This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I'ts quite good, she seems to listen much to Cecilia Bartoli, her way of expression ( to much air in many sounds) her coloraturas are very much alike. I also don't hear a young man, but a woman, it's to feminin and i hear more "listen to me, what a reat singer i am" than the role of Sesto. To me this more Rossini than Mozart. Listen to Garancia's Sesto, it is mor Mozartian and much more honest and in the role!
@operaticxingenue Glad someone agrees with me! Everything Garanca does is commendable, in its way - solidly sung, is the word I would use. But I can't ever remember a note of it.
I actually read one reviewer on Amazon put both she and diDonato in his category of "anonymous-sounding modern-day mezzos." Whaaaa? Joyce is many things, but anonymous certainly isn't one of them!
@90lysander That really is totally crazy. DiDonato inhabits her characters and sings with a fluidity and beauty of tone that's missing in a lot of singing right now. Garanca has a lovely instrument, but she's kind of like the Netrebko of mezzos.
@amarantaviera I think Garanca is a superior singer to Netrebko (although the latter has a more individual tone), but yes, very few of their performances stick in my minds.
Wow, I didn't know Johnny Depp was a classical music fan, let alone Didonato's. But then, he always seems to have good tastes in just about everything else, I guess it makes sense.
What's whetting my appetite even more is actually Anna Caterina Antonacci's Vitellia. I really hope this production is available on DVD.
Hmmm, it's possible that diDonato had gone somewhere to see Depp, rather than vice versa. But I'm really not sure as to the origin of the picture. Leo (you don't mind if I call you that, do you?) - do you have any more info about this?
She's really good!!!!! Elina Garanca, Joyce diDonato and Cecilia Bartoli are my favourite mezzos of today! Each of them is a great artist and personality!!
Gorgeous as always!!!
vendettamia 7 months ago
Who is the clarinettist on this recording?
SuperOrganmaster 1 year ago
Are you gossiping ?
dacor31 2 years ago
And the winner is...
Joyce Di Donato...
Miss Photogenic
Dogaradodia 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'ts quite good, she seems to listen much to Cecilia Bartoli, her way of expression ( to much air in many sounds) her coloraturas are very much alike. I also don't hear a young man, but a woman, it's to feminin and i hear more "listen to me, what a reat singer i am" than the role of Sesto. To me this more Rossini than Mozart. Listen to Garancia's Sesto, it is mor Mozartian and much more honest and in the role!
SAMARA3365 2 years ago
@SAMARA3365 This sounds nothing like Bartoli ... and is FAR more interesting that Garanca, who puts me to sleep.
90lysander 1 year ago 2
@90lysander AMEN to Garanca being boring. She's just... *SNOOOOORE*
operaticxingenue 1 year ago 2
@operaticxingenue Glad someone agrees with me! Everything Garanca does is commendable, in its way - solidly sung, is the word I would use. But I can't ever remember a note of it.
I actually read one reviewer on Amazon put both she and diDonato in his category of "anonymous-sounding modern-day mezzos." Whaaaa? Joyce is many things, but anonymous certainly isn't one of them!
90lysander 1 year ago 2
@90lysander That really is totally crazy. DiDonato inhabits her characters and sings with a fluidity and beauty of tone that's missing in a lot of singing right now. Garanca has a lovely instrument, but she's kind of like the Netrebko of mezzos.
amarantaviera 1 month ago
@amarantaviera I think Garanca is a superior singer to Netrebko (although the latter has a more individual tone), but yes, very few of their performances stick in my minds.
90lysander 1 month ago
pas terrible! ily a un souffle sur cetaines notes et ça manque de legato
acanthe83 2 years ago
@acanthe83 . Avec le son Youtube et ce MP3 hyper écrasé, il y a de toute façon de l'air sur tous les sons, comment juger quoi que ce soit?
foropera 1 year ago
Wow, I didn't know Johnny Depp was a classical music fan, let alone Didonato's. But then, he always seems to have good tastes in just about everything else, I guess it makes sense.
What's whetting my appetite even more is actually Anna Caterina Antonacci's Vitellia. I really hope this production is available on DVD.
vitellia 2 years ago
Hmmm, it's possible that diDonato had gone somewhere to see Depp, rather than vice versa. But I'm really not sure as to the origin of the picture. Leo (you don't mind if I call you that, do you?) - do you have any more info about this?
nclysander 2 years ago
no I don't mind, that's my name xD about the picture, I don't have information, sorry, I just took it from DessayBestSinger XDDDDD
leoperarm 2 years ago
@leoperarm hm...podrias llamarme por mi nombre! kidding ^^
DessayBestSingerII 1 year ago
That´s an original photo from
Montblanc's 100th Anniversary Celebration on April 5, 2006 in Geneva, Switzerland.
JaRoWi1647 2 years ago
according to joyce's website, they met at an event joyce was singing at in paris.
tenorelirico001 2 years ago
oh nice! TY!
leoperarm 2 years ago
Can we have 'Deh per questo istante solo' too?
Thrax1982 3 years ago
OK...no problem ;)
leoperarm 3 years ago
Thanks!
'Parto, parto' is one of my favourite arias but there are so many different versions already on Youtube.
'Deh per questo' is equally great but not so well represented.
Thrax1982 3 years ago
there it is!
leoperarm 3 years ago
Leo, las arias de Vitellia por favor...y DiDonato como siempre impresionante :)
leporello89 3 years ago
oki...jeje!
leoperarm 3 years ago
any way you could post Vitellia's arias pleaseeee?
hillevifan 3 years ago
She's really good!!!!! Elina Garanca, Joyce diDonato and Cecilia Bartoli are my favourite mezzos of today! Each of them is a great artist and personality!!
Klassizismus 3 years ago
TOTALLY agreed!!!^^
leoperarm 3 years ago
wAw the aria is really difficult! and DiDonato really great!
I love the picture with Johnny Depp at the end!
DessayBestSinger 3 years ago
me too!^^
nice movie btw xDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
leoperarm 3 years ago
yeah, a little break xD
DessayBestSinger 3 years ago