Lori vs. Alyssa 1

[sancharram1]

Wow, I had no idea.....I love Alyssa I can't imagine another Phoebe but her. I've never even seen that other girl, who is that chick???

[josephasikhiahannah1]

Alyssa is a way better Phoebe then Lorie Charmed wouldn't be the same if she was played by Lori not to mention the effects and the stunts Premonition is million times better with Alyssa

[farrahslife]

alyssa! <3 her!

[Bcrusader12]

does anyone agree, that Alyssa seemed to contribute her dialogue into the scene where as lori seems to just say her lines as he queue comes up? Im sure she is better in other things, but i definitely like the final version....on the other hand, does lori remind you of the flair that Page has in the show....i kinda thought of her a bit.

[TheTwlightSagaLover]

Loris premonition face sucked soo bad glad she was replaced soo fake

[sanja15807]

alyssa is better then lori

[LadyMarJona]

I LOVE CHARMED I WACHT IT EVERY DAY

[lukadeadman99]

lori is better actress but not for charmed

[CarolAnnePoltergeist]

Alyssa is prettier than Lori.

[shairasuni]

i like alyssa than lori!!alyssa made well!!

[maskeyfilmz117]

i like the lethal weapon bit lori did but alyssa is so much of a better actress.

[o0XmsJadeX0o]

Alyssa!!!

[aaroncraskeofficial]

wow whats with the premonition in the end? haha she sucks

[hillaryreid1]

ya i dont like her playin this role, not that she is a bad actress but she just isnt right for it, she is to old, and mature, her acting is more lawyer then wild sister who is excited for magic...

[578b32675]

wow lori is so bad

[officiallytyshay]

I don't like the way Lori did the premonition, she looks like it hurts. Alyssa looked shocked and caught off guard when she got premonition although the way Alyssa is kind of funny to me but yeah totally glad she ended up playing Phoebe.

[Screamqueen2]

So happy they decided to have Alyssa play Phoebe instead of Lori

[emmanrulz]

i like Alyssa Milano better than lori rom.

[atwtlukesnyder]

This would be excellent to watch if it wasn't for the ANNOYING music!

[ojrustin]

man the old phobe sucked she cant act that good. Alyssa way better in comparison

[CharmedSuperGirl]

Lori roms premonition face was really bad lol! Im glad alyssa got the role instead!

[ariharveykinkle]

lori rom as phoebe is the adopted sister

[Charmed806]

Alyssa is way Better, Huh that is why Lori hit the Car!!!

[floritka85]

Alyssa was way better. Lori looks older than the girls, and I think they had better chemistry with Alyssa than Lori.

[newyorkerboy1]

Alyssa is better

[buckeykentucky]

lori rom isnt acutally oder in fact shes 3 years younger than alyssa milano but she looks way older

[buckeykentucky]

true but alyssa is a way better actor and way more famous so she would probaly get the show more views jsut because shes on there and even if lori stayed i dought the show wouldnt have made it to 3 seasons because she left for religious reasons not because she wanted and shannen is very famous to i do wish she coulda stayed but her and alyssa never got along plus lori was taller and slightly biger so alysaa is way better

[bolynne]

would rather have had lori maybe the show would not have taken the slutty turn it did in season 4

[abooood95]

lori is kool but she is too old

alyssa is better though and looks younger

[madamprezident]

so very happy alyssa was cast instead. she is a better phoebe all day long. haha thats why i have all 8 seasons . yay me

[rbd43091]

alyssa was the best!!! she made the show worth watching

[mandawander]

im glad Alyssa got the role! i think she gave her character alot more something, but Lori, to me, i though she was boring and looked the oldest out of the 3..!

[shanpas]

Alyssa is the only reason i watch the show top 5 in the world no contest

[MilanoHorsShineHotel]

Go Alyssa Milano she is definately the best!!! XP

[timmypop1]

in the second with lori i recon that was good second alyssa 3rd lori 4th lori

[charmedfan995]

I wonder how the show would of been if they hired lori?

[usermee]

the episode that they aired was soo much better. they didn't even have a table on this and they used a pan for the spell hehehe

[favm360]

I like alyssa better. She brought more to the character. Lori wasn't that bad but i like alyssa better

[BrendalovesDylan]

alyssa is best as the youngest one

[joeytimo]

its really amazing how i never seen this one with lori rom in it! ive seen all of the charmed episodes from series 1-8 and this one is so different compared to the other one with alyssa in it!

[NcisGirl15]

ya its like watching another tv show i own all the season of charmed on dvd so seeing this one was weird

[zoocome]

Lori looks old for a youngest sister role =(

[Leyuann]

come on lori wasn't that bad! you just got used to alyssa.

[RossM3838]

alyssa is a far more versital and lively actress. I am glad they hired her. She really makes the sho.

[Carin116]

Alissa is the best EVER

[dancrloveex3]

so wait, when lori played phoebe was she the oldest or the youngest?

[hiddenfairys]

she was still the youngest. it was just a different actress playing the character. al though they did fix up the set and some of the scenes

[dancrloveex3]

yeah, but lori looks older than all of them,

thats all.

[PiperHalliwell1230]

alyssa is better but lori wasen't bad

[WeLoveJenAniston]

lori sucked as phoebe!

Alyssa is way better.

[chibidibidi]

Alyssa is so goog compare to lori rom oh my goddddd it s unbelievable to see the difference ALYSSA is the Best

[meggzzie]

Lori's 'premonition' was soooo bad, and she looks taller, so its so unbeliveable to see her as the youngest. plus the house looks so bad in the lori versions, if yoiu watch carefully. eugh

[caitlinrenee33]

omg im so glad the stupid lori chick left and alyssa is phoebe. alyssas personality makes the character sooo much better. ist ANYONE likes lori rom. anyone second that?!

[fredm74]

Can anyone figure out WHY Phoebe (the Lori version) had a premonition about the demon just out of thin air? She didn't even touch anything. I'm so glad they changed that. It just didn't make sense. It's as if she was having stomach cramps and had to use the toilet.

[TheFifthHalliwell]

deffo alyssa, she is so much more convincing as phoebe

[birdsfan08]

Lori rocks she has a way better figure and face than Alyssa skank face

[cherryelectra]

Alyssa so suits this part and shes a better actress lori looks older then prue and the attitude it looks like piper hates her

[shaider1921]

Lori having a premonition, she looks like she's going to poo anytime..

[downuptv]

Haha, ye

[tannerheathmay]

well i think that Alyssa brings a joy and cheerfulness that Lori didnt and her reaction to her premention was 200X better plus i couldnt imagine charmed any other way ALYSSA ROCKS!!!!

[solrey74]

indiscutiblemente!!! Alissa tenia que ser Phoebe!!!

[p3charmedonesp4]

Alyssa is so much better then lori by a long shot. and the effects with Alyssa are a whole lot better then the ones w/lori. You really don't have to think twice about who's better!

Holly and Shannen are also awesome!

[Toni013]

I hate that Lori fuckin bitch i only like Alyssa

[pheebsandpaigio2]

No offense to Lori and stuff, but Alyssa had actual passion for the job. Lori wasn't that good of an actor, had no passion, and was just bland. Also, maybe it's because I've only seen Alyssa, but she fit the part more, and Lori was too old. Lastly, Shannen and Holly acted better in the one with Alyssa Milano. Alyssa rocks and there's nothin' to it!

[2ndKidd]

uhh... lori is actually the youngest out of the 4(umm...5?) of them, shannen is first(oldest) then alyssa, holly then rose and finally lori lol just wanted to say that and the fact that i totally agree with you charmed wouldnt be the same without alyssa (though some would disagree with the whole shannen alyssa thing. pfft i got off topic umm yah that was long XD)

[KAbigD]

Alyssa is way better!! all d way foo!

[TiffanysBreakfast88]

i really like Alyssa better then this lori person,....she's just not Phoebe.

[ystaL24]

i don't know if i have just watched charmed with alyssa milano as phoebe for too long and that i couldn't accept any other actress playing phoebe or lori rom is just not right for this role..it's not so much about her physical appearance but more on how she portrayed the role of phoebe..there's no eagerness and where's the free spirit?..im just glad that alyssa played it and i will really miss charmed..although,,i'm rewatching it!!from season 1 to 8!!=)

[PirplePashn]

No disrespect to Lori but she looks older than Shannon. I don't think she really fit the role of younger sister. And she seemed so dry Alyssa's acting makes her seem more eager to learn about her powers. Lori's acting is like what ever I'm here getting paid.

[seeleyboothfan]

You read my mind.

[sarahhalliwell1102]

It lasts interesting to see what lasts become Lori would have played Phoebe because she looks riper and less childishly.

[dimitrisp3]

the scene where lori has that premonition abour the demon sucks. it's rediculus

[randomgurl101]

wow no offence but i think that lori sucks playing phoebe. i love alyssa milano better! no offence though!

[christinaaguilera08]

Lori's car scene looked better.

[xSomethingSpecialx]

Alyssa Plays Pheobe so much better than Lori

shes much prettier

looks and sounds younger

and all in all acts that bit better!

[whitelighter521]

you may wanna check the news. title is "Shannen About Leaving Charmed"

[whitelighter521]

it's not alyssa's fault why shannen left the show. i love shannen as well but i think we're being unfair with alyssa. in the news, shannen said that it's her own choice to leave the show. it has nothing to do with alyssa or anyone on the cast. she even said that alyssa's one of her besfriends and she loves her dearly... just my two cents.

let's not blame alyssa guys. i admit i don't know her personally but for me, she looks nice and good...in and out. we'll surely miss charmed. =)

[whitelighter521]

i can't imagine charmed without alyssa. i love her so much. =)

[whitelighter521]

yeah, not to be rude with lori, but alyssa's more competent to play the role of phoebe halliwell. regarding the issue between shannen and alyssa, it's not true taht they had a fight. i've watched the news. shannen even said that alyssa's one of her bestfriends and she loves alyssa dearly. it's a personal reason according to her... just sharing my two cents. =)

[hailsilver]

lori rom sux. im so glad alyssa was the real phoebe.

lori couldnt do anything compared to alyssa

[charmed224p3]

alyssa is so must better

[michellechasez81]

Wow...Lori really sucked. This would've been better without the music. It really distracts from the comparisson being made. In other words...it's annoying.

[hiddenfairys]

sorry, i put it in there to make it pass as a music video so i wouldnt have to delete it for copy right or w.e

[michellechasez81]

Wow...Lori really sucked.

[MarkJohnPaul]

I h8 LOri specially her premonition!! IWW

[britshadowcoven]

that premonition near the end was crap!

[hiddenfairys]

lol

[sointhedark]

alyssa is better, but if phoebe is Lori, Prue may not died

[charmedonenicky]

alyssa is way better :p lori sucks

[tweetybird64]

alyssa is so much better! lori is not that good an actor and doesn't really suit the role...

[StevieD266]

No contest, Alyssa

[amyanda]

this would have been fine w/ out the music. I'm not trying to be mean, but I don't think that Lori is very "sexy" and it seems like that's a big part of who Phoebe is. Also, she acts too mature... not to play the younger sister because the family "roles" in this show are stereotypical and not necessarily real, but to play the character of phoebe who's written that way.

[cekothepro]

Alyssa > Lori ^^

[LithelArendi]

hello every can just see that ummm she is the tallest she acts like to oldest and is overdramatic

Alyssa is so much better and prettyer plus she acts like its real not fake and cheesy

Alyssa rox!!!

[cHARMEdLov3r16]

very cool. although i must say alyssa is like 999999999 times better. lol =P

[sesaw7]

I guess we got used to Alyssa Milano, just like what happened with Rose, but thank goodness with started with Alyssa!

[mz4cb]

oh my gosh alyssa milano is so much better... and who put that twat there

[Mike6E]

HA! Lori sounded like a man. Alyssa looked more like Holly and Shannen, fit the part better, and acted like a little sister. Go Alyssa!

[charmedgeek33]

wow THAT lori girl was like bad

[sourcedemon666]

i cant imagine seeing Lori kissing Julian McMahon...Alyssa and Julian forever! :D

[lilangel05]

im SO glad alyssa got the part! its totally weird seeing phoebe being played by lori. alyssas so much better

[Emma7639]

Haha this is like watching the pilot of Buffy with that weird girl playing Willow instead of Alyson.. Now that was wrong.

[hiddenfairys]

i know.. right! lol

[randdom]

Its so strange and slightly wronge seeing someone else playing pheobe