if you know anything about music, stop comparing her with tarja, the classical singer who sings this song with her head voice. annette sings it with her chest voice which needs much more power and is very very exhausting
ESTA COMPADRE LA CAGARON CON CAMBIAR A LA GRAN TARJA YO CACHO QUE SE ARREPIENTE TODAVIA .... ES QUE NO PODI HACER ESE TIPO DE CAMBIO ESTA NUEVA VOCALISTA DE DONDE LA SACARON NO PODI CAMBIAR UNA VOCALISTA LIRICA POR UNA POPERA DE POP.... SI LA POBRE CON SUERTE CANTA LAS CANCIONES
I do respect her efforts to try to fit the old NW's songs. Her voice sounds good in Sacrament of Wilderness. But not this song. She makes me feel like NW now is a Nightmare.
Dios mio de verdad quien le dijo a esta mujer que funcionaba para el metal??
Intente darle un voto de confianza pero en esta cancion y en the siren me dejo con la sangre helada de lo mal que se escuchan letras escritas para tarja en su voz, , me gustaria que de verdad pudiera lucirce un poco ya no cantando lo anterior de este grupo tan genial si no con algo nuevo y presiso para su timbre de voz ya que no es soprano y viene del pop
@a11retro JAJAJAJA MAS TROLES.... MALDITA SEA ELLA SE ESCUCHA MUY BIEN, SU ACTITUD Y TODA ELLA LA HACEN APTA PARA EL METAL.. ADEMAS QUIEN LE DIJO A TARJA QUE SERVIA PARA COMPONER CANCIONES... PERO EN FIN SU VOZ NO ES PARA EL POP...SU VOZ VIENE DE UNA BANDA DE ROCK.... Y YA ES OVBIO QUE NO ES SOPRANO
@NwDevotion Para poder criticar comentarios hace falta leer de una manera critica, las dos son buenas pero al menos deberian darle a anette la oportunidad de vivir sin el fantasma de otro toque al cantar y lucir en el escenario, acaso nunca escucharon ever dream con ella??
Los gallos a causa de cubrir los tonos de la ex vocalista hicieron ver que la señora la paso mal en ese mometo; con el tiempo fue mejorando y su propia version de esa cancion para mi es muy respetable.
@NwDevotion Tampoco es muy grato que se desmerite el trabajo de la señora Tarja cada uno hace lo mejor en su trabajo, a imi me gustaria ver a olzon con canciones a partir del darck passion play en las cuales de verdad respeto su trabajo, de tarja no estoy muy a gusto, pero el trabajo que ha hecho con scorpions y diversas personalidades del mundo musical han quedado muy bien.
Y la voz no viene de una banda de rock la voz viene de muchos años de estudio de la opera
@NwDevotion como se ve ke eres un estúpido fanboy... POR DIOS! creo ke ahora escuchas nightwish por anette y se nota aleguas que la sigues desde ke empezó su carrera, peor x ke no comparas anda yo se ke kieres compara esta grandiosa canción con tarja y con anette y VERÁS LA GRAN DIFERENCIA y ahm por lo de trol... TU ERES EL PUTO TROL...
the register of the songs isnt for Anette, i insist, if that the band has to change the music, with tarja they sound more epic with the same backward and anette's voice they sound like Karaoike, she is trying, but indeed they should change all the band concept in order to make the new "nightwish" work out. They are gret musicians, Thomas wrote all the "tarja song's" as people said, so they can write great music, just changing the focus its everything gonna be awesome with Anette voice.
stfu with tarja at last!!! you're anoying....anette's IN tarja's OUT.....if you like tarja...she has solo career...anette's better....and all of us who think this way should be here posting comments and everything....none of us want's your crappy comments.....i respect tarja as a singer...but she's out the band.....and face it!
Anette is a pop singer, not a metal singer. Tuomas should just write new songs for her alone, not make her embarrass herself singing what was made for Tarja. She just CAN'T pull it off without making all the heavy metal fans puke.
when anette sings it, you can actually hear which words is sung...! X3 Tarja does a better job on 'Tarja-songs' though. Anette should stay with amaranth, and those DPP songs!
@deswar7 I think that too. And I would say that the people should support Anette. Ok Tarja was great, is great, but it´s over. Tarja will never come back. And I´m happy that they do now another album. Nightwish was great, is great.
Olzonka to mogłaby smerfne hity śpiewać,a nie taką piosenkę.Przecież ona ten utwór tak masakruje,że aż przykro tego słuchać To brzmi jak jakiś żart . Nieudacznicy z idola, ku uciesze Wojewódzkiego zresztą nie tylko nie tylko:), tak śpiewają. Klapa na całej linii.
To be honest, Tarja bored me with many songs. This one included. In my opinion, these songs fit a more cleaner style. You can hear Anette struggling here but she's gotten better. Tarja fits more operatic songs like Passion and The Opera
Annette isnt bad at there new stuff but she CAN NOT sound like tarja hence do not try to sing any songs like this..or anything that takes even a bit of opera sounding vocals...I do like amaranth though.
not nightwish without tarja? well tuomas writes the songs so its still nightwish, i think dark passion play album is amazing but i do miss tarja alot. tbh i feel sorry for any1 who had to replace tarja.
Tarja Turunen's fans. Honestly, I never seen a fanbase that bitches more than her fans. Don't get me wrong, i like Tarja and I've met a couple who are extremely cool and are understanding but the majority I've encountered are big cry babies. Honestly it's been 5 years and they are still complaining. Compare to say when Rob Halford left Judas Priest, no one threatened Tim Ripper Owens life. It was "hey he isn't bad" or "meh." Some even gave him his credit.
i think that anette should stick to her songs because shes good just she cant compare to tarjas voice on songs that were written with tarja singing them in mind
yo me pregunto ¿como hizo annete para que no la abuchearan en wacken? yo pense que al final del video el publico iba a tirarle cosas por cagarse en la cancion
mae annete hay que admitirlo ella es buena cantante pero nightwish se vendio cuando llego ella
pero annete no tiene voz para el nightwish viejo la verdad es que esta canción es buenisima pero la cago no tiene voz para cantar las canciones viejas y yo estoy seguro de que ahorita hacen como arch enemy y sacan un disco con las canciones viejas con la nueva vocalista
y va a ser la porqueria mas grande de la historia
OMG that cant be like that Annete cand be the singer of Nightwish. Tarja and her angel voice made those songs wonderfull. Please Tarja come back and save this band :( :(
al leer todos los comentarios apoyo a aquellos q siguen a la gran tarja turunen mientras otros se empeñan en decir q paren de comparar las voces pero es algo q da pena y corage al ver q con tarja nightwish era fuerza e inspiraba a seguir escuchando una y tora vez los discos hasta en ONCE pero al escuchar el dark passion play y este concierto me decepciono de ellos q alguan vez fueron mis idolos ahora veo q se vendieron al comercio musical, que pena
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I think the band should be devoted to singing the songs of "their new era" ... anette no good to sing songs from "the tally was" ... anette is good with the new songs ... if I listen to these songs I'd rather listen to my cds .... how good was that lacanze to see them live tarja ... that never come with anette
I love Nightwish no matter if tarja or anette is singing BUT i just listend to tarja singing it and the i listened to this version and tarja's singing makes this look bad
wtf is up with all this Tarja vs. Anette face it ppl Tarja is now solo and anette is here they are both amazing yes there style are diff but they still rock and and besides you dont like her? quit commenting and watch Tarjas vids!!!
I like her more and more... everytime i hear her singing "tarja's songs" i think... tarja sits at a pc and looks a nightwish video and thinks: "Oh shit... she can sing it, too!"
You're right. ;) I can understand that the old fans want Tarja back but it doesn't help screaming:: 'Anette sucks! We want Tarja! (Or the athoer way round)!
All these people saying "tarja was the true nightwish" is reallly insulting to the guys! They write the freaking music after all, and are all totaly badass! :P
Then go, and listen to her, and don't blame Anette, bacause the boys chose her, to sing with them...so if you blame Anette, you blame the boys, so you blame the Nightwish...that's all...
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Voi jumalauta se hephepittää tänkin biisin! D: I HATE HER SOOOOOOO MUCH. And her voice. And.. and.. That, uh, what is it, singing? No, that... howling. Screaming, whatever.
Tarja songs? I only know Nightwusg songs, as far as i know, Tarja does not own any of the songs from Nightwish and neither does Anette, so isn't it up too Nightwish who sings what?
anette is making money to because is her job but she loves nightwish and all the band is very happy with anette, and dont talk about stuffs that you dont have any idea, anette was picked between 2000 singers this is not lucky and she also have a carrrer is different that she wasnt very famous, and if the first singer is fired what do you think that a band have to do???, just pick a new singer IDIOT is OBVIOUS, tarja was fired because she was a diva
Mira pequeño... en primera no estamos hablando de las "aptitudes" vocales de ninguna de las dos OK?
estamos hablando de que algunos estan diciendo que a Tarja la corrieron porque "amaba el dinero" solo basandose en el hecho de que ella no queria tocar en lugares pequeños, pero eso es porque para un cantante , por bueno que sea, es muy perjudicial sobretrabajar la voz. Es mejor tocar de 1 vez frente a mil personas que 10 veces frente a 100... ejemplo? mira a anette. cada vez suena mas cansada
And what about Tarja's luck? Tarja wasn't lucky? If she wouldn't be the classmate of Tuomas, Tarja wouldn't know nothing about the Nightwish...
Anyway, if Tarja wouldn't join the Nightwish 13 ago, she would be an unkonown opera singer in a little opera house in Finland, wouldn't she? And if Anette would't decide to try to join the band, she would be famous either, because she was a member of a band, and she sang duets, ect...
Tarja didn't work hard to get famous. She onöy singed in nightwish. Male members of the band made music and othe stuff. Tarja only singed. Without nightwish, Tarja would be maybe unknown classical singer, and good. But not famous.
In a band like NW a singer can ruin her/his voice very fast. They want to performe very soon in many concerts for a long time and with a loud sound.
Besides, many years ago, they interviewed Tarja and she said that it was very difficult that the guys enjoy drinking and smoking and Smoke is really BAD for voice and she couldnt be with them for a long time because of that.
she asked them to play less often in bigger places with more people to avoid ruining her voicenot for themoney
Annette rocks, so everyone that thinks otherwise should just shut up and go cry to Tarja's record istead of whining about stuff you can't do smt about ANYWAY!
Personally, I think Annette totally rocked that performance. I mean, I thought she'd have to strain her voice to reach some of Tarja's notes, but she improvised and it sounded great.
I love Nightwish, I wish they could unite.. Tuomas makes the music, its all about his visions, he doesnt bend when it comes to his visions and lyrics.
Everybody needs to shut it. Anette is here to stay, and your crying about it like bitches isn't going to change anything. If you were a real fan, you'd respect Nightwish's descion. You don't have to listen to them if you don't like it. Deal with it.
believe it or not, these comment boxes are here for people to voice their opinions, and it seems real nightwish fans respect Tarjas voice more than they respect their decision, because Tarja was the voice of Nightwish, put simply, Anette cant sing Tarjas songs!
Indeed. And I voiced mine, and you voiced yours. Wow! What a concept. Tarja was a voice. Did you know she's making music that's actually very beautiful? So if you liked Tarja, go listen to her and quit complaining like a bitch on Nightwish music. They work damn hard to make you happy. And besides, let me see you try to do that in front of at least a thousand people. Let me know when YOU get up on stage and try to please countless fans and clear non-fans. Then you'll know how it feels.
fuck, you just a moody little cunt! Iv heard Tarjas music, but it just sucks that Tarja wont be playing anymore nightwish songs, personally, i think Nightwish should have reformed to a new band, i dont think its fair that anette has to sing Nightwish songs, it leaves her open to a lot of criticism
HAHAHA! AH HA. You ran out of comebacks. Anyway, we need to stop spamming the video with shameless and/or degrading bitching at one another. It makes me look like a crazed bitch. (Which I probably am, but aren't we all in a way? Hahaha.) Love the opinion, and it ain't really a bad one. Well, be seeing you around.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
she is too POP.... I´ve tried to find the metal element from Anettes vocal style... but it´s time to face the fact.....there is none. No more headbanging either.
hay anette tienes una voz muy bonita pero como crees de que tu viniendo de cantor algo como un hard rock vas a dar la talla en una banda de metal gotico
To be honest, this sounds like a good Nightwish tribute band.
cuttlefisch 3 months ago
The Drumer is the best...he's really great!
emes1982 4 months ago
if you know anything about music, stop comparing her with tarja, the classical singer who sings this song with her head voice. annette sings it with her chest voice which needs much more power and is very very exhausting
philemall 5 months ago
@MrWankata You mean without sucking?
Iasonasf 6 months ago
I jus LOVE the new spirit Annette has brought to the band! ¡¡¡VIVA ANNETTE!!! :D
icabreracederwall 7 months ago
ESTA COMPADRE LA CAGARON CON CAMBIAR A LA GRAN TARJA YO CACHO QUE SE ARREPIENTE TODAVIA .... ES QUE NO PODI HACER ESE TIPO DE CAMBIO ESTA NUEVA VOCALISTA DE DONDE LA SACARON NO PODI CAMBIAR UNA VOCALISTA LIRICA POR UNA POPERA DE POP.... SI LA POBRE CON SUERTE CANTA LAS CANCIONES
rodrigoguitar69 9 months ago
Anette sings fantastic on this one.
reindeerride 10 months ago 4
I do respect her efforts to try to fit the old NW's songs. Her voice sounds good in Sacrament of Wilderness. But not this song. She makes me feel like NW now is a Nightmare.
ShretteMarte 10 months ago
Dios mio de verdad quien le dijo a esta mujer que funcionaba para el metal??
Intente darle un voto de confianza pero en esta cancion y en the siren me dejo con la sangre helada de lo mal que se escuchan letras escritas para tarja en su voz, , me gustaria que de verdad pudiera lucirce un poco ya no cantando lo anterior de este grupo tan genial si no con algo nuevo y presiso para su timbre de voz ya que no es soprano y viene del pop
a11retro 10 months ago
@a11retro JAJAJAJA MAS TROLES.... MALDITA SEA ELLA SE ESCUCHA MUY BIEN, SU ACTITUD Y TODA ELLA LA HACEN APTA PARA EL METAL.. ADEMAS QUIEN LE DIJO A TARJA QUE SERVIA PARA COMPONER CANCIONES... PERO EN FIN SU VOZ NO ES PARA EL POP...SU VOZ VIENE DE UNA BANDA DE ROCK.... Y YA ES OVBIO QUE NO ES SOPRANO
NwDevotion 10 months ago
@NwDevotion Para poder criticar comentarios hace falta leer de una manera critica, las dos son buenas pero al menos deberian darle a anette la oportunidad de vivir sin el fantasma de otro toque al cantar y lucir en el escenario, acaso nunca escucharon ever dream con ella??
Los gallos a causa de cubrir los tonos de la ex vocalista hicieron ver que la señora la paso mal en ese mometo; con el tiempo fue mejorando y su propia version de esa cancion para mi es muy respetable.
a11retro 10 months ago
@NwDevotion Tampoco es muy grato que se desmerite el trabajo de la señora Tarja cada uno hace lo mejor en su trabajo, a imi me gustaria ver a olzon con canciones a partir del darck passion play en las cuales de verdad respeto su trabajo, de tarja no estoy muy a gusto, pero el trabajo que ha hecho con scorpions y diversas personalidades del mundo musical han quedado muy bien.
Y la voz no viene de una banda de rock la voz viene de muchos años de estudio de la opera
a11retro 10 months ago
@NwDevotion como se ve ke eres un estúpido fanboy... POR DIOS! creo ke ahora escuchas nightwish por anette y se nota aleguas que la sigues desde ke empezó su carrera, peor x ke no comparas anda yo se ke kieres compara esta grandiosa canción con tarja y con anette y VERÁS LA GRAN DIFERENCIA y ahm por lo de trol... TU ERES EL PUTO TROL...
ReisenHaizen 10 months ago
@ReisenHaizen PUTA MADRE DE QUE EXISTE UNA GRAAAAN DIFERENCIA, ESO ES OBVIO NOO??
PERO NO ENTIENDO POR QUE DICEN QUE SU VOZ VIENE DEL POP, CUANDO ES OBVIO QUE NO
Y PARA TU INFORMACION A ANETTE NO LA CONOCIA HASTA QUE ENTRO A NW♥
Y AQUI EL TROL ERES TU, POR QUE SI NO T GUSTA ANETTE PARA QUE MIERDAS VES VIDEOS DE ELLA ??? PINCHE TROL MEJOR VETE A VER A TARJA
NwDevotion 9 months ago
Dudes right man, After Tarja left Marco has up his singing 10 fold. He was alright in the Tarja era but in the Anette era he is just epic singer
Ross175 10 months ago
the register of the songs isnt for Anette, i insist, if that the band has to change the music, with tarja they sound more epic with the same backward and anette's voice they sound like Karaoike, she is trying, but indeed they should change all the band concept in order to make the new "nightwish" work out. They are gret musicians, Thomas wrote all the "tarja song's" as people said, so they can write great music, just changing the focus its everything gonna be awesome with Anette voice.
julianaariza84 1 year ago
Una vez que la escuchamos con Tarja esto parece como karaoke :-x.
nyx020419 1 year ago
WHY!?!?!?!? :O
Aaga223 1 year ago
tarja is nightwish
anette is pop...
supereend666 1 year ago
@supereend666 TROLL
NwDevotion 10 months ago
wtf????
Anette... stop to scream!!!
eze22bv 1 year ago
horrible
quaikero 1 year ago
stfu with tarja at last!!! you're anoying....anette's IN tarja's OUT.....if you like tarja...she has solo career...anette's better....and all of us who think this way should be here posting comments and everything....none of us want's your crappy comments.....i respect tarja as a singer...but she's out the band.....and face it!
MrTenisMaster 1 year ago
I think that this song Anette sing very well, also she very fervent)
AlexxSmog 1 year ago
Wow! She almost can sing! :D. She screams very baaaaaaaaddd! :((:((.
skumpik666 1 year ago
seriously, that outfit and that glove? that ain't working...
Veparrr 1 year ago
Anette is a pop singer, not a metal singer. Tuomas should just write new songs for her alone, not make her embarrass herself singing what was made for Tarja. She just CAN'T pull it off without making all the heavy metal fans puke.
TheOodGuild 1 year ago
@TheOodGuild Most of us aren't puking though...
BrandonHarami 1 year ago
if im annette..it will be better if she make her own songs..in order for her not to be compared with tarja...
wardenec 1 year ago
poor annette, it looks good and sings pretty nice but, those songs she performed at wacken doesnt sound good
Theabsbot 1 year ago
on my opinion anette is doing a great job but in this song in particular I miss tarja's voice!
MarsTerrible 1 year ago
Omg I love how she smiles at almost the end of the vid with that flying to a dream part
Anette rocks! \m/
catweazeltje 1 year ago 3
when anette sings it, you can actually hear which words is sung...! X3 Tarja does a better job on 'Tarja-songs' though. Anette should stay with amaranth, and those DPP songs!
SilverSong1234 1 year ago 4
she looks like shes really enjoying singing this
kavyaanshrike 1 year ago 4
i wonder how a combination of Tarja and Annette sound....lets campaign for them both to be the vocalist ;P
XodusOnan 1 year ago
@XodusOnan but you'd never hear Annette because Tarja's voice is just so much stronger
TheOodGuild 1 year ago
Not Bad.
Anette is not better than tarja but anette ist very good:D
deswar7 1 year ago 2
@deswar7 I think that too. And I would say that the people should support Anette. Ok Tarja was great, is great, but it´s over. Tarja will never come back. And I´m happy that they do now another album. Nightwish was great, is great.
ScorpeX1992 1 year ago 2
muy bien nightwish! arruinaste otra cancion! sigan asi... poco les queda de vida
MauroMaegael 1 year ago
my god poor anette too much song too her! i'm sorry guys! NW is not gothic metal anymore
uzumakiarual 1 year ago 2
@uzumakiarual for me only instruments sounds good. and i always lauging from this '(hemp hemp hemp, hemp ) anette rocks hemp hemp /m\
mmaattii777799 1 year ago 2
@mmaattii777799 \m/ ok!!! and anette is good not rocks!! pops maybe! =D
uzumakiarual 1 year ago
great! She's good like tarja - great song, great voice! Do it again anette!
schnitzerfelix 1 year ago
Tarja and Anette are both beautiful and they can both sing. There's no contest
BloodyRose150 1 year ago 2
she getting better... :)
n14joe 1 year ago 4
oww... So bad Tarja is left... She was so much better than she...
aikom10m 1 year ago
Olzonka to mogłaby smerfne hity śpiewać,a nie taką piosenkę.Przecież ona ten utwór tak masakruje,że aż przykro tego słuchać To brzmi jak jakiś żart . Nieudacznicy z idola, ku uciesze Wojewódzkiego zresztą nie tylko nie tylko:), tak śpiewają. Klapa na całej linii.
ZIPANC 1 year ago
To be honest, Tarja bored me with many songs. This one included. In my opinion, these songs fit a more cleaner style. You can hear Anette struggling here but she's gotten better. Tarja fits more operatic songs like Passion and The Opera
ComaLies225 2 years ago 5
Emppu ROCKED this song! Especially the opening riff sounds amazing on this video, even better than on End of an Era!
luckyluke193 2 years ago 5
Annette isnt bad at there new stuff but she CAN NOT sound like tarja hence do not try to sing any songs like this..or anything that takes even a bit of opera sounding vocals...I do like amaranth though.
Rebel12guagez 2 years ago 2
nightwish without tarja are good but with tarja are amazing !!!
xXxnightwish1992xXx 2 years ago 4
@xXxnightwish1992xXx : agreeeeeeeeeeeeeee
n14joe 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
annette..sucks. wtf ,nightwish without tarja is not nightwish
Knochensplitter 2 years ago
not nightwish without tarja? well tuomas writes the songs so its still nightwish, i think dark passion play album is amazing but i do miss tarja alot. tbh i feel sorry for any1 who had to replace tarja.
megamaidensabbath 2 years ago 17
"tbh i feel sorry for any1 who had to replace tarja."
Yeah because all her shitty fans on youtube seem to bitch more than anyone else in the metal genre.
Other than that, I agree with the rest of your post. BTW, Megadeth, Iron Maiden, and Black Sabbath fucking rock. Good taste you have :)
ComaLies225 2 years ago 4
Sorry whos shitty fans? Hell yeah! those bands are the best dude \m/ in my opinion. UP THE IRONS!
megamaidensabbath 1 year ago 2
Tarja Turunen's fans. Honestly, I never seen a fanbase that bitches more than her fans. Don't get me wrong, i like Tarja and I've met a couple who are extremely cool and are understanding but the majority I've encountered are big cry babies. Honestly it's been 5 years and they are still complaining. Compare to say when Rob Halford left Judas Priest, no one threatened Tim Ripper Owens life. It was "hey he isn't bad" or "meh." Some even gave him his credit.
ComaLies225 1 year ago 2
I even got harassed by two dingbats only because I said her album was a disappointment Apparently having an opinion was a little hurtful.
ComaLies225 1 year ago
@ComaLies225 Well, people are still bitchin on the Tarja and Anette thing.
BloodyRose150 1 year ago
@BloodyRose150 hahaha! nightwish is still awesome with or without tarja, it's about toumas!
hslee89 1 year ago
I must say......not bad for a live performance on singing. Sang a Tarja song using her own style of singing, which sounded pretty good to me.
TheGuitarFreak22 2 years ago 2
i think that anette should stick to her songs because shes good just she cant compare to tarjas voice on songs that were written with tarja singing them in mind
grimreaper11114 2 years ago
yo me pregunto ¿como hizo annete para que no la abuchearan en wacken? yo pense que al final del video el publico iba a tirarle cosas por cagarse en la cancion
darkwarrior1194 2 years ago
mae annete hay que admitirlo ella es buena cantante pero nightwish se vendio cuando llego ella
pero annete no tiene voz para el nightwish viejo la verdad es que esta canción es buenisima pero la cago no tiene voz para cantar las canciones viejas y yo estoy seguro de que ahorita hacen como arch enemy y sacan un disco con las canciones viejas con la nueva vocalista
y va a ser la porqueria mas grande de la historia
darkwarrior1194 2 years ago
WTF! She can't replace Tarja, its like Ripper Owens replacing Matt Barlow, you just can't fucking do it.
CrimsonApron 2 years ago 3
Definitivamente Viva tarja turunen carajooo! :D
dannyramms 2 years ago
OMG that cant be like that Annete cand be the singer of Nightwish. Tarja and her angel voice made those songs wonderfull. Please Tarja come back and save this band :( :(
basedrum1000 2 years ago
I agree with you!!
The Tarja has the most beautiful voice of this world! Lord Have Mercy on us! the Anette is awful!
And also the Emppu who is the most beautiful of the band, they do not show!
mariachystine 2 years ago
Totally agree.!
MissyFan80 2 years ago
Annete screams singing this song and some other songs that Tarja did such a great job singing them. Sleeping Sun and Nemo Tarja sing them great!
fantasyminas 2 years ago
al leer todos los comentarios apoyo a aquellos q siguen a la gran tarja turunen mientras otros se empeñan en decir q paren de comparar las voces pero es algo q da pena y corage al ver q con tarja nightwish era fuerza e inspiraba a seguir escuchando una y tora vez los discos hasta en ONCE pero al escuchar el dark passion play y este concierto me decepciono de ellos q alguan vez fueron mis idolos ahora veo q se vendieron al comercio musical, que pena
TheMetalChains 2 years ago 2
nada que ver con la diva
la vos mas hermosa
tarja
que lastima que ya no estes
alejandra123aguidiax 2 years ago 4
Que porqueria!! perdio toda su energia la canción con esa entrada de Annete. Casi me duermo. Fue inevitable el bostezo
losmonjes 2 years ago 2
much horrible...
kremastanera 2 years ago
hep hep! :D
if you guys don't compare and just evaluate anette herself you'll see that she sounds good too in the old songs.
hep hep!
darkis1201 2 years ago
hey, i think they forgot to run the orchestra track, all i hear is tuomas' keyboard
sabianrox1 2 years ago
i don´t like annette...
her voice is not good enough for this kind of music =(
666hermannski 2 years ago
can't you just stop discussing who's the better one? Since the change there is only this discussion and there must have been said all about!!
SinfulEarth 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I think the band should be devoted to singing the songs of "their new era" ... anette no good to sing songs from "the tally was" ... anette is good with the new songs ... if I listen to these songs I'd rather listen to my cds .... how good was that lacanze to see them live tarja ... that never come with anette
AlexanderMetal2009 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Anette looks like my really old 2nd grade teacher.... I hated her.
myaccpwnsurs 2 years ago
your right. Anette sings not bad, but i think, that Tarja sings the old songs much better.
Donutnoe 2 years ago 5
I love Nightwish no matter if tarja or anette is singing BUT i just listend to tarja singing it and the i listened to this version and tarja's singing makes this look bad
Ferikj 2 years ago 7
Let's put aside the Tarja/Annette debate for a moment.
Nightwish's light show is just getting better and better is it not?
SuicidePinguin 2 years ago 24
More lightshow and more pyro ftw ^^
JeshAndStuff 2 years ago 3
This is good... I would say sometimes even better than Tarja...
ignorence8 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
She is even worse than the old one.She has much more flaws that the other one and the same bad attitude.....
miryalice 2 years ago
nice
TheSergantwarhead 2 years ago
she sounds just like James LaBrie live, ha,ha,ha!!!!
zalebb 2 years ago
Anette und Tarja waren/sind auf ihre Art und Weise gut und ein Teil von Nightwish.
Ich glaube wenn die Trennung von Tarja anders verlaufen wäre würde der ganze Tarja vs Anette-Terz garnet stattfinden.
Aneete ist jetzt und damit Ende der Diskussion!!
6574893 2 years ago
I agree! :)
Iormugand 2 years ago
go anette!!!
mukundalonso 2 years ago 3
wtf is up with all this Tarja vs. Anette face it ppl Tarja is now solo and anette is here they are both amazing yes there style are diff but they still rock and and besides you dont like her? quit commenting and watch Tarjas vids!!!
TheApoctylipticAngel 2 years ago 6
Love the way she struts in on this'n. :)
BumblerootBumblefoot 2 years ago 2
I like her more and more... everytime i hear her singing "tarja's songs" i think... tarja sits at a pc and looks a nightwish video and thinks: "Oh shit... she can sing it, too!"
GO ANETTE GOOOOOO
ToastOfFear 2 years ago 54
:D:D:D
Iormugand 2 years ago
@ToastOfFear hahahahaha beauti comment!
uzumakiarual 1 year ago
@ToastOfFear Das Mag ich bezweifeln ..... Weil Tarja keine Angst haben sie kann diese Lieder einfach besser Singen... :)
Tarja > All
TheElefanti 1 year ago
@TheElefanti Stimmt ... aber Anette kanns gut vertreten ;D
ToastOfFear 1 year ago 2
Anett lixoo
christiancearamor 2 years ago
AsserKortteenniemi, i agree. You're right.
ironheaven 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she is pretty beautiful
but her voice...
albernozes 2 years ago
I think this Tarja Vs. Anette crap sucks.
It's all about Marco :D
BrandonHarami 2 years ago 61
@BrandonHarami
You're right. ;) I can understand that the old fans want Tarja back but it doesn't help screaming:: 'Anette sucks! We want Tarja! (Or the athoer way round)!
Please, stop discussing!
idiotenskater 1 year ago
@BrandonHarami
AND Tuomas :D
SuchBrokenx3 1 year ago
@SuchBrokenx3 of course!
BrandonHarami 1 year ago
@BrandonHarami lol geil :D:D:D:D
Plunkx 1 year ago
@BrandonHarami TOOO TRUE!
All these people saying "tarja was the true nightwish" is reallly insulting to the guys! They write the freaking music after all, and are all totaly badass! :P
WatcherOnTheWall 1 year ago 2
@BrandonHarami fuck yes! THANK YOU BRO!
deadtotheworld00 1 year ago
Annete is a great singer and shes very sexy and Beautiful
akaboo69 2 years ago 18
Why's it every Nightwish video from now on has the "Tarja vs. Anette" crap discussion?
Honestly, Anette isn't as bad as people are saying! She's improving and those Wacken Open Air Live show proves that she could run with the band.
The versions are different but not bad!
simonitro 2 years ago 18
yeah I agree its just like the Ozzy vs Dio crap people do in sabbath
akaboo69 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WE WANT TARJA!!!
epicmetalkong 2 years ago
YOU want Tarja...
MetalJanka92 2 years ago 2
FUCK!
epicmetalkong 2 years ago
Me TOO
ClaudiaDenise 2 years ago
Then go, and listen to her, and don't blame Anette, bacause the boys chose her, to sing with them...so if you blame Anette, you blame the boys, so you blame the Nightwish...that's all...
MetalJanka92 2 years ago 2
I dont really listen to a band for the people in it
I listen to a band for the good sound they have
and if they lose that of course that people who good taste in music wont like it
so im not an Annette fanatic like many of you
but im not Tarja's either... i just wanted to make a point
because everybody are telling that Tarja's a bitch etc etc and you dont even know
of course this new woman is thinking in money too!!! she left her little band for free? of course no
ClaudiaDenise 2 years ago
people with a good taste in music*
ClaudiaDenise 2 years ago
I dont love the guys
I dont love them like you do
because I dont know these people in their real lives and personalities
im not a FANATIC
i used to love their music so much
and respected them as muscicians
and honestly i dont come here to listen to anette just because "i like her personality" or "dont like her personality"
i came to listen to this version because i wanted to give it a chance and they said this one was her best performance
and if it is... i dont like it
my opinion
ClaudiaDenise 2 years ago
Fuck you.
to the down guy
Lusomaster 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Oh HELL NOOOOO!!!! Burn in Hell Anette, if it exists!!!!!
KillTheSonsOfPlunder 2 years ago
right!! the dark passion songs are perfect with anette, some of the old ones, too(see everdream for ex.) but this one... nono
hardy1001gs 2 years ago
Comment removed
florynj 2 years ago
Hep, hep?
hehe
Try Googling "hep hep riots."
kurackurackurac 2 years ago
I love this so much.
She is awesome.
I played this over and over.
I got goosepimples from hearing this!
xx
AmandaTheMCRFAN 2 years ago 6
Why do people upload live videos? there such made quailty
coreyshadow 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Voi jumalauta se hephepittää tänkin biisin! D: I HATE HER SOOOOOOO MUCH. And her voice. And.. and.. That, uh, what is it, singing? No, that... howling. Screaming, whatever.
Spiny0808 2 years ago
This song is much better with Tarja IMO, but anette is trying her best, and I give her GREAT props for trying hard
dabomber1300 2 years ago 6
Tarja songs? I only know Nightwusg songs, as far as i know, Tarja does not own any of the songs from Nightwish and neither does Anette, so isn't it up too Nightwish who sings what?
wrathofsllim 2 years ago 9
wow this version sucks see ya goin to see tarjas.
Ne0nLiteZ 2 years ago
Oh, Tarja? Well, say hi to that greedy, stuck up, nightwish-covering diva, for me :)
IKEAFTW 2 years ago 2
who doesnt like money?
Ne0nLiteZ 2 years ago
obviously tarja like the money, she loveeeeee it
nic19913 2 years ago 9
i love money too.
Ne0nLiteZ 2 years ago
specially tarja loves money ( even more than nightwish at her time)
nic19913 2 years ago 2
so how did she love money more than nightwish
Ne0nLiteZ 2 years ago
she didnt
just because she asked them to play less often people think that
the reality is that she was getting tired and
her voice was getting weak
she asked them to play in bigger places with more people instead of performing many times in little places with a few people...
that way she was going to take care of her voice
the quantity of money was going to be te same... just less effort to her
ClaudiaDenise 2 years ago
anette is making money too...
she is in the band and gets paid
does it sing for free??
did you forget that Tarja was with NW when they were Unknown??
Anette was just lucky... she didnt work hard to be famous... she joined the band when they had a very important place
ClaudiaDenise 2 years ago
anette is making money to because is her job but she loves nightwish and all the band is very happy with anette, and dont talk about stuffs that you dont have any idea, anette was picked between 2000 singers this is not lucky and she also have a carrrer is different that she wasnt very famous, and if the first singer is fired what do you think that a band have to do???, just pick a new singer IDIOT is OBVIOUS, tarja was fired because she was a diva
nic19913 2 years ago
Mira pequeño... en primera no estamos hablando de las "aptitudes" vocales de ninguna de las dos OK?
estamos hablando de que algunos estan diciendo que a Tarja la corrieron porque "amaba el dinero" solo basandose en el hecho de que ella no queria tocar en lugares pequeños, pero eso es porque para un cantante , por bueno que sea, es muy perjudicial sobretrabajar la voz. Es mejor tocar de 1 vez frente a mil personas que 10 veces frente a 100... ejemplo? mira a anette. cada vez suena mas cansada
ClaudiaDenise 2 years ago
pff -.-"
And what about Tarja's luck? Tarja wasn't lucky? If she wouldn't be the classmate of Tuomas, Tarja wouldn't know nothing about the Nightwish...
Anyway, if Tarja wouldn't join the Nightwish 13 ago, she would be an unkonown opera singer in a little opera house in Finland, wouldn't she? And if Anette would't decide to try to join the band, she would be famous either, because she was a member of a band, and she sang duets, ect...
So what are we talking about?
MetalJanka92 2 years ago 4
you didnt even understand my message
SO what are you talking about!
ClaudiaDenise 2 years ago
Tarja didn't work hard to get famous. She onöy singed in nightwish. Male members of the band made music and othe stuff. Tarja only singed. Without nightwish, Tarja would be maybe unknown classical singer, and good. But not famous.
AsserKortteenniemi 2 years ago 13
not exactly.
In a band like NW a singer can ruin her/his voice very fast. They want to performe very soon in many concerts for a long time and with a loud sound.
Besides, many years ago, they interviewed Tarja and she said that it was very difficult that the guys enjoy drinking and smoking and Smoke is really BAD for voice and she couldnt be with them for a long time because of that.
she asked them to play less often in bigger places with more people to avoid ruining her voicenot for themoney
ClaudiaDenise 2 years ago
annette should sing the songs from dark passion play and only because tarja's songs are not made for her voice.
lioubinos99 2 years ago
this song Tarja better - -+
pohskin 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Anette suckz
ChoasLifestyler 2 years ago
great song!!! One of my favorites. And Anette rocks!!!!!!
llostandddelirius 2 years ago 2
I like the dual hi-hats Jukka uses
KevinCarey 2 years ago 2
Annette rocks, so everyone that thinks otherwise should just shut up and go cry to Tarja's record istead of whining about stuff you can't do smt about ANYWAY!
GreveNightwish 2 years ago 4
Anette's belting...
:) :) :) :)
analikewhoa1 2 years ago
Personally, I think Annette totally rocked that performance. I mean, I thought she'd have to strain her voice to reach some of Tarja's notes, but she improvised and it sounded great.
TwilightMember30 2 years ago
fuck sake! she sucks at doing tarjas songs!
spankmonkey6669 2 years ago
These are not Tarja's song. She had very little to do with the creative process.
Hemanthemannequin 2 years ago
I love Nightwish, I wish they could unite.. Tuomas makes the music, its all about his visions, he doesnt bend when it comes to his visions and lyrics.
digipuk 2 years ago 2
Everybody needs to shut it. Anette is here to stay, and your crying about it like bitches isn't going to change anything. If you were a real fan, you'd respect Nightwish's descion. You don't have to listen to them if you don't like it. Deal with it.
HopefulHarmony 2 years ago
believe it or not, these comment boxes are here for people to voice their opinions, and it seems real nightwish fans respect Tarjas voice more than they respect their decision, because Tarja was the voice of Nightwish, put simply, Anette cant sing Tarjas songs!
spankmonkey6669 2 years ago
Indeed. And I voiced mine, and you voiced yours. Wow! What a concept. Tarja was a voice. Did you know she's making music that's actually very beautiful? So if you liked Tarja, go listen to her and quit complaining like a bitch on Nightwish music. They work damn hard to make you happy. And besides, let me see you try to do that in front of at least a thousand people. Let me know when YOU get up on stage and try to please countless fans and clear non-fans. Then you'll know how it feels.
HopefulHarmony 2 years ago
fuck, you just a moody little cunt! Iv heard Tarjas music, but it just sucks that Tarja wont be playing anymore nightwish songs, personally, i think Nightwish should have reformed to a new band, i dont think its fair that anette has to sing Nightwish songs, it leaves her open to a lot of criticism
spankmonkey6669 2 years ago
HAHAHA! AH HA. You ran out of comebacks. Anyway, we need to stop spamming the video with shameless and/or degrading bitching at one another. It makes me look like a crazed bitch. (Which I probably am, but aren't we all in a way? Hahaha.) Love the opinion, and it ain't really a bad one. Well, be seeing you around.
HopefulHarmony 2 years ago
but guess what, Tarja was fired, and the main singer of nightwish nos is Anette Olzen =)
Daworldendswithyou 2 years ago
..... Al igual que con TRISTANIA (R.I.P)
¿que les esta pasando...?
pienso que de Nightwish, tristania y sirenia...
la mejor eleccion la tuvo sirenia
aunque Ailyn canta algo freson.. por lo menos canta.....
Vibeke Stene tristania por siempre!!!!
VibekeGothicBeauty 2 years ago
Tarja tarjaaa!!!! ANETTE! YOU'RE A FUCKING LOOSER BITCH!
gokuvillarreal 2 years ago
Yeah... If you're going to call someone a loser on the internet, you may want to spell it correctly...
I swear, you retards never cease to amaze me...
xZELLx 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She's that retarded she doesn't deserve proper grammar! she sounds fucking terrible
spankmonkey6669 2 years ago
Comment removed
hilflosmara 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
R.I.P nightwish,u were amazing while u were an operatic metal band but ur old songs are now ruined as u didnt hire a proper singer
drumdemon3 2 years ago
The other singer was way better
Heavymetal195 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she is too POP.... I´ve tried to find the metal element from Anettes vocal style... but it´s time to face the fact.....there is none. No more headbanging either.
Quake227 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
its sickening to watch this fraud trying to sing for, what used to be, one of the best Symphonic Metal bands ever.
BenLovesKamelot 2 years ago
Naaaaaaaaaaaa
mi cancion favorita lrpm
daaaaaaaa matense :S
que se preparen para mayo les va a encantar los palos q les voy a tirar :S
agustinromero84 2 years ago
I saw them last night in Italy...
they were fantastic... I love them..
and I love this song
elysfis 2 years ago 3
бля ей только народный фольклор исполнять, у неё б хорошо получалось орать хоровые песни! ваще не катит! хоть старые песни Тарьи не трогала бы!
podguzdy 2 years ago
hay anette tienes una voz muy bonita pero como crees de que tu viniendo de cantor algo como un hard rock vas a dar la talla en una banda de metal gotico
nfsAndres 2 years ago
Anette laulaa tosi hyvin vanhoja biisejä. Varsinkin Sleeping sun, Romanticide, Come Cover Men...
silmalia 2 years ago