@NokturnoCulto88 anything is possible who knows. point is mlk jr. changed the way the world sees ethnic groups and the way we treat each other in general. still doesn't change the fact that you are probably a neo-nazi virgin who lives with his parents.
@Carlibengarli its kind of the same like the shell symbols.. mercedes are expensive cars but there are so MANY out of them.. its just... some people are cold and hungry and other drive mercedes and polluts the environment ... kind of that way...
Please do some research on the Shell Corporation. It is generally (historcally) regarded as the incarnation of evil, corporate capitalism. Do you have any idea what it's done? I sincerely doubt it's a concidence Shell was originally the sole company to be featured among the falling "bombshells". I also doubt the presence of the Mercedes-Benz logo is random.
Who knows? Maybe Waters has bought an MB in his life and wasn't a particularly satisfied customer? :P
im 13 and have loved pink floyd since i was 12. me and my dad have been to loads of floyd tribute acts, aussie floyd, floyd spirit, brit floyd (which is only a week before i see roger) but i cannot believe i am seeing the man who made all this real!
@mountainbmx your a very lucky person and same here cause i literly was born with pink floyd cause my dad always tells me when i camback from the hospital when i was born he was listening to goodbye blue sky and i loved that he did that for me
just another lib that NEVER sees the need for war. if we hadn't kicked germany's ass for lil roger....he'd be named adolf, and doing his govt approved concerts in leiderhosen!
@rants2004 Seems like the internet is back on in Tehran so before I lose the connection let me shit on ur fuck face Mozdore Basiji. Since you live in NYC u can send ur bitch ass sister or madare jendat (we will accept other family members pending availability like ur Niece) to Nezam Abad so we can send you a direct and personal message this way ham khalg ham khoda will be proud of you.
@rants2004 Listen goli, being a bitch ass that you are, there is no doubt that you are proud of bending over to pay homage to your masters Ahmadinejad and his thugs and seeing nothing wrong with that speaks of your long family trait to accumulate merit to go to Akhunds heaven. So who is Jerry, ur daddy? No let me guess Hooman is ur daddy isn’t it? U like to use the word son, ru a pedophile, now what would Jerry say about that let me guess “its very telling”
There are few artists with the courage of Roger waters, few with his integrity. Depeche Mode, Elton John, etc, all played in Israel, the Jewish (only) state, for the money, right after their latest massacre. The rest of the imagery makes it clear that Roger Waters is no fan of organized religion. It takes a special kind of ignorance to single him out as anti-Semitic, even though in these days of 'the Jewish state's' wanton criminality, one has to wonder if that kind of label is such a bad thing.
@123decoeli I LOVE your analysis of this. And MSMSValve below. In this day and age here in the US it takes guts to even say anything slightly against Israel.
Ugly disgusting money obsessed Roger Waters will do anything in order to earn even more money - after spitting on every moral idea represented by pink - floyd, and using the most vicious tactics against his fellow band mates in court, he is now using antisemitic ideas to earn some more -
While Maybe Waters can distinguish the star of David as a symbol to Zionism he disagree with from the Jewish people, many cannot tell them apart and Waters knows it well. His act is purely antisemitic since the star of David is synonymous with the Jewish people and the cross represent a religious belief. The Jewish people are the only ethnic group shown in the clip. By ignoring these facts, Waters flames the raging fire of antisemitism around the world. Shame on you!
@nrgl123 I don't understand you. Sure, he shows the star of David, but he also shows the Christian cross, and the Muslim Crescent Moon. And later on you can't even see the Star of David.
He's criticizing all the blood that has been spilled in the name of religion (all of them... well, the monotheistic ones), for the greed of money and power.
He didn't treat Judaism any different then the rest of religions. Let me remind you that he performed in Israel 3-4 years ago...
@MSMSValve of course he showed the Christian cross and the Muslim Crescent Moon, but non of them represents a ethnic group like the star of David is. the way I see it, by showing the dollar sings, Shell and Mercedes sings he refers to what is wrong with the world in his view.
showing the star of David and ignoring its wider meaning is irresponsible and provocative Regarding his visit to Israel - He was most disrespectful, almost called it of and preached against Israel even when he was here.
@nrgl123 I'm not sure that Judaism represents an ethnic group. It is a faith, the same as Christianity, Hinduism, Islam etc. You can be a Christian-born person, but regard yourself as French, English, etc. The same for a Jew.
I think that Mr. Waters was criticizing religion in general. Due to the fact that the main religions in the west are the monotheistic ones, he "mentioned" all the 3.
And as far as I know, these religions cause more wars than any other religions (Hinduism, Buddhism, etc.).
@MSMSValve sure i understand that he showed the 3 "major" religions.
BUT, the last time we saw the star of david "mentioned" together with money, it didn't end well... btw, i wrote "major" religions, because there are about 1.3 Billion muslims and 1+(dont know exactlly) Christians.
BUT there are only about 12.5 Million jews all together.
@paladinCHAUVIN my friend, from talking to people from all over the world, there are MANY, who think that there are hundreds of millions of jews, and that israel's population is about 70-100 mil...
people are not even close to know the real number because they get their info from the media, and israel is "staring" on the news almost on a daily basis...
Oh my firend(that talks to people from all over the world), you're from Israel !
That's explains your focalisation on the david star...Judaism IS a major religion, it gave Christianism and Islam( 2 important religions that believe in jewish prophets). You felt singled out because of the david star that actually refer to your "country" (hum)? Do not deny that Israel has no influence on the powerful western world especially USA. Number of jews doesn't matter, Israel crimes does(39vetos my friend)
@nrgl123 the whole point of the song/video is to practically show the ignorance of war...and greed; the "falling bombs" are represented by religion as representation to show what most wars are about religion/greed [hence; the cross, star of david, etc.] but clearly you couldn't see passed that and realize the true meaning, nrgl123s flames the raging ignorance and tunnel visioned politics of today...among other idiots, which is why you shouldn't listen to Floyd/Water's or anyone with a vision
Es increible como Rogers hace 30 años ya haya visto la que se venia... y hoy pueda corporizarla ... lucha por el poder, the money, la monstruosa industria automotriz, y la lucha a muerte por encima de cualquier pueblo o nacion por capturar todo el petroleo.. y el adios al cada vez menos "cielo azul "Un visionario que sigue siendo fiel a sus principios
@NokturnoCulto88 anything is possible who knows. point is mlk jr. changed the way the world sees ethnic groups and the way we treat each other in general. still doesn't change the fact that you are probably a neo-nazi virgin who lives with his parents.
jonnytrooper 3 months ago
"anti-zionisim is anti-semitism"
- Martin Luther King jr.
jonnytrooper 3 months ago
@jonnytrooper Martin Luther King Jr was an idiot.
NokturnoCulto88 3 months ago
i just think that nrgl123 is troll.
MikeMallorca2010 8 months ago
can somebody explain me, why the mercedes-benz symbols?
Velovsky 11 months ago
@Velovsky
Yeah I don't get it either. :S
Is there something we should know? xD
Carlibengarli 8 months ago
@Carlibengarli its kind of the same like the shell symbols.. mercedes are expensive cars but there are so MANY out of them.. its just... some people are cold and hungry and other drive mercedes and polluts the environment ... kind of that way...
vivustemporis 8 months ago
@vivustemporis
Please do some research on the Shell Corporation. It is generally (historcally) regarded as the incarnation of evil, corporate capitalism. Do you have any idea what it's done? I sincerely doubt it's a concidence Shell was originally the sole company to be featured among the falling "bombshells". I also doubt the presence of the Mercedes-Benz logo is random.
Who knows? Maybe Waters has bought an MB in his life and wasn't a particularly satisfied customer? :P
Carlibengarli 8 months ago 2
Every time someone criticizes Israel they are labeled anti-semitic. I am surprised how the other religions haven't spoken against him as well?
spiralingcrazies 11 months ago
great!!!!
jembozzo 1 year ago
02 arena in may
im 13 and have loved pink floyd since i was 12. me and my dad have been to loads of floyd tribute acts, aussie floyd, floyd spirit, brit floyd (which is only a week before i see roger) but i cannot believe i am seeing the man who made all this real!
TEAR DOWN THE WALL!
mountainbmx 1 year ago
@mountainbmx your a very lucky person and same here cause i literly was born with pink floyd cause my dad always tells me when i camback from the hospital when i was born he was listening to goodbye blue sky and i loved that he did that for me
soontobefamous11 1 year ago
Did, did, did, did, did, did you see the aerial spraying this morning?
ausseratem 1 year ago
this was such a great show i saw it last night in boston so beyond words
Taurusaud 1 year ago
"itegrity?" LOL!
just another lib that NEVER sees the need for war. if we hadn't kicked germany's ass for lil roger....he'd be named adolf, and doing his govt approved concerts in leiderhosen!
angusruler 1 year ago
@angusruler
that's what adolf said about poland the night before
you are the definition of FAIL. exit the internet for great justice!
TheAntiVigilante 1 year ago
Thank you Mr. Waters for supporting the plight of Palestinians and exposing the fascism, racism and inhumanity of the apartheid state of Israel.
Please ignore racist scumbags like Abe Foxman.
rants2004 1 year ago
@rants2004 Seems like the internet is back on in Tehran so before I lose the connection let me shit on ur fuck face Mozdore Basiji. Since you live in NYC u can send ur bitch ass sister or madare jendat (we will accept other family members pending availability like ur Niece) to Nezam Abad so we can send you a direct and personal message this way ham khalg ham khoda will be proud of you.
ArasheKamanGeer 11 months ago
@rants2004 Listen goli, being a bitch ass that you are, there is no doubt that you are proud of bending over to pay homage to your masters Ahmadinejad and his thugs and seeing nothing wrong with that speaks of your long family trait to accumulate merit to go to Akhunds heaven. So who is Jerry, ur daddy? No let me guess Hooman is ur daddy isn’t it? U like to use the word son, ru a pedophile, now what would Jerry say about that let me guess “its very telling”
ArasheKamanGeer 11 months ago
There are few artists with the courage of Roger waters, few with his integrity. Depeche Mode, Elton John, etc, all played in Israel, the Jewish (only) state, for the money, right after their latest massacre. The rest of the imagery makes it clear that Roger Waters is no fan of organized religion. It takes a special kind of ignorance to single him out as anti-Semitic, even though in these days of 'the Jewish state's' wanton criminality, one has to wonder if that kind of label is such a bad thing.
123decoeli 1 year ago 10
@123decoeli I LOVE your analysis of this. And MSMSValve below. In this day and age here in the US it takes guts to even say anything slightly against Israel.
sosadogtap 2 months ago
Comment removed
123decoeli 1 year ago
Roger is one of the best artists ever! Just fantastic!
SteveMorty 1 year ago
disgusting antisemitic bastard!
gogo4466 1 year ago
@gogo4466 You idiot.
thatstheguy07 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ugly disgusting money obsessed Roger Waters will do anything in order to earn even more money - after spitting on every moral idea represented by pink - floyd, and using the most vicious tactics against his fellow band mates in court, he is now using antisemitic ideas to earn some more -
Roger waters is a money thirsty son of a bitch!
catch22112 1 year ago
While Maybe Waters can distinguish the star of David as a symbol to Zionism he disagree with from the Jewish people, many cannot tell them apart and Waters knows it well. His act is purely antisemitic since the star of David is synonymous with the Jewish people and the cross represent a religious belief. The Jewish people are the only ethnic group shown in the clip. By ignoring these facts, Waters flames the raging fire of antisemitism around the world. Shame on you!
nrgl123 1 year ago
@nrgl123 I don't understand you. Sure, he shows the star of David, but he also shows the Christian cross, and the Muslim Crescent Moon. And later on you can't even see the Star of David.
He's criticizing all the blood that has been spilled in the name of religion (all of them... well, the monotheistic ones), for the greed of money and power.
He didn't treat Judaism any different then the rest of religions. Let me remind you that he performed in Israel 3-4 years ago...
MSMSValve 1 year ago 8
Comment removed
nrgl123 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MSMSValve of course he showed the Christian cross and the Muslim Crescent Moon, but non of them represents a ethnic group like the star of David is. the way I see it, by showing the dollar sings, Shell and Mercedes sings he refers to what is wrong with the world in his view.
showing the star of David and ignoring its wider meaning is irresponsible and provocative Regarding his visit to Israel - He was most disrespectful, almost called it of and preached against Israel even when he was here.
nrgl123 1 year ago
@nrgl123 I'm not sure that Judaism represents an ethnic group. It is a faith, the same as Christianity, Hinduism, Islam etc. You can be a Christian-born person, but regard yourself as French, English, etc. The same for a Jew.
I think that Mr. Waters was criticizing religion in general. Due to the fact that the main religions in the west are the monotheistic ones, he "mentioned" all the 3.
And as far as I know, these religions cause more wars than any other religions (Hinduism, Buddhism, etc.).
MSMSValve 1 year ago
@MSMSValve sure i understand that he showed the 3 "major" religions.
BUT, the last time we saw the star of david "mentioned" together with money, it didn't end well... btw, i wrote "major" religions, because there are about 1.3 Billion muslims and 1+(dont know exactlly) Christians.
BUT there are only about 12.5 Million jews all together.
so judaism, is not really a "major" religion...
eitan71 1 year ago
@eitan71 judaism, is not really a "major" religion...
What ! Judaism is not a major religion!! I AM shocked! You're such an anti-Semitic.
Bahahahaha
paladinCHAUVIN 1 year ago
@paladinCHAUVIN my friend, from talking to people from all over the world, there are MANY, who think that there are hundreds of millions of jews, and that israel's population is about 70-100 mil...
people are not even close to know the real number because they get their info from the media, and israel is "staring" on the news almost on a daily basis...
that's why i wrote that
eitan71 1 year ago
Comment removed
paladinCHAUVIN 1 year ago
Oh my firend(that talks to people from all over the world), you're from Israel !
That's explains your focalisation on the david star...Judaism IS a major religion, it gave Christianism and Islam( 2 important religions that believe in jewish prophets). You felt singled out because of the david star that actually refer to your "country" (hum)? Do not deny that Israel has no influence on the powerful western world especially USA. Number of jews doesn't matter, Israel crimes does(39vetos my friend)
paladinCHAUVIN 1 year ago
@nrgl123 the whole point of the song/video is to practically show the ignorance of war...and greed; the "falling bombs" are represented by religion as representation to show what most wars are about religion/greed [hence; the cross, star of david, etc.] but clearly you couldn't see passed that and realize the true meaning, nrgl123s flames the raging ignorance and tunnel visioned politics of today...among other idiots, which is why you shouldn't listen to Floyd/Water's or anyone with a vision
noveltyskateboards 1 year ago
Es increible como Rogers hace 30 años ya haya visto la que se venia... y hoy pueda corporizarla ... lucha por el poder, the money, la monstruosa industria automotriz, y la lucha a muerte por encima de cualquier pueblo o nacion por capturar todo el petroleo.. y el adios al cada vez menos "cielo azul "Un visionario que sigue siendo fiel a sus principios
anamgify 1 year ago
ver un concierto de the wall y después morir ...
faunoram 1 year ago
The Master!!
jansenmann 1 year ago