@apunkalipse13 no, I mean i haven't seen the film (bad of me, i know, but it didn't come to my town's cinema) but you're right in saying Ben isn't in this song because it is only Rob's and Joe Echo in the credits for it. But it's fun to see people debate on what they can hear! x
to cut the confusion, the deep voice belongs to robert sheehan. its actually a second voice. the melody of the song is performed by joe echo. only the two of them were credited in the soundtrack for this song. in the movie, it was only robbie and the band who were performing when shook up sang this song bcoz at that time, ben was kicked out from the band. ben, on the other hand, took the lead vocals of 10 of the songs in the movie and soundtrack.
This is incredible. I actually think if Ben and Robert formed a real band they would do amazingly well. They are both very talented and gifted young men
I just watched this scene, and the higher voice is actually the background one in the film... Robert is the deeper voice, which is more prominent in the film version. I love that the actors are not really just lip-synching to the soundtrack... the versions of the songs in the movie actually SOUND live. :) Lovely song, Robert does a great job!
Well, I finally saw the movie, and it appears the higher voice is actually Robert. In the movie, he performs a bit with the supporting deeper vocal not as prominent.
I'm curious as to which voice is Robert's. Is he the deeper voice? I really love this song. One of my favorites on the soundtrack. Thanks for sharing.
@mkitty03 I'm not completely sure but I think he may be the deeper voice. I haven't seen the film so I'm not sure if you can find out from a scene in there or not :D
@mkitty03 I just saw the movie and I can probabaly say that Roberts voice is the deeper one. In the movie Ben plays the lead singer and that's the voice you hear the strongest in the song.
@Melloship no cause he wasn't actually on stage. Another member of the band sang that part but you're right about Robert's voice being the deeper one.
I love hearing this song, it reminds me why i married him <33 x0x0x0x0x0x
GreenGoodbyes 1 month ago
Comment removed
BejnXander 2 months ago
I've seen the movie twice and I watched the clip of the scene where Robert is singing this and it appears he is the deeper voice.
Taytay92115 5 months ago
Does someone know FOR SURE witch voice is Robert ?
Because i've heard Joe Echo and it don't really looks like him...
Also... In the movie it seems like it might be the Higher Voice...
And it sure sounds like his voice....
He could do both... ?
Is Anyone 100% Sure ??
StSLaff 5 months ago
Robert can do everythiiiing ! I fuckin love him !
LittleCarow 7 months ago 7
Joe Echo is the higher voice, Robert Sheehan is the deeper one.
Robert is amazing!
RMichelola 7 months ago 4
Comment removed
RMichelola 7 months ago
the higher voice is propably robert sheehan voice
shatooish 7 months ago in playlist Killing Bono OST
Robert and Ben don't sing this song... this is a song by Ed Kowalczyk (singer from the band Live)
Just check out the names of the soundtrack and on youtube. that's on his solo album
apunkalipse13 7 months ago
@apunkalipse13 No, I have both versions and I did not upload the Ed Kowalczyk version. This is the version with Robert Sheehan in and Joe Echo.
cookiesrulesophie 7 months ago 5
@cookiesrulesophie yes you're right. anyway, people who said Ben voice's is the deeper voice are wrong, he doesn't sing on this one.
apunkalipse13 7 months ago
@apunkalipse13 no, I mean i haven't seen the film (bad of me, i know, but it didn't come to my town's cinema) but you're right in saying Ben isn't in this song because it is only Rob's and Joe Echo in the credits for it. But it's fun to see people debate on what they can hear! x
cookiesrulesophie 7 months ago
to cut the confusion, the deep voice belongs to robert sheehan. its actually a second voice. the melody of the song is performed by joe echo. only the two of them were credited in the soundtrack for this song. in the movie, it was only robbie and the band who were performing when shook up sang this song bcoz at that time, ben was kicked out from the band. ben, on the other hand, took the lead vocals of 10 of the songs in the movie and soundtrack.
bbkulotz 8 months ago
This is incredible. I actually think if Ben and Robert formed a real band they would do amazingly well. They are both very talented and gifted young men
Teeny123abc 9 months ago 2
lol, half's saying the deeper voice is Robert's, others - Ben. :D
Well, I just saw the movie n I think it's Ben. Listen to Where We Wanna Be, his voice is too deep, he could sing so high here.
Err, yet I'm confused. :D
applemarta 9 months ago
@applemarta Oh no!Ben's voice is much higher believe me,the deeper one DOES belong to Robert.;)
frodolover14 6 months ago
@mkitty03 i think both the high and low voices are Robert's he just recorded 2 tracks, basically he harmonized himself
themoska 9 months ago
Robert is the deeper voice.
BabycakeBRIT69 9 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
i hate that this movie isnt out in the US
BoredChick21 9 months ago
Comment removed
whatisair813 9 months ago
I just watched this scene, and the higher voice is actually the background one in the film... Robert is the deeper voice, which is more prominent in the film version. I love that the actors are not really just lip-synching to the soundtrack... the versions of the songs in the movie actually SOUND live. :) Lovely song, Robert does a great job!
pixiestix44 9 months ago 3
Well, I finally saw the movie, and it appears the higher voice is actually Robert. In the movie, he performs a bit with the supporting deeper vocal not as prominent.
mkitty03 10 months ago
Comment removed
pixiestix44 10 months ago
I'm curious as to which voice is Robert's. Is he the deeper voice? I really love this song. One of my favorites on the soundtrack. Thanks for sharing.
mkitty03 10 months ago
@mkitty03 I'm not completely sure but I think he may be the deeper voice. I haven't seen the film so I'm not sure if you can find out from a scene in there or not :D
cookiesrulesophie 10 months ago
@mkitty03 I just saw the movie and I can probabaly say that Roberts voice is the deeper one. In the movie Ben plays the lead singer and that's the voice you hear the strongest in the song.
Melloship 9 months ago 2
@Melloship no cause he wasn't actually on stage. Another member of the band sang that part but you're right about Robert's voice being the deeper one.
octopuspriime 2 months ago
@mkitty03 i've seen the film and i'm pretty sure it's the deeper voice
xvisionairx 9 months ago
@mkitty03 @mkitty03 Ben Barnes is the deeper voice, he's a great singer :)
phoebe8979 9 months ago 3
Robert is gorgeous. And his voice is as well!
McFleurieAndMcFlurry 10 months ago 23
Brilliant song!
courttv89 10 months ago
@landsebb I know! Well, it hasn't even been released in many cinema's in the UK so, it's so annoying.
cookiesrulesophie 10 months ago
Ahh, this song is great :) now if only the movie could come out in the US...
LandsEbb 10 months ago