On earth... there has always been more women than men. And In Islam to be a complete momeen one has to get married. Single females has rights too... they have wants and needs as every human being on the planet. So some people should stop biasing.
@Myquestion100: Please inform yourself and please don't make assumptions. educate yourself about Islam. On earth... there has always been more women than men. And In Islam to be a complete momeen(being a good follower of god) one has to get married. Single females has rights too... they have wants and needs as every human being on the planet. So some people should stop biasing.
@plutity (1) THERE are reports that the prophet had preformed temporary marriage. (2) there are numerous and enormous and undeniable reports that the prophet allowed temporary marriage and you see this in the books of all the different sects under saheeh (authentic) classifications. The burden of the proof is upon the one who makes the claim. I claimed the prophet condoned it and i provided the proof. you claim he didnt and he never practiced it himself then its upon you to provide the proof
@plutity religion is not your desire. the law is stated and its not our choice to prohibit or make lawful based on desires. temporary marriage was allowed by the prophet so if you say its a brothel are you accusing our prophet of allowing brothel or are you denying it?
@afridisworld khaibar took place in the year 8 of hijrah, we have hadeeth in (saheeh bukhari Volume 7 tradition 13a) ibn masood says the prophet allowed mut3a and he read the Surah ALMaidah:87 from SURAH ALMAIDA, all Traditions are unanimous that Surah ALMaidah was revealed in 10th Hijri and it was the last or the 2nd Last Surah that was revealed. this is a clear proof that in 10th alhijrah it was allowed so the other hadeeths are lies.
Why does any of this matter? Whether you arrange "temporary marriage" or not, both Sunni and Shias have premarital sex anyways. Whether it is with a girlfriend or paid PROSTITUTES. Haha, don't lie. There are brothels all over the Middle East, even the imams go there. :D
@AdvanXer yes many people are hypocrites and fornicate and god knows the need of the human thats why god legitimized temporary marriage. the difference between marriage and fornication is a big difference. it can mean the difference between hell and heaven. Also the fact that marriage has a set contract with binding rules and a constitution to refer to but the (girlfriend boyfriend or forincation ) is a random and savage behavior with no binding contract or laws attached to it
in surah 4 Ayah 24, For the Shia, it is a law that you pay the dower before the enjoyment or else there cannot be a Mut'a. This Ayah is talking about coming to an agreement and discussing the payment of the dower even after the whole thing is over or paying it after the enjoyment. So we can see that Mut'a does not fit.
@shorty40merza YOU KNOW THE TRUTH BUT YOU LIKE TO HIDE THE TRUTH ABOUT PEOPLE , The Prophet allowed Mut'a (Temporary Marriage ) for three days, at the war of Khaiber, and after three days it was made haram .Once Ali argued with a man who believed in Mut'a and told him that the Prophet made Mut'a and the meat of donkey haram on the day of Khaiber (Bukhari vol. 7, pg. 287 and vol. 4 pg. 134
@MuslimJordan1 The Shia themselves have a hadith narrated by Ali (r.a.a) which states that the Prophet made Mut'a haram on the day of Khaiber (Book of Tahdeeb: vol. 7, pg. 251, rewaya 10). The author states that Ali lied for the purposes of Taqiya. In Book of Istebsar: vol. 3, pg. 142, rewaya 5, there is a declaration by Ali that Mut'a is haram. Again they accuse Ali of lying for Taqiya.
@MuslimJordan1 not taqyah but just false hadeeths , the hadeeth books are full of false hadeeths. taqyah is to protect yourself from death not to lie just for the hell of it
@MuslimJordan1 what if i bring you evidence from saheeh muslim that in 10th alhijra it was allowed? you say it was prohibited in khaibar which is 8th hijrah right and it was only for three days? muslim says it was more than three days lol ,
@shorty40merza the Prophet allowed it for three days, and then he made it haram again till the day of Judgment (Muslim vol. 4 pg. 133). Notice.: Imam Ahmed s Musnad vol. 16 pg. 192-193, Muslim vol. 4, pg. 132, Bayhaki vol. 7 pg. 293-294. Since there was a time when Mut'a was halal. Therefore, one can find hadith saying that it was halal. However, the latter hadith, which follows the final order of jurisprudence set by the the Prophet, takes precedence over the former hadith.
@MuslimJordan1 i just showed you that there is a hadeeth in bukhari proving it was allowed in 10th alhijrah , all the prohibition claims are before 8th alhijrah,
@shorty40merza i just want you to be good resarcher not just , copy and paste from there and there , be honest with your self , in bukari and moslem that hadith was just for limit days becouse of some situation and after that the psrophet (PBUH) made it haram , and from moslem and bokhari ,, and Ali (R) said that on shia book also look to alistbsar part 3 p 142 ,wsalel al shia part 14 page441 ,tahdeeb al al7kam part 7 paper 251... and more more ,,, i wana ask you know is the mut'a real marraige?
@shorty40merza inn shia books all imams said that mut'a not marraige ,,, so change you video title to mut'a >> if you want to se that look to 1:-alkafi root ( 43/2) , 2:- altahdeeb by altosy (2/ 188) , 3:- alisbsar ( 3/ 147) and more and more ,,, so change it from marragie to mut'a ,, be hounst with your self .. by
I will ask you one question. The fabricated hadeeths state that the prophet made mut3a finally haraam on the 8th of Hijra, right? In (saheeh bukhari Volume 7 tradition 13a) ibn masood says the prophet allowed mut3a and he read the verse 5:87 from SURAH ALMAIDA, all Traditions are unanimous that Surah Maidah was revealed in 10th Hijri and it was the last or the 2nd Last Surah that was revealed. (cont)
(cont) so did the prophet read the verse of sourah almaida before the 8th year of hijrah? did he read it before the verse was even revealed? or is your hadeeths through the mouths of the enemies of Ali whom have cursed him for years on the pulpits have fabricated and lied upon Ali? no the umayah wouldn't lie upon Ali, ibn shahab who worked 40 years for Umayah woudlnt lie upon Ali would he?
@shorty40merza Also in the Quran, we see that when ever Allah mentions marriage he also teaches us about divorce. When a man marries a chaste woman, and wants to leave her, he has to first divorce her. This can be seen in the following surah and Ayahs, 65:1, 2:231, 2:232, 2:236, 2:37, 33:49, 66:5 ,BUT In Mut'a, there is no divorce; once you pay the set amount of money and the assigned time ends there is no rights.... SO MUT'A IT IS NOT MARRAIGE :) ... I KNOW YOU WILL DELETE MY COMMENTS >>HAHAHA
@MuslimJordan1 no why should i delete your comments you are not swearing, you accused me of lying but its okay as long as you don't swear your welcomed to state your opinion. Arguments usually increase the knowledge of the people,
@owoyalefemi1 in all books there are all types of hadeeths and many are fabricated so the person who picks and chooses has to be very unbiased because many people disregard hadeeths simply because they don't agree with their desires. I dont condemn most of the hadeeths you know , I only condemns some of them with proof why they should be condemned.
@shorty40merza But I have read and believed for many years that the Holy Prophet Mohammed SAW allowed temporary marriage but later condemned it.Is this not right?
@owoyalefemi1 yes brother thats what they say but to know the truth it is required to investigate when there are conflicting reports about anything. we have conflicting reports, some say the prophet condemned it later and some say the prophet never condemned it and Omar himself condemned it in his khilafa time. as you see one of the hadeeths in this video says Mut3a was practiced in the prophet's time and abubakr's time until the incident of Amro bin alhuraith took place at the end of Omar's
@owoyalefemi1 Also jalal aldeen alsayooty says in his book where he mentions the first ones (alawael) , the first one who prohibited mut3a is Omar , to get more information watch all the 4 parts that i made, part one is introduction, part two (this one ) shows that Omar prohibited the muta of marriage and part three showing Omar prohibiting the muta of hajj and part four analyzes the hadeeths that say the prophet prohibited it
@owoyalefemi1 my brother we read and believe many things but as truth seekers we must constantly study and investigate and in many cases we find that our beliefs are wrong so we change , this is the way to god,,, but to say i follow the forefathers is condemned by the quraan many times. I give you one example, maybe for years you say (Mohamad SWS) which means Mohamad Salla allah alayh Wa Sallam. Now you pray right ? If you say it like this will your prayer be accepted?
@owoyalefemi1 regardless of which school of thought you follow in the prayer its compulsory to say " Allahuma Sali Ala Muhamad Wa Ali Mohamad" if you say only Mohamad then your prayer is not accepted, if you say only Mohamad and his companions then your prayer is not accepted right? the only way it to say Mohamad and Ahlulbait ,,, so the big question is if this is so in prayer howcome many people say only upon prophet Mohamad? and how come they give the companions an elevated position
@shorty40merza hmm....that's some thought,man.I have been a muslim right since birth but I have a lot of questions in my head to ask.
One of the things that yet bother me is how my prayers would not be accepted if I prayed it somehow.In all I do, I "must" compulsorily do it in certain ways because no other method to it would be accepted.I must do it according to the sunna.There are way too many rules to doing things in our religion,Islam.There are benefits of doing so but also stereotype
@owoyalefemi1 dont worry brother,,, as you say there are many ways to pray and only one way is true so many times in our life we might be doing the wrong way but allah forgives the ignorant. we pray " Birajaa almatloob" ( in the hope that this is whats required) and as we learn we fix, but my example is to highlight that many times we go by things for years then discover that its wrong. we must have courage to change and fix during our life. (which other languages you speak ?)
@owoyalefemi1 mashallah , your welcome brother,, I dont know how to speak that language, I thought you might speak arabic, you can watch the opposite view to me here; watch?v=FYQSLpYKJn4 I was also participating in the discussion there. i will paste one of the posts that i wrote to here (cont)
@owoyalefemi1 I will ask you one question. The fabricated hadeeths state that the prophet made mut3a finally haraam on the 8th of Hijra, right Zakah? In (saheeh bukhari Volume 7 tradition 13a) ibn masood says the prophet allowed mut3a and he read the verse 5:87 from SURAH MAIDA, all Traditions are unanimous that Surah Maidah was revealed in 10th Hijri and it was the last or the 2nd Last Surah that was revealed. (cont)
@owoyalefemi1 so did the prophet read the verse of sourah almaida before the 8th year of hijrah? did he read it before the verse was even revealed? or is your hadeeths through the mouths of the enemies of Ali whom have cursed him for years on the pulpits have fabricated and lied upon Ali? no no the umayah wouldn't lie upon Ali ibn shahab who worked 40 years for Umayah woudlnt lie upon Ali would he?
so let me answer you all if Muta was mentioned Haram in 7th Hijri from your own Alh-sunnat books and from your own Ulammas...
Abn-Hajar Asqalani says: the people who say that Hazrat Mohammad(S.W) had notified Muta as haram in Khyber war's time(7th Hijri), they don't have knowledge,Serah,history and neither knowledge in narration.
Vast majority of Suni are idiot fools. They do not realize that All hadith imams of Persian Origin imam-Muslim Bokhari ibne maja Nisaie abu Daud Kaaafi etc were criminal parsi-shia disguised under Muslim names. All narrrators of Muta-zina in sunis books were also bastrd shia. There is no any trace of Muta-zina in Quran. Shia twist verse 4:24-25 to validate Muta-zina but in fact this verse says do not mary for just sexual lust so in this way this verse forbids Muta-zina.
Bhai loggo ko bewakuf na banae Sura e nisa ki ayat jis ka ap ne howla dea hai is me Allah ne saaf tor par Nikka ka farmaya hai. na k Mutta ka, Allah farmarahe hai ye taluk sirf SHAWAT k le na ho. jab k Matta to hota hi Shawat k le.
wasnt mut3a practised by the prophet and all the men at his time...why are the shai so hated know for practising something that the prophet allowed isnt that what you call sunnatel rasool
Khomeini stated in his book "Tahir-ul-Wasila", Vol. 2, Page No. 292, "Muta (Zina) can be for one day, a night, and even just a few hours!. But for Khomeini, that was not enough so he further states in the same book on Page No. 292, "Temporary marriage can be performed with harlots and prostitutes". According to the Shia's, lie was attributed to Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.w):
@Factszz: The fact is Khomeini is not the imam of the Shai's... He's leader of a country. Shia's follow the 12 imam's (Ahlulbayt's) from the words of Prophet Mohammad (pbh). Prophet Mohammad's (pbh) grandson's and so fort.
Shia are kaafirs and their nasty Zani cult is based on two frauds:
1- Based on millions of forged hadiths that were never siad by Prophet.
2- their 2nd crime is to twist the meanings of verse 4:24 of Quran. In fact there is no any trace of Shia muta in this verse 4:24. In fact this verse says, be aways from Muta zina.
Also u all should know that Bokahri, Imam Muslim, Ibne Maja, Nisaie, Tirmidi , Kaafi all were Irani Sabaite Parsi shia criminals hidden under Taqayya. Their books R crap
Was qurtoby an angel, or Prophet, or a superman or an infallible? He could be just a normal muslim or a scholar or even could be a freak faggot like all crmininal imams of hadith books of persian Original who have ruined Islam by fabricating 2.3 millions hadith in the name of Prophet that were not said by SyedNa Muhamamd. U blindly following Personality-worshiper shits are real cancer in Islam
@shorty40merza ... this was about mutta,, before 7th hijri. when mutta was allowed,, this ayat is now MANSUKH, and in 7th hijri MUTTA was declared haram by PROPHET SAWW.... like similar to WINE (sharab),
@Factszz ... i agree with ur 2 points... but what u said at last about the BOKHARI, IMAM MUSLIM etc,,,, WAS JUST A CRAP, bcoze u dont know that why they written about mutta in their hadith books....
Imam Qartabi who is a trustworthy among Ahl-sunnat brothers, says in his explanation:(و قال الجمهور المراد نكاح المتعة الذي كان في صدر الإسلام.) Tafseer Al-Qartabi,Volume 5 page number 130.
ACCORDING TO OUR ISLAM,ALLAH AND RASUL(SAW) PROHIBITED FROM ABUSING.BUT UR WORDS R TELING,WHAT UR MAZHAB TEACHES U.I THINK U HAVE NEVER EVEN READ QURAN,WHICH GIVES US LESSON OF IKHLAQ E HASANAH.
now the uploader of this clip is making platitudes to be innocent that cult islam wanted to show us...
if muhammad would himself forbade the muta marriage thus, it would be reveled in quran, but there is no forbidden on muta marriage. if 4.24 could be reveled then it would must be reveled the prohibition verse for this nast and maqrooh practice. like other verses in quran pork is forbidden. the truth is that allah didnt wanted to forbate muta, but later idiot muslims forbade it. hahahahaha
And who ever believes that ALLAH and his Quran Issue an order and later find out it was WRONG and desided to abolish it ,IS AN ABSOLUTE KAFIR (KAFIR AL MOTLAQ).
Kafir wo hay jo Quran Ma Tehreef karay Kafir wo hay jo sahaba ko Nabee kay baraber samjhay Kafir wo hay jo Ahal-e-bait e Rasool ko sahaba say kam manay Kafir wo jo Ahal e bait kee Shan walee Hadison ko Zaeef manay Kafir wo hay jo Missyar (zina) karay or Muta ko Haram manay Haqiqat hay KAFIR Bidha Wahabi HAY Bidha salafis hay Bidha deobandi hay Iss liye Bidha Wahabi, salafis ore deobandi Iss kaiynat Kay badtareeen Najis tareeen Ore paleed tareen loge hain Ab khosh Yazeed kee Nasal
so all these sunnies books which referennesa are given in the video r written by some basterds u must sa sunnies basterd these books r wrong otherwise that was omer basterd who change the islam education
my question is that u r trying to say these sunnies books r written by some harami moulvis , nd my other question is who is umar gando who can chane quraniq education who give him a right to overooled quran
afir wo hay jo quraaan ko threef shuda manay Kafir wo hay jo Ayimma ko AMbiya sa afzal manay Kafir wo hay jo ashaab-e-rasool ki gustaakhi kare Kafir wo hay jo baitullah pa hamla kare Kafir wo hay jo muutta(zina) ko ibaddat samjhay khul k q na kahoooooooooon KAFIR SHIYA HAY SHIYA HA SHIYA HAY q k is khabeeeeees is laanti shiya mein yeh sari baatain paayeeeeen jaati hain is kiye shiya is kaaiynaat ka badtareeen najis tareeen or paleed tareeeeeeen KAFIR HAY
actually Kaafir wo hay jo Khuda ko na maane, not at all what u said, thats why Christians and Jews are not considered Kaafir. What you are experiencing is a mild case of Jihalat, you might wanna get that checked out. That will only be done by saying BAR UMER LANAT!!!
Dude this is sick. In Islam temporary marriage is prohibited. Scenario that you are referring to is if you decide to divorce your wife before you had sex with her, you don't have to pay mahr (bridal money)( it is advised still though) but if you did than it is a must. But it docent refer to temporary marriage at all. it is talking about legitimate marriage.
TurkmenIRAQI4LIFE (2 months ago) Show Hide 0 Marked as spam Reply | Spam The Prophet (saws) was only allowed for a very short time... and then the Prophet (saws) forbade it...
...do you then accuse the Holy Prophet (saww) of being sick?
because surely you must accept what your scholars claim that he (saww) allowed it at least for a while!
My friend the main idea of this video and other like it is that temporary marriage is something that is still halal and it is not and it is sick. I can say that drinking alcohol is sick and stupid and every muslim would agree, but Mohammed(pbuh) did not forbade it right away. To try and justify it right now that is just wrong, also to misinterpret quran quoting verses that relate to other things and not muta is totally wrong.
no akhee, the Holy Prophet (saww) never commanded people to drink alcohol, right?
But even according to your own sources he did command people to commit mut3a, and according to our sources he allowed it and only 3umar forbade it and so you are the ypocrite if you follow the 3umar!
Akhee bring me ahadith where Mohammed commanded muta. There are so many ahadith from Al-Bukhari saying otherwise. And quranic verses that this idiot brought to prove muta... just read them yourself in the contest and that's would be enough for you.
Another thing would you give me in muta your daughter for an hour? And then to my friend for an hour, and then to me again?
What about waiting period that is prescribed in the quran that was OMAR too???!!! God you people are ignorant.
Mut3a was prohibited by the Prophet (saws)... and it´s not allowed until the youm al ghiyamah... and to come to the Verse in Quran alkarim... that´s just the interpretation of shias....
ignorant ingorant and stupid ! its a shame that majority of people dont understand the classical arabic .. you really gotta look at the texts that are from africa of quran and hadith.
Verse 2:196 is strictly about pilgrimage and makes no mention of this filth called Mutaa. And 4:24 is about financial rights of the divorced woman, which Islam protected. How can anybody twist these two verses and misinterpret them to mean legal prostitution is beyond me.
Alright, I have endured watching the rest of your videos. It's a pity, you speak Arabic and you are western educated and yet you fail to understand the basic message of the holy Quran. What is Haram or Halal is very clear. And prostitution, make no mistake about it "Mutaa" is prostitution", is Haram.
Blaming Omar (r.a.a) or cherry picking contradictory Ahadiths about the topic doesn't prove your position.
Try to put those Ahadiths in their proper context. The exceptions that might have happened to turning the blind eye to Mutaa were in times of war. 1400 years ago, when armies marched for months and camped far from home for months and years even.
What excuse do you Shia have today where traveling is at fast speed?
There is no doubt about it, Mutaa is Zinaa which is Haram. Marriage is sacred in Islam. And a woman is not a commodity for your temporary entertainment (Mutaa).
Try to learn the proper ways of Islam by looking at the big picture of the divine message.
May Allah guide us both to what is best in this life and the next. Peace.
your funnt man,,, since when did wars stop and armies stop??? army people go for months,,, and most of them are gay,,, look at saudi stats say that 50% are gay... and sunies invented a million types of marriage , misyar , misyaf .....
actually brother Zakah made his vedio as a response to my arabic version of this one,,, so i translated the arabic one to english and its what you see right here in this 4 parts,,, i am trying to promote it so it gets heard by those who visit zakahs one...
On earth... there has always been more women than men. And In Islam to be a complete momeen one has to get married. Single females has rights too... they have wants and needs as every human being on the planet. So some people should stop biasing.
FSAYED04 1 month ago
if islam allows prostituton then i can not follow it!! cuz i find that disgusting
Myquestion100 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Myquestion100: Please inform yourself and please don't make assumptions. educate yourself about Islam. On earth... there has always been more women than men. And In Islam to be a complete momeen(being a good follower of god) one has to get married. Single females has rights too... they have wants and needs as every human being on the planet. So some people should stop biasing.
FSAYED04 1 month ago
@plutity (1) THERE are reports that the prophet had preformed temporary marriage. (2) there are numerous and enormous and undeniable reports that the prophet allowed temporary marriage and you see this in the books of all the different sects under saheeh (authentic) classifications. The burden of the proof is upon the one who makes the claim. I claimed the prophet condoned it and i provided the proof. you claim he didnt and he never practiced it himself then its upon you to provide the proof
shorty40merza 10 months ago
@plutity religion is not your desire. the law is stated and its not our choice to prohibit or make lawful based on desires. temporary marriage was allowed by the prophet so if you say its a brothel are you accusing our prophet of allowing brothel or are you denying it?
shorty40merza 10 months ago
Meet beautiful Russian girl now gettop5.info
rhonamolinardhc 10 months ago
@afridisworld khaibar took place in the year 8 of hijrah, we have hadeeth in (saheeh bukhari Volume 7 tradition 13a) ibn masood says the prophet allowed mut3a and he read the Surah ALMaidah:87 from SURAH ALMAIDA, all Traditions are unanimous that Surah ALMaidah was revealed in 10th Hijri and it was the last or the 2nd Last Surah that was revealed. this is a clear proof that in 10th alhijrah it was allowed so the other hadeeths are lies.
shorty40merza 1 year ago
Why does any of this matter? Whether you arrange "temporary marriage" or not, both Sunni and Shias have premarital sex anyways. Whether it is with a girlfriend or paid PROSTITUTES. Haha, don't lie. There are brothels all over the Middle East, even the imams go there. :D
AdvanXer 1 year ago
@AdvanXer yes many people are hypocrites and fornicate and god knows the need of the human thats why god legitimized temporary marriage. the difference between marriage and fornication is a big difference. it can mean the difference between hell and heaven. Also the fact that marriage has a set contract with binding rules and a constitution to refer to but the (girlfriend boyfriend or forincation ) is a random and savage behavior with no binding contract or laws attached to it
shorty40merza 1 year ago
in surah 4 Ayah 24, For the Shia, it is a law that you pay the dower before the enjoyment or else there cannot be a Mut'a. This Ayah is talking about coming to an agreement and discussing the payment of the dower even after the whole thing is over or paying it after the enjoyment. So we can see that Mut'a does not fit.
MuslimJordan1 1 year ago
why you lieing ? the second vesre talk about the Real marriage not Temporary marriage ,,,, lier rafthdy
MuslimJordan1 1 year ago
@MuslimJordan1 Qurtoby and Razi say opposite to you , are they lairs too?
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@shorty40merza YOU KNOW THE TRUTH BUT YOU LIKE TO HIDE THE TRUTH ABOUT PEOPLE , The Prophet allowed Mut'a (Temporary Marriage ) for three days, at the war of Khaiber, and after three days it was made haram .Once Ali argued with a man who believed in Mut'a and told him that the Prophet made Mut'a and the meat of donkey haram on the day of Khaiber (Bukhari vol. 7, pg. 287 and vol. 4 pg. 134
MuslimJordan1 1 year ago
@MuslimJordan1 The Shia themselves have a hadith narrated by Ali (r.a.a) which states that the Prophet made Mut'a haram on the day of Khaiber (Book of Tahdeeb: vol. 7, pg. 251, rewaya 10). The author states that Ali lied for the purposes of Taqiya. In Book of Istebsar: vol. 3, pg. 142, rewaya 5, there is a declaration by Ali that Mut'a is haram. Again they accuse Ali of lying for Taqiya.
MuslimJordan1 1 year ago
@MuslimJordan1 not taqyah but just false hadeeths , the hadeeth books are full of false hadeeths. taqyah is to protect yourself from death not to lie just for the hell of it
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@MuslimJordan1 what if i bring you evidence from saheeh muslim that in 10th alhijra it was allowed? you say it was prohibited in khaibar which is 8th hijrah right and it was only for three days? muslim says it was more than three days lol ,
shorty40merza 1 year ago
its actually in bukhari ont muslim. i will paste for you
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@shorty40merza the Prophet allowed it for three days, and then he made it haram again till the day of Judgment (Muslim vol. 4 pg. 133). Notice.: Imam Ahmed s Musnad vol. 16 pg. 192-193, Muslim vol. 4, pg. 132, Bayhaki vol. 7 pg. 293-294. Since there was a time when Mut'a was halal. Therefore, one can find hadith saying that it was halal. However, the latter hadith, which follows the final order of jurisprudence set by the the Prophet, takes precedence over the former hadith.
MuslimJordan1 1 year ago
@MuslimJordan1 i just showed you that there is a hadeeth in bukhari proving it was allowed in 10th alhijrah , all the prohibition claims are before 8th alhijrah,
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@shorty40merza i just want you to be good resarcher not just , copy and paste from there and there , be honest with your self , in bukari and moslem that hadith was just for limit days becouse of some situation and after that the psrophet (PBUH) made it haram , and from moslem and bokhari ,, and Ali (R) said that on shia book also look to alistbsar part 3 p 142 ,wsalel al shia part 14 page441 ,tahdeeb al al7kam part 7 paper 251... and more more ,,, i wana ask you know is the mut'a real marraige?
MuslimJordan1 1 year ago
@shorty40merza inn shia books all imams said that mut'a not marraige ,,, so change you video title to mut'a >> if you want to se that look to 1:-alkafi root ( 43/2) , 2:- altahdeeb by altosy (2/ 188) , 3:- alisbsar ( 3/ 147) and more and more ,,, so change it from marragie to mut'a ,, be hounst with your self .. by
MuslimJordan1 1 year ago
I will ask you one question. The fabricated hadeeths state that the prophet made mut3a finally haraam on the 8th of Hijra, right? In (saheeh bukhari Volume 7 tradition 13a) ibn masood says the prophet allowed mut3a and he read the verse 5:87 from SURAH ALMAIDA, all Traditions are unanimous that Surah Maidah was revealed in 10th Hijri and it was the last or the 2nd Last Surah that was revealed. (cont)
shorty40merza 1 year ago
(cont) so did the prophet read the verse of sourah almaida before the 8th year of hijrah? did he read it before the verse was even revealed? or is your hadeeths through the mouths of the enemies of Ali whom have cursed him for years on the pulpits have fabricated and lied upon Ali? no the umayah wouldn't lie upon Ali, ibn shahab who worked 40 years for Umayah woudlnt lie upon Ali would he?
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@shorty40merza Also in the Quran, we see that when ever Allah mentions marriage he also teaches us about divorce. When a man marries a chaste woman, and wants to leave her, he has to first divorce her. This can be seen in the following surah and Ayahs, 65:1, 2:231, 2:232, 2:236, 2:37, 33:49, 66:5 ,BUT In Mut'a, there is no divorce; once you pay the set amount of money and the assigned time ends there is no rights.... SO MUT'A IT IS NOT MARRAIGE :) ... I KNOW YOU WILL DELETE MY COMMENTS >>HAHAHA
MuslimJordan1 1 year ago
@MuslimJordan1 no why should i delete your comments you are not swearing, you accused me of lying but its okay as long as you don't swear your welcomed to state your opinion. Arguments usually increase the knowledge of the people,
shorty40merza 1 year ago
So, what are the original and correct Hadiths if you condemn most of the ones we know?
owoyalefemi1 1 year ago
@owoyalefemi1 in all books there are all types of hadeeths and many are fabricated so the person who picks and chooses has to be very unbiased because many people disregard hadeeths simply because they don't agree with their desires. I dont condemn most of the hadeeths you know , I only condemns some of them with proof why they should be condemned.
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@shorty40merza But I have read and believed for many years that the Holy Prophet Mohammed SAW allowed temporary marriage but later condemned it.Is this not right?
owoyalefemi1 1 year ago
@owoyalefemi1 yes brother thats what they say but to know the truth it is required to investigate when there are conflicting reports about anything. we have conflicting reports, some say the prophet condemned it later and some say the prophet never condemned it and Omar himself condemned it in his khilafa time. as you see one of the hadeeths in this video says Mut3a was practiced in the prophet's time and abubakr's time until the incident of Amro bin alhuraith took place at the end of Omar's
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@owoyalefemi1 Also jalal aldeen alsayooty says in his book where he mentions the first ones (alawael) , the first one who prohibited mut3a is Omar , to get more information watch all the 4 parts that i made, part one is introduction, part two (this one ) shows that Omar prohibited the muta of marriage and part three showing Omar prohibiting the muta of hajj and part four analyzes the hadeeths that say the prophet prohibited it
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@owoyalefemi1 my brother we read and believe many things but as truth seekers we must constantly study and investigate and in many cases we find that our beliefs are wrong so we change , this is the way to god,,, but to say i follow the forefathers is condemned by the quraan many times. I give you one example, maybe for years you say (Mohamad SWS) which means Mohamad Salla allah alayh Wa Sallam. Now you pray right ? If you say it like this will your prayer be accepted?
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@owoyalefemi1 regardless of which school of thought you follow in the prayer its compulsory to say " Allahuma Sali Ala Muhamad Wa Ali Mohamad" if you say only Mohamad then your prayer is not accepted, if you say only Mohamad and his companions then your prayer is not accepted right? the only way it to say Mohamad and Ahlulbait ,,, so the big question is if this is so in prayer howcome many people say only upon prophet Mohamad? and how come they give the companions an elevated position
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@shorty40merza hmm....that's some thought,man.I have been a muslim right since birth but I have a lot of questions in my head to ask.
One of the things that yet bother me is how my prayers would not be accepted if I prayed it somehow.In all I do, I "must" compulsorily do it in certain ways because no other method to it would be accepted.I must do it according to the sunna.There are way too many rules to doing things in our religion,Islam.There are benefits of doing so but also stereotype
owoyalefemi1 1 year ago
@owoyalefemi1 dont worry brother,,, as you say there are many ways to pray and only one way is true so many times in our life we might be doing the wrong way but allah forgives the ignorant. we pray " Birajaa almatloob" ( in the hope that this is whats required) and as we learn we fix, but my example is to highlight that many times we go by things for years then discover that its wrong. we must have courage to change and fix during our life. (which other languages you speak ?)
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@shorty40merza thanks bro.I speak yoruba from West Africa
owoyalefemi1 1 year ago
@owoyalefemi1 mashallah , your welcome brother,, I dont know how to speak that language, I thought you might speak arabic, you can watch the opposite view to me here; watch?v=FYQSLpYKJn4 I was also participating in the discussion there. i will paste one of the posts that i wrote to here (cont)
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@owoyalefemi1 I will ask you one question. The fabricated hadeeths state that the prophet made mut3a finally haraam on the 8th of Hijra, right Zakah? In (saheeh bukhari Volume 7 tradition 13a) ibn masood says the prophet allowed mut3a and he read the verse 5:87 from SURAH MAIDA, all Traditions are unanimous that Surah Maidah was revealed in 10th Hijri and it was the last or the 2nd Last Surah that was revealed. (cont)
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@owoyalefemi1 so did the prophet read the verse of sourah almaida before the 8th year of hijrah? did he read it before the verse was even revealed? or is your hadeeths through the mouths of the enemies of Ali whom have cursed him for years on the pulpits have fabricated and lied upon Ali? no no the umayah wouldn't lie upon Ali ibn shahab who worked 40 years for Umayah woudlnt lie upon Ali would he?
shorty40merza 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why are you waiting here online Russian woman gettop5.info
DesgWamrt 1 year ago
so let me answer you all if Muta was mentioned Haram in 7th Hijri from your own Alh-sunnat books and from your own Ulammas...
Abn-Hajar Asqalani says: the people who say that Hazrat Mohammad(S.W) had notified Muta as haram in Khyber war's time(7th Hijri), they don't have knowledge,Serah,history and neither knowledge in narration.
فتح الباري لإبن حجر، ج9، ص145
zakirtanha 1 year ago
shia kafir
saad984 1 year ago
Appeal to all truth seekers:
Search in Google it will be first two hits at top
"Actual status of Hadith"
Factszz 1 year ago
Vast majority of Suni are idiot fools. They do not realize that All hadith imams of Persian Origin imam-Muslim Bokhari ibne maja Nisaie abu Daud Kaaafi etc were criminal parsi-shia disguised under Muslim names. All narrrators of Muta-zina in sunis books were also bastrd shia. There is no any trace of Muta-zina in Quran. Shia twist verse 4:24-25 to validate Muta-zina but in fact this verse says do not mary for just sexual lust so in this way this verse forbids Muta-zina.
Factszz 1 year ago
Bhai loggo ko bewakuf na banae Sura e nisa ki ayat jis ka ap ne howla dea hai is me Allah ne saaf tor par Nikka ka farmaya hai. na k Mutta ka, Allah farmarahe hai ye taluk sirf SHAWAT k le na ho. jab k Matta to hota hi Shawat k le.
ansaikhan007 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wasnt mut3a practised by the prophet and all the men at his time...why are the shai so hated know for practising something that the prophet allowed isnt that what you call sunnatel rasool
sprintspirit10 1 year ago
Khomeini stated in his book "Tahir-ul-Wasila", Vol. 2, Page No. 292, "Muta (Zina) can be for one day, a night, and even just a few hours!. But for Khomeini, that was not enough so he further states in the same book on Page No. 292, "Temporary marriage can be performed with harlots and prostitutes". According to the Shia's, lie was attributed to Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w.w):
Factszz 1 year ago 18
@Factszz: The fact is Khomeini is not the imam of the Shai's... He's leader of a country. Shia's follow the 12 imam's (Ahlulbayt's) from the words of Prophet Mohammad (pbh). Prophet Mohammad's (pbh) grandson's and so fort.
FSAYED04 1 month ago
Shia are kaafirs and their nasty Zani cult is based on two frauds:
1- Based on millions of forged hadiths that were never siad by Prophet.
2- their 2nd crime is to twist the meanings of verse 4:24 of Quran. In fact there is no any trace of Shia muta in this verse 4:24. In fact this verse says, be aways from Muta zina.
Also u all should know that Bokahri, Imam Muslim, Ibne Maja, Nisaie, Tirmidi , Kaafi all were Irani Sabaite Parsi shia criminals hidden under Taqayya. Their books R crap
Factszz 1 year ago 22
@Factszz qurtobi says 4:24 is about mut3a and you say its not!!!! okay we will listen to you not qurtoby
shorty40merza 1 year ago
@shorty40merza
Was qurtoby an angel, or Prophet, or a superman or an infallible? He could be just a normal muslim or a scholar or even could be a freak faggot like all crmininal imams of hadith books of persian Original who have ruined Islam by fabricating 2.3 millions hadith in the name of Prophet that were not said by SyedNa Muhamamd. U blindly following Personality-worshiper shits are real cancer in Islam
Factszz 1 year ago
@shorty40merza ... this was about mutta,, before 7th hijri. when mutta was allowed,, this ayat is now MANSUKH, and in 7th hijri MUTTA was declared haram by PROPHET SAWW.... like similar to WINE (sharab),
tajsalman 1 year ago
@Factszz ... i agree with ur 2 points... but what u said at last about the BOKHARI, IMAM MUSLIM etc,,,, WAS JUST A CRAP, bcoze u dont know that why they written about mutta in their hadith books....
tajsalman 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Imam Qartabi who is a trustworthy among Ahl-sunnat brothers, says in his explanation:(و قال الجمهور المراد نكاح المتعة الذي كان في صدر الإسلام.) Tafseer Al-Qartabi,Volume 5 page number 130.
Seyoti in Al-Dar-Al-Mansoor volume 2 page 140
Tabari in Jame-Al-Bayan volume 5 page 18
Tafseer Abu-Hayan volume 3 page 218
Shokani in Fath-Al-Qader volume 1 page 449
zakirtanha 1 year ago
@Factszz Tafseer Abn-Kaseer volume 1 page 486
in these books your Ulamas have mentioned the ayat number 24 Sura Nisa, have talked about Muta
zakirtanha 1 year ago
ACCORDING TO OUR ISLAM,ALLAH AND RASUL(SAW) PROHIBITED FROM ABUSING.BUT UR WORDS R TELING,WHAT UR MAZHAB TEACHES U.I THINK U HAVE NEVER EVEN READ QURAN,WHICH GIVES US LESSON OF IKHLAQ E HASANAH.
sun10khan 1 year ago
@Factszz: Stop these lie's... it makes you look stupid. A saying of a wise man: "stupid statements makes a stupid person. lol Totally Jahil
FSAYED04 1 month ago
now the uploader of this clip is making platitudes to be innocent that cult islam wanted to show us...
if muhammad would himself forbade the muta marriage thus, it would be reveled in quran, but there is no forbidden on muta marriage. if 4.24 could be reveled then it would must be reveled the prohibition verse for this nast and maqrooh practice. like other verses in quran pork is forbidden. the truth is that allah didnt wanted to forbate muta, but later idiot muslims forbade it. hahahahaha
mautand 2 years ago
Well done. its enough for those who are looking for truth and are not blind and dumb. please watch all 4 parts
and search this "mutaa - mut3aa - Explained with proof"
tajamulnaqvi 2 years ago
Comment removed
tajamulnaqvi 2 years ago
Comment removed
tajamulnaqvi 2 years ago
And who ever believes that ALLAH and his Quran Issue an order and later find out it was WRONG and desided to abolish it ,IS AN ABSOLUTE KAFIR (KAFIR AL MOTLAQ).
irooni100 2 years ago
Umar did not hear from prophet (SAVA),to change the laws of the Quran,He heard it from SHAITAN RAJEEM ,Who made him Khlifa in the first place.
irooni100 2 years ago
mutah misyaar in saudia its halal now now in dubai its legal too i m converted shia plus x wahabi who knows better me or u
massive8819 2 years ago
Comment removed
khalid622 2 years ago
thanks for posting this video ,
This is the absolute truth........ a truth and reality that is very hard for the jahils to digest. May God guide us to the straight path.
Yes (According to ahadith and Quran What God nad his massengers said ) the Muteh is abslutly Halal and it is actualy Mustahab and it has Savab.
Since it saves the sociaty from adultry and prostituion. and FAHSHA.
m410m133 2 years ago
Truerightous 3 years ago
Kafir wo jo kalmay mai jama tafreeq karay
Kafir wo jo Azan mai jama tafreeq karay
Kafir wo jo apni maa ko galian they
Kafir wo jo Quran ki hifazat mai khuda k waday pay shak kray
kafir wo jo apni behn k liyay tou muta pasand na kray lakin mashray mai isay aam kray
kafir wo jo Ashra-e-Mubashra pay lan tan kray
Kafir wo jo Abdullah-ibne-saba ka pairokar ho
KAAFIR KAAFIR SHIA KAAFIR
artistdigital 2 years ago 3
(shiapigs) ,ur saying mut3a is haram and discusting, that means ur saying the Quran is full ov bullshit ,istakhfir rabak ya akhi .
shi3a4lyf 3 years ago 3
SUNNI do that shame on sunni
janisar87 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Muta is HARAM
Temporary marriage.. Astugfurullah! What a disgusting act!
Shame on shia!
shiapigs 3 years ago
so all these sunnies books which referennesa are given in the video r written by some basterds u must sa sunnies basterd these books r wrong otherwise that was omer basterd who change the islam education
EXDEOBANDI 3 years ago 2
"mutah" was practiced by the holy prophet of islam & most of the pious sahabas(his companions)! so did the holy prophet & the sahabas commit sin?
twelversessence 3 years ago 2
He practiced this did he create it so he coud have women at the last minute and discard of them? This is a heartbreaking practice
cymbeli 3 years ago
my question is that u r trying to say these sunnies books r written by some harami moulvis , nd my other question is who is umar gando who can chane quraniq education who give him a right to overooled quran
EXDEOBANDI 3 years ago
sunnis do misyaar and egyptions do urfi
how about that?
alimolahaq 3 years ago
shiapigs 3 years ago
actually Kaafir wo hay jo Khuda ko na maane, not at all what u said, thats why Christians and Jews are not considered Kaafir. What you are experiencing is a mild case of Jihalat, you might wanna get that checked out. That will only be done by saying BAR UMER LANAT!!!
nayem90 3 years ago
Comment removed
saszpalm 3 years ago
Comment removed
saszpalm 3 years ago
mutah is halal. listen you sunni you people don't have the right to add or remove any part of islam.
exsunni 3 years ago 3
Dude this is sick. In Islam temporary marriage is prohibited. Scenario that you are referring to is if you decide to divorce your wife before you had sex with her, you don't have to pay mahr (bridal money)( it is advised still though) but if you did than it is a must. But it docent refer to temporary marriage at all. it is talking about legitimate marriage.
tubeAbdullah 3 years ago
TurkmenIRAQI4LIFE (2 months ago) Show Hide 0 Marked as spam Reply | Spam The Prophet (saws) was only allowed for a very short time... and then the Prophet (saws) forbade it...
...do you then accuse the Holy Prophet (saww) of being sick?
because surely you must accept what your scholars claim that he (saww) allowed it at least for a while!
bakhtash 3 years ago
My friend the main idea of this video and other like it is that temporary marriage is something that is still halal and it is not and it is sick. I can say that drinking alcohol is sick and stupid and every muslim would agree, but Mohammed(pbuh) did not forbade it right away. To try and justify it right now that is just wrong, also to misinterpret quran quoting verses that relate to other things and not muta is totally wrong.
tubeAbdullah 3 years ago
no akhee, the Holy Prophet (saww) never commanded people to drink alcohol, right?
But even according to your own sources he did command people to commit mut3a, and according to our sources he allowed it and only 3umar forbade it and so you are the ypocrite if you follow the 3umar!
bakhtash 3 years ago
Akhee bring me ahadith where Mohammed commanded muta. There are so many ahadith from Al-Bukhari saying otherwise. And quranic verses that this idiot brought to prove muta... just read them yourself in the contest and that's would be enough for you.
Another thing would you give me in muta your daughter for an hour? And then to my friend for an hour, and then to me again?
What about waiting period that is prescribed in the quran that was OMAR too???!!! God you people are ignorant.
tubeAbdullah 3 years ago
Muta is HARAM
Temporary marriage.. Astugfurullah! What a disgusting act!
Shame on shia!
nav1nav2nav3 3 years ago
some hadiths that show that mu'ta is haram:
Muslim :: Book 8 : Hadith 3261
Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 62 :: Hadith 52
Bukhari :: Book 9 :: Volume 86 :: Hadith 91
Bukhari :: Book 5 :: Volume 59 :: Hadith 527
Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 62 :: Hadith 50
Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 67 :: Hadith 432
Muslim :: Book 8 : Hadith 3264
Muslim :: Book 21 : Hadith 4763
layziethabone 3 years ago 2
The Prophet (saws) was only allowed for a very short time... and then the Prophet (saws) forbade it...
TurkmenIRAQI4LIFE 3 years ago
Mut3a was prohibited by the Prophet (saws)... and it´s not allowed until the youm al ghiyamah... and to come to the Verse in Quran alkarim... that´s just the interpretation of shias....
TurkmenIRAQI4LIFE 3 years ago
ignorant ingorant and stupid ! its a shame that majority of people dont understand the classical arabic .. you really gotta look at the texts that are from africa of quran and hadith.
juliayg77 3 years ago
Verse 2:196 is strictly about pilgrimage and makes no mention of this filth called Mutaa. And 4:24 is about financial rights of the divorced woman, which Islam protected. How can anybody twist these two verses and misinterpret them to mean legal prostitution is beyond me.
May Allah guide his creation.
MoslimDude 3 years ago
watch parts 2 - 4 and think before you talk
shorty40merza 3 years ago
Alright, I have endured watching the rest of your videos. It's a pity, you speak Arabic and you are western educated and yet you fail to understand the basic message of the holy Quran. What is Haram or Halal is very clear. And prostitution, make no mistake about it "Mutaa" is prostitution", is Haram.
MoslimDude 3 years ago
Blaming Omar (r.a.a) or cherry picking contradictory Ahadiths about the topic doesn't prove your position.
Try to put those Ahadiths in their proper context. The exceptions that might have happened to turning the blind eye to Mutaa were in times of war. 1400 years ago, when armies marched for months and camped far from home for months and years even.
What excuse do you Shia have today where traveling is at fast speed?
MoslimDude 3 years ago
There is no doubt about it, Mutaa is Zinaa which is Haram. Marriage is sacred in Islam. And a woman is not a commodity for your temporary entertainment (Mutaa).
Try to learn the proper ways of Islam by looking at the big picture of the divine message.
May Allah guide us both to what is best in this life and the next. Peace.
MoslimDude 3 years ago 2
your funnt man,,, since when did wars stop and armies stop??? army people go for months,,, and most of them are gay,,, look at saudi stats say that 50% are gay... and sunies invented a million types of marriage , misyar , misyaf .....
shorty40merza 3 years ago
so your comapnions were prostitutes ? the doughter of abubakr was prostitute ?
shorty40merza 3 years ago
brother shorty40merza you should use this video as a response to zakah1's 2hour video about mutah
ziyarat4imams 4 years ago
actually brother Zakah made his vedio as a response to my arabic version of this one,,, so i translated the arabic one to english and its what you see right here in this 4 parts,,, i am trying to promote it so it gets heard by those who visit zakahs one...
shorty40merza 4 years ago
very good job
dlinkdj 4 years ago