Response to Critics of Dr. Tiller (Abortion Doctor)

[relliknomlas]

Scott Roeder is my hero

[CRUSADE358]

How can it be a grey issue abortion is either murder or not and

Tiller did kill children

[MarysMyMom]

Actually Hitler used Margret Sanger's ideals in his "Final Solution". And abortion is scientifically murder. So don't use science in your argument if your argument defeats your personal beliefs. Embryology clearly shows us that human life begins at conception. There is no gray area about that.

[tommythegun555]

sweet, then guess what.. i wouldnt exist if i were aborted, and wouldnt fucking care hahaha. and sperm are living things, but fuck people murder those every day, and they have a chance of becoming babies... lets save the SPERM!!!

[0chris69]

So, you support the killing of babies that are unborn? If you support pro choice where is the unborn child's choice, what if you where that unborn child and your mother had a abortion done to you. Also history has been show to come back and happen over and over aging, never forget the old ways of the past because they will be priceless in the future...

[Califman831]

what was the basis for slavery? The laws supporting it were upheld for years. The supreme court upheld those laws up til the civil rights act. I for one am glad Tiller is dead and is now rotting in hell.

[bushnest]

No, I am not for killing people for simply disagreeing with me. I am for killing people who kill little precious babies! Yes, abortionists and their supporters are responsible for killing way more than Hitler ever did. Douchebag, here's a Bible passage which totally justifies Tiller the Baby Killer getting taken out: Romans 1:32-- "Who knowing the judgment of God, that they which commit such things are worthy of death, not only do the same, but have pleasure in them that do them." AMEN!!!

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

My entire point is that you want to fight a wrong with a wrong, even though I don't think what Tiller did was wrong, YOU do, and the fact that you think what you support is okay scares the hell out of me.

As for the Hitler comparison... comparing Nazi Germany to this, is EXTREMELY disgusting, and antisemitic. Making such an illogical comparison diminishes the significance of the Holocaust... and I'm sorry, but Tiller "killed" a few MILLION less than Hitler, so get your facts straight.

[bushnest]

How am I advocating fighting a wrong with a wrong? It does say in the Bible that people like Tiller are worthy of death, right? As to my comparison of Tiller and his kind to Hitler & the Nazis, the combined amount of people(yes, babies are people too) who have gotten killed by Tiller and his kind since Roe vs. Wade totals way over 50 million. Therefore, that comparison is quite valid.

[stevienickslover]

@MarcusSilvaVideos im pro life, but realisticly sick of argueing with people, in the real world i cant control what you do personally as you cant with me, but maybe should look at the amounts of times iv got attacked by pro choicers, you cant say that all pro lifers are "mad" and "crazy" because there are mad crazy ones on pro choice too,lol, not looking for a mad fight,lol

[bluhhhhhhhh04]

You are a dumb bitch bushnest.

[bushnest]

Boo Hoo Hoo! You hurt my little feelings!!! :-(

[MsWilatowska]

@bushnest Asshole, the Nazi regime (with help, of course) killed about 11 million people all together. Jews, Poles, Gypsies, homosexuals, the mentally and physically disabled--all living, breathing, sentient people. I'm sure you've never roamed the barracks of Oświęcim, and until you have, don't even begin to make that kind of comparison. You have no idea what you're evoking.

[jaydawg34]

Other countries look at the "lack of respect to human life" and think bad of America. This includes casual abortions as well as other types of deaths by hands of others. The human body supports a fetus, if not meant to be born it will die. NO ONE should consider a fetus less than what it is because they "dont want a baby". "That" is psychotic. As for rape and incest, that is "NOT" casual abortion and not up for men to debate since the "female" is the victim of the rape or incest.

[bushnest]

It's just another example of America's sickenly disgusting throwaway culture.

[RedXIIIx]

Wow, the comments on this video are absolutely appalling. It sickens me that so many fucking morons inhabit this planet.

[kirstiedale3]

YOU ARE NOT PRO CHOICE YOU ARE PRO ABORT;You agree with abortion,right?

A choice is " what will i wear today ?2

" do i go to work today ?"

THAT IS A CHOICE;

IM sorry tiller was BRUTALLY MURDERED !

But HEY tiller went BEYOND the call of the law for money,,,PLEASE read his RECORDS ! nice to meet you anyway x kirstie, ENGLAND x

[wrodjr]

If Dr. Tiller was murdered in a church, maybe it's time to hunt down anti abortion protestors? That would scare all you wacko religious fanatics huh? Now breath in and out , in and out lol

[nurseincharge]

Scientifically speaking, abortion is the killing of an individual human life. That's a scientific fact. Remember that famous pic of the fetus that was grasping the surgeons finger has he or she was repairing a neural tube defect? If the mother would have "chosen" to see Tiller. He would have killed him.

But, hey, mom's "privacy and court precedent" are more important, right?

Pro-unilateral-choice indeed.

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

No, actually, it is NOT a scientific fact that an abortion is the killing of an individual human life. Abortions can occur before a cells can be called a "human life". Scientific fact says that there is a type of life inside the mother... however, calling it a "human life" is adding a context that science stays out of.

[Texasjim2007]

It is scientific fact that defining a human fetus as non-human does turn it into a goat fetus you can sell in resturants as

food. There is nothing inherently scientific

about changing the politically established legal definition of human to rationalize it being legal to kill them. Hitler's Nazis and slave owning racist Democrats defined

all sorts of people as non-human in order

to kill them for financial gain, Abortion is

a similar class war against poor families by greedy elites.

[kirstiedale3]

MARCUS PLEASE!

IF your wife \girlfriend was pregnant AND WANTED! you would be pregnant with your babie !

The law is made by MAN !

SCIENCE is determined by MAN !

IM AN ATHIEST BY THE WAY F**K The god shit i dont belive;

If the law said : BLACK WAS WHITE : You have no say do you ? because the law states THIS IS RIGHT !

The MURDER of tiller was wrong,but so was all the MURDER of all those babies(FETUS ) HEY TWO WRONGS DONT MAKE A RIGHT !

[bushnest]

1. A baby's heart begins to beat 18 days from conception, and by 21 days the heart is pumping blood through a closed circulatory system.

2. A baby's brainwaves can be detected at 6 weeks from conception.

3. Fingerprints have formed on an unborn child's hands by 14 weeks from conception.

4. By 9 weeks from conception, all the structures necessary for pain sensation are functioning.

The unborn baby in the mother isn't a human life, you say? I'd say that the facts state otherwise.

[bcmasta1returns]

@MarcusSilvaVideos No, your confusing human with person. It is factually an living organism of the human species, where the debate comes in is when it is a viable person and if so, weather or not their right to live outweighs the woman's choice to remove it from her body.

[getplaning]

There is no difference between a person who kills a man in his own church because of his religious convictions and a person who uses a boxcutter to steal an airplane full of people and fly it into a building full of people because of his religious convictions. None. Both are terrorists and should be hunted down and killed as threats to civilization.

[grpeters89]

He was sentenced to death for the many lives that he took!

[shayneerin]

Tell me if you think it makes sense that people can't legally drink alcohol in our country until they are 21 yrs old. Yet, our government seems to think that young teenage girls are mature enough to make the choice to end the life of a baby... and even fund programs to encourage them to do it. Sounds like the government would rather spend money on more bombs than help a young mother with the expenses of raising a baby. It's all about money with the government. Our leaders dont trust in God.

[shayneerin]

Abortion doctors beware... the war against you has only started. We will continue to make you pay the price for your sins against life.

[Ate0s]

I'd like you to know that I thumbed this up, because it's really great when you Right-Wing crazy assholes make comments that will provide excellent evidence at the trial.

Thank goodness most of the people in this country are sane enough not to listen to you idiots.

[dbahardstyle]

Liberals will and atheist will always think they are smarter than Christians and conservatives. God will stay true to his word, and everybody will see the truth one day. I pray that God will open your eyes one day.

[InterWebsTuberNetter]

There are Christian Liberals, and Conservative Atheist and plenty of others. I know decent and reasonable people on all sides. This is not an us against them matter like the video poster wants it to be.

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

I don't want it to be anything.  You are making this all up in your heads.

[dbahardstyle]

99% of Christians dont agree with the murder of tiller. But you reap what you sow.

It is ironic though he was murder somewhere where he felt safe,secure, and loved, remind of anywhere else

[lordcron]

I have always said religion is nothing more than terrorist sleeper cells waiting to kill for a belief system regardless of the law. What the fuck are we doing in Iraq? We have the same insane bastards right here in our own backyard! Fucking fake ass bible thumping pimps using religion when its convenient. Yet covering up you child molesters. The war should be here at home against you religious freaks who kill over abortion yet won't put your money where your mouth is and adopt. Fuck you all!

[InterWebsTuberNetter]

I'm appalled by the murder of Dr. Tiller, and only see it as a set back for those who wish to have abortions reduced in this country and world. Stop acting as if this terrorist represents anyone with the exception of a very small percent of people on the right.

[InterWebsTuberNetter]

Do you realise how snotty you sound when you talk about the Supreme Courts decision. People have every right to disagree with Roe Vs Wade and they are not necessarily stupid people. Grow up please.

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

My point is that the Supreme Court's decision was not based on evil agenda of infanticide, it was based on logic and reason... and I'm sure I sound snotty, but I don't care, this pro-"life" movement is responsible for MURDERING another person, if your concern is my reaction being snotty, then you need a priority check... I just can't believe that you're problem is me being snotty, not the fact that Dr. Tiller is dead.

[InterWebsTuberNetter]

The Supreme Court decision was based on logic, reason, AND Ideology. All of which can be questioned, and reconsidered by the Supreme Court. Here you go again stating the Pro Life Movement is responsible rather than the single lunatic. Please provide examples that show where the MAJORITY or even the AVERAGE Pro-Lifer supports this criminality. Your snottyness is your problem.

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

Snotty-shmotty... a man is DEAD. Get over YOUR little issue with my TONE. Forgive me for sounding snotty in reaction to people REJOICING that Dr. Tiller is no longer with us... Why do you have to make this about my tone, when we should be discussing the issue... you conservatives like to do this- muddy up the waters because you don't have viable reasons for what you stand for. I can see you shenanigans from a mile away- you're not fooling anyone...

[InterWebsTuberNetter]

I made one comment about you being snotty, you're milking it. A few idiots rejoice in this, yet you blame millions for it. And use those few to pigeon hole the millions, and accuse me of shenanigans. I'm not the one playing games, nor am i the one avoiding issues.

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

You probably don't even know that's what you're doing... Let me quote myself for the billionth time.

"the base of the pro-life movement is responsible for the RHETORIC that pushes people to KILL those who are pro-choice... and that my friend, is lunacy"

You should look up the word "context" it will do you some good. Leave your Amelia Bedelia tendencies and please TRY to understand the word. I'll repeat it for you since you have problems with remembering what people say... it's "context".

[InterWebsTuberNetter]

LOL, look at your own words clown. You say its context, but the context of your statement is just a sweeping generalization that doesn't come close to describing the people your criticizing.

Anyways, keep spilling your Kool Aid theirs always some out there to lap it up.

[InterWebsTuberNetter]

You're an Idiot. This is America, if people wish to discuss their impassioned views on abortion they are free to do so. And are not responsible for what some far right lunatic does.

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

The right wing lunatics are the BASE of the pro-life movement. These people don't ALL kill abortion doctors, but they are responsible for the galvanizing of those who do kill... and HELLO, discussing this issue is what I have JUST done. I just gave you the context and opportunity to discuss your opinion, so I don't know what you mean when you suggest that I am saying that people shouldn't have the freedom to do so when the reason you are discussing your opinion is because of the video I posted.

[InterWebsTuberNetter]

Funny, I thought Youtube gave me the opportunity. Anyways, can this crap about "Right Wing Lunatics" as the base. Your argument is based on pigeon holing the people with differing opinions than yours as being responsible for the extreme act of murder. The few people over the years who wrongly and appalingly cheer on the acts of murder, dont make up the base of the pro life movement made of millions. The Pro-life movement is vastly made up of decent law-abiding citizens.

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

Yeah well, I started this specific DISCUSSION, which was my point. It seems hard for you to understand contextual points, which is the one I'm making... so I'll try again, JUST FOR YOU... the base of the pro-life movement is responsible for the RHETORIC that pushes people to KILL those who are pro-choice... and that my friend, is lunacy.

[InterWebsTuberNetter]

I suppose all the Anti-War and Anti-Waterboarders are responsible the rhetoric that led to the murder that happened at the recruiting station in Little rock. I don't think so, but by your logic they are. You're whole arguemant is to blame good people for hienous crimes becuase you dont want the facts discussed.

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

WRONG AGAIN... You see, unlike you're movement, we don't don't APPLAUD murder or galvanize those who do it. We galvanize those who stand up for freedom and and American principle. Liberals do things like sit in streets and block traffic. We scream and yell, we don't bomb buildings and shoot people.

[shayneerin]

You APPLAUD abortion, which is murder in our eyes.

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

I NEVER "applauded" abortion... You're just making things up now. You're not entitled to your own facts. If you paid ANY attention to what I said, you would have understood my CLEAR English which said that "I think abortion is horrible", however, even though I feel that way, it is NOT my right, nor is it your right to take away the option from women to choose.

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

You can want to believe that a cluster of cells is a life and a human that would become savior of the world if it was allowed to actually BECOME a living person, then go ahead... but not everyone is going to join in.

[ihateneveen]

ok but people do not oppose abortion because of RELIGION. I know plenty of pro-lifers who see abortion as murder, because they see a fetus as LIFE, not because is is dictated on the bible...

[watcherkatt]

What do you mean"our eyes" do you have more than two eyes? are you a potato?See you cant talk for others !

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

And the Pro-Life movement is made up of a bunch of "law-abiding" citizens that wish to change the law to restrict freedoms and privacy.

[19lfm12]

If you play 'connect the dots' you will see that the hand at the wheel behind the Pro-Life agenda is: Opus Dei. There are cogent links between it & every major name & group; directly or indirectly. They are famous for Fanaticism & Fascism....

This is NOT about religion & everything about a political agenda of creating an army of Fantatics. They are also playing a Dialectic.....they want a 'war' & will get it....so the victimizer will appear as the victim.

Just watch.......!

[staringintotheabyss]

Soon the world will see, why "lion dens" were built for the crazy ass Christians when they first started pushing their religion around.

[HowardSternn]

Fanatics are responsible for his death. Stupid Fanatics. He only aborted 60,000 fetuses.

Bababooooey

[shayneerin]

Don't think of the killing of Tiller as MURDER. Think of it as a really really really late term abortion... and the shooters right to choose. Hmmm... starting to see the problem with your moral (lack of) principles???

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

How can you say the shooters had a right to choose when you don't even support a woman's right to choose? Why do you have to jump to saying I'm an immoral person? I'm not immoral, I think abortions should happen extremely rarely and carefully. I'm just outraged that people think the way to stop abortions from occurring is to kill someone. It's circular logic and based on a lack of rationale and a CONFIRMED lack of morality, since they do think it's okay to murder (now that you mentioned it).

[livelovebe1970]

Get a clue...when a woman has a fetus that dies and it is killing her because its causing her kidneys to fail and she cannot find anyone to help her its YOUR FAULT. Or another woman who has a fetus with no skull and no brain AT ALL. You are clueless!

[shayneerin]

There are obvious cases where a baby may have to be aborted, but those are not the abortions we are talking about. So YOU need to get a clue. Most abortions are done for other selfish reasons and should result in imprisonment or execution for the doctor and mother. An eye for an eye is the only true justice.

[livelovebe1970]

WRONG....those women COULD NOT FIND A DOCTOR TO HELP THEM BECAUSE OF PEOPLE LIKE YOU IDIOT!

[shayneerin]

The slutty girls of the world who make bad choices and then expect a doctor to save them the inconveniece of having a baby are the worst... most selfish... murderous people on earth. You keep talking about God and the Bible... it has nothing to do with that for me or most conservatives. Conservatives simply have the ability to tell right from wrong at the most basic moral human level, which liberals don't. Women who get abortions, and the doctors who perform them should all be equally killed.

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

You seem to think that abortions only occur as results of hedonistic promiscuity, when many abortions happen as a result of rape, incest, or the mother's life being in danger. It has everything to do with God and the Bible because of how the conservative movement in America has used the idea of God to bully people into fearing a place as ridiculously fictional as Hell.

[shayneerin]

more than 99% of abortions have nothing to do with rape, incest, or mothers life. It's all about people being selfish. I can see an argument in those cases but they are rare. Most abortions happen because the boyfriend, parents, or mother simply don't want to deal with the baby. It's not fair what happens to these innocent lives. It's a terribly immoral act to kill an unborn child. Those who willingly participate in abortion better hope there is no God.

[staringintotheabyss]

Shayneerin, abortion is ones right. Abortion has been around since the beginning of time, it's just easier today. Go ahead, make it illegal, it'll still happen, there's nothing you can do to stop it. Also, a fetus is not a child.

[shayneerin]

Abortion won't be a right for long. The movement in this country will outlaw abortion in most cases or abortion doctors heads will continue to roll. Murder has been around since the beginning of time, you are right about that. And if a "fetus" in not a child, then what is it? you moron??? A so called "fetus" is an unborn child. Again you liberals deny common sense and try to put another name on it to make ok.

[staringintotheabyss]

Shayneerin, abortion will always be a right, even if it is unjustly outlawed and becomes a christionofascistly restricted right. Abortion is not murder, confusing the two proves ignorance. A fetus is "potential life" not life itself. If Christians are going to shoot up civilians, expect other crazies to also shoot up Christians and churches too, people aren't going to just lay down with your terrorism. Also, I'm not a liberal, nice presumption fail.

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

A conservative talking to a liberal about common sense... I like that.

Aren't you the ones who think the Bible is as valid as a Biology text book, or that dinosaurs had saddles because man rode them?

[shayneerin]

The Bible says that shedding innocent blood is forbidden... Tiller was not innocent. There is no gray area... Tiller is a murderer, not based on the law of men, but based on common sense (or the Bible for those who believe in it). Killing an innocent person is murder. Tiller was not innocent. You're just another pussy ass liberal who has no moral back bone. So let me ask you... do you believe that killing a baby inside a mother, cutting it into pieces, and sucking it out is a good thing?

[MarcusSilvaVideos]

No, it is not a good thing. I don't know why you asking this when I have already stated that abortion is horrible, just complicated.