Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (567)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • from 3:04... wowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww

  • never , NEWYORK ! all day

  • good singing good try but there was reason why the song was made about NY . That music just has that NY climate

  • i aint from america at all but NEW YORK so fits bettr

  • Comment removed

  • Broadways in New york... :x I should know, CUZ BABY IM FROM NEWWWWWW YORKKKKKKKKKKKK CONCRETE JUNGLE WHERE DREAMS ARE MADE OF

  • They just messed up the song new York is BEST!!!!!

  • ok ... i have always wondered if all utube singers know each other :PP

  • @rnaz they didn't steal this song dumbass...it's originally by Alicia Keys. That's why it says cover.

  • At least you didn't bother to write your own lyrics for the song that you blatantly stole. Douchebags.

  • @rnaz21 it freaking says alicia keys in the title

  • amazing!!!

  • I think they're singing the wrong lyrics...

  • This is sick... P.S. Andrew was my pick for Idol winner. :)

  • it's a cool version sometimes it is difficult to offer something different but... it sounds good thogh.... your own style...

  • what's the point of changing the entire aim (NEW YORK!) into LA?

  • @paulvanbeelen its a cover, they make it their own. and do a fantastic job at that...

  • @paulvanbeelen i think they live in LA.

  • vyhubjihohugfWAYQHBJKI UR COOL. I LOVE THIS SONG. U GUYS R AWESOME.

  • Dude! somethimes, your voice sound like Jackson Rathbone<3 (Ya are amazing!)

  • lol great cover great harmonies... but c'mon lol LA??? you know you can only make it in LA if you're white and loaded with millions, west coast too fake. I mean how many artists do you know that have been inspired by L.A. besides Paris Hilton LOL

  • I love you !

  • harmonies are all over the place.

  • tabs? :)

  • oh man they got the guy from american idol on there.

  • Awesome!! Love LA, love NY, love all states and much love to zurich city

  • Love this cover. Also love the candy cane next to your mic :p

  • J'adore tellement !!!

  • Good cover !

  • You should sing some Daughtry. I hear a resemblance in your voice && his. THUMBS UP if you think so too !

  • Phili hat. Boston Red socks shirt. Singing about LA :)

  • could you post the tabs to this song?

  • Great distraction and great vide0!! thank u downloadmusic .im

  • I'm not sure how many times I've watched this video. It's AMAZING! Anyone else notice the candy cane next to the mic? xD

  • 2:28 Perfection!

  • Theres a candycane on the mic. :D

  • PERFECT! wow (Y)

  • LOL, andrew almost kissed that guy in the end.

  • Damn Good! (:

    Greetings from Zurich. :D

  • amazing

  • love you guys....thats so special and the first time I heard it, I loved it!!!!

    greats from Germany....

    and a happy new YEAR!!!!

  • Heyy i just watched made and there were 3 guys who wanted to be made into singers and the 2 with the guitar and the one with the sheet of paper kinda look them!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @11RnB11 yes he was..... America is stupid 4 bootin him

  • wasnt that guy with the glasses on american idol?

  • @11RnB11 I was thinking the same exact thing. haha

  • The guy with the paper sounds like NeverShoutNever :D

  • DOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOPE!!!!!! ENOUGH SAID! GREAT JOB GUYS!

  • NY FTW

  • Fantastic guys. Great cover!

  • 1641 normal people and 48 spastics < this is awsome....

  • greaaaaaaaaaaat =)

    that was awesome =)

    keep it up guys

  • OMFG. i love andrew garcia.

  • thumbs up for philly. andrew <333

  • why do the second guy has a philadelphia cap on when theyre singing about L.A. ? :D:D

  • why do theyre singing about L.A. when the second guy has a philadelphia cap on? :D:D

  • why do theyre singing about L.A. when the second guy has a philadelphia cap on? :D:D

  • Comment removed

  • @Klaehn93 "mainly the guy with the glasses"??? you've gotta be shitting me!!

  • This is amazing! Good job! I love how Andrew is in this!!

  • This is amazing! Good job! I love how Andrew is in this!!

  • Thats amazing:-)

  • There is no way to fault that.

  • i love songs about LA. these guys sound great. definitely prefer it to the original.

  • waaa is gerald from la?? dood maybe i'll see him around LOL

  • Boo L.A!!!  GO Minnesota!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LOL

  • go home :D jokin ur good guys but in my opinion nyc is way better than L. A. but the lakers are beautiful :D 5*

  • im in love with all of you (: <3

  • Andrew Garcia as in the one from American Idol? Or Andy Garcia like from the Godfather, and the Ocean's films?

  • wow! it sounds amazing and has a own stil...great! :))

  • this is just tooo good!!

  • Hi what chords are you playing ?

  • great! :))

  • damn the harmonies sounds awesome.. u guys rock!

  • Great cover, definitely original and fresh thinking :)

  • LA!? Philly rules!!! lol great job guys ;-)

  • this makes me want to do my own version.. lolz

  • WOW! I Love it! First guys who do it like it supposed to be..... awesome!

  • amazing, i can proudly say im addicted to singindork888 and youtube, once again, is my dealer! LOVE LOVE LOVE

  • better than the real one!

  • wow.. :D

  • you shpuld try out for america gots talent i heard there making another season

  • SPEECHLESS!

  • whats the chords for the way you play it :)

  • OH MY HOLYYY----?!??

    wtf? You guys are frickin AWESOME!!

  • great <3

  • GREAT singing...but LA just doesn't cut it like NYC does...AND I've lived in both cities...Luv the attempt though...great musicianship.

  • do you have a record deal, you really should!

  • omgee rock on

    heck Yeah! L.A..

  • U know Andrew Garcia??

  • EPICLY GOOD

  • Brill guys, you have left me absoulutly dry mouthed! That was ace, could you be done with a rapper ? :L:L

  • Guys, amazing work (y) ;]]]

  • where did u get the tabs

  • Nice solos

  • heyy!

    they sound pretty good. ;)

  • slowed up during the refrain

  • @silentinvi is that a problem?

  • i want it on mp3!!

  • lol i like how the guy with long hair is doing jazz hands when he sings lol

  • andrews wearing a phily hat and their singin bout LA  nicee lol

  • When you make it, PLEASE DONT USE ANY VOICE TECH I want O natural your damn good

  • I realy loved!!

  • oo that candy cane looks tasty

  • Wow very cool : )

  • wel done lad's i realy liked this!! good on you all

  • OMG You know Andrew Garcia thats crazzzzzyyyy! I bet he could get you a record deal now that he has all that fame! So weird what a small world.

  • AMAZINGNESS AT THE MAX!!!!! :D!!!

  • Wow.....this was amazing. Favorited this RIGHT AWAY. I want to listen to it all the time. And that I will do!! :)

  • sorry dont like it , good singers and muscians though!

  • <3 2 Frank Hagen and Andrew Garcia // Adrian William Project ftw

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @DominicanReina check out andrew garcia (guy with the cap on).. he was in American Idol top ten xD

  • @DjKaupapa Thanks.. lol I realized it after i wrote the comments... LOL

  • can anyone post chords? pls

  • Holy EFF! you guys are amazing! i wish i had friends like you we would jam all day (Y) :D

  • BOMBASTIC <33

  • this is amazing!!!

  • I actually think ive listened to this about 121 , 713 times myself!

    Love it!

    Scottish love

  • Awesome guys! congrats...

  • awesome

  • where can i download this?

  • Fucking love this!!!!

  • hey i want to DOWNLOAD THIS SONG! and make it my ring tone! YOU GUYS ARE AMAZING SINGERS!

  • I love you Andrew Garcia! i loved you on Am IDOL

  • hey i liked it !! :D

  • So glad I stumbled on this. U guys r so talented.

    Singindork, u'd be huge in hk in a heartbeat. Not many artists have talent here.

    Looking forward to ur next video!

  • hey guys, i really enjoyed the singing but i honestly wished you'd changed the lyrics to fit LA. it felt kind of weird 'cause the lyrics were clearly about ny :\

  • ha nice they're singing bout L.A. but andrews got a phili hat on. still an amazing singer though. go andrew

  • and frank is wearing a boston shirt

  • Ooooohh. L.A! L iLike ;)

  • best cover ever!

  • why arent Andrew and the guy on the left on the radio already?

  • @dirtylos30 so your saying you can sing better? oh wait, I checked your channel and you ain't got SHIT.

  • the song is about new york. not l.a. just makes this cover crap

  • The way that the guy who's wearing blue shirt have a nice voice ;;> but his mouth something is wrong =))

  • NY > LA :P

  • Literally my 519th time listening to this!

  • wow the first guy who sang sounds like Chris Daughtry! nice harmony! keep it up! ^-^

  • @ailefofelia it's Frank Hagen

  • WAY BETTER THEN THE ORIGINAL

  • O dang !!! Philly and boston up in here ?!?!? NYC rocks find your own song !!!

  • red socks suck !

  • strong beach!!!! hahaha yesss

  • This is seriously the best discovery ever. <3 Love it.

  • niice nice :D

  • Awsome guyz!!!!!!! You all should join idol next yr. Like andrew.

  • WAY better than the original!!!!

  • smooth harmonies! what a great rendition!

  • Awesome, accept you changed New York (Greatest place on the planet) to L.A. ( Biggest shithole on the planet). It was pretty awesome besides that.

  • 1:50 and 2:10 amazing! you should be pro/!

  • simply amazing!!

  • wow....hammmer...;-)

  • I swear. Every time I listen to this cover, I just wanna go to LA soooooooo bad.

  • Gerald, lets do another video mang! Miss you man!

    Jon Esposito

  • this is such an amazing cover! i also did one too of this song but in a different way

    hope u can check it out :)

  • 1 866 idols 03

    or text the word "vote" to 5703

    to vote for ANDREW GARCIA ON AMERICAN IDOL TONIGHT!!

    REMEMBER THE LINES DON'T OPEN TILL 10/9C

  • awesome 5/5

  • Man this is hella dope! Actually better than i expected...check out my version and tell me what you think!!!

  • ANDREW GARCIA is decidedly the big S.T.A.R of youtube first and secondly of the world of music in this year 2010 go AMERICA et ANDREW you're my IDOL haha

  • i love this version

  • "Yo,What's up LA?!? What's up LA?!? Even though, I got a Philidelphia hat, I'm from LA! That was stupid!" Lmao!

    I love him! <3

  • Candy cane!

  • "..even though i got a philadelphia hat, im from LA!" haha i love andrew :)

  • LA??

    lol still love it

    u guys r awesome. keep it up

  • LA??

    lol still love it

  • SO AMAZING

  • So AMAZING! I LOVE Andrew!!!

  • very impressed - bit of scottish love and glaswegian appreciation guys

  • great !

  • wow you guys are AMAZING

  • Andrew from American Idol ! Good luck for him.

  • Perfect!!!! luv it

  • HAHAHAHA muuito bom *.*

  • I did a ukulele version of this check out my page please raecarter82

  • wat dah, i cant favorite this song????? i press the button but it wont show up on my channel

    :(

  • That was amazingg, i actually prefer it to the original, harmonies great, you all have different voices so when you put them to gether its just awesomee, i'm subscribin, keep going guys yourr amazingg ;)

  • nice:)) !!

  • flippin' tight! love it. and im not from LA either. snap

  • LOVE!!!!!!!!!!!

    u all rock!

    Team Andrew Garcia!

  • vote for andrew garcia on american idol!