fight4 1 year ago
@2fight4 that's right, but the weight isn't the same, the understeering isn't the same , the handling of the car, ect.... so it would have been better to do rwd vs rwd, to avoid any discussion of the haters , you know, all theses bmw forever forza guys ;)
Trystelune 1 year ago
@Trystelune yeah, i know what you mean ;) and i totally agree, i thought you were some of these bmw guys, thinking the Porsches 4wd would be an advantage.
2fight4 1 year ago
@2fight4 oh no, i like any kind of cars, no matter the brand :) i don't understand theses guys too !
Trystelune 1 year ago
On a track - the BMW would loose even more to the 4x4 996. Straight ahead runs, shows nothing about a car.
ClausFrederiksen911 1 year ago
didnt expect the awd tiptronic Porsche would win.
2fight4 1 year ago
i do enjoy the outcome of this video! =D
freeviber 2 years ago
BAD VIDEO
jamecontent 2 years ago
fuck bmw
tomtomfrance 2 years ago
If you buy a Porsche (or any other sportcar) whitout a manuel gearbox you probably have a lot of money and just want to show it, for an enthusiast or anyone who likes do drive there is no substitut for a manuel !!!
sampras1979 2 years ago
@sampras1979 You can shift gear manuel, in a Triptronic 996. On the steering wheel. Its a lot of fun ;-)
ClausFrederiksen911 1 year ago
@sampras1979 automatics porsche are cheaper, so , you're totally wrong...
Trystelune 1 year ago
@Trystelune hmm, my point is you are still buying a expensive sportscar but proberbly not for the driving-pleasure but for other reasons!!
sampras1979 1 year ago
The bmw actually did very well
krugerwr 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i would love to have an "porsche", but the 996 is the only one i could afford
and, uh, dont get me wrong, its a great car, but... its kinda ugly and too old...
fuck, i need to start selling drugs... lol
FragtheSnack 2 years ago
wel the 996 has great power as seen. if you want the look of the 997 just do a conversion to the round lights. jacquemonde does a nice conversion
philyfree 2 years ago
but your interior will still look like shit. have you seen the interior of a 996 vs a 997? the difference is day and night
NehpetsK57 2 years ago
I would rip out the interior
philyfree 2 years ago
poor 3 series
y0urSJ 2 years ago 3
The 335 could be an everyday car the Porsche is a sunday sort of say and in my country there are no roads for Porsche's except the Cayenne
ricedie 3 years ago
All you'd need is a small modification to beat that 911, good race!
kc550 3 years ago
All 911 is fast is hell !
The base 911 997 is fast id IS-F
BMW130ii 3 years ago
You should watch the 335i Vishnu V3 race...
theseventhday 3 years ago
well i was betting on 335i. The carrera has a 4x4 tranny so it must loose lots of power on high speed but i don't remember if it is a viscous tranny like the old 996 turbo, if it is , then the power will go 100% to the rear wheels on a straight line wich will explain this result.
tawa3nadz 3 years ago
yea but that s a 996..997s with PDK are sure faster..
golf1diesel 3 years ago
just shows how slow those lower-end 911s are...they still cost a shit load tho lol
kubomon17 3 years ago
Seems to me like the guy in the 335i is shifting a bit slower than the guy in the porsche.
divineguy 3 years ago
Could be. The Porsche was autoatic.
m5boarddotcom 3 years ago
Comment removed
divineguy 3 years ago
man the BMW is so impressive, its not even an M3 and it held its ground
maaitah 3 years ago
Add it is stock :D
m5boarddotcom 3 years ago
The 996 has an antique automatic gearbox which costs arround 4 seconds from 0-200 km/h. A handshiftet version would clearly win against a 5 years younger 335. And not to forget: the 996 has 4-Wheeldrive!!! So the "lower-end" Porsches aren't slow at all....
herbelcerbel 3 years ago 11
why did you delete my comment???? I just said that the 996 has automatic transmission and this makes the porsche very slow and the 335 not as fast as you tryed to implicate by this vid....
still, i love your races but why the deletion??
herbelcerbel 3 years ago
A tiptronic 996 is just as fast as a manual 996.
Go drive both transmissions on a 996 before posting stupid comments...
Besides, the 996 did bloody well beating a 3L TT car...
GT3LM 2 years ago
For persons who can't shift the tiptronic will be even faster. Probably this is the reason why you overestimate the potential of the outdated tiptronic of the 996 model. Go ask the owner of M5Board. He will verify my "stupid" comment.
herbelcerbel 2 years ago
I know what I'm doing with a manual - don't even go there!
The tiptronic tranny on the 996 doesn't make the car 'very slow', it merely adds milliseconds onto acceleration times. Stating that the Tip makes the car 'very slow' is what I was referring to when I said you'd made a stupid comment, because, you said it yourself, the tip is faster for a fair few drivers.
GT3LM 2 years ago
Dude, this is boring. Just face it: The tiptronic of the 996 makes the porsche 4 seconds slower compared to the excellent manual gearbox from 0-200km/h (what is on your roads like 0-125 mp/h). If you would be aware of the technical conditions of this generation of tiptronic (only 5 gears, + 115 pounds, poor response...) you wouldn't even think about merely miliseconds. But I've never said that the 996 tiptronic is a slow car anyhow! Just that the manual is quite faster
herbelcerbel 2 years ago
4 seconds, now that's significant - I was taking a look a 0-60 times.
GT3LM 2 years ago
@maaitah And the Carrera is 8 years old...
GT3LM 1 year ago
@maaitah yeah but its also a carrera...amazing car none the less ...but its no gt3
jayman81424 1 month ago
Good video.
BMW held up well.
MeLikeGoFast 3 years ago 2
FIRST
gundamforever129 3 years ago