Andreas Scholl: Furibondo spira il vento - Partenope

[ladentelliere77]

So, I try in english, with less "camaieu" in words, sorry...

D.Daniels and P.Jaroussky are sure more virtuosos in their versions. But, D.Daniels shows us the violence of feelings of a man torn between desire and passion. Andreas Scholl shows us the distress of a wounded man splitted between the desire for a woman and his deep tenderness for another. This delicacy in feelings leads to an admirable interpretation, above all for me.

[MisterPapageno]

I find the accompagnato rather rude and noisy... Scholl has no voice for this piece, and the legato line is missing complitely.

[pr21pr21pr21]

but andreas has the best coloratura...

[ladentelliere77]

@pr21pr21pr21

Je viens d'écouter les versions d'A.Scholl, P. Jaroussky (concert) et D.Daniels (opéra). Incontestablement ces deux dernières sont plus virtuoses mais :

David Daniels nous montre la violence des sentiments d'un homme partagé entre désir et passion.

Andreas Scholl, tout en retenue nous montre la détresse d'un homme blessé partagé entre désir pour une femme, et profonde tendresse pour une autre. C'est cette délicatesse de sentiments qui rend sa version admirable et insurpassable.

[pr21pr21pr21]

@ladentelliere77

unfortunately i dont speak french ;-(

[mapawista]

I think, Rene Jacobs with La Petite Bande performance is the best one!

[Gentario]

Non ci siamo, mi dispiace per Scholl.

[MisterPapageno]

@Gentario L'accompagnamento è chiassoso e rozzo; e Scholl non ha l'etereità di un legato continuo.

[SlovenskyRaj]

Wow, an aria which allows me to objectively state - David Daniels performs this one better.