Fwiw, 'prolific' doesn't mean good or great. It refers to quantity (a LOT), not quality. Elvis C was very prolific in his early years and in remains so. In the his case the songs were (mostly) good, better and frequently great. I bet he still writes a ton and would be releasing CDs of new material constantly - 70s-80s style- if he had an audience to support it. Paul McCartney remains prolific too, even if the audience for new Macca tunes has dwindled over the decades. imho, Btw, huge fan of both
You gotta hand it to Elvis, great songwriter, great lyrics. In fact Paul McCartney once said he thought Elvis Costello was one of our most prolific songwriters. I personally like the version done by Dave Edmunds but this version has to be held in great respect coming from the writer himself.
Strange bass progression in the bridge, goes to C# minor which makes it sound much different from the Dave Edmunds version, which is the one I'm used to. But its Elvis' song so who the fuck am I to complain ?!
@Yorkmackem These strange changes are almost always key to Elvis' kick ass musical twists; Spike is loaded with them and it's probably my fav album. Kudos for your good ear BTW!
I'll be happy to disagree. I think this stripped-down version is as good (if not slightly better) than Edmunds', which I consider great anyway. I like having the best of both worlds.
@redphonedeb i was gunna post the same thing til i saw ur post. ya know i love elvis costello but this versions just kinda ehh , ok, much prefer dave edmunds version. cant get it outta my head
Fwiw, 'prolific' doesn't mean good or great. It refers to quantity (a LOT), not quality. Elvis C was very prolific in his early years and in remains so. In the his case the songs were (mostly) good, better and frequently great. I bet he still writes a ton and would be releasing CDs of new material constantly - 70s-80s style- if he had an audience to support it. Paul McCartney remains prolific too, even if the audience for new Macca tunes has dwindled over the decades. imho, Btw, huge fan of both
GuiitarBilly 1 month ago
You gotta hand it to Elvis, great songwriter, great lyrics. In fact Paul McCartney once said he thought Elvis Costello was one of our most prolific songwriters. I personally like the version done by Dave Edmunds but this version has to be held in great respect coming from the writer himself.
robininspain29 1 month ago
both versions are so, so great. I love them each more because of the other versions. gets better every year.
fashionartbooks 1 month ago
Strange bass progression in the bridge, goes to C# minor which makes it sound much different from the Dave Edmunds version, which is the one I'm used to. But its Elvis' song so who the fuck am I to complain ?!
Yorkmackem 2 months ago
@Yorkmackem These strange changes are almost always key to Elvis' kick ass musical twists; Spike is loaded with them and it's probably my fav album. Kudos for your good ear BTW!
musoshi 1 month ago
It's great to hear both versions ( Edmunds & Elvis C.)
mm040462 4 months ago
I'll be happy to disagree. I think this stripped-down version is as good (if not slightly better) than Edmunds', which I consider great anyway. I like having the best of both worlds.
noseycunningham 4 months ago
Love both versions. I think Dave Edmunds gets the best out the very clever Costello lyrics
northernhecklet 5 months ago
nice song
cheleni1 9 months ago
@cheleni1 better by dave edmunds
redphonedeb 6 months ago
@redphonedeb i was gunna post the same thing til i saw ur post. ya know i love elvis costello but this versions just kinda ehh , ok, much prefer dave edmunds version. cant get it outta my head
adzug 6 months ago