Brat'ja (English Lyrics) Karaoke Version

[cyberdrago2]

IF YOU WANT TO WATCH ALL OF FMA AND FMAB THEN GO TO FULLMETALDUBBED HE HAS THEM THERE!!!!😄😄

[AnimeNovice2010]

@cyberdrago2 better yet, go onto into the funamtation channel and watch FMAB there and watch FMA on netflix (though netflic also has part 1 and 2, maybe 3, of FMAB too)

[SuppahOtaku]

i cant get the download to work =(

[BurningNeons]

Thank you for uploading it this helped me a lot!

[missmurder008]

You know I have never been into FMA. My best friend and my bf love it. They say its cause I never watched it from the beginning, like why I used to not like death note. My best friend gave me this link, and I love this song. And one day I was on the phone with my bf and he said he was listening to fma music, and I put this on and he started screaming cause he loves it xD he said he doesn't like this version of the show but always loved this song xD

[YorozuyaNeesan2010]

Thank you so much for this

[aang4all]

:P vic forgot to sing a part, I have never heard it being sung before, and now I can sing it

Dohmo arigatoh gozaimasu

[MattKitten]

@aang4all Vic didn't forget to sing it, it was a part meant to be sung by Alphonse, but the voice actor didn't want to sing, so they just skipped over it (technically the whole thing from 1:53 to 2:33 is supposed to be sung by Alphonse. I think they should've forced him into it, like "your contract says you do what i say" but i guess they couldn't do that, no matter how bad ass it would be.

[aang4all]

@MattKitten Well I know that but I would have still liked to hear it, and since aaron has hit puberty, I would at least like to hear maxey sing it, I WANNA HEAR ALPHONSE SING!!!!

[MsApplechan]

@aang4all Which reminds me- "It's called puberty, Ed. Maybe it'll happen to you someday ^^"

[MattKitten]

@rainclawwarriorcat I believe it was written specially for FMA, but i could definitely be wrong.

[rainclawwarriorcat]

@MattKitten thanks :)

[morningpaw123]

i love this song i played it for my talent show and everyone loved it

[ushixkarin]

YES i found a karaoke of brothers your the first personto have a brothers karaoke and good job making it

[petaltailify97]

11 people deserve to be turned into the philosopher's stone.

Beautiful Song

[delightXD]

Amazing lyrics, very nice work!

[DragonFox84]

the words are different the the vic version in some places but its still a good song

[welshchick1201]

2:13 - Vic didn't sing those words in his version, did he? wow, i wonder why not, would've sounded beautiful

[Mrs4inchheels]

@welshchick1201 Probably because he was singing it from Ed's POV, and singing that would just mean "Oh, I love you, it's my fault, but your desires were the same as mine" which was only partially true. O.o

[welshchick1201]

@Mrs4inchheels haha true, ;D

[1Puppeteer1]

I came up with lyrics to this in Alphonse's pov!

[11111ichigo]

@1Puppeteer1 You did? Well done!:3

[1Puppeteer1]

@11111ichigo thank you soooo much

[peanutbutterlovesme1]

most of the lyrics are freaking messed up>.>

[InuMermaid82]

11 people cried their eyes out.. Beautiful song I love it! =3

[sasukehotty62s]

how can i repay you brother mine how can i expect you to forgive

clinging to past i shared our blood and shattered your chance to live

though i knew the laws i payed no heed how can i return your wasted breath

what i did not know has cost you dear for there is cure for death beautiful mother soft and sweet once you were gone we were not complete Back through the years we reached for you alas twas not meant to be and how can i make amends for all that i took from you l lead you

[Canadiangirl123453]

In the break (Where it starts @ 1:30 ) , the violin is missing. :P All I hear is the harp

[TheCryptidman]

@Canadiangirl123453 Notice how the Harp defines itself more? It's supposed to be more like that.... And W00t Canada, eh?

[Canadiangirl123453]

@TheCryptidman Well I suppose you're right :D

[peanutbutterlovesme1]

@Canadiangirl123453 no the violin is there i hear it i played with it

[LadyHashiro]

I can sing it, too. ^^ My boyfriend loves me singing it.

[FullMetalHeart7]

@LadyHashiro brag....... my voice sucks...

[BeaSan95]

I made a cover of it! Piano and vocal. Thanks for the lyrics! Why didn't Vic sing the 'how can i expect to call you wrong' to?

[KunKosh]

Thanks for downloading! Now I can make a flute-cover version ;)

Русская версия лучше английской. =)

[feradraco]

this is simply beautiful ... perfectly expresses the position of the Elric brothers ... Ed seemed to sing ...

[natsuki963]

Hey thanks for the links! ^_^ I've been looking everywhere for them! I really apreciate it! I love it!

[Lavibi]

Thanks, I mastered singing this.

Wonder why do adults call anime a "cartoon"

And why do younger people read more anime than an average adult?

[SheenaMalfoy]

@Lavibi Because adults don't have the time.

[TheCeliance]

@Lavibi My Best friends dad reads more Manga than me and my average is around 4 volumes an hour.

[xavier8994]

if this is the original english version, then its sung by Vic Mignogna, the english voice actor for Ed

[Bleachie100]

can anyone get me the sheet music for this (guitar or piano I play both)? Such a beautiful song!

[kikyou90]

Thanks A LOT for the download link, I'll need it for a talent show and I didn't know where to look :D you made my night! Favorite and thumb up!

[MidnightDestiny04]

Would it be alright if I posted a video response using this karaoke, please? (since I already downloaded it.) ^.^;;

[BeastGirl7]

Thanx so much!

[MiSsShInNiGaMi13]

me and friend did a covr of this song. it sounded almost exaxctly lik the orignal, very pretty!!! :,( :D

my friend on violin (wy to go lorz!)

n me on harp and vocals

i luv this song so much it makes me cry!!!

[SakurasCorporation0]

GOSH!

I can't believe, that's beautiful!

[xXPandaTsubasaXx]

I love this song!!!! but...I can't sing....so I can't sing it even if I wanted to ;_;

[PurpleHillSeeker]

......this guys in everything, caught his voice in an episode of Devil May Cry, he was a demon XD

[harvestmooncute6]

@PurpleHillSeeker DMC rulz XD i caught that to

[PurpleHillSeeker]

yay!

[WeCosplayForFun]

mmkay very good

but its SHED our blood not SHARED

[AngelinTrainingx3]

...a bit fast, dontcha think? compared to the original

[Stanzapro83]

Ty so much for the mp3´s!<3

[XXBleedingrose]

Love this song soo much

[Kejoin95]

(☻) \ (☻)  _\ _____ Wow

[GeminiGal24]

omg i love this song. its soooo good, and soooo sad!!

[saynsoldier]

thanks for download link

this is a great video thank for the upload

[alisjdof]

I LOVE IT!!! and i love singing it :)

[SageNaru]

Thanks a lot for the download link!

^_^

[ghannis]

thanks for the links to download, i googled for a long time but its hard to find , thank you ^^

[alexlefou26]

tro émouvente cette music !!!

[airiaram]

thanks for the link downloads! ^_^

[sakuraharunovsino]

waaa...i am crying.....i love this song!!

[RossielleXiel]

wwaaaaaaaaaa, I'm gonna cry ToT , I love this song!

[sakuraharunovsino]

hey i commented the same thing as you did...lol....i didnt c it....

[RossielleXiel]

Hahahhaha we thought the same! xD

OMG this song is so beautiful, if could learn it in its original version: in Russian, it would be fantastic! but it's kind of difficult ToT

[sakuraharunovsino]

ya...it is so sad...and beautiful.....and i like eric...the older guy... i think he is cute

[RossielleXiel]

Eric? who's Eric?

[sakuraharunovsino]

i mean Elric

[RossielleXiel]

waaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhh me too!!! I think he's so cute!!! and strong!!! I love it, too!!! *¬*

[hotfored]

In FMA I think you mean Elric, Edward Elric? Is that what you meant?

[EighthHomunculus]

Al's second verse (the ones after the harp solo... the one that starts here with "How can I expect to call you wrong") is written wrong... in the English version (sung by Vic) isn't there... it's the solo ("Beuatiful mother...") then it continues as posted here. Were you using the direct translations from russian when you made this...?

[VickyStrawberry]

Please can you send it to me too?

I love this song and i try to sing it^^

[CombatSpecialist18]

There should be a list of download links in the video description. :)

[YoushiieElf]

Thank you so much for the download and making the karaoke version! Me and my sister are having tons of fun attempting to sing this! Your the best!!!!

[CombatSpecialist18]

Thanks ^_^

[Kejoin95]

can you send it to me too? along also separate with words?

[CombatSpecialist18]

sure

[themovieman247]

nono it's right

it's

"clinging to the past i shared our blood, and shattered your chance to live"

at least, that's how vic sings it

[EighthHomunculus]

no, if you listen closely when vic sings it, it's "shed our blood". Besides, "shared our blood and shattered your chance to live" doesn't make sense. Sharing blood doesn't kill people (usually); SHEDDING blood does.

[themovieman247]

yea but this song was written FOR fma

it follows along with the storyline

and i asked him

it's "shared"

[Gilesiskool]

if only you had audio for the voice, thatd be kinda better,but this is good too

[KHLovergirl13]

How can I download this version? D: I want to sing it!

[CombatSpecialist18]

I'll send it to you via You Tube message. ;)

[KHLovergirl13]

Thank you! <3

[Laiffi29]

How am I supposed to sing this when I'm crying all the time? T_T

The song and the anime is soooo beautiful...

[fairiegirl2992]

okay, this is where the anime stops being an anime and becomes something else. Oh my gosh. I love this show so much. I wish Ed and Al were real.

"To obtain, something of equal value must be lost." In short, Sacrifice, the one word that sums up FMA.

*Starts crying*

[animaegirllover]

i wish i could do this on my violin!!!

[mellowkid9090]

i gave the violin music to my friend and he played it for me

[unco2662]

this moves me to tears everytime i hear it.

FMA was more than just some anime to me.

[MewMizu13]

I just love this song! It's so sad.. TT TT

It

s really good in english, but it's best in it's original, russian! ^^

[1nickythenick]

every night, when i put them to bed, i would thank god for giving me two beautiful angels, i would promis them everynight that i would do anything for them...know, i find peace in this song, since it's just me know, i find this the only thing to bring me piece. nothing brings back what is gone, but helps to keep the memories...the emptyness echoeing in the backround of this heavenly tune, still echoes from my heart when i look at the photos or videos i used to take of them. i love u my babies...

[visiblechunk]

yo thx i needed the words to sing if any of u want to now were i singed go to facebook and look for phillip vladimir klochan

[FlowerEmblem]

To the person who posted up this vid:

Just so you know, I think 168712324 copied you a few months after you posted the video up ^^'' One of his videos is the exact same as this one - it even has the same typo DX

[CombatSpecialist18]

o rly?

[FlowerEmblem]

The instrumental and the lyrics are beautiful - thanks for putting it up ^^ I'd sing but I'm too busy listening to the pretty violin and the harp duet =D

[Evilhamster13]

beautiful song....

beautifu and sad anime.

[narutard11]

This is one of the most beautiful and sad songs I have ever heard...

[YukiNyoko]

when i first heard it, it was truely beautiful. However, i was payiing more attention to the anime instead ;-; i feel so ashamed! Such a beautiful song...T_T it touches the soul, really.

[nannynicklife]

like a child who cries in pain for a lack of words to explain their suffering, the violin lead is stronger then the words. so strong that like a blade it cuts my soul till i my soul bleeds. when i first heard this song playing in the backround of episode 8, kevin (4yr) was alseep in my arms and the song made want to hold him forever, afraid that i would loose him if i put him down. such a strong, sad, and deep sound.

[vivamexico254]

that was ....deep men it is a beutifull thing been a brother isnit mate even if you sister is the devil u knwo deeply in your heart that you will stand for er /him anyday he/she need u

[WariAyap]

you know, i tried to sing along..but i just can't..i end up crying like wuss as i sing..i guess i know how they both feel now...Fullmetal Alchemist was more than just an anime for me... it wasn't a cartoon..

[JOSHSNIFF]

you know, i felt the same way. the cartoon part anyhow. after i finished the series and watched the movie, i started reading the manga. i thought that it would be better than the anime, as this is the case with most manga and its anime counterparts. however, it it was not as good a the anime. something about it is just missing from it...

[aang4all]

@WariAyap I know this comment was two years ago, but I know how you feel... if any one DARE call Fullmetal Alchemist a cartoon, I get p.oed

[wolfsong3420]

You can get the song off of limewire or rocket...or the video with vic singing it with firefox and download helper add on. Beautiful

[t0ki0hoteln0rway]

What is the song really about ? <3

[CombatSpecialist18]

Remember when Ed wanted Alphonse to help him resurrect their mom? In this song, Ed wants to take the blame for turning their mom into a homunculi; not only that, but also losing Al's body. But Al tells him to stop and that it's BOTH their fault that they each lost something.

[TalesofMusica]

WHen does this song play in the show?

[CombatSpecialist18]

Throughout the whole series, usually when Ed and Al are contemplating on trying to resurrect their mom.

[TalesofMusica]

Anyone know where I can get this song for my iPod

[walklo99]

i have the russian version if you want it, send me a message ;)

[TyRyProductions]

Dude, can you upload the MP3 to mega-upload for me? I love this Song and I want it on my iPod!

[vegetarian106]

Thank you for giving the complete lyrics; the English version sung by Vic Mignogna is unfortunately missing a stanza.

[RIKUOFHEARTS]

if i can sing it in front of my school,everyone else can sing it!

[zeldarox11]

I couldnt sing this even if my life depended on it!

[KikumaruKaidoh]

can you send me the karaoke version and the english version? *_____* please!!!!

[CombatSpecialist18]

Sure.

[AnnaBella5789102]

could you send me it to please. i want to dothis for karoke night

[Malless3]

I like just hearing the music, but I'm not gona wimp out and not sing it. I will try! Eventually....

[HyperZxTole57]

scary but true if i sing it ...i sound sorta like ed lol. well i think i sound close to vic's voice but i have to sing it softly lol. idk..if i get it down enough i know im posting my attempt up ^^

[Malless3]

I sound kinda like him too. Well to an extent. I'd post my try, but I don't have a microphone.

[HyperZxTole57]

lawl good luck with it. i need a good program to record with lol...which means.. omg downloads.

[Slayerslover]

I sing at with the violin's level and i am a girl but i sound so good! I am a low singer can't go high!

[Todosaiji]

what key are you supposed to sing this in? I'm learnin it for my fiancee

[WoWRoX1]

i dont know exact key, but the violin that plays, is playing the notes that it is sung at.

[CombatSpecialist18]

I play it on the piano, and the sheet music tells you to play it at key of D minor. A lot of Russian songs are like that... I think.

[Sesshomaru4evr]

If Your a guy sing at the violin's level. If your a girl sing high.

[darkwolf287]

this song is sad and makes me cry cuz it relates to my life..

[blahhaha55]

tis song makes me sad and happy it reminds me of my life

[animegirl1190]

The first time i heard that song it made me cry :(

[funkykitten123]

there is one part of the song that does not exist! tell me what is up with that?!

[Sesshomaru4evr]

where?

[MrsCamui]

"How can I expect to call you wrong

How can I blame you for what I've done

We were both fools in other desires

As we flew to close to the sun"

That verse is in the Russian , the original, version but for some reason Vic left it out. I noticed it not to long ago too.

[batdiva101]

He forgot to put the part in. The girl who wrote the english translation told me. ^^

[slimey18]

Plus it's kinda hard to sing too. You need to get the exact timing.

[OhioAnimeCons]

the violin should help you out alot foro timing

[TsukabuNosoratori2]

I find it really does help when I sing it to have something to guide me like that.

[Natalock]

This song always makes me cry.

[135Pumpkin246]

neat

[Ragmesesis]

its not right in some parts sorry to say...

[CombatSpecialist18]

Yeah, I've noticed that weeks ago. I'll have to make a list of all the typos in the video description; but I don't think there are that many.

[RachiruJakotsu]

yeah, it is wrong is some parts, but it's the best way to match the english rhythm to the russian. besides, it all makes sense anyways.

[ProdigyAngel]

I really love this song, and it's nice to have the lyrics handy. Is there anyone who knows where a good quality MP3 of this song lies?

[CombatSpecialist18]

ProdigyAngel, I downloaded this song for free at Gendou[dot]com. Just create an account.

[ProdigyAngel]

Thank you very much

[Legault397]

Hey by the way, does anyone know where I can get the sheet music?

[Legault397]

thank you for this. It is a great song and having the lyrics readily available is huge.

[darklady5]

thx 4 the upload now i can totally do the duet with my friend (Piano+Flute) while i sing for the talent show at the end of the year *sighs inrelief* my hero!

[SonicGameFan]

Hm.... The infamous missing lyric from Vic's version... It flows perfectly this way:

How can I expect to call you wrong?

How can I blame you for what I've done?

We both let our stupid, childish dreams

Fly us too close to the sun.

The only differences, too, are minimal; it's calling the "desire" a "dream" which I think actually sounds more dramatic, and it ends up calling the dream stupid, not them themselves, which also seems more like Al would say....

What do you think? ^^

[pickleband]

Actually, what I read was the second verse (neither you nor I are free from blame) was supposedly from Al's POV...Why they couldn't get whats-his-face to accompany Vic on this is beyond me.

[kotakotsu]

vic asked arron but he said he doesnt sing whitch suxz T.T

[arijanian]

Thanks for the lyrics patch! It's very close. Actually, the original lyrics for that verse are:

How could I expect to call you wrong?

How could you be blamed for what we've done?

Both of us were fools in our desires

As we flew too close to the sun

Vic's version forgot them somehow. It's still beautiful, though, isn't it?

-Tobu Ishi, original lyricist of this English version of "Brothers"

[Sakura713713]

thanx 4 this vid!!!!!

[Wateria88]

I thought there was a verse missing. I use to hum the lyrics that Vic had used to the russian one and it didn't make sense cause it didn't fit in that one spot. Thanks for the psoting!! That makes a lot more since.

Wonder if Vic knows about the missing lyrics. It's funny that he never intended on it going anywhere, but it got spread all over the place, and he was just having fun like all of us fans :)

[arijanian]

He knows. It was an accident, but it's still a lovely version, isn't it?

The full lyrics are on my deviantART account, "TobuIshi".

[RachiruJakotsu]

yours are just the same as his......

[StarlightXKira]

thank you!!

[0KenTexanChik]

Thank you!!

I have to do a project concerning making your own song based off of a existing one, and this will DEFINATELY help! *hugs to death*

[catkid1233]

were can i download the music?

[nekospirit]

gendou dot com but you have to register to download. Just search for Brothers and there should be a violin version of it or a karaoke...

[catkid1233]

thanx! :D

[KazekageGaara15]

or it also comes in soundtrack #2 and #3

[xXSxyDemonessXx]

omg, umm, quick question, the file on filefront, is it the music only or the whole video itself? AWESOME btw!!!

[CombatSpecialist18]

It's the video itself.

[kurobarakyomu]

dude u rock, thank you so much! n_n

[Toyomo16]

This is pretty good, but I think there are a few problems with the rhythms in this version. "Alas it was not meant to be" should really be "Alas 'twas..." And the line at 2:27 sound grammatically and rhythmically better as "flew us to close to the sun."

[keeeeeeeeeelly]

It is so.... amazing......

I prefer the russian version, but the instrumental version is so beautiful....

;_; Thanks!!!

[samouraigirl74]

well those kinda videos are pretty useful but one thing i wasn't sure about is the verse that ends with somethin' like 'too close from the sun' i didn't even know it was existing cuz i got a version without this whole verse...

[KayzarIrish]

thanks for uploading this. i might upload a shitty AMV of me singing this so crapely. ^^

[xXanimexfanxgirlxX]

YES!! Thnxn so much for uploading this, I was looking all over for a version with out singing! (going 2 sing it at talent show, maybe) UR THE BEST!

i hav vic singin the whole song but its not the same. i w