I liked all of their covers up until this one. The other covers seem to capture the feel of the original song fairly well--this one misses the mark entirely.
@AGrangerDouglas I see what you're saying, but I disagree. Polar Opposites is a song title that works on two levels - (1) the lyrics themselves; but mostly (2) the fact that the song is so upbeat, but the lyrics are rather depressing. This cover makes the song possibly even more upbeat, so it's keeping with the feel of it.
@BeLiterary You might want to read the entirety of my comment before replying to it. That was my whole point. I wrote "the lyrics are rather depressing". That's why the song's title works on two levels: the one being that the lyrics are themselves about polar opposites, i.e. bipolar disorder; and the other being the fact that the lyrics are depressing, but the song itself (the music) is upbeat. Have you even heard the original? It's catchy as hell.
@upyr1: *facepalm* i feel sorry for you, if you can't appreciate Isaac Brock's style. Not everyone does. There's a reason it's called alternative music- It breaks boundaries between genres, pushing our limits. Modest Mouse's music experiments with so many different instruments, levels of dissonance, etc. etc.
This is an awesome cover, don't get me wrong- but if you find the covers "better" than the originals that's because their easier to listen to. There's less depth.
@Serendipitiouss *facepalm* the old You don't like it because you don't understand it line- that's such BS the issue is simple I like blugrass and I don't think the song worked as well with isaac brock's vocals on this song. I'll admit I prefer blue grass over modest mouse-
youre soooooo right. no one should be positively influenced by anything outside their own "genre", that wouldnt make music grown at all. fuck that noise!
Agreed, Love it. I'm a lover of many kinds of music. I really like Modest Mouse. My best friend played "Pickin' On Modest Mouse" for me a little over a year ago. I told her, "That's awesome!". I like the covers they do as much as the originals :)
Well this sucks..i checked this song out just yesterday and favorited it..now it wont load!
Kingofmean 1 month ago
this might be the best cover of all time.... OMFG I love you Iron Horse.... BANJO NOW!!!
bhenry411 2 months ago
Wow this might be my favorite song of all time love it!!
djgiga 3 months ago in playlist iron horse - pickin on modest mouse
Better than the original.
griffomac1 4 months ago
Remember how 'Shiny happy people" was supposed to be an insult but people loved it instead?
sharonb314 6 months ago
What a retarded cover.
BeLiterary 6 months ago
@BeLiterary Ever heard of an artistic license? "BeLiterary" Ha!
eljordo765 1 month ago
the lyrics are absolutely perfect for a bluegrass cover.
9ner 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out my videos for bluegrass tributes to Jack Johnson!
codyrmartin 7 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i kinda think modest mouse sucks, but these covers are the shit
jammin6491 8 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wow, this makes modest mouse tolerable.
fashioncorpse 1 year ago
I liked all of their covers up until this one. The other covers seem to capture the feel of the original song fairly well--this one misses the mark entirely.
AGrangerDouglas 1 year ago
@AGrangerDouglas I see what you're saying, but I disagree. Polar Opposites is a song title that works on two levels - (1) the lyrics themselves; but mostly (2) the fact that the song is so upbeat, but the lyrics are rather depressing. This cover makes the song possibly even more upbeat, so it's keeping with the feel of it.
ModestMousekateer 1 year ago
@ModestMousekateer The song isn't supposed to be upbeat. Go read the lyrics.
BeLiterary 6 months ago
@BeLiterary You might want to read the entirety of my comment before replying to it. That was my whole point. I wrote "the lyrics are rather depressing". That's why the song's title works on two levels: the one being that the lyrics are themselves about polar opposites, i.e. bipolar disorder; and the other being the fact that the lyrics are depressing, but the song itself (the music) is upbeat. Have you even heard the original? It's catchy as hell.
ModestMousekateer 6 months ago
@ModestMousekateer That's a cool point I hadn't thought about that. A lot of blues is like that too I feel like. Its a sweet sadness.
djgiga 3 months ago
Anyone out there know the banjo tuning used in this song?
sieg37 1 year ago
@sieg37 i belive its standard tuneing
80ProofEngine 1 year ago
@80ProofEngine Thanks for the reply,now to figure out the rolls . . .
sieg37 1 year ago
@80ProofEngine Thanks pard!
sieg37 1 year ago
buck chardler
deckthepizmp 1 year ago
a great song transcending it's original genre
redyryhpaj 1 year ago
we love it here in these here mountains of western north carolina!!!!!!
bmxman246 1 year ago
we love it here in these here mountains of western north carolina!!!!!!
bmxman246 1 year ago
This is alot better than the modest mouse version
upyr1 1 year ago
@upyr1: *facepalm* i feel sorry for you, if you can't appreciate Isaac Brock's style. Not everyone does. There's a reason it's called alternative music- It breaks boundaries between genres, pushing our limits. Modest Mouse's music experiments with so many different instruments, levels of dissonance, etc. etc.
This is an awesome cover, don't get me wrong- but if you find the covers "better" than the originals that's because their easier to listen to. There's less depth.
Serendipitiouss 1 year ago 2
@Serendipitiouss *facepalm* the old You don't like it because you don't understand it line- that's such BS the issue is simple I like blugrass and I don't think the song worked as well with isaac brock's vocals on this song. I'll admit I prefer blue grass over modest mouse-
upyr1 1 year ago
An awful cover of my favorite song.
MaxLinc5555 1 year ago
Ya i gotta say this ones way offff...
"(̅_̅_̅_̅_̅_̅_̅_̅_̅_̅_̅_̅̅_̅() ڪ ے Blaze It!
MeSh479 1 year ago
I'm tryin', I'm tryin' to drink away the part of the day that I cannot youtube away!
wonreebaemssap 1 year ago
@wonreebaemssap hahaa yes
jezzacaple 1 year ago
fuck yeaaaaa
garrettiscrazy 1 year ago
wtf? ;o
TheRoxy3 1 year ago
they are all like completely different. i still like the modest mouse versions more but this is still amazing.
LiftedxResearch 1 year ago
This cover is wrong on so many levels....lol
deejour 1 year ago
@deejour
youre soooooo right. no one should be positively influenced by anything outside their own "genre", that wouldnt make music grown at all. fuck that noise!
skaguy88 1 year ago
@skaguy88 ha
xXkingPurpXx 1 year ago
interesting perspective. i dig it.
burnnout 1 year ago
sik cover!!!!!
ianisdead 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
modest mouse is 20x better. i just heard that some one did a cover so i checked it out...this sucks ass.
iPodAwesum 2 years ago
@iPodAwesum
Try being civil, you obnoxious jerk.
Zasserman 2 years ago
I can't stop listening to this..
grogface 3 years ago 2
fucking gnarlitude song!
drizzle989 3 years ago 4
bad ass song
bfodge 3 years ago 10
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Not
Klingan846 3 years ago
douche bag
vincentbryce 2 years ago
damn right blue grass stizz this shits tha bomb nigga
lilwaynedick 1 year ago
definitely needs to be a little more... minor. it's too damn giddy and annoying, and modest mouse and bluegrass are two of my favorite things.
lovethesideways8 3 years ago 3
modest mouse version so much better...
ellennelellen 2 years ago
thats because they wrote it you douche. respect the blue grass
PoetryofDarkness 2 years ago 3
Agreed, Love it. I'm a lover of many kinds of music. I really like Modest Mouse. My best friend played "Pickin' On Modest Mouse" for me a little over a year ago. I told her, "That's awesome!". I like the covers they do as much as the originals :)
theedictator 2 years ago 4
äre du som är skate avesta adam? :O
spfab666 3 years ago
Ja dårå?
Klingan846 3 years ago
@Klingan846 ol? skavr?
cameroaj91 8 months ago
Nemen! Adam! Fet låt
TokfulFlensOst 3 years ago 5
men orka LoL XD
PanicKimAtTheDisco 3 years ago 5
Nice Låt Adam :P
axberg94 3 years ago 5