When did Korean start this Korean crap? Ah hahahahahaha! Let me guess! It must be 5000 years of Korean art! Ah hahahahahaha! It's so funny to see the inferior copy of Japanese Kendo, which was made after ww2. Do you have a brain, stupid Korean? Nobody would buy such a stupid Korean lie!
Why does the Japanese accuse the forged Korea samurai and Korea martial arts?
As for the reason, Korea samurai and the Korea martial arts of the imitation insist on a genuine Japanese samurai and the origin of the martial arts, and this is because it pollutes a Japanese samurai and the honor of the martial arts, and an usurption does Japan samurai culture.
@enushisama, you can say whatever you want. Haidong Gumdo is Korean, and unrelated to any japanese style, unless Gicheon and Shim Gumdo are Japanese-and they aren't. I can see clearly you are Taiwanese/Chinese troll who wishes he was Japanese. You should be happy to be yourself and not copy Japanese. BTW your Super-7 girl group really shouldn't copy Korean girl group So Nyeo Shi Dae and song "hoot" That is really lame.
Where did you get "original text from, this is what I am asking you? I'm sure you do not own a physical copy of the book, somewhere are you getting this from? Or are you just cut and pasting every other Japanese Nationalists "selected quotes?"
본국검 本国劒 (KoreanSword) From 무예도보통지(武藝圖譜通志): It appears Wubei Zhi ( 武備志) written by Mao Yuanyi (茅元儀) acquired the book of sword combat from Chosun considering he compared Chosun sword methods with Dang Un's. It is obvious Chosun Had already developed the manual of Bon Guk Gum ( 본국검 本国劒) as they were compared to Japanese Ssangsu
제독검 (提督劍) Not Chinese! 제독검 is traced back to General Yi Yu Song -A Chinese General of KOREAN Decent! His 5th descendent, Yi Won, had Korean concubine who had some Chun Keun. Chun Keun was given Yi Won's sword. Around 1746 Mu Chun, Chun Keun's descendent still had the sword and the historical facts of the sword were engraved for him by Yi Un Sang.
@enushisama Yeah whatever ....the Muye Dobo Tongji mentions many korean martial arts such as various types of swords, spears, halberds as well as unarmed combat, and the whole point of it was to revitalise korean martial arts which went out of practise during the Joseon dynasty. Therefore, korea had a very rich martial history particularly in the three kingdoms period. Also, why is copying and sharing such a big deal? They are neighbouring countries and will have influenced each other.
If they say this is Kendo and put the name on the tile, no one blames them. The problem is Koreans usually start claiming that Kendo originated from korea....
Because there is not even a temple, a work of art and a park and a theater, a historic site and the library do it without documents in Seoul if there is not the force that the religion building in 清 and Japan gives in Seoul.
These ppl dont know about asian history. They dont even know how japan it self originated... Why do u think japan burned the korean history down and so many koreans risked their lives to protect it? Stfu if u dont know anything.
Why does the Japanese accuse the forged Korea samurai and Korea martial arts?
As for the reason, Korea samurai and the Korea martial arts of the imitation insist on a genuine Japanese samurai and the origin of the martial arts, and this is because it pollutes a Japanese samurai and the honor of the martial arts, and an usurption does Japan samurai culture.
South Korea began to plagiarize the Japanese martial arts from the late 20th century. Korean martial arts is nothing to the history of Korea. Individual martial arts was not developed in the Joseon Dynasty(Korea).
Taekwondo plagiarized the Shotokan Karate. Tang Soo Do plagiarized Gojyuryu Karate. Haidong Gumdo and Kumdo plagiarized Kenjutsu and Kendo. Hapkido plagiarized the Daitoryu Jujutsu and Aikido. Yudo plagiarized Judo. Hwa Rang Do is not historical martial arts. Hwa Rang was dancer.
There is not the fact that there was a samurai in history of the Korean Peninsula.
There is not the social system-like background where there was a samurai in Korea.
By the rank system of Li-regimed Korea, how you can exist (prove it)
In imitation of a Japanese samurai and the form of the martial arts, stop that I intend so that I insist on a Japanese samurai and the origin of the martial arts, and an usurption does honor and samurai culture.
@wolfpack13000 well it should be remembered, twice in Japan's Sengoku Jidai, Toyotomi Hideyoshi invaded Korea with the intent to take over China. During this period, the Samurai raped and pillaged throughout Korea. And before you assume im putting down the Samurai, i come from a Japanese family.
Neo Nazi Japanese Nationalist are the only ones complaining about who made the curved blade. Who the hell invented the automobile and curry and blue jeans then. Stop all the FUCKING hating, you guys sound like little bitches. Japan did not invent the curved blade you morons. Stop arguing for fuck sakes.
South Korea begins to copy the Japanese martial arts from the late 20th century. Individual martial arts was not developed in the Joseon Dynasty(Korea). Taekwondo, Haidong Gumdo, Kumdo, Hapkido, Yudo is nothing to the history of Korea.
Taekwondo copied the Shotokan Karate. Haidong Gumdo and Kumdo copied Kendo. Hapkido copied the Daitoryu Jujutsu and Aikido. Yudo copied Judo. Hwa Rang Do is not historical martial arts. Hwa Rang is dancer in the Silla and Kogryo Dynasty.
@shachikujira Shotokan is not Japanese original culture, it was Okinawan's, and before that from China. how can you claim it as Japan's original culture then be upset when another country modified it and integrated it with their own martial arts?
@sakura0jp0aikidodesu Can you list an instance where a child with a wooden sword in Korea killed someone with a wooden sword? I lived in Korea and watched the children train and the discipline the children receive for treating the wooden sword without respect was severe! You would be sued in the United States for doing those things to a child. I myself teach children and they know they will be severly punished for playing around with any weapon.
@sakura0jp0aikidodesu Can you list an instance where a child with a wooden sword in Korea killed someone with a wooden sword? I lived in Korea and watched the children train and the dicsipline
Why does the origin even matter... It's an art... And from what I see many of those who practise it are incredibly skilled swordsmen.
The principles and lessons within any martial art remain virtually the same regardless of style or history, in the end each will drive you to your physical and mental limits, and to the same understanding.
I respect simply what they are able to do with mind and sword... Not what the sword 'is'. ^^
Korean Gumdo is very dangerous art,since they let children hold wooden swords or imitation Katana easily.In Japan we can't use its easily till master give the pardon.why Kendo use bamboo sword?since even just wooden or imitation sword can kill.if the children kill other people slily,could you accept the blame? Korean Gumdo show the brassy performances and get many student and money teaching in hazard without any definite knowledge.this is serious problem for society.
So very sad to see a bunch of Japanese descendants and others who have affinity for a nation who still dwell on uttering pure ignorance out of their asses. LOL Can you see the obvious loathing of another nation in your stupid statements.The few who think they are represent the truth of an art or culture without having to study the history before opening their shit hole. sad sad sad......boo fucking whooooo
Gumdo swords actually aren't katana. There are slight differences to them, though they still look very similar. The differences can only be seen up close, not in videos like these.
Kinda hard for Koreans to not mimick other cultures martial arts when their own were made illegal during Japanese occupation. What you see when you look at Gum Do and Taekwondo is Korea trying to make what they were aloud to learn (Japanese martial arts) as close as they can to their own arts which have almost completely died out.
Please stop mimicking Japanese. Why do you use samurai swords? Please be proud of your own country's culture. Due to a part of Koreans like you, all Koreans are fooled by Japanese. You are ridiculing your ancestors.
korea was the only nation that used the two handed sword technique
in japan they only used the katana and wakizashi when they didnt need their katana. only miyamoto musashi used the two sword technique but had his own way of doing it.(probably uses the japanese swords because you don't see a whole lot of korean swords made.)
idk who had the curved blade first....but gum-do would destroy any old traditional sword martial art...because the koreans invented gurilla warfare. not the vietnamese or the british or any other culture...koreans historically used all sorts of things as wepons to dispatch invaders so you dont suppose its possible that some korean guy killed some japanese dude and picked up his sword and hacked up the other japanese invaders because its simply just a good sword?
I wish I have those mats they have,I can easily do those cuts,with their super thin samgakdo.It requires almost no strangth nor skill,But I got to say,The samgakdo design is great for mat cutting.The losely woven straw mats are also great for show,You can never mess up a cut with those,and it does not put up any restriction during cutting. so much quicker and fancier motions can be acheived.
It's a martial arts demo, folks. Enough with the racism and all this fear and hate. It doesn't even matter where exactly the disciplines comes from directly. It matters that it exists now and it's a serious discipline now.
Also, as a matter of fact, straight and curved blades had their place in both Japanese and Korean wars in the past. So it's false to even assume that one nationality holds an exclusive right to the creation of such blades. Also, Persians did curved blades eons before everyone
@Shippoyasha though those who are ignorant of east asia usually misunderstand,japanese culture is not very similar with chinese and korean one.
japanese one is often distinguished from them. en.wikipedia. org/wiki/The_Clash_of_Civilizations
we are just sick of the korean's lie that every japanese one is their origine.now it seems to resemble japanese one account of japan's rule period.even they steal chinese one.
this is not racism but truth.there are many videos made by chinese criticize korea.
@shachikujira They probably have derived from them from the natural cultural exchanges. It doesn't matter in the end. I think you are taking too much offense from the crazy Korean zealots who actually thinks it's from Korea first.
What about respectful Korean martial artists who just practice their craft seriously? In the end, I would think most martial artists hold great respect regardless of nationality. I think that's pretty important. Also, Korea has plenty of native arts other than these.
@Shippoyasha if you call them crazy,it is all korea.each korean copy culture association declared their origine.most the koreans also believe it.in the end,japan kendo association put the statement against them on internet.as for history education,they have taught japan exploited korea.but the fact is the other way around.there are many grounds japan invested in korea without return though,they would not admit it.they are too proud to face it.
@Shippoyasha i am ok how they hate us on the basis of wrong knowledge but i cant forgive they steal culture,do business or sell their bodies pretending to be japanese.even big companies like samsung do it.in taiwan,a korean pretened to be japanese when she commited a crime.they join japan expo and insist the title change asia expo.they should hold korea expo.they are truly crazy.i just want korea not to involve in japan.
@shachikujira is wrong on this statment because i studied both Taekwondo and isshinryu and those two arts are nothing alike. nice try tho. come back after 7 yrs of taekwondo and 6 years of karate and tell me that they are the same.
@pcporter78 my statement was not accurate.as for taekwondo,崔泓熙 named it had learned shotokan karate and invented taekwondo.do of taekwondo is road in japanese.japanese traditional cultures often use do such as sado,kado,koudo,kendo,judo,karatedo and so on.the feature is not seen in chinese civilization.their outfits and color obi show japanese features too.but i think taekwondo is aldready their original culture.it is ok.you think the others are also korean original?
@shachikujira is it Japanese invasions of Korea?you think once korean style kendo or something existed,right?i think you misunderstand korean history.
William Elliot Griffis 『Korea the Hermit Nation』（1882）
Korea has no samurai. She lacks what Japan has always had - a cultured body of men, superbly trained in both mind and body, the soldier and scholar in one, who held to high ideal of loyalty, patriotism, and sacrifice for country.
@shachikujira kendo is japanese, gumdo is korean. are you saying that japan, a lone island to the east, learned how to do everything by themselves? of course you guys got ideas from korea and china. how else would have japan become civilized? im just saying that not to say that only korea stole from japan. accept facts
@Cubalisk gumdo didnt exist by nature.do you understand a katana is japanese original stuff?japanese marcial arts dont exist without samurai.of course,korea didnt have samurai.
japanese culture have something with not korea but china.korea was a path of chinese culture.peninsula of korea exists between japan and china by chance.korea was a slave of china for a long time.korean culture is chinese culture itself.japan changed chinese culture to original culture because of island.face the truth.
@shachikujira are you saying that the lone island in the middle of the ocean learned how to create weapons, use steel, farm rice and other grains, use hiragana and katakana (your writing system) was changed chinese culture? japan learned writing chinese letters from korea, and also how to use steel. if it wasnt for steel no swords or gumdo of today. Know before you argue, and you argument does not have any evidence of korea = china.
@shachikujira blacksoulsaion is very right, he is telling the truth. the katana is japanese, but japan learned blacksmithing from korea. accept the facts. and btw... your arguments have totally no supporting facts at all.
@shachikujira gumdo is a changed form of kendo since ever japan 's imperialism over asia. yes i understand that gumdo = kendo, but now you're just being dumb. wtf? silla and baekje a part of japan? dude, we fucking used korean instead of japanese language, how is that japan? you are not making sense. how is it japanese? the world knows that it is korean history, japanese people should stop with the lies. also about china and korea...
@shachikujira ...since when was a korea a slave of china? you people in japan are learning some outrageous historical facts. right now, you are trying to disagree with history confirmed by the whole world. only japan thinks that way maybe, cuz they're bunch of liars who dont accept facts. and stop saying everything is your japans, you dont even have facts to support how baekje and silla is japans. for me, i dont need to prove it, cuz the world already knows and you are obviously lying.
@shachikujira i have to say, go learn history from lvl 1 again.
btw if japan didnt learn it from korea, you must have learned it from china. however that is very unlikely, because korea is much more closer to japan, and korea at that time had advanced technology (for that time) along with china.
@shachikujira i will agree with you that kendo is japanese i understand. gumdo isnt korea stealing kendo, its like any other country playing a famous sport or art. however, why i am arguing with u is that the japanese people here keep on saying SOTP STEALING JAPANESE CULTURE, which is obviously really immature and dumb. we are not stealing it, we are practicing it like japan playing soccer, a sport from europe.
@Cubalisk many koreans are claiming origin of japanese culture is korean.such as marcial arts,sado,kado,japanese garden,ukiyoe,manga,japanese great man,japanese language and so on.so All Japan Kendo Federation posted an article kendo is japanese original culture on english website.
Chinese ancient historical book "Book of Song(宋書)," Goguryeo's "Gwanggaeto Stele,"Japanese one "Nihon Shoki(日本書紀)"Korean one“Samguksigi(三国史記)“say that about baekje and silla.
@shachikujira i found blacksoulsaion's claim was written on page of kumdo on wikipedia.he thought wikipedia was right.
there are many video about korean history on youtube whchi japanese and chinese posted.you yourself must eventually verify whether it is right or not.
sorry,koreans often swear at me.so i tend to use an aggressive word.but i dont mind if you report it.
@shachikujira its ok, i guess that japan learned more from china than korea. kendo is japanese culture, which came over to korea during japanese imperialism and yatayayayayayayayaya it became popular blah blah blah yes conclusion : kendo is japanese, gumdo is korean pronounciation of kendo, but basicially same thing except for some minor details which myself idk. good bye~
@Cubalisk you dont understand at all.japanese culture is derivation of chinese.korean is a part of chinese.japanese culture directly has nothing to do with korean.korean culture is by far more similar to chinese than japanese by nature.so korea,too,has culture which japan has is totally wrong.
@shachikujira no japanese thinks japan acquired korean culture .koreans dont realize them,so they are insisting on their origin of japanese culture.it is natural that we should tell them not to steal japanese culture.btw,they are insisting on origin of chinese too lol of course,chinese are angry with them too.
@shachikujira Korean culture is NOT a part of Chinese culture...just saying, and i have a right to say that because i'm South Korean, so i know what i'm talking about
@shachikujira 1. Korean culture is not a derivation of chinese at all. Korea existed as a nation for many many thousands of years, since the GOGURYO kingdom. China now claiming goguryo as Chinese history is nothing short of preposterous and is being done so that in the case of a collapse of north korea with the death of Kim Jong Il, they can insert their military and claim north korea as a chinese region. Korea has adopted Confucian ideals but their culture has existed for a very long time.
@shachikujira 2. Korea has existed as a nation many many years before Japan existed as a nation. People from the Beakje kingdom introduced their culture to the native people of Japan. It was only then that Japan was united as a nation and had a common culture. Japanese people deny this vehemently but the Japanese emperor has recently admitted that he has Korean blood. Of course, Japanese culture has developed on it's own a great deal since then, but it's seen that Korea has been very influential
@shachikujira 3. In modern times, Japanese culture is seen as the 'origin' of similar aspects between korea and japan because Japan has shared its culture with the rest of the world much earlier and for longer than korea. Korea opened it's doors to foreigners very late compared to Japan.
@shachikujira 4. Modern technology and culture (electronics, automotive) have been burrowed from Japan by Korea because Japan has been developed much more than Korea. In the distant past this was the other way round, where Korea was the more advanced and developed country and Japan burrowed many things from Korea. Recently though, modern Korea has improved to the point that it is now improving without burrowing from Japanese modern culture and technology.
korea was nothing but a path to introduce it to japan as long as i know.it is said both baekje and silla were under the rule of japan in 4th and 5th century by old historical data such as book of song(宋書),gwanggaeto stele,nihon shoki(日本書紀),samguksigi(三国史記) and so on.goguryo and baekje were different from now korea in ethnic.so strictly speaking,the emperor dont have korean blood.
@fdota korea originally had been a part of chinese civilization until it was be set free by japan.now korea is similar to japan because of japan's ruling.
korea was later than japan for 1,000 years before japan's modernizing it.it goes without saying that it didnt have money economy at that time,and what is worse,it didnt have even skill of bending wood or dyeing.so they had been wearing only white dress.you dont know japan spreaded hungle,do you?
@shachikujira wrong. just wrong. baekje was never under rule of the japanese. you say the korean language was spread by japanese people... if baekje was being ruled by the japanese, why did they create and spread hangul among the people in stead of introducing japanese? like japan tried to do during the annexation of korea in the early 1900's. u say korea didn't have dyes for clothes and skilled woodworking? completely outrageous and baseless accusation and bigotry.
@shachikujira i think that you should think carefully what your own government is teaching you. think logically and without bias rather than coming rashly to convenient conclusions. your half knowledge and blind patriotism is only fueling you to spread hate and racism to others.
@fdota it is not korean language but hungle which japan spread in 1900's.in japan,govt directly has nothing to do with making textbooks.what i am saying is true.korea was one of the poorest countries in asia at that time.i am just opposed to korea's lies.
watch?v=A7a-V0i9zK8
taiwanese knows the truth,so many of them dont hate japan except chinese.
@shachikujira you're claiming that japan spread korea's own written language in the 1900's? it is common knowledge that hangul was in use since the 15th. what japanese people did during the annexation of korea was to teach all things japanese and forbid the learning and practice of korean. and why wouldn't this happen? korea signed a (coerced) treaty to become part of japan. but why you claim that japan spread the korean hangul in korea during this period is so outrageous it blows my mind away.
@fdota hangle had been used in newspaper published by japanese and korean and taught in schools.you must have noticed the education of korean history was wrong,when you had watched the video.
hungle was not so commonly used because the korean had worshiped chinese culture,on the other hand looked down on others'.even their own character.google sinocentrism.
@shachikujira also you are not making sense, u are not supporting how baekje and silla is japanese, and how korea was a slave of china with facts. you're just being totally dumb and stubborn with facts that never existed, only in the corrupted mind of japanese historians.
Even if u want 2 stick to your Samurai Fantasy Addictions; It was Jpn in the first place that destroyed Kr Culture and Then forced the learning of their ways on Kr. At the same time many Koreans STUDIED Jpns martial arts before, during, and after occupation. They are merely doing what ANY asian or non (actually) has done with all martial arts since the beginning. Study, adopt, and enhance. Kr has been a huddle since the beginning between china and kr; they share alot n adopted a lot t/o history
@BlackSoulsAion you are fundamentally wrong.japan didnt destroy korean culture.korea had no foundation to create martial arts. how to make a katana is japanese original method shows koreans'lies.the culture that japan received was not korean but chinese.korea was nothing but a path of culture.you seem to swallow korean's claim.
they dont know even their own history.they have believed japan hindered modernization of korea.watch?v=94umHT7aBu4
@shachikujira Japan "did" destroy Korean Culture in Occupations (more then once) Thats like saying the jews had not holocaust. it came from CHINA (i said first -_- and also Korea. Same story with Karate,and a million other things.) Its about the evolution of 1 sided blade. Which Japan made into a curve. Korea had many martial arts styles. Which were eliminated by both themselves and occupation. Read my comment again. I "Said" What u just said. So theres no argument; other then ur hate 4 korea.
@BlackSoulsAion I luv Japan. Im not defending Korea; Im defending the truth. I dont care about the Jpnese that still think they r the asian super race. ur a well known racist troll it seems on utube. If you would like ill make better sentence 4 you. The _____ came by way of China and Korea. This Jpnese atking Kor on utube is so damn immature.I didnt say who taught who lol. B glad the evil US didnt wipe u all from the face of the Earth. Btw -blocking- Try focusing more on the future my friend.
@BlackSoulsAion it is hard for me to understand your english.
your thought is absolutely one-sided,korean itself.rebutting their lies makes me a racist?
i say again.how to make a katana is japanese original method.old korean data indicate a katana is japanese too.show me grounds of your some claim.and what did japan destroy?
People that keep throwing out Korea copy's Japan are clueless. Read your history of the wars and the occupations. I love Japan and I love Japanese Culture; I favor it over Korean; However these lies need to stop being spread.
Its like telling the Japanese to stop Copying the Okinawans when Karate styles spread. A HUGE amount of martial art techniques and blades/weapons etc; migrated from China and Korea to Japan. Both have not COPIED but rather adopted and then given there own taste.
(2) training in Hakama's? why I have no idea but there 2 style swords methods certainly where deadly and effective....All of you should read history before making comments on shit YOU KNOW NOTHING ABOUT!!!!! the only problem I have with these vids is the practistioners should be wearing traditional Silla clothing or robes instead of Japanese Hakama(Seems to be a modern thing) with all the Japanese influences in this Silla art form nowdays,
(3)and before you all start on me by the way I practice Japanese Kenjutsu for 15 years now and I still see the orriginal Korean in this martial style of the Silla....
(1)Gumdo the way of the Silla Knights of the kingdom of the Silla (57 B.C-935 A.D) who by the way kicked the shit out of the Japanese in 663 A.D are an ancient group of highly skilled warriors whos style blades and tacticts where simmilar to the Japanese but not japanese (many asian styles have simalarities) they spent most of there time training there art out in nature and mountanous areas. The reason you all think JAPANESE is because these guys are wearing japanese style Gi
good point. Arent we all wearing Japanese style gi usually? Hapkido, Some Shaolin kungfu, BJJ, they all wear a version of a Japanese gi, but they don tmake it japanese...very good point highlander
I think they are good at what they are doing, just not right to claim origin as korean. I mean, come on. They are using a katana and a wakizashi what more is there to say
This thing wa created 1980's by Korean "wannabe Japanese" monk. Very shallow stuff. No elegance backed up by historical facts nor real Samurai battles.
These guys cut with so little effort it's amazing. You'd think their swords were made of aluminum from the speed and accuracy they're cutting at. Damn, these guys are pro.
the gumdo swords we use in class are slightly curved and as i was aware korean swords are used even in the hwa-rang dynasty but if you sit back and think about it any style or art that is being practiced for true passion, self-defense and to stay physically fit is never wrong you don't knock basketball players for liking the sport when all you ever liked was football. we all are good at something so let each person find their own tru passion. i am studing multiple arts right now i love them all
it is unfortunate that so much of korean history was lost during the war, and even more unfortunate that the korean people have to rely on retracing the roots of gumdo through japanese swordsmanship. im still hopeful that there is someone that knows the true identity of korean swordsmanship, and that the art has not been totally lost.
This has been flagged as spam show
Why does GUMDO use the similar Japanese sword?
KURIGATA and SAGEO for thrusting into a belt are the feature of Japanese sword.
I can never find them by existing old Korean sword or historical record
enushisama 2 months ago
When did Korean start this Korean crap? Ah hahahahahaha! Let me guess! It must be 5000 years of Korean art! Ah hahahahahaha! It's so funny to see the inferior copy of Japanese Kendo, which was made after ww2. Do you have a brain, stupid Korean? Nobody would buy such a stupid Korean lie!
NoNoSpice 2 months ago
Why does the Japanese accuse the forged Korea samurai and Korea martial arts?
As for the reason, Korea samurai and the Korea martial arts of the imitation insist on a genuine Japanese samurai and the origin of the martial arts, and this is because it pollutes a Japanese samurai and the honor of the martial arts, and an usurption does Japan samurai culture.
I want you to wake from shameful Korea clown.
It is only a monkey clown.
yuukoku11 2 months ago
The Korean martial arts and fencing are monkey business.
Because there is not the culture that there was a samurai in the Korean history.
The Korean uses a castle of Japan and the sculpture including the Asura by an image strategy in imitation of the style of the Japanese samurai in HP.
I understand it if I examine it, but, in the Korean Peninsula, culture and the castle of the samurai do not have the trace.
I want you to wake from shameful Korea clown.
It is only a monkey clown.
yuukoku11 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
“There is no sword art which has continued without breaking off from ancient times in Korea.”
朝鮮王朝實録：The Annals of the Korean Dynasty
【June 11, 1480】矧惟國人, 不慣槍劍, 專業弓矢, 爲禦敵之備
The people are not accustomed to use of sword or spear, defended from enemies only by archery...
【October 13, 1592】上敎政院曰“我國絶無劒手”
The king said “There is no swordman in our country at all...”
【July 11, 1594】我國自古劍術不傳
The king said “Any sword art has not been succeeded from ancient time in our country...”
enushisama 3 months ago
@taihuu25go Great another Taiwanese/ Chinese wannabe Japanese troll.
HDGDisnotfromkendo 3 months ago
@HDGDisnotfromkendo
Inferior Korean wannabe Japanese Samurai. Don't make me laugh. You must be Chosun STUPID Ninja.
77rouji 3 months ago
Korea under the dominion of China
watch?v=1MAE1Ul35A0&feature=feedf
taihuu25go 3 months ago
@enushisama, you can say whatever you want. Haidong Gumdo is Korean, and unrelated to any japanese style, unless Gicheon and Shim Gumdo are Japanese-and they aren't. I can see clearly you are Taiwanese/Chinese troll who wishes he was Japanese. You should be happy to be yourself and not copy Japanese. BTW your Super-7 girl group really shouldn't copy Korean girl group So Nyeo Shi Dae and song "hoot" That is really lame.
HDGDisnotfromkendo 3 months ago
@HDGDisnotfromkendo
A Korean unique part.
The Korean introduces beginning page of "Muyedobotongji" written, "there are not the martial arts in Korea from ancient times" to people and says.
"There were martial arts in Korea for a long time"
Background of Korean martial arts
watch?v=_Xz_6MUYHcM
taihuu25go 3 months ago
Comment removed
HDGDisnotfromkendo 3 months ago
Where did you get "original text from, this is what I am asking you? I'm sure you do not own a physical copy of the book, somewhere are you getting this from? Or are you just cut and pasting every other Japanese Nationalists "selected quotes?"
HDGDisnotfromkendo 3 months ago
Comment removed
enushisama 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@HDGDisnotfromkendo I have the PDF files which copied all pages of the Muye Dobo Tonji. There are 79MB. It is not from website.
However, you will find it or similar graphics files easily, if it searches.
But if you do not know Chinese characters, it will be worthless for you.
enushisama 3 months ago
@enushisama no, please show me web address or something where you are getting Muye Dobo Tongji from. No quotes.
HDGDisnotfromkendo 3 months ago
@HDGDisnotfromkendo It is not from website.
I read the original text by myself.
enushisama 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
본국검 本国劒 (KoreanSword) From 무예도보통지(武藝圖譜通志): It appears Wubei Zhi ( 武備志) written by Mao Yuanyi (茅元儀) acquired the book of sword combat from Chosun considering he compared Chosun sword methods with Dang Un's. It is obvious Chosun Had already developed the manual of Bon Guk Gum ( 본국검 本国劒) as they were compared to Japanese Ssangsu
HDGDisnotfromkendo 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@HDGDisnotfromkendo Mr. Mao did not compare sword art. He compared “the situation".
等韻dang un= Pronunciation of ancient Chinese characters. It was found in the western.
尚書= Chinese ancient books. It was found in Japan.
Chinese lost things were found in foreign countries. Sword art is also the same.
He did not call it “Korean sword art”. He called it “the lost Chinese sword art”.
You should read the original text with Chinese characters.
今其方不伝断簡残編中有訣歌不詳其説近有好事者得之朝鮮其勢法倶備固知中国失而求四裔不独西方之等韻日本之尚書也
enushisama 3 months ago
제독검 (提督劍) Not Chinese! 제독검 is traced back to General Yi Yu Song -A Chinese General of KOREAN Decent! His 5th descendent, Yi Won, had Korean concubine who had some Chun Keun. Chun Keun was given Yi Won's sword. Around 1746 Mu Chun, Chun Keun's descendent still had the sword and the historical facts of the sword were engraved for him by Yi Un Sang.
HDGDisnotfromkendo 4 months ago
Comment removed
enushisama 3 months ago
@HDGDisnotfromkendo It is written to the Muedobotonji like this.
The Chinese officer駱尚志 advised the Korean minister柳成龍.
"The Korean army is weak. But, the Japanese army has not been withdrawn from Korea yet. You should teach soldiers martial arts. "
He chooses ten Chinese and began to make Koreans teach sword art and others.
Since 駱尚志 was the admiral李如松's subordinate, it called the admiral sword.
enushisama 3 months ago
@enushisama Please show me your source for Muye Dobo Tongji.
HDGDisnotfromkendo 3 months ago
@HDGDisnotfromkendo The admiral sword on the Muye Dobo Tonji
“懲毖録曰癸巳夏病臥漢城墨寺洞天将駱尚志訪余臥次因言朝鮮微弱而賊猶在境椉天未廻修練兵法可以守国余即馳啓使禁軍韓士立招募七十余人往駱公請教駱発張六三等十人爲教師練習槍剣狼筅等技即駱是李提督票下提督剣之名”
enushisama 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
liar liar liar liar liar liar liar!!
kururuyuu 4 months ago
ugly korean!
fake culture!
tetupop12 5 months ago
Comment removed
tetupop12 5 months ago
What that?
KARATE DOUGI&NIHON TOU
(Karate martial arts Costume & Japanese Sword)
mrMars1999 5 months ago
何で日本刀使ってるんだ？？
einwasser 5 months ago
oh great japan.
isikawa46 5 months ago
why too many peoples talking about cultures and history only.
your ages not know about lots of old history of the world.
japan invated our country to destory it and tring to change our culture and history.
you should more respect for the people who trained it hard for they like.
that's it.
korwarrior 5 months ago
Korea and swordmanship
watch?v=uQ5zOKB3yzw
BuffonSarutobi 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Koreans lie naturally as breathing and a thief country.
It is not nice to steal culture.
Chinese people are angry. Thais people too.
Japanese people are feeling sad.
japanohji 5 months ago
why they used Japanese sword???
it's fake culture.
korean's lie.
they don't have "do"
calibianable 6 months ago
Nice video. Much more energy than regular mat cutting.
katanamaru1 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Please watch
watch?v=uQ5zOKB3yzw
enushisama 6 months ago
武藝圖譜通志Muye Dobo Tongji (1790) : Comprehensive Illustrated Manual of Martial Arts in Korea
【 It is the official document at Korean Dynasty, written by The Korean King order in the 18th century 】
國練兵之制三軍練于郊，衛士練于禁苑，其禁苑練兵盛自 光廟朝，然止弓矢一技而已如槍劍法技，既未之聞焉，
Archery was the only martial art that had been practiced by Korean soldiers. They have no skills of sword or spear fighting.
購得戚繼光紀效新書遣訓局郎韓嶠遍質東來將士
Therefore, Koreans began learning sword skills and others from Chinese .
enushisama 6 months ago
@enushisama Yeah whatever ....the Muye Dobo Tongji mentions many korean martial arts such as various types of swords, spears, halberds as well as unarmed combat, and the whole point of it was to revitalise korean martial arts which went out of practise during the Joseon dynasty. Therefore, korea had a very rich martial history particularly in the three kingdoms period. Also, why is copying and sharing such a big deal? They are neighbouring countries and will have influenced each other.
ASHJBKH2 5 months ago
@ASHJBKH2 The main sword arts in the Muye Dobo Tongji.
雙手刀 (LongSword) = Japanese sword art
提督劒 (AdmiralSword) = Chinese sword art
雙劒 (DoubleSword) = Chinese sword art
本国劒/鋭刀 (KoreanSword) = The lost sword art. It was only a few documents. Can the martial art be learned only by reading the document?
Where is the sword art of Korea which continues without breaking off from ancient times?
Koreans forgotten own sword art.
"本國之人、何不自傳自習"The author was sad about that.
enushisama 5 months ago
朝鮮王朝實録：The Annals of the choson Dynasty (The True Record of the Korean Dynasty)…
【June 11, 1480】矧惟國人, 不慣槍劍, 專業弓矢, 爲禦敵之備
The people were not accustomed to use of sword or spear, defended from enemies only by archery...
【October 13, 1592】上敎政院曰“我國絶無劒手”
The king said “There was no swordman in our country at all”...
【July 11, 1594】我國自古劍術不傳
There has not been descendent any swordplay from ancient time in our country...
enushisama 6 months ago
Go home kimchi !!
liar is history of Korea.
colony ancient times of China !!
msann100 6 months ago
OINK
evilcutter 6 months ago
If they say this is Kendo and put the name on the tile, no one blames them. The problem is Koreans usually start claiming that Kendo originated from korea....
Silverstein1883 6 months ago
@Silverstein1883 im korean and we give all credit to japan for kendo.
TheLakers987654321 6 months ago
Korea and Her Neighbours(Isabella L. Bird)
Because there is not even a temple, a work of art and a park and a theater, a historic site and the library do it without documents in Seoul if there is not the force that the religion building in 清 and Japan gives in Seoul.
wolfpack13000 6 months ago
Japan does not burn up a Korean book.
Stop the claim of the guess without grounds.
李氏朝鮮 Korea oppresses Buddhism culture in oneself and destroys it.
李氏朝鮮 was Confucianism.
wolfpack13000 6 months ago
These ppl dont know about asian history. They dont even know how japan it self originated... Why do u think japan burned the korean history down and so many koreans risked their lives to protect it? Stfu if u dont know anything.
danksil80 6 months ago
Why do you accuse the Korea martial arts of the imitation?
If an imitation copies brands such as Vuitton or Armani, and an imitation forges it with a genuine article, and a monkey business, can you be angry?
All of you wanting to be the world martial arts do not be deceived.
Only Japan has the genuine samurai and martial arts.
wolfpack13000 6 months ago
False forgery and judgment were over the 海東kumdo at a trial of Korea.
Origin of the samurai of the 海東kumdo and person 士武郎 who insisted got a forgery and judgment by a lie.
wolfpack13000 6 months ago
The Korean martial arts and fencing are monkey business.
Because there is not the culture that there was a samurai in the Korean history.
The Korean uses a castle of Japan and the sculpture including the Asura by an image strategy in imitation of the style of the Japanese samurai in HP.
I understand it if I examine it, but, in the Korean Peninsula, culture and the castle of the samurai do not have the trace.
wolfpack13000 6 months ago
>langying
I translate Japanese mechanically.
(Japanese → English)
Do not you make sense?
I am thankful when I have you understand the meaning of the claim.
wolfpack13000 6 months ago
Why does the Japanese accuse the forged Korea samurai and Korea martial arts?
As for the reason, Korea samurai and the Korea martial arts of the imitation insist on a genuine Japanese samurai and the origin of the martial arts, and this is because it pollutes a Japanese samurai and the honor of the martial arts, and an usurption does Japan samurai culture.
wolfpack13000 7 months ago
@wolfpack13000 Okay, first of all can you please type in a way that your sentences make sense?
langying 6 months ago in playlist Unique Blades
There is not the Korean fact that the samurai existed in history.
There is neither the society scenery created historically nor the inevitability.
Though there is not the base which existed, the person forging Korea samurai spreads a lie.
I imitate a Japanese samurai and divert castles of Japan to their HP and develop the false martial arts that I forged for an image of Japan.
wolfpack13000 7 months ago
What, this?
It is only the dance of the clown.
In front of the true samurai, it is spoiled eyewink.
yuukoku11 7 months ago
ha ha ha....
Liar's Korean people
mimic military arts
This is imitation of Japan
Melchiorbv 7 months ago
I wonder why Korean people are imitating Japanese everything,
kendo,tea ceremony,ninja,samurai,judo,
and arts,foods,religion,comic,etc.
Moreover,they are insisting that those cultures which came from Japan
originated in Korea.
Why? I think, they should be proud of their own history and culture,
need not to MIMIC or STEAL Japanese culture.
lumine66 7 months ago
78 people wish they could cut...(whispering "WOW")
glenntherookie 7 months ago
South Korea began to plagiarize the Japanese martial arts from the late 20th century. Korean martial arts is nothing to the history of Korea. Individual martial arts was not developed in the Joseon Dynasty(Korea).
Taekwondo plagiarized the Shotokan Karate. Tang Soo Do plagiarized Gojyuryu Karate. Haidong Gumdo and Kumdo plagiarized Kenjutsu and Kendo. Hapkido plagiarized the Daitoryu Jujutsu and Aikido. Yudo plagiarized Judo. Hwa Rang Do is not historical martial arts. Hwa Rang was dancer.
unkeihokusai 8 months ago
So funny.
This is Japanese kendo!
ks19220124 8 months ago
JAPAN EXPO Paris will open within 48 hours!!!!!stop exhibiting fake kendo,korean Haidong Gumdo!!!!
watch?v=hix9SGnUz58 english
watch?v=tVJOcwPprVo french
sakura0jp0aikidodesu 8 months ago 2
There is not the fact that there was a samurai in history of the Korean Peninsula.
There is not the social system-like background where there was a samurai in Korea.
By the rank system of Li-regimed Korea, how you can exist (prove it)
In imitation of a Japanese samurai and the form of the martial arts, stop that I intend so that I insist on a Japanese samurai and the origin of the martial arts, and an usurption does honor and samurai culture.
wolfpack13000 8 months ago
Foolish South Korean. Thief South Korean. Deceitful Korea.
arata9 8 months ago
Do not talk about martial arts.
自国の文化に誇りが持てないからまた日本の真似をする。
koisan1000 8 months ago
You should use true Korean traditional sword, without using Japanese sword.
enushisama 8 months ago
A Korean insists on the origin of the samurai mimicking the martial arts of Japan,
This is an act to dirty the honor of the classic Japanese samurai having the long history.
The history of the samurai is because there is nothing for the Korean of the Korea dynasty.
wolfpack13000 9 months ago
@wolfpack13000 well it should be remembered, twice in Japan's Sengoku Jidai, Toyotomi Hideyoshi invaded Korea with the intent to take over China. During this period, the Samurai raped and pillaged throughout Korea. And before you assume im putting down the Samurai, i come from a Japanese family.
MissyMarieN 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Neo Nazi Japanese Nationalist are the only ones complaining about who made the curved blade. Who the hell invented the automobile and curry and blue jeans then. Stop all the FUCKING hating, you guys sound like little bitches. Japan did not invent the curved blade you morons. Stop arguing for fuck sakes.
MASTERNCS 9 months ago
Korea is a liar.
tangeko1 9 months ago 17
South Korea begins to copy the Japanese martial arts from the late 20th century. Individual martial arts was not developed in the Joseon Dynasty(Korea). Taekwondo, Haidong Gumdo, Kumdo, Hapkido, Yudo is nothing to the history of Korea.
Taekwondo copied the Shotokan Karate. Haidong Gumdo and Kumdo copied Kendo. Hapkido copied the Daitoryu Jujutsu and Aikido. Yudo copied Judo. Hwa Rang Do is not historical martial arts. Hwa Rang is dancer in the Silla and Kogryo Dynasty.
unkeihokusai 9 months ago
@shachikujira Shotokan is not Japanese original culture, it was Okinawan's, and before that from China. how can you claim it as Japan's original culture then be upset when another country modified it and integrated it with their own martial arts?
pomminsu 9 months ago
@sakura0jp0aikidodesu Can you list an instance where a child with a wooden sword in Korea killed someone with a wooden sword? I lived in Korea and watched the children train and the discipline the children receive for treating the wooden sword without respect was severe! You would be sued in the United States for doing those things to a child. I myself teach children and they know they will be severly punished for playing around with any weapon.
pomminsu 9 months ago
@sakura0jp0aikidodesu Can you list an instance where a child with a wooden sword in Korea killed someone with a wooden sword? I lived in Korea and watched the children train and the dicsipline
pomminsu 9 months ago
Why does the origin even matter... It's an art... And from what I see many of those who practise it are incredibly skilled swordsmen.
The principles and lessons within any martial art remain virtually the same regardless of style or history, in the end each will drive you to your physical and mental limits, and to the same understanding.
I respect simply what they are able to do with mind and sword... Not what the sword 'is'. ^^
xDrakengardx 10 months ago
Even an amateur has such a thing.
Are not you stupid with a sword as a show?
When Japanese culture is accepted in the world, the Korean wants it.
A child
I turn and why am a kung fu movie?
Do these people think that martial arts are dramas?
Are there really few samurais whom I was able to manage by practice with 2 swords?
Impurity do not hold traditional culture in Japan!
There is always only the culture that was the dependency of the large country in Korea!
koisan1000 10 months ago 3
Why do they copy the Japanese kendo?
yamahanaya 10 months ago 36
Korean Gumdo is very dangerous art,since they let children hold wooden swords or imitation Katana easily.In Japan we can't use its easily till master give the pardon.why Kendo use bamboo sword?since even just wooden or imitation sword can kill.if the children kill other people slily,could you accept the blame? Korean Gumdo show the brassy performances and get many student and money teaching in hazard without any definite knowledge.this is serious problem for society.
sakura0jp0aikidodesu 10 months ago 2
So very sad to see a bunch of Japanese descendants and others who have affinity for a nation who still dwell on uttering pure ignorance out of their asses. LOL Can you see the obvious loathing of another nation in your stupid statements.The few who think they are represent the truth of an art or culture without having to study the history before opening their shit hole. sad sad sad......boo fucking whooooo
MASTERNCS 10 months ago
Gumdo swords actually aren't katana. There are slight differences to them, though they still look very similar. The differences can only be seen up close, not in videos like these.
SheenaMalfoy 10 months ago
Kinda hard for Koreans to not mimick other cultures martial arts when their own were made illegal during Japanese occupation. What you see when you look at Gum Do and Taekwondo is Korea trying to make what they were aloud to learn (Japanese martial arts) as close as they can to their own arts which have almost completely died out.
reckedu 11 months ago
Please stop mimicking Japanese. Why do you use samurai swords? Please be proud of your own country's culture. Due to a part of Koreans like you, all Koreans are fooled by Japanese. You are ridiculing your ancestors.
centraltheorem2076 1 year ago
korea was the only nation that used the two handed sword technique
in japan they only used the katana and wakizashi when they didnt need their katana. only miyamoto musashi used the two sword technique but had his own way of doing it.(probably uses the japanese swords because you don't see a whole lot of korean swords made.)
inthetoilet4456 1 year ago
idk who had the curved blade first....but gum-do would destroy any old traditional sword martial art...because the koreans invented gurilla warfare. not the vietnamese or the british or any other culture...koreans historically used all sorts of things as wepons to dispatch invaders so you dont suppose its possible that some korean guy killed some japanese dude and picked up his sword and hacked up the other japanese invaders because its simply just a good sword?
pcporter78 1 year ago
I wish I have those mats they have,I can easily do those cuts,with their super thin samgakdo.It requires almost no strangth nor skill,But I got to say,The samgakdo design is great for mat cutting.The losely woven straw mats are also great for show,You can never mess up a cut with those,and it does not put up any restriction during cutting. so much quicker and fancier motions can be acheived.
DaDaoChen 1 year ago
It's a martial arts demo, folks. Enough with the racism and all this fear and hate. It doesn't even matter where exactly the disciplines comes from directly. It matters that it exists now and it's a serious discipline now.
Also, as a matter of fact, straight and curved blades had their place in both Japanese and Korean wars in the past. So it's false to even assume that one nationality holds an exclusive right to the creation of such blades. Also, Persians did curved blades eons before everyone
Shippoyasha 1 year ago
@Shippoyasha though those who are ignorant of east asia usually misunderstand,japanese culture is not very similar with chinese and korean one.
japanese one is often distinguished from them. en.wikipedia. org/wiki/The_Clash_of_Civilizations
we are just sick of the korean's lie that every japanese one is their origine.now it seems to resemble japanese one account of japan's rule period.even they steal chinese one.
this is not racism but truth.there are many videos made by chinese criticize korea.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@Shippoyasha now korean martial arts are copy of japanese ones except for korean archery.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira They probably have derived from them from the natural cultural exchanges. It doesn't matter in the end. I think you are taking too much offense from the crazy Korean zealots who actually thinks it's from Korea first.
What about respectful Korean martial artists who just practice their craft seriously? In the end, I would think most martial artists hold great respect regardless of nationality. I think that's pretty important. Also, Korea has plenty of native arts other than these.
Shippoyasha 1 year ago
@Shippoyasha if you call them crazy,it is all korea.each korean copy culture association declared their origine.most the koreans also believe it.in the end,japan kendo association put the statement against them on internet.as for history education,they have taught japan exploited korea.but the fact is the other way around.there are many grounds japan invested in korea without return though,they would not admit it.they are too proud to face it.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@Shippoyasha i am ok how they hate us on the basis of wrong knowledge but i cant forgive they steal culture,do business or sell their bodies pretending to be japanese.even big companies like samsung do it.in taiwan,a korean pretened to be japanese when she commited a crime.they join japan expo and insist the title change asia expo.they should hold korea expo.they are truly crazy.i just want korea not to involve in japan.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira is wrong on this statment because i studied both Taekwondo and isshinryu and those two arts are nothing alike. nice try tho. come back after 7 yrs of taekwondo and 6 years of karate and tell me that they are the same.
pcporter78 1 year ago
@pcporter78 my statement was not accurate.as for taekwondo,崔泓熙 named it had learned shotokan karate and invented taekwondo.do of taekwondo is road in japanese.japanese traditional cultures often use do such as sado,kado,koudo,kendo,judo,karatedo and so on.the feature is not seen in chinese civilization.their outfits and color obi show japanese features too.but i think taekwondo is aldready their original culture.it is ok.you think the others are also korean original?
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira their cultures are what they just changed the way reading kanji into korean style.
sorry,i am not good at english.what do gurilla warfare and to dispatch invaders mean?
>some korean guy killed some japanese dude and picked up his sword and hacked up the other japanese invaders because its simply just a good sword?
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira is it Japanese invasions of Korea?you think once korean style kendo or something existed,right?i think you misunderstand korean history.
shachikujira 1 year ago
Comment removed
xwindxmistx 1 year ago
you gota luv this shit i hope im not the only one picturing that stick as a human lol
slicetwiceknife 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
William Elliot Griffis 『Korea the Hermit Nation』（1882）
Korea has no samurai. She lacks what Japan has always had - a cultured body of men, superbly trained in both mind and body, the soldier and scholar in one, who held to high ideal of loyalty, patriotism, and sacrifice for country.
jazztarou 1 year ago
wow i wish i can handle two swords at the same time.u are excellent .
Yaki1wolf 1 year ago
왜 여기 일본 사람들이 다 왜 한국이 일본문화를 뺏어간다고 하는지 원... 불안하군요. ㅋ
일본사람들도 한국 문화의 영향을 받았습니다. 왜 계속 우리 탓 만 하냐고?!?! 한국 없었으면 "우리 일본 어떻게 됐을까..." 생각 안 해 보셨나?? 우리가 다 중요한거 가르쳐 줬는데?!
Stop saying Korea is taking japanese culture, japanese people took parts of korean culture too, dont forget that.
Cubalisk 1 year ago
@Cubalisk what korean culture did japan steal?
korea have stealing every japanese culture.kendo is obviously japanese original culture.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira kendo is japanese, gumdo is korean. are you saying that japan, a lone island to the east, learned how to do everything by themselves? of course you guys got ideas from korea and china. how else would have japan become civilized? im just saying that not to say that only korea stole from japan. accept facts
Cubalisk 1 year ago
@Cubalisk gumdo didnt exist by nature.do you understand a katana is japanese original stuff?japanese marcial arts dont exist without samurai.of course,korea didnt have samurai.
japanese culture have something with not korea but china.korea was a path of chinese culture.peninsula of korea exists between japan and china by chance.korea was a slave of china for a long time.korean culture is chinese culture itself.japan changed chinese culture to original culture because of island.face the truth.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira are you saying that the lone island in the middle of the ocean learned how to create weapons, use steel, farm rice and other grains, use hiragana and katakana (your writing system) was changed chinese culture? japan learned writing chinese letters from korea, and also how to use steel. if it wasnt for steel no swords or gumdo of today. Know before you argue, and you argument does not have any evidence of korea = china.
Cubalisk 1 year ago
@shachikujira blacksoulsaion is very right, he is telling the truth. the katana is japanese, but japan learned blacksmithing from korea. accept the facts. and btw... your arguments have totally no supporting facts at all.
Cubalisk 1 year ago
@shachikujira and now japan is now even saying that dokdo is their damn land. it is ours. since when was it japan's?!
Cubalisk 1 year ago
@Cubalisk a katana is japanese stuff represents gumdo is imitation.
do you want to say that korea influenced japan culture?japan had never gotten korean culture.
btw,Baekje was not ancient korea.whats more,Baekje and Silla were dependency of japan.
dont koreans know even korea was slave of china?if you study true history,you will know korean culture is a part of chinese.
watch this video since 3:07. v=9RPRRKNYdTA.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira gumdo is a changed form of kendo since ever japan 's imperialism over asia. yes i understand that gumdo = kendo, but now you're just being dumb. wtf? silla and baekje a part of japan? dude, we fucking used korean instead of japanese language, how is that japan? you are not making sense. how is it japanese? the world knows that it is korean history, japanese people should stop with the lies. also about china and korea...
Cubalisk 1 year ago
@shachikujira and saying a country is a slave of another country is obviously racism, i can report you to youtube for that.
Cubalisk 1 year ago
@Cubalisk prove blacksoulsaion's claim instead of him.
google Rusk documents about takeshima.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira ...since when was a korea a slave of china? you people in japan are learning some outrageous historical facts. right now, you are trying to disagree with history confirmed by the whole world. only japan thinks that way maybe, cuz they're bunch of liars who dont accept facts. and stop saying everything is your japans, you dont even have facts to support how baekje and silla is japans. for me, i dont need to prove it, cuz the world already knows and you are obviously lying.
Cubalisk 1 year ago
@shachikujira i have to say, go learn history from lvl 1 again.
btw if japan didnt learn it from korea, you must have learned it from china. however that is very unlikely, because korea is much more closer to japan, and korea at that time had advanced technology (for that time) along with china.
Cubalisk 1 year ago
@shachikujira i will agree with you that kendo is japanese i understand. gumdo isnt korea stealing kendo, its like any other country playing a famous sport or art. however, why i am arguing with u is that the japanese people here keep on saying SOTP STEALING JAPANESE CULTURE, which is obviously really immature and dumb. we are not stealing it, we are practicing it like japan playing soccer, a sport from europe.
Cubalisk 1 year ago
@Cubalisk many koreans are claiming origin of japanese culture is korean.such as marcial arts,sado,kado,japanese garden,ukiyoe,manga,japanese great man,japanese language and so on.so All Japan Kendo Federation posted an article kendo is japanese original culture on english website.
Chinese ancient historical book "Book of Song(宋書)," Goguryeo's "Gwanggaeto Stele,"Japanese one "Nihon Shoki(日本書紀)"Korean one“Samguksigi(三国史記)“say that about baekje and silla.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira i found blacksoulsaion's claim was written on page of kumdo on wikipedia.he thought wikipedia was right.
there are many video about korean history on youtube whchi japanese and chinese posted.you yourself must eventually verify whether it is right or not.
sorry,koreans often swear at me.so i tend to use an aggressive word.but i dont mind if you report it.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira japan also was taught directly by china.without korea,history would hardly change.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira its ok, i guess that japan learned more from china than korea. kendo is japanese culture, which came over to korea during japanese imperialism and yatayayayayayayayaya it became popular blah blah blah yes conclusion : kendo is japanese, gumdo is korean pronounciation of kendo, but basicially same thing except for some minor details which myself idk. good bye~
Cubalisk 1 year ago
@Cubalisk you dont understand at all.japanese culture is derivation of chinese.korean is a part of chinese.japanese culture directly has nothing to do with korean.korean culture is by far more similar to chinese than japanese by nature.so korea,too,has culture which japan has is totally wrong.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira no japanese thinks japan acquired korean culture .koreans dont realize them,so they are insisting on their origin of japanese culture.it is natural that we should tell them not to steal japanese culture.btw,they are insisting on origin of chinese too lol of course,chinese are angry with them too.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira wtf? we dont insist on origin of chinese culture, thats weird, thats what the dumb idiots say.
Cubalisk 1 year ago
@Cubalisk It's oriental culture,ok?No question!
slivedkillu 1 year ago
@shachikujira Korean culture is NOT a part of Chinese culture...just saying, and i have a right to say that because i'm South Korean, so i know what i'm talking about
xwindxmistx 1 year ago
@shachikujira 1. Korean culture is not a derivation of chinese at all. Korea existed as a nation for many many thousands of years, since the GOGURYO kingdom. China now claiming goguryo as Chinese history is nothing short of preposterous and is being done so that in the case of a collapse of north korea with the death of Kim Jong Il, they can insert their military and claim north korea as a chinese region. Korea has adopted Confucian ideals but their culture has existed for a very long time.
fdota 1 year ago
@shachikujira 2. Korea has existed as a nation many many years before Japan existed as a nation. People from the Beakje kingdom introduced their culture to the native people of Japan. It was only then that Japan was united as a nation and had a common culture. Japanese people deny this vehemently but the Japanese emperor has recently admitted that he has Korean blood. Of course, Japanese culture has developed on it's own a great deal since then, but it's seen that Korea has been very influential
fdota 1 year ago
@shachikujira 3. In modern times, Japanese culture is seen as the 'origin' of similar aspects between korea and japan because Japan has shared its culture with the rest of the world much earlier and for longer than korea. Korea opened it's doors to foreigners very late compared to Japan.
fdota 1 year ago
@shachikujira 4. Modern technology and culture (electronics, automotive) have been burrowed from Japan by Korea because Japan has been developed much more than Korea. In the distant past this was the other way round, where Korea was the more advanced and developed country and Japan burrowed many things from Korea. Recently though, modern Korea has improved to the point that it is now improving without burrowing from Japanese modern culture and technology.
fdota 1 year ago
@fdota hat was korean culture japan borrowed?
korea was nothing but a path to introduce it to japan as long as i know.it is said both baekje and silla were under the rule of japan in 4th and 5th century by old historical data such as book of song(宋書),gwanggaeto stele,nihon shoki(日本書紀),samguksigi(三国史記) and so on.goguryo and baekje were different from now korea in ethnic.so strictly speaking,the emperor dont have korean blood.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@fdota korea originally had been a part of chinese civilization until it was be set free by japan.now korea is similar to japan because of japan's ruling.
korea was later than japan for 1,000 years before japan's modernizing it.it goes without saying that it didnt have money economy at that time,and what is worse,it didnt have even skill of bending wood or dyeing.so they had been wearing only white dress.you dont know japan spreaded hungle,do you?
korea govt by no means teach you the truth.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira wrong. just wrong. baekje was never under rule of the japanese. you say the korean language was spread by japanese people... if baekje was being ruled by the japanese, why did they create and spread hangul among the people in stead of introducing japanese? like japan tried to do during the annexation of korea in the early 1900's. u say korea didn't have dyes for clothes and skilled woodworking? completely outrageous and baseless accusation and bigotry.
fdota 1 year ago
@shachikujira i think that you should think carefully what your own government is teaching you. think logically and without bias rather than coming rashly to convenient conclusions. your half knowledge and blind patriotism is only fueling you to spread hate and racism to others.
fdota 1 year ago
@fdota it is not korean language but hungle which japan spread in 1900's.in japan,govt directly has nothing to do with making textbooks.what i am saying is true.korea was one of the poorest countries in asia at that time.i am just opposed to korea's lies.
watch?v=A7a-V0i9zK8
taiwanese knows the truth,so many of them dont hate japan except chinese.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira you're claiming that japan spread korea's own written language in the 1900's? it is common knowledge that hangul was in use since the 15th. what japanese people did during the annexation of korea was to teach all things japanese and forbid the learning and practice of korean. and why wouldn't this happen? korea signed a (coerced) treaty to become part of japan. but why you claim that japan spread the korean hangul in korea during this period is so outrageous it blows my mind away.
fdota 1 year ago
@fdota hangle had been used in newspaper published by japanese and korean and taught in schools.you must have noticed the education of korean history was wrong,when you had watched the video.
hungle was not so commonly used because the korean had worshiped chinese culture,on the other hand looked down on others'.even their own character.google sinocentrism.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira also you are not making sense, u are not supporting how baekje and silla is japanese, and how korea was a slave of china with facts. you're just being totally dumb and stubborn with facts that never existed, only in the corrupted mind of japanese historians.
Cubalisk 1 year ago
The most incredible two handed sword handling I have ever seen..Very very impressive!! Thank you for the post..
pdxrhythm 1 year ago
小中華主義なのに何で青龍刀をコピーしないんだよ。宗主国様に失礼だろ？
farenopusizu 1 year ago
Even if u want 2 stick to your Samurai Fantasy Addictions; It was Jpn in the first place that destroyed Kr Culture and Then forced the learning of their ways on Kr. At the same time many Koreans STUDIED Jpns martial arts before, during, and after occupation. They are merely doing what ANY asian or non (actually) has done with all martial arts since the beginning. Study, adopt, and enhance. Kr has been a huddle since the beginning between china and kr; they share alot n adopted a lot t/o history
BlackSoulsAion 1 year ago
*R..between china and Japan
BlackSoulsAion 1 year ago
@BlackSoulsAion you are fundamentally wrong.japan didnt destroy korean culture.korea had no foundation to create martial arts. how to make a katana is japanese original method shows koreans'lies.the culture that japan received was not korean but chinese.korea was nothing but a path of culture.you seem to swallow korean's claim.
they dont know even their own history.they have believed japan hindered modernization of korea.watch?v=94umHT7aBu4
shachikujira 1 year ago
@shachikujira Japan "did" destroy Korean Culture in Occupations (more then once) Thats like saying the jews had not holocaust. it came from CHINA (i said first -_- and also Korea. Same story with Karate,and a million other things.) Its about the evolution of 1 sided blade. Which Japan made into a curve. Korea had many martial arts styles. Which were eliminated by both themselves and occupation. Read my comment again. I "Said" What u just said. So theres no argument; other then ur hate 4 korea.
BlackSoulsAion 1 year ago
@BlackSoulsAion I luv Japan. Im not defending Korea; Im defending the truth. I dont care about the Jpnese that still think they r the asian super race. ur a well known racist troll it seems on utube. If you would like ill make better sentence 4 you. The _____ came by way of China and Korea. This Jpnese atking Kor on utube is so damn immature.I didnt say who taught who lol. B glad the evil US didnt wipe u all from the face of the Earth. Btw -blocking- Try focusing more on the future my friend.
BlackSoulsAion 1 year ago
@BlackSoulsAion as i expected you are mean korean.dont tell a lie any more.
shachikujira 1 year ago
@BlackSoulsAion it is hard for me to understand your english.
your thought is absolutely one-sided,korean itself.rebutting their lies makes me a racist?
i say again.how to make a katana is japanese original method.old korean data indicate a katana is japanese too.show me grounds of your some claim.and what did japan destroy?
shachikujira 1 year ago
People that keep throwing out Korea copy's Japan are clueless. Read your history of the wars and the occupations. I love Japan and I love Japanese Culture; I favor it over Korean; However these lies need to stop being spread.
Its like telling the Japanese to stop Copying the Okinawans when Karate styles spread. A HUGE amount of martial art techniques and blades/weapons etc; migrated from China and Korea to Japan. Both have not COPIED but rather adopted and then given there own taste.
BlackSoulsAion 1 year ago
There are many major difference between Gumdo and Kendo. Iknow I study both
Gerstein1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(2) training in Hakama's? why I have no idea but there 2 style swords methods certainly where deadly and effective....All of you should read history before making comments on shit YOU KNOW NOTHING ABOUT!!!!! the only problem I have with these vids is the practistioners should be wearing traditional Silla clothing or robes instead of Japanese Hakama(Seems to be a modern thing) with all the Japanese influences in this Silla art form nowdays,
Highlandersforever 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(3)and before you all start on me by the way I practice Japanese Kenjutsu for 15 years now and I still see the orriginal Korean in this martial style of the Silla....
Highlandersforever 2 years ago
(1)Gumdo the way of the Silla Knights of the kingdom of the Silla (57 B.C-935 A.D) who by the way kicked the shit out of the Japanese in 663 A.D are an ancient group of highly skilled warriors whos style blades and tacticts where simmilar to the Japanese but not japanese (many asian styles have simalarities) they spent most of there time training there art out in nature and mountanous areas. The reason you all think JAPANESE is because these guys are wearing japanese style Gi
Highlandersforever 2 years ago
@Highlandersforever could you explain to me why are they wearing japanese hakama instead of the gowns worn by Shilla knights of the three kingdoms?
malevolenceXXXensues 2 years ago
good point. Arent we all wearing Japanese style gi usually? Hapkido, Some Shaolin kungfu, BJJ, they all wear a version of a Japanese gi, but they don tmake it japanese...very good point highlander
DustinAdam07 1 year ago
Comment removed
Highlandersforever 2 years ago
Comment removed
Highlandersforever 2 years ago
Comment removed
Highlandersforever 2 years ago
I have to say that it is a very pathetic inferior copy of Japanese style.
NoNoSpice 2 years ago 8
I think they are good at what they are doing, just not right to claim origin as korean. I mean, come on. They are using a katana and a wakizashi what more is there to say
xZatoichix 2 years ago 4
Comment removed
xZatoichix 2 years ago
This thing wa created 1980's by Korean "wannabe Japanese" monk. Very shallow stuff. No elegance backed up by historical facts nor real Samurai battles.
tokyocityrat 2 years ago 2
These guys cut with so little effort it's amazing. You'd think their swords were made of aluminum from the speed and accuracy they're cutting at. Damn, these guys are pro.
TheWitnesserer 2 years ago
i wanna be like this
xXDansonDeltaXx 2 years ago
It is OK to copy, but they claim "Our Origin" .
omanchinkaizokudan 2 years ago 19
the gumdo swords we use in class are slightly curved and as i was aware korean swords are used even in the hwa-rang dynasty but if you sit back and think about it any style or art that is being practiced for true passion, self-defense and to stay physically fit is never wrong you don't knock basketball players for liking the sport when all you ever liked was football. we all are good at something so let each person find their own tru passion. i am studing multiple arts right now i love them all
uaintreedy 2 years ago
it is unfortunate that so much of korean history was lost during the war, and even more unfortunate that the korean people have to rely on retracing the roots of gumdo through japanese swordsmanship. im still hopeful that there is someone that knows the true identity of korean swordsmanship, and that the art has not been totally lost.
cheemanfu 2 years ago
Copy of Japan
teen150 2 years ago 27
the dual swords are cool.
tkddiuryl 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Japanese should stop spreading lies that Koreans are copying Japanese style.
Chinese & Korean styles are focused to fight SEVERAL enemies in surrounding environment.
Japanese style is more focused on ONE on ONE.
Basic strategies of Korean & Japanese are DIFFERENT.
Europeans don't accuse other Europeans of copying their style of fencing, archery, etc.
Chinese DON'T even accuse Koreans of copying their style.
Only Japanese accuse Koreans of copying their style.
LOL
KimInLosAngeles 2 years ago