Yeah, so a lot of stuff had to be left out of the bogart version because of the hays code. dirty books, gay dudes, naked girls etc., so a post hayes remake makes sense, but why london? and putting it in contempory times is a mistake. has to be a period peice in the 40's.
Does anyone know those two tracks that were playing on Marlowe's television in the background, while Miles and his heavy were there, having waited in his apartment, talking to him? The first went something like 'I just can't get you out of mind, seems I'm a cold and hopeless case', and the second; 'Give me a reason, feel like I do'. There was applause between the two so it may have been Top of the Pops. For all I know they were probably dummy songs, made up to avoid royalities....
It's just you. :-) If you should ever have the opportunity to watch the complete movie. listen to how Mitchum changes the reading of the line "I'm not looking for Rusty Reagan". He has to say it half a dozen times, and says it half a dozen different ways. I think what you're picking up on is Marlowe's stoic character, which Mitchum captures perfectly. In this and Farewell My Lovely Mitchum is easily the best Philip Marlowe on film.
@diddymuck When it comes to actors who have played Phillip Marlowe, I think it's a toss up between Humphrey Bogart and Dick Powell. By the time Robert Mitchum made this film, he was pushing 60. I'm not saying Mitchum wasn't a great actor, he was. Even Robert Montgomery was better as Marlowe. Mitchum made a lot of great movies such as Out of The Past and The Racket, as well as The Friends of Eddie Coyle.
@flhinton Watch Humphrey Bogart's films and you'll see that he IS Marlowe. The hard-boiled cynic with the heart of gold, the guy who will do what is right even if it costs him or even if he doesn't quite know what that is. Dick Powell was good, Farewell My Lovely/Murder My Sweet was excellent, but nobody embodies Marlowe like Bogart, he should've definitely done more. Mitchum was an excellent actor as well, but he's done better film noir, he was best when he wasn't trying to be Bogart.
@MrLunitunz I've seen Bogart in The Big Sleep. I have it on DVD. I think that Bogart was excellent as Marlowe. But, I also liked Dick Powell in the role. He gave a different take on the character, as did Robert Montgomery. And later on, James Garner. While I think Bogart's portrayal of the character was the best, I also like the other three.
@flhinton I could see how one would think Dick Powell to be the definitive Marlowe, he's played him more times than anyone else, including Bogart. But y'know, the other two's film adaptations kinda leave a lot to be desired. I don't think that, aside from those two, there will ever be anyone capable of playing Marlowe well, on the big screen or the small one. He's an anachronism now. Chivalry is dead, the hard-boiled mode is, at least in normal proportions, dead.
@MrLunitunz Dick Powell only portrayed Marlowe in one film. You might be thinking of his radio show, Richard Diamond, Private Detective. That is a particular favorite of mine. I wasn't comparing the two. I said that Powell brought something significant to the role. Murder My Sweet was the only movie he made based on one of Raymond Chandler's novels.
@flhinton There was the film. Then he did an adaptation of The Long Goodbye for the Climax! TV series, that particular show famous for having one of the villains, who'd been shot dead, just get up and walk off stage while still on camera. And he played Marlowe a couple of times on radio. This in addition to being Richard Diamond.
@MrLunitunz I don't want to argue which actor or performance was the best. To me, they each stand on their own. The only actor that played Marlowe that I didn't like was Elliot Gould. But, Bogart, Powell and even Montgomery's performances stand on their own. They each brought their own interpretation to the character, which isn't necessarily a bad thing.
@flhinton Certainly not, and I'm not trying to argue that it was. Simply to argue that, of all of them, Bogart was the most like Marlowe, in life and in his other roles.
The only reason why I watched it was due to Mitchum. I'm a bigger fan of that guy than I ever was for Bogart! That being said, this remake is unfortunately inferior to the great original
Mitchum was perfect for the role of Marlowe. Too bad he didn't play him in the 1940's, when he was young. But at least he played him.(twice) It's fun seeing him opposite Oliver Reed.
this was free with one of hte national papes a couple of years ago. its intresting comparing this with the original bogart one, to see how the scene play out ( bet someones already done that)
Apart from cahnging the location to London, it sticks to the original story more than the 1946 version, including the line near the end that gives the book it's title"And in a little while he too,like Rusty Regan, would be sleeping the big sleep" The changes in the 1946 script were to give Bogie and Bacall a romance.
"If you listen real hard you'll hear my teeth chatter" Lol, classic.
otochari 1 month ago
Yeah, so a lot of stuff had to be left out of the bogart version because of the hays code. dirty books, gay dudes, naked girls etc., so a post hayes remake makes sense, but why london? and putting it in contempory times is a mistake. has to be a period peice in the 40's.
wiseass2147 3 months ago
Does anyone know those two tracks that were playing on Marlowe's television in the background, while Miles and his heavy were there, having waited in his apartment, talking to him? The first went something like 'I just can't get you out of mind, seems I'm a cold and hopeless case', and the second; 'Give me a reason, feel like I do'. There was applause between the two so it may have been Top of the Pops. For all I know they were probably dummy songs, made up to avoid royalities....
Smellthecoffee100 5 months ago
It's just you. :-) If you should ever have the opportunity to watch the complete movie. listen to how Mitchum changes the reading of the line "I'm not looking for Rusty Reagan". He has to say it half a dozen times, and says it half a dozen different ways. I think what you're picking up on is Marlowe's stoic character, which Mitchum captures perfectly. In this and Farewell My Lovely Mitchum is easily the best Philip Marlowe on film.
liblabyt 9 months ago
Why was this movie even made?
cb4life100 1 year ago 3
@cb4life100 They said if nothing else it did bring together a lot of veteran stars for the last time.
JuanMacready 1 year ago
@cb4life100 response to the success of Farewell My Lovely. MItchem is the greatest Marlowe of them all.
diddymuck 11 months ago
@diddymuck When it comes to actors who have played Phillip Marlowe, I think it's a toss up between Humphrey Bogart and Dick Powell. By the time Robert Mitchum made this film, he was pushing 60. I'm not saying Mitchum wasn't a great actor, he was. Even Robert Montgomery was better as Marlowe. Mitchum made a lot of great movies such as Out of The Past and The Racket, as well as The Friends of Eddie Coyle.
flhinton 10 months ago
@flhinton Watch Humphrey Bogart's films and you'll see that he IS Marlowe. The hard-boiled cynic with the heart of gold, the guy who will do what is right even if it costs him or even if he doesn't quite know what that is. Dick Powell was good, Farewell My Lovely/Murder My Sweet was excellent, but nobody embodies Marlowe like Bogart, he should've definitely done more. Mitchum was an excellent actor as well, but he's done better film noir, he was best when he wasn't trying to be Bogart.
MrLunitunz 5 months ago
@MrLunitunz I've seen Bogart in The Big Sleep. I have it on DVD. I think that Bogart was excellent as Marlowe. But, I also liked Dick Powell in the role. He gave a different take on the character, as did Robert Montgomery. And later on, James Garner. While I think Bogart's portrayal of the character was the best, I also like the other three.
flhinton 5 months ago
@flhinton I could see how one would think Dick Powell to be the definitive Marlowe, he's played him more times than anyone else, including Bogart. But y'know, the other two's film adaptations kinda leave a lot to be desired. I don't think that, aside from those two, there will ever be anyone capable of playing Marlowe well, on the big screen or the small one. He's an anachronism now. Chivalry is dead, the hard-boiled mode is, at least in normal proportions, dead.
MrLunitunz 5 months ago
@MrLunitunz Dick Powell only portrayed Marlowe in one film. You might be thinking of his radio show, Richard Diamond, Private Detective. That is a particular favorite of mine. I wasn't comparing the two. I said that Powell brought something significant to the role. Murder My Sweet was the only movie he made based on one of Raymond Chandler's novels.
flhinton 5 months ago
@flhinton There was the film. Then he did an adaptation of The Long Goodbye for the Climax! TV series, that particular show famous for having one of the villains, who'd been shot dead, just get up and walk off stage while still on camera. And he played Marlowe a couple of times on radio. This in addition to being Richard Diamond.
MrLunitunz 5 months ago
@MrLunitunz I don't want to argue which actor or performance was the best. To me, they each stand on their own. The only actor that played Marlowe that I didn't like was Elliot Gould. But, Bogart, Powell and even Montgomery's performances stand on their own. They each brought their own interpretation to the character, which isn't necessarily a bad thing.
flhinton 5 months ago
@flhinton Certainly not, and I'm not trying to argue that it was. Simply to argue that, of all of them, Bogart was the most like Marlowe, in life and in his other roles.
MrLunitunz 5 months ago
@cb4life100
The only reason why I watched it was due to Mitchum. I'm a bigger fan of that guy than I ever was for Bogart! That being said, this remake is unfortunately inferior to the great original
CesMan83 5 months ago
Wow...this looks really sucky compared to the Bogart version...
wewantsthering 1 year ago 10
@wewantsthering looks arent deceiving...lots of bad acting in this movie; acting comes off like some agatha christie drawing room mystery.
monk22yrs 3 months ago
mitchum was so old then..i wish he played that at least two decades earlier.
GustaveKwak 1 year ago
Mitchum was perfect for the role of Marlowe. Too bad he didn't play him in the 1940's, when he was young. But at least he played him.(twice) It's fun seeing him opposite Oliver Reed.
Zacatown 1 year ago
this was free with one of hte national papes a couple of years ago. its intresting comparing this with the original bogart one, to see how the scene play out ( bet someones already done that)
Pauluk33 2 years ago
Apart from cahnging the location to London, it sticks to the original story more than the 1946 version, including the line near the end that gives the book it's title"And in a little while he too,like Rusty Regan, would be sleeping the big sleep" The changes in the 1946 script were to give Bogie and Bacall a romance.
suir52 2 years ago
I saw this film ages ago, and it was quite good - in a bad way.
Someone should post the entire thing!
koln1996 2 years ago
This doesn't look nearly as good as the earlier version.
nclysander 3 years ago
At least they show some tits in the movie.
OmonRa71 3 years ago
was that Richard Todd ?
mcgiver02 3 years ago
certainly was richard todd
binker1 3 years ago
Anyone know if there is a soundtrack album?
AbsurdChessOpening 3 years ago
one cornball remake.
sakara18235 3 years ago
I don't know, it wasn't that bad. Michael Winner's a fairly limp director. But you can't beat that star power -what a cast!
GroovyBlackCat 3 years ago
compared to the original film remake of the book - nothing
PhoenixZappa 3 years ago
wow simon was a talented actor as well as a singer
where was it filmed
pilotpotty 4 years ago
it's filmed in putney i think
binker1 3 years ago