Added: 5 years ago
From: SJGrantski
Views: 197,974
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (501)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the video has gone blurry for some reason.

  • Thank you very much a wonderful tribute to those with disappeared loved ones. I was very young when the cold war started and our family left Chile when I was 6 so my memories are the heartbreaks and my lifelong hope of the disappeared being found to be laid to rest properly.

  • Un himno para todas aquellas personas a quienes se les fue arrebata una parte de su vida...se me hace un nudo en la garganta con esta canción.

  • Essa também é nossa história. Nossas condolências do Brasil

  • :(

  • Absolutely INCREDIBLE MAY ALL THE MOTHERS BE REUNITED WITH THEIR LOVED ONES!!!!ONE DAY WE SHALL ALL BE TOGETHER AGAIN!!!

  • Brian Eno's influence is clearly in this song

  • Ni olvido ni perdon ..Grande Bono

  • this song sends shivers down my spine

  • does anyone else hear how Coldplay ripped them off from 1:43?

  • @WhyIAm7 O yeah, Coldplay want to be U2! What they've got to remember is U2 have been top of the tree for 25 years, just cant see Coldplay having enough ideas to last that long.

  • @Robcatist yeah.. seeing as they stole from Joe Satriani and U2. in one song. tsk tsk.

  • I love the people of Chile. I lived there a few years and they have much to be proud of. VIVA CHILE!!!

  • what does in 3:01 mean? in english? i love when he say that but i dont know what this means..

  • @drdrak3290 "el pueblo vencerá" = "a people united will overcome", a phrase used by the Mothers

  • 3:55 what does the lyrics means?

  • Beautiful haunting song.

    

  • I'm writing a 10 page research paper on this subject, and knowing that someone like Bono cares about what these women went through ... So heart warming. Their story needs to be heard!

  • More than 40,000 disappeared persons since the murder of President Allende on Sept 11, 1973. ¿Qué digan dónde están?

  • Dieses Lied macht mich tränen ....

    Mich schwer Ärgern macht mich, dass 'U2' NICHT in 'Irland' versteuern lässt!

    'U2' ist 1e verlogene Truppe!

  • The one and only

  • Wow. Simply amazing

  • Was at the POPMART tour in Edmonton, Alberta. They did not play this song. Wished they did. This is why U2 are who & what they are. An aweome rock band with a conscience!!

    I cry everytime I watch this.

    Humans are capable of such terrible atrocities to each other. Our planet is experiencing this reality & we will all pay dearly - & I ain't talking about money. Can't eat money.

    Hear their heart beat!

    U2 fan since the boy album. (blessed to see them twice - no line on the horizon)

    Namaste

  • 7 of Pinochets Relatives have found this video distastefull.............Fuck 'em"""""""""".

  • 2:22 charlie sheen hahahahaha

  • probably the most surreal moment on the whole entire POPmart tour, after of course the show in Sarajevo. awesome awesome awesome awesome. still words cant describe how awesome this moment is.

  • Chile ! Ireland loves you !

  • C.I.A. backed death squads killed a bunch of idealistic kids because they dared to want american freedoms. Lest we forget.

  • Fuck. Totally crying.

  • @paulderev me too. I lost my first son back in 2004 and now my only other child - also my son. he is slipping through my fingers and there is nothing I can do. Somedays I hate being a dad with such an intense passion. I dpn't klnow why God is not answering yes to my prayer and bringing Matthew home to me. Didn't expect to cry tonight at 11:20 all alone in my apartment....

  • @richardthewriter hang in there man! you will find what you are lookin for!

  • An amazing heartfelt piece that I have loved since the 9th of March 1987 when I bought The Joshua Tree.

    Dónde Están Corazón?

    And where is Madeleine McCann and all of those other poor babies who have been taken?

    Yet another timeless U2 classic.

  • El pueblo, vencera.

  • this is powerful.

  • Bono gets unfairly slagged sometimes, this shows why he shouldnt.

  • @Robcatist You are damn right.You can just feel the love in the air.Absolutely epic moment.

  • ¿DONDE ESTAN?

    Es muy triste nuestra historia. Compartimos al militar mas grande de la historia, y a las basuras mas inmundas.

    Saludos desde Argentina!

  • ¿DONDE ESTAN?

  • Midnight, our sons and daughters Were cut down and taken from us. Hear their heartbeat We hear their heartbeat. In the wind we hear their laughter In the rain we see their tears. Hear their heartbeat, we hear their heartbeat. Night hangs like a prisoner Stretched over black and blue. Hear their heartbeats We hear their heartbeats. In the trees our sons stand naked Through the walls our daughter cry See their tears in the rainfall.
  • Comment removed

  • por eso y mucho mas son la mejor banda del mundo u2 I LOVE YOUUUUUUUUUUUUUOOOO

  • La mujer que habla al comienzo es Zola Sierra ella murio sin poder llevar un flor a una tumba.Quienes critiquen esta accion de grandeza y crean que fue desmedida por parte de U2 lean el libro los " los zarpasos del Puma" enteran y si tienen sentimientos sabran cual es el dolor de buscar un hermano padre o hijo y encontrarlo en fosa comun, sin dignidad, sin una flor, leer ese libro te cambia la vida, no tengo ningun familiar desaparecido, pero aun me conmuevo con el dolor ajeno.

  • Incredible that 6 people dislike this video. Even if you don't like U2, this gesture is priceless.

    Viva la justicia de la gente!

  • los cuicos que estaban les cayo como pata en los cocos esto incluso se empezaron a ir del concierto

  • Gracias por hacer sentir de nuevo el corazón en el pecho, y hacer saltar las lágrimas. No hay palabras. Love U.

  • Comment removed

  • U2 lo mejor!!!

  • que bonito

  • Me emocionó hasta las lagrimas... es impresionante la energía que tiene este video, gracias U2 por dar este hermoso homenaje!

  • According to Rettig Report (The National Commission for Truth and Reconciliation Report of Chile), within the missing persons, there are 49 children <16 years old; and 269 between 16 to 20 years old.

    It mean, the dictatorship KILLED INNOCENT CHILDREN. Recently I heard that within this list there is a baby of 3 years old.

    When I heard this I cried. I have no family member disappeared, but it hurts the soul, knowing that they killed only for "pleasure" to feel powerful.

    Thanks you U2!!.

  • Comment removed

  • All the mothers of this disappeared are demanding is to know what happened. They know their loved ones were murdered, they just want to know where they were buried. Pinochet, Saddam, Gadaffi, All of you will stand before god one day, and have to answer that question. Even Ted Kennedy, Justice will be served, god will hold you to your actions.

  • Y los tendremos nuevamente este 25 de Marzooo ... salU2.

  • Unbelievable performance...i you like U2/Bono or not this must touch you!

  • IMPRESIONANTE

  • Dress it up in bubble wrap and Pop all you want, you can't escape U2.

  • thanks you bono thanks you u2 / gracias bono gracias u2 por apoyar a las familias de los detenidos desaparecidos del la disctadura del asesino augusto pinochet k ahora esta en el infierno pudriendose gracias bono

  • The line about the sons standing naked made me remember a passage in the Nunca mas! (Never Again!) where teenage detainees were blindfolded and told they were about to be executed. According to the survivours all of them cried for their mothers. I could never finish that book cause I started to cry. This song tells about a real event. Always remember, never forget.

  • One of the few things that still makes me cry, how people can hate Bono is out of my understanding, a man with a bigger heart is hard to find.

  • So good...goosebumps!!

  • Bono I love you. You help so many. Please know that in the US many black Americans are with you for the bond of slavery. Listen to Tupac Shakur. Many young men listen and hear the call of poverty. He would love for you to preach now and for us for all time. Thank you Bono

  • @deepblueocean86 makes me cry too...

  • Bono looks really good here....

  • Teary eyes here too.

  • Thanks for this great live performance.

    I got tears in my eyes...

  • 6 dislikes? omg

  • Look up Stephen Biko

  • This man, his concious, bono I loveyou. Dr. King was here in this country and this is in Bono's land. Dr. King would be proud.

  • When we can sing this song and no one have to cry? Never forget this sons and daughters! Thank you for this video.

  • even so I have no clue

  • "and when the disappeared returns ?

    every time the thought returns him back And how you speak to the disappeared?

    tightening with emotion inside.... RUBEN BLADES

  • No more words to say..........chicken skin!

  • Comment removed

  • LA PIù GRANDE BAND MAI ESISTITA PER MUSICA, IMPEGNO SOCIALE,SERIETA',E PER TUTTI GLI EMOZIONI CHE CI REGALANO IN OGNI CANZONE IN OGNI CONCERTO IN OGNI TESTO. SONO TROPPO GRANDI DOPO OLTRE 30 ANNI SONO SEMPRE ALLA CIMA DEL MONDO E ANCHE SE CE' GENTE CHE OSA CRITICARE QUESTA BAND E SOLO PER INVIDIA.GRAZIE U2 DI ESISTERE GRANDI!!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • This is amazing. Tears welling up as I watch......

  • desapapecidos y con fusil en mano

    no eran tan santos estos pobres weones marxistas

  • @Alvi316 Pobre weon nadie dice que hayan sido santos pero al menos sus familiares merecian recuperar sus cuerpos para despedirse de ellos y estar en paz aparte muchos de ellos murieron simplemente por pensar distinto

  • @Alvi316 para que te metes aqui entonces po

  • @Alvi316 ¿Te gustaría que no te entregaran el cuerpo de tus padres para darles digna sepultura?...Nadie es santo, pero todos merecen descansar en paz.

  • Thank you thank you thank you for somebody as influential as Bono to display the truth about what has gone on in South America with the help of US retardicans. When he could have done his own show with U2, he takes time out of the show to allow victims of injustice to have their voices heard. True indeed, how anybody can hate U2 after this I'll never know.

  • I hope pinochet and the fucking shithead nixon are burning in hell...leave it to a republican to back a dictator...

  • Comment removed

  • y como pifian derrepente los momios...........

  • its politicaly motivated action, being hit by a meaningful song...

  • Una bella canción que nace de los lamentos de las Madres de los hijos desaparecidos durante el conflicto armado de El Salvador en la década de los 80´s. Adelante mi hermosa tierra de El Salvador, con amor y nostalgia desde Buenos Aires, Argentina.

  • Bono had alot of trouble with his voice on this massive tour, but it sounded better than ever on this! Ive been with U2 for 27 years where are they gonna take me next, U2 RULE!!!!!!!

  • La verdad es que poco importa se fue inspirada en san salvador, argentina, chile, nicarágua... lo importante es que una persona con la visibilidad de bono dé voz a las madres que han perdido sus hijos y que se hable de estas situaciónes y otras atrocidades que no debrian pasar nunca en parte alguna del mundo! quedate bien.

  • Comment removed

  • @dreadmaniaco La canció fue escrita inspirada en lo que pasó en el savador, despues de un viagem que bono ha hecho en los años 80 durante la guerra civil, donde conoció un grupo de mujeres "las comadres", tambien conocidas como "las madres de los desparecidos". Sus hijos habian side llevados por la noche por los entonces conocidos "escuadrones de la muerte"...pero la verdad es que esta cancion se aplica a todos los regimens de ditadura... sry 4 my not very good spanish.

  • Comment removed

  • @dreadmaniaco Lamento, pero estas engañado. lo que pasó con las madres de la plaza de mayo, fue bastante después de el tener compuesto la canción que también se adaptava a la situación de las madres argentinas. como te dice, "mothers of diseppeared" fue inspirada por lo que pasaba en el salvador, así como la canción "bullet of blue sky" también de joshua tree... pero, quien mejor que Bono para decir-lo? hizo lo que me deciste: busqué en la net.. mira este site - youtube.com/watch?v=FQGNSmWt5K­8

  • Comment removed

  • Great stuff this. Well done U2. Awesome as the video poster says.

  • "Where I can get this concert in Chile? I began to mourn as a child here"

    ¿donde puedo conseguir ese concierto de Chile? me he puesto a llorar como un niño aquí mismo

  • man i have tears in my eyes

  • Bono eres un tio grannnnde!!!....

  • AMO U2 ES LO MEJOR son muy buenos con chile y BONO es todo un personaje mundial

    :D Son unicos!

  • como dice Jorge González: Pretendes pelear y solo eres una mierda buena onda / nunca quedas mal con nadie : )

  • @StgoSupersonica quien es jorge gonzales? estas hablandod e un conchesumare jajaja ni cerebro tiene tanto acido

  • @NOSEKENSOYYO Jorge "El Mágico" Gónzalez es el mejor jugador de fútbol de El Salvador mi buen amigo. El Mágico jugana en el Cádiz de España y era tan bueno que hasta Maradona lo pidió como compañero de juego en el Barcelona. Hay un refrán que dice: la ignorancia es curable la imprudencia un mal de nacimiento, mide tus palabras para la próxima.

  • @hielena toy hablando de jorge gonzales el vocalista de los prisioneros ahueonao, 0 comprension de lectura marrano

  • @StgoSupersonica jajaj te dolio parece. Bono es una mierda buena onda y hay muchos q ya no le compran la pomá.

    me da igual lo q haya hecho jorge gonzalez con la droga y con su cerebro; no soy la tipica chaketera q se fija en weas y q le chupa la verga a cualkier weon q llega con discursillos de paz y amor y q se llena los bolsillos de plata con sus conciertos de beneficencia. Tu sí parece = (

  • El pueblo vencerá...

  • I had a tears in my eyes while watching this :(

  • very,very emotional...thanks bono.

  • the lady at 4:05 "i want justice!!!"

    

  • Amazing Sound!!!

  • viva CHILE, viva su GENTE, viva U2

  • I hate U2 because they make me cry.........

  • one of my favorite moments of the band. really really touching

  • bono u are unbelivebel well done mate

  • thats why...i still love U2!!!

  • wena bono....la cagaste pa ser wena onda

  • Viva Chile mierda

  • Verdaderamente conmovedor...

  • I don't understand most of the words that are said but I understand.... thnks..........

  • Fantástico

  • Lo bello de este grupo es que están dispuestos a crear música con carácter social y político. No son de aquellas bandas que hacen música comercial, o que vaya dirigida a las masas. Bono y sus amigos son verdaderos artistas...

  • In honor of Mako

  • @delphine199 Fuckin right, totally agree with you

  • I had a staffordshire bull terrior put down at the age of 10 coz of a tumor. I laid in my bed alone, and sobbed every night . . . every night. To push me through and past my pain I listened to this song and continued to sob. Some how It helped. Get well soon Bono. and when you get back up on stage, put out the show of you're fucking life. R.I.P Stuart Adamson.

  • @twonky721 sorry about youre dog mate ! but youre right about this song the lyrics are very moving and u2 songs are very emotional but thats why they are the best band on the planet by a distance theres nobody 2 touch them live !

  • This is what makes U2 the biggest band ever. Not only their amazing music, but how they use it to change mentalities.

  • the band with a mission... the best band ever... Bono.. MY HATS OFF TO YOU..

  • Bono is a prophet of our century....

  • if there ever is a powerful song done by U2 this has got to be the one...I get the bumps just listening to it and my heart breaks, knowing these mothers will never know what happen to their children, so all we can do is hear their laughter in the wind, and see their teardrop in the rain...

  • Bono,you are the best!

    south amerika,afrika,you are for all! i am a graet fan since 20 years! You`ll never walk alone!! we see us in 29 of september in Sevilla! U2 is the best band ever and i love you!

  • awesome! thanks for posting! never heard this live before..

  • Impresionante!!!

  • La gente crea que estos actos no significan nada. En terminos sustanciales no significan nada. Al menos creo yo. Crean una conciencia colectiva de justicia. Una persona mas sensible es mas humana y empatica al dolor de los demas. VIVA U2.

  • It was written that the great writer, Charles Bukowski pretty much thought Bono was a phony because of his millions even though Bono was a fan of his. I say fuck Buckowski! (even thought I love his writing) How many other men of means like Bono would make the statement that he made during this vid and when U2 wrote the song back in '87 about the slaughter in Central America and elsewhere in the world? Good for Bono for championing the causes of the less fortunate despite his many riches.

  • Bono, I want your bubble suit.

  • one of the most moving things i have ever seen at a rock concert tears

  • delphine sos un ignorante mediocre hijo de puta

  • exijo justicia! impactante

  • @elevete qué lo parió ese grito eh, se me hizo un nudo en la garganta...

  • fuck racism !!! everybody is equal , in this fucking world !!

  • un saludo hermanos desde mexico!

  • un saludo hermanos desde mexico!

  • un saludo hermanos desde mexico!

  • sin palabras!

  • @Kj4sro, how can you possibly say something like that? These m others have lost their loved ones..their husbands, thieir children. All of a sudden, their whole world collapses, they do not know if their loved ones are dead. Everyday they live in the hopes that their husband/children are alive and they can see them. What would you do if you were in your shoes? What would you do if you lost somebody you love? Afterall, a mother's love is neverending.

  • What say at 4:04?

  • I demand justice

  • @egdeth thanks!

  • I demand justice

  • Linda musica, emocionante....u2 pra sempre !

    Emerson

    São Paulo

    Brasil

  • Amazing tears in my eyes :-(

  • kj4sro

    WHAT THE FUCK DO YOU KNOW ABOUT THAT YOU STUPID ASSHOLE a lot of things happend to inocent people back then my dad was tortured and beaten for 6 months when he was in the navy during the dictatorship of pinochet.

    so that means that he is a terorist ingnorent motherfucker

  • I really don't understand how anyone could hate Bono or U2 their pure majic right infront of us

  • AMEN Y'ALL!!!

  • Comment removed

  • I agree. I cannot watch this without crying like a baby.

  • What is your major malfuction? The women on stage here have all lost sons.

  • kj4sro, your ignorance here is simply staggering. Truly mind blowing that you are defending this genocide. You are one genuinely sad and sick person. Thanks so much for sharing.

  • I enjoy working in the squads, was a nice job....

    they use to call me the duracell...hehe

  • Which name does the song have, which is playe at the end?

  • Comment removed

  • @spammer2004

    "Stranger in a Strange Land"

  • really?! i think its different...

    some kind of live version?

    do you have a link?

  • Comment removed

  • its called scarlet, album october

  • thanks, that is the right song

  • amazing

  • EL PUEBLO VENCERÁ

  • Bono is very possibly the best person in the world to make a connection or two with a gigantic crowd. He came to my highschool auditorium to debut their spectacular movie called U23D. He said "Well, we are a high school band." This occasion is no different.

  • Bonostrepitoso

  • all chilean people say:

    thanks Bono.....

  • @donkan74 not all, i like U2's music except this act

  • One of the most beautiful, powerful and moving moments in the great history of the greatest band in the world!!!!