of course emily watson doesn't play the cello, and what if she doesn't make it right? She plays an amazing character, she deserved more than jsut a nomination to the oscar.
This movie deserved multiple oscars... it is no doubt the greatest biographical movie ever, the best British movie ever made and in my opinion; one of the best 10 movies ever made in the history of cinema... How sad it is to have such success end in such tragedy...
any1 can understand that "Jackie"'s actress isn't playing coz her moves are so unnatural...and when we hear vibrato she act like she isn't doing vibrato,look it for yourself and correct me (if I'm wrong)
any1 can understand that "Jackie"'s actress isn't playing coz her moves are so unnatural...and when we hear vibrato she act like she's doing vibrato,look it for yourself and correct me (if I'm wrong)
....sigh...... I can't remember the last time the ELgar really got to me like it did this time...there's something about the way the music becomes when someone is talking over it...
ok, I see & I'll accept your point. Every cellist may do things differently, but they all hold the cello in a similarily way, & at least in a way that they'd play in tune. Like I said, I think Emily did a great job in the role. I just felt that she didn't hold the cello properly, esp. not to play in tune.I'm sure there are others who feel similiarly.
Sorry to have upset anyone, I had not intened to do so
Jackie didn't hold hold her cello that way, and that really annoys me. I mean, who can you hold the cello like that and play in tune. Good clip though, good acting, just not cello wise
well Jackie also wasnt an award winning actress like Emily Watson. As far as cello acting goes, she did a much better job than most, she obviously had some instruction and training. you need to find something worth getting annoyed at.
I didn't mean to upset any one, but after hours of research on Jackie, and on proper cello posture and technique, this kinda upsets me, as it's just so completely wrong. EMily did to a great job in the role, just not holding the cello properly.
Also, Jackie may not have been an award winning actrees, but she was a pretty good actress and mimic.
I didn't mean to upset anyone, it was just something that I wanted to comment on
once again, you need to find something else to get upset about. I'm sure she did the best that she could and she was nominated for an academy award for the role. how can you expect her to hold the cello exactly the way jackie did with such precision that it would satisfy an anal retentive cello student at Interlochen?
I have to agree. Every cellist (yes, Emily Watson did have to learn cello for this role) does things differently, whether it be vibrato, posture, or tempi. You, as a student at an acclaimed music academy should know this.
Watson should've gotten an oscar for this
maryamjanahi333 8 months ago
Cello Concerto in E minor by Edward Elgar
saveen3 1 year ago
what music is she playing???
saveen3 1 year ago
emily watson sooooooooooooodid deserved the oscar!! sublime interpretation de Jaqueline du pre...
Dogos73 2 years ago 4
Instead they gave it Gwyneth Paltrow for an awful performance in Shakespeare In Love.
frodoireland 1 year ago 5
What movie is this? I only looked at this for the cello solo, but now I'm interested :)
StripedxStockings 2 years ago
es una capa, la amo jacqi siempre en mi corazon
TheNoeliita 2 years ago
of course emily watson doesn't play the cello, and what if she doesn't make it right? She plays an amazing character, she deserved more than jsut a nomination to the oscar.
iamtheladyofsorrows 2 years ago
Does any one knows about a link to this movie in youtube but ordered by secuencial scenes?
raulishnikov 2 years ago
This movie deserved multiple oscars... it is no doubt the greatest biographical movie ever, the best British movie ever made and in my opinion; one of the best 10 movies ever made in the history of cinema... How sad it is to have such success end in such tragedy...
ramsesthethird2 2 years ago
Comment removed
margaret8216 2 years ago
Caroline Dale is the cellist who plays the music for this film. She also did the cello solos for Atonement.
But this song in particular is the Cello Concerto in E minor by Edward Elgar.
jennyfairy56 2 years ago
does anyone know where i can get this song? also this was an amzing movie.
newmindandsoul1 2 years ago
any1 can understand that "Jackie"'s actress isn't playing coz her moves are so unnatural...and when we hear vibrato she act like she isn't doing vibrato,look it for yourself and correct me (if I'm wrong)
SC2larry 3 years ago
Yeah she isnt playing its someone else i just can't remember her name...but she has her fingers in the right place just like the music is written.
kevalenoxx 3 years ago
The actress is Emily Watson.
PrincessVoldemort 2 years ago
I'm not talking about the actress..i'm talking about the person that played the actual music for the movie..which wasnt J dupre.
kevalenoxx 2 years ago
any1 can understand that "Jackie"'s actress isn't playing coz her moves are so unnatural...and when we hear vibrato she act like she's doing vibrato,look it for yourself and correct me (if I'm wrong)
SC2larry 3 years ago
best movie ever so nice
NANAWBAS 4 years ago
....sigh...... I can't remember the last time the ELgar really got to me like it did this time...there's something about the way the music becomes when someone is talking over it...
sonata1992 4 years ago 7
it is her signature piece
lavendersharpies 4 years ago 7
aww hilary
gsak14 4 years ago
I will always love Jackie.
ichliebegeige 4 years ago 3
Don't know exactly, but try to search for: Elgar: cello concerto in E minor, First song: Adagio (moderato), thats the same piece.
xjannekex 4 years ago
Thanks. Its awesome.
ichliebegeige 4 years ago
what is she playing at the begining
wkdoem 4 years ago
Elgar Concerto, practically her signature piece
TheTradge 4 years ago 5
yo what piece is that
wkdoem 4 years ago
ok, I see & I'll accept your point. Every cellist may do things differently, but they all hold the cello in a similarily way, & at least in a way that they'd play in tune. Like I said, I think Emily did a great job in the role. I just felt that she didn't hold the cello properly, esp. not to play in tune.I'm sure there are others who feel similiarly.
Sorry to have upset anyone, I had not intened to do so
InterlochenCellist 4 years ago
don´t forget that she´s an actrice not a cello player....it´s too dificult to imitate a cello player...
barbaracevasco 4 years ago
Jackie didn't hold hold her cello that way, and that really annoys me. I mean, who can you hold the cello like that and play in tune. Good clip though, good acting, just not cello wise
InterlochenCellist 4 years ago
well Jackie also wasnt an award winning actress like Emily Watson. As far as cello acting goes, she did a much better job than most, she obviously had some instruction and training. you need to find something worth getting annoyed at.
colba55o 4 years ago
I didn't mean to upset any one, but after hours of research on Jackie, and on proper cello posture and technique, this kinda upsets me, as it's just so completely wrong. EMily did to a great job in the role, just not holding the cello properly.
Also, Jackie may not have been an award winning actrees, but she was a pretty good actress and mimic.
I didn't mean to upset anyone, it was just something that I wanted to comment on
InterlochenCellist 4 years ago
once again, you need to find something else to get upset about. I'm sure she did the best that she could and she was nominated for an academy award for the role. how can you expect her to hold the cello exactly the way jackie did with such precision that it would satisfy an anal retentive cello student at Interlochen?
colba55o 4 years ago
I have to agree. Every cellist (yes, Emily Watson did have to learn cello for this role) does things differently, whether it be vibrato, posture, or tempi. You, as a student at an acclaimed music academy should know this.
CelloFiend 4 years ago
The best motion
Sarlota 4 years ago