CARNIFEX - Answers in Mourning [MTV2 Music Video]

[xxXCrabcoreXxx]

headbangers ball... remember? :/

[IamTheDeathMachine]

the through struggle breakdown sounds a tad different. I can tell

[a7xrulz96]

What's with all the As I Lay Dying gay faggot shit? They suck. Carnifex Rules. Point made

[Xenon797]

kicks as i lay dyings ass

[TheTrueHunter]

This gets me PUMPED!

[StrYke4707]

As I Lay Dying and Carnifex are both great bands! Just different styles and genre.

[planelement]

Carnifex does it better than as i lay dying

[CODMasterBoys]

omg..this is not the same breakdown?? it sounds similar but its still different... listen to it closely before you bitch around like some abused assholes..

[CARNIFEX666austria]

got the same breakdown... who gives a fuck? awesome song!

[JamesH32682]

carnifex got a pet moth awesome!!!

[TheMcSteezy]

but really why would Carnifex rip a shitty band such as As I Lay Crying? Carnifex would do no such thing. and how do you fags even know that song?

[blastbeatdown]

it happens guys.. i accidentally ripped off a martyr a.d. breakdown once haha.. this is a basic pattern.

[jnsbeyer]

does the drummer have a straight edge tattoo?

[TheMcSteezy]

@jnsbeyer yes he does and is

[DownFromTheSky89]

ok seriously elitists need to stop bashing bands just bc they have choruses and solos. I love deathcore and metalcore. Honestly yhough the labels dont matter bc I think both are metal and sound better than every other genre of commercial music.

[blehblehblahh]

The breakdown is definitely not the same as the one in Through Struggle, the tempo is the same, but the notes are different, the picking is different, and the tuning is different.

[FleshOracle]

i just searched up that faggot band and the song and it sounds nothing like the break down. quit raging fags.

[peniku8]

watch?v=48nnZuaBxp8

The Video in HD - also better sound quality

[syndr6me27]

fuck your breakdowns. shut up and go somewhere else fags!

[ashantae2]

OMGS. The breakdown at 1:10 sounds like every other breakdown. EVER

[calibancore]

"the breakdown is the same like blablabla"

you fag, almost 75% of the breakdowns sounds similar

so stfu and enjoy this fucking great band !

[SlipknotXxMaggotXx]

Everyone talking about As i lay dying shut up. carnifex is better than those fags. and if anything they made the breakdown sound way better.

[jordidomine]

i dont think the vocalist of aild can do this shit

[Flyhazeman22]

this band shits on as i lay dying so who give a fuck if they stole it..they whole song is completely different

[Ar0474]

@Flyhazeman22 I agree, it fits this song! :D

[foxgentlemaenner]

the breakdown is nothing like the breakdown of aild so what the fuck complaining? :D

eeeehr yeah never knew they had a video for this song. I didn't like their 2nd album that mutch. but gotta say that song + video. sick! sad that mtv now doesn't show newer stuff but just the mainstream stuff.... they should restart broadcasting all genres. fuck yeah!

[taberman]

Breakdowns are so generic who argues about who did it first, they've all been done before by some band

[emandemon1]

HAHAHA. At 1:10 that's the same breakdown as Through Struggle by As I Lay Dying.

[CyborgPunisher]

@emandemon1- o really? :)

[SharkChode]

@emandemon1 Lmao, are you kidding? Firstly, no it isn't, you can clearly tell in the second verse of Carnifex' breakdown they continue the down-up stroke to coincide with the drums, AILD doesn't.

SECONDLY, every single breakdown sounds pretty much exactly like this at point. It's hard to be creative with a breakdown, they're meant to just be churning moments in a song.

[Powerman6002]

@emandemon1 no its not they are close not the same though

[ElijahJohnCirricione]

@emandemon1 As I Lay Dying took the breakdown from them. but really, it doesn't matter

[doggiedreads]

I'm surprised that no one mentioned Gojira's track "Lizard Skin" off Terra Incognita has a similar breakdown. That came out in 2001!

[TheNinjaOfAwsome]

Wtf no carinfex Is way better than chelsea grin

[xM15T3Rm5T33zYx]

fuck any genre that is brutal death metal or deathcore or whatever...

[Tcithere]

Chelsea Grin is better

[xGRiiNz]

@Tcithere Hell yeah!

[death4deathcore]

@Tcithere depends on what albem dude i honestly dont like thier newer stuff but their still brutal as fuck

[screamobeast]

fuck u mtv 2 for leavn a awsome music nd puttn sm nigga fucked up music

[mbopm]

Hellyeah, waybetter sui cide silence

[xxrob511]

wow mtv isent even music television anymore is freakin Drama Central!

[BeyondAllEnds]

hey guys, check us out! We are playing with Carnifex on May 12th!!

leave us some comments and reviews!!!

/watch?v=F-Us3tyfhmY

[cannibalcorpsesaw]

Fuck genres. If it sounds good it sounds good.

[1stBroly]

lol same breakdown like as i lay dyings through struggle. 1:1. lol^^

[CyborgPunisher]

@1stBroly just one question. if they copied the breakdown, wouldn't they know the criticism the band would face?

[Gagechannel]

@CyborgPunisher yeah for real dude they didnt copy shit, and aild doesnt have shit on carnifex.

[bananenschale99]

@Gagechannel cmon its almost the same^^

[200StringGuitar]

@CyborgPunisher Too bad Carnifex is so much better than As I Lay Dying, thus making this comment pointless.

[prayersofanathema]

@CyborgPunisher dude, listen to through struggle then listen to this song, its borderline the same shit, who cares though really

[AliveWithinReach]

@CyborgPunisher technically its not the same, i mean same pattern but theyre in 2 different tunings...ironically enough theyre both signed to the same record label

[mrice102888]

@1stBroly scenekidscenekid dotdotcurve

Look that up. It'll piss you off. It sure made me wanna break some bones...

[1stBroly]

@mrice102888

i dont understand what ur writing there? where up? what should pisse me off? bones?

[mrice102888]

@mrice102888 Sorry. It's a band called "DotDotCurve" doing a song called "scenekidscenekid." They took a very distinct riff from Metallica's "Wherever I may roam" and butchered it. IMHO, that "cover" blew big stinky greasy buffalo balls.

[partoffelkuffer]

true



[partoffelkuffer]

true



[prayersofanathema]

@1stBroly well they did leave out the artificial harmonic, haha way to take someone elses idea like a highschool student writing an essay

[megadethfan110]

@1stBroly Difference is carnifex is actually good

[josephcarnes1876]

THIS WAS ON MTV!? Omfg, why don't MTV play shit like this all the time? Haha

[SadedFuk666]

Not a big fan of Deathcore if thats what this is, but Carnifex is pretty dope.

[SlaughterEmos]

@SadedFuk666 my thoughts exactly dude

[VcExPos3d]

What the fuck is everyone talking about. It was never good, you were lucky too find Carnifex or something, it never changed it was always shit.

[blairg337]

when mtv was good...

[ihatethisstupidform]

Knowing MTV as what it is now. I had a hard time believing they actually played this. It's amazing to think they actually play good music. Why don't they do more deathcore?

[xxrob511]

its always the fat kids that get pick on everywhere

[GothVampireQueen]

I love the way it starts.

[dcboy98]

that's the breakdown from Through struggle by As i Lay Dying ... just sayin.

[xXEsPLoVeRXx]

@dcboy98 thats the not the break down from Through Struggle at all. they both have triplets and 4ths in it... thats the closest thing i can thing of for them to be similair at all.

[Necrephorus]

MTV had so many fucking awesome bands,like Nile and carnifex.... fuck new mtv

[garretts431]

I saw this on MTV. Why the fuck did MTV have to change. fuck lil' wayne.

[smakingtheway]

Didn't MTV banned a bunch of sick videos like this?

[jacobecky12]

this was on headbangersball on mtv...

so dont expect to see necrophagist to play right after kyane on the "Top 20" or somthn :P

...which they should be

[666x666Slipknotx]

Since when was this one mtv :o but they don't put shit now?

[Zofti]

which country's mtv was that?

[brutalcoregrowls]

i never knew mtv or mtv2 had a real taist of music

[TehKrakerzGuy]

At least they were able to put this on MTV, something that they can NEVER do with the "Lie to My Face" video, lol.

[mousy2021]

to be honest im suprised mtv played this they rarely play anything worth listening to.

[albinoguitar1120]

1:14: sounds like they copy the breakdown from "I never wanted" - As I lay dying /watch?v=85iMAm18oRc 1:43 :) :) :) :) :) :) :)

[MetaloOOoReason]

@albinoguitar1120

or the breakdown of " through struggle" :D

[lambofgod94]

@albinoguitar1120 simple fact is that this song came out before as i lay dying s song i never wanted come out moron... sorry to say this, just because it sounds a lil like the same doesn t man they are copying anything here... the breakdown here sounds MUCH better than AILD does

[ROFLCOPTER2112]

carnifex is fucking beast mode. but mtv = fail.

[metalmoniker]

this is sick and these guys rule

[FaceIsMutitlated]

@deluxe345 No it's metal on tv.

[EAsternHIpster]

im guessin this was only played on headbangers ball now way regular mtv would play this. carnifex kicks fucking asshole!!

[achtelpetit]

@ joeyaner

yes, that's a big problem, I don't get why this is so.Perhaps have too many mainstream idiots here.

[Holloweeed]

ich will das das auch bei uns auf MTV läuft !!!!!

scheiß hopper und raver wichser diese behinderten hurensöhne haben uns die musik ausm fernsehr und radio gestrichen.

diese ....

AAAAAHHHH

ich könnte mich jedesmal aufregen wenn ich den fernsehr einschalte und zu mtv rüberzappe oder irwo das radio läuft

früher war alles besser...

[KraySilence]

we have MTV 2 in germany..But they would never play deathcore on TV o_O

[Jonianer]

@KraySilence oh yeah your sooo right and i don't even get it only the comercial main MTV... anyway............

[Lyvcan]

channels like MTV 2 are missing here -.- only got MTV where are stupid R'n'B, House, Hip Hop and Electro are played

[deathcorezach]

is there? or are you just hoping

[BrutalityBrett]

LOL they copied as i lay dyings through struggle breakdown. or one of them copied each other.

[ChaosLegends666]

@BrutalityBrett as i lay dying's through struggle released in the album Shadows are security (2005) and carnifex The Diseased and the Poisoned in 2008 ..

so IF someone copied then carnifex. but i doubt they did

[12345Carlos]

mtv2?

[Malignanttorture]

Fuck me. Very good. Video made me think of The Number 23

[ItsTheColeTrainBaby]

cant wait till their new cd in march!

[DeathBeforeLife1992]

This kicks ass