Ministry of Magic- Snape vs. Snape

[diddleybombom]

Wow. I love it! And ur a great singer :D

[supertaquito94]

Lily must believe that people can change. She hated James, but after he changed she went with him. (I dislike James quite a bit. Maybe just cause I never read anything about him after he changed.)

[boxerdogify3]

12 people Don't like Snape



[jake19581]

i like the music and the video i have just finished reading hp7 for the 3rd time how cool is that

[jake19581]

i dont like the video but i like the MUSIC

P.S that dark mark tatoo is total fake it shows you one in the movie

[PokemonGirls24]

12 people let Lord Voldemort win

[Blackrose6767]

11 people are Death Eaters!!

[iamnuff1992]

stuff like this always suprises me...

both snape from harry potter and itachi from naruto (please no comments on naruto) both did evil things for a good reason, and that makes them good people (in the eyes of their fans) but even if he was batting for the side of "good" all along snape was still a scumbag

same thing applys to albus. yes your doing it "For The Greater Good(tm)" but you still pulled A SCHOOL FULL OF CHILDREN into your little war. i mean really? what could he have been thinking?

[SmilesInTheDark]

@iamnuff1992 I don't think Albus had a choice, he knew he was going to die and made sure that Snape would be there to protect the students, Dumbledore would never want to get Hogwarts involved in the war (I think).

[iamnuff1992]

@SmilesInTheDark

ha... im not talking about the 7th book, or about albus death...

book one, the VERY first thing albus has hagrid do after picking harry up.

grab something he KNOWS the evil mass murderers want and hide it in a school full of 11-18 year old children.

albus did some stupid shit, and some stuff he has no right to do.

but snape? snape was just a dick, sure he might not have been evil all the time, but he was still a douchebag

[LightningRodOfHatee]

@iamnuff1992 About snape being a douche...

wouldn't you have been a douche too?

If everything you had in your life completely sucked?

If the only person you loved rejected you because of your mistakes?

if you had everyone blame you for what they didn't know?

if you had to risk your life every day for a boy that constantly reminded you of what you did?Snape did treat everyone like crap, especially Harry.

I think if I was in that situation, I'd probably been treating everyone like crap too.

[iamnuff1992]

@LightningRodOfHatee

...

point.

one other thing,

notice how noone seems to mind what james almost fed snape to remus...

wut?

yeah, so on a "prank" harrys dad almost made one of his best friends MURDER their schoolyard rival???

and this just get brushed off?

[xxpinkgrlxx]

i love this song so much

[LemonFairyLili]

:O Why would anyone by an "Evil" button from Pottercast? I still have my "Good" one lying around! :D Good times, good times! (I was at their last cast--though it was not recorded, because I missed the recorded one earlier in the day) before DH was released, their first cast after. *memory swoon*

[lilikaberry96]

this song is so sad... T.T

[Sayaka1537]

It's just that the ending bugs me, as if it denied Snape's evolution, you know ? Oh come on, am I really the only one disturbed by this message here ?! What do you think ?!

[AuroraDragomir]

@Sayaka1537 the song came out before DH was released, I think. Many people weren't sure whether or not they trusted him after HBP, perhaps including the songwriters.

[Sayaka1537]

Some may call me naïve but I believe in people and I believe they evolve. And though I agree that it is unlikely for people with "death-eater-personnalities" you can't tell anything without actually knowing a man/woman, his/her life and experiences, ... I'm thinking of Severus Snape but I'm also thinking of Malfoy for instance.

[Sayaka1537]

I don't get this song... I mean, I think the message and the character kind of contradict each other, don't they ?! Severus Snape became a Death Eater but he didn't die as one and "Lord Voldemort" certainly DIDN'T win, Severus Snape wasn't his, like Harry so truly says. So I admit I have a problem with the end of this song... And putting aside Severus Snape himself, talking about the song in more general terms, I still have a problem with it, message-wise.

[MrTylerKoster]

The best way to download this as an mp3 is on that site mp3iifffy. Awesome site. GOOGLE mp3iifffy

[MissDanaWeasley]

I like this. (:

[Treemeadow]

Put your hand up if you trusted Snape, from the beginning.

0/

(well, I doubted him for about 2 minutes in Yr 12, but then decided to trust him anyway)

Snape had supporters right through!

[GeorgiLovesYou]

i never trusted snape, i always trusted harry and his judgement haha :(

but i think snape is a great character, so amazing what he did xx

[huskey122]

@Treemeadow

i kinda had doubts in the 6th and 1st but then i read the books and no i know! lol

[MissDanaWeasley]

-puts hand up in front of my computer-

[Treemeadow]

Yay!

[marchellabella]

way to go it's really good!!!!!!!

[shdy14]

wow.. good job dude, way to go

[LeahstineandSmeghan]

This is so good.

Excelent!

[tribebohemian]

this was put together really well. i enjoyed it and it went with the song brilliantly. great job. your efforts paid off.

[xKiryuZerox]

Do you know where i can download the song? D:

[MissDanaWeasley]

iTunes... but you'd have to buy it. You could get JUST this song for 99 cents, or they're ENTIRE album for $9.99 ... So get the whole album, it's saving money.

[xKiryuZerox]

i found a place where i downloaded the song for free ^^

[Treemeadow]

Nooo, support them! They're not like rich bands who have a lot of sponsorship.

Downloading for free is stealing from them- and they're doing this for us to enjoy!

[xKiryuZerox]

Well, now i've alredy downloaded it ^^'

[xXharrypottergeek1Xx]

i bet you got it from borders everyone got a sighned copy of 7 and there were a few big events including is snape good or evil

[Toboekyo]

Aww this was nice....did you get the buttons at an event? They are really cool~<3

[deathcat51]

where did you get all of the cool stuff?!?!?!?!?!?! i rilly want sum butons lik that...

[OHRLYGRLZ]

Really fantastic ideas, and very well put together :D I thought it represented Snape well...and I loved what you added at the end.

You do sound a bit like Kristen Chenoweth!

[Vampirebloodthirst]

that's a good idea thank you.

[Marj12592]

:O

You sing kinda like Kristen Chenoweth.

[Vampirebloodthirst]

Yeah it is kind of hard sometimes to find the right stick. Sometimes I think I've found a good one and then it breaks or something while I'm trying to make it into a wand.

[Ioveisdead92]

try a drum stick

[BellGirl26]

This is cool!

[Vampirebloodthirst]

I took some sticks and shaped them into wands. The kind of suck and don't totally look like the ones in the movies but oh well.

[Animutant666]

cool i was trying to make voldemorts but i failed couldnt find big enough sticks

[jasuschrist]

ballsack

[TieDyedTacos]

ok why would you say that on a harry potter vid? retard.

[annamae970]

shut uup your a retaRD AND if you knew how to read it says HARRY POTTER!!

[michaelsensation13]

then why the hell are you on this video dumbass?

[annamae970]

because i luv harry potter too!!!!!DUMBASS

[annamae970]

Okay guys which one:  TWILIGHT or HARRY POTTER?

I just wanna find everyones opinion and i love both.

[385Casey]

Thumbs Down :D ♥

[OfficialOOTP]

One of the best times. Right before the 7th book came out and all the debate about Snape being evil or good. I remember all the stuff they had at Boarders about that. I wish i could go back to that for just a day :( I miss those days.

[xHermione31x]

i was in one of those debates on the team FOR Snape :) haha everyone kinda just stared at me, which all the things i had to prove he was good :) great times :) i Do wanna go back..my timeturner is broken though

[katiebit09]

great job, and I agree, you have an AWESOME voice! I would buy this song WITH your voice on it too!

[LilJamieP]

OMG!!!

at first i was ;like...woa..that's a cool mask to use for a death eater...then i saw a pic of all the death eaters and it actually IS THE MASK THEY USE!!

omg....i feel so relieved now...

[arwenae]

Brilliant vid. It was cool to see the US covers etc for HP as well.

[LilJamieP]

wow.

u have a really pretty voice ^_^

[TheRainsMelody]

I love all the border's things xD That's so great. It turned out awesome~

[Vampirebloodthirst]

I have made several wands though some are kind of suckie and none of them look like the ones in the movies. Oh well not everythings perfect.

[annamae970]

what do you mean you made wands?

[Painfoot]

You did a really good job with this! The work and effort shows, and it's a great video to a great song =)

[Vampirebloodthirst]

cool video. I want the dark mark tatooed on my arm but it possiblie would cost a lot of money. I want a wand too. My sisters, our neighbor and I saw some thing at a mall when we went there and we were playing with them. I think I actually said a curse oopps lol.

[avatarkairi]

I bought the Hermione wand replica. My nephew has this generic wand from somewhere, can't remember where. Once, we got bored, so we decided to have a Wizard Duel. It was fun...my mom made us stop though.

[Roxel42]

The more I watch this, the more I wish that I had gotten some more of the Snape friend/foe paraphernalia.....ah well....I still LOVE this video!!!!!!! *gives cookies*

[SeverusSnapelovesME]

haha! so do i. i wasn't that bothered with Snape until the end to be honest! :D

[candicane23456]

Siriusly jealous!!!! Great video. I wish I had as many Potter stuff as you :( awesome vid. going on my favs lol

[sevenluck77]

wooah so jealous.. you have a lot of potter things! awesome video, nice job (:

[Roxel42]

That was amazing!!! Very well done, and it really shows how much thought you put into it! I concur with you about the last lines of the song, but also think about it this way. Severus never had to change, because he was never evil in the first place.

[itsbenJARmin]

I really would love to forget what happened in the books and re-read them and have all the "OH MY GODz!!!" all over again mainly I would love to re-find out about Snape.

[lilpup101mg]

do it.

i did

[tearsXonXBella]

you have a really beautiful voice, i'm jealous =(.

oh well, still pure amaze! =D luv it! i gave it five stars

[Tujdosen]

everytime I tried to download this it wouldnt work :(

ah well, I like coming to watch your vid, its pure awesomeness... ness... ness.

100 comments =D

[daisuke7]

omg. absoulutely amazing...and how old are you? This is incredible! I always try to do stuff like this...but for some reason, my vids never upload correctly! Oh, well for me--good, no, GREAT JOB for you! YAY! :D

[XxThaDogxX]

I love the song.I love it alot.

[SuaveSweetie]

WOAH! You can actually tell how much thought you put into this. wow. that was very enjoyable.

[shanthenonbelivers]

Still love it!

[rinscott]

Wow, VERY impressive!

That was great!!!

Srsly, I'm a hard critic and I loved it and gave it a 5/5!

<33

[rinscott]

ps.. I think you should've won, I've watched the other vid and I'm much less impressed.

[SpringxorxWinter]

I love the ending part really. I didn't read the information on the side, but when I heard you singing I thought it was part of the song. It needs to be. KU-DOS!

[SnapeAndLilyLove]

This was just...amazing. i really really loved it.

[xGottaHaveFaith]

love it

[compuzzled13]

I <33 it! it was amazing =]

[mytwilightsong]

this video made this song jump from a 10 to an 11.......out of 10:):):)

[noodlemuffin7]

This is really good!!!

[Rose1844]

J'adore!

[seventeenchick49988]

who did win?

[MelPuff]

Potterink with their video "Ascendio: Ministry of Magic"

[babykabuto]

book or song?

[harrypotterrocs]

SNAPE VS. SNAPE is like my favourite WRock song and you just made it better

[ghostmadlittlemiss]

Wow. That's all I can say, just wow. That was really amazing. I don't know if you won or not, but you deserve to have.

Kayleigh

[MelPuff]

No I didn't lol.

But thank you very much for the nice comment.

[ghostmadlittlemiss]

You're welcome.

Kayleigh

[lovelin123]

I have an account on a website that is 'Severus Snape'

It looks effin hilarious on screen. xD

[ratflavoredgum]

Is that website called "gosupermodel"?

[lovelin123]

If you are talking to me, yes. :)

[SeverusSnapeHermione]

A cool VID. Its the dark Mark Tattoo real?

[MelPuff]

No. I drew it on my arm with erasable marker lol.

[knakts]

The video has some interesting content but it is too slow for the song. The fast beat doesn't go along with the slow motion and the same image being shown for several song lines.

[tastychicken007]

i love this song

[Rock5054]

if u ppl read the books alot Lily went for James bc she thought Snape couldn't wait to be wit Voldemort, and she stopped liking him bc he called her a mudblood o.O

[RayneMarie]

Thank you! Oh, and btw, isn't that so sad, the whole Snape/Lilly story :*( *Tear*

[SILVERArroWGRIFFIN]

wicked

[littlemissobvious]

lovelovelovelovelove this video a million times over =D

[mcrfreak4life93]

Lily/Snape 4ever!!! This song almost makes me cry...I feel sorry for Snape he deserved Lily...and i just hate hat jerk Potter forever...

[gibziesgirl]

No lilly was in love with snape she just never showed it

[MelPuff]

It's kinda hard to say she never showed it since it's a book.

But still I understand what you're saying, I just personally think she COULD have fallen in love with him but she never had the chance. He wouldn't change. He changed too late, she was already dead.

[gibziesgirl]

comment to HPobsessor92. Snape was in love with Lily and Lily was in love with Snape. But Snape turnt to Voldemorts side becuase Lily went off with James.She loved James but she didnt really like him. Lily isnt an animagus u got that right but the doe thing is that its her petronus and cuz snape loved her so much his formed into a doe as well. That make any better sence?

[MelPuff]

Snape was in love with Lily, and Lily COULD have fallen in love with him, but Snape didn't love her enough to change his evil ways, so she fell in love with James.

I don't think she ever fully fell in love with him.

[littlemissobvious]

Fantastic voice you have there.

And also, i love this song. Go MoM and the Parselmouths!!

[SweetItsSmack430]

This is so well timed and edited

I Love It!!!!!

[Alicecullen9]

I love the video! it's really well made and the song is amazing!!!

[abbyemarlowx3]

this is amazing i simply adored the video.

very nice work. (:

[malilite]

this song is really good too !

[JNKBSugarland]

i def. have an unhealthy obsession with wrock! i luv MoM! this is one of my fav songs by them and the vid is gr8 to!

[Hermionellony]

the deer (doe) part made me cry. this was a good video.

[ratflavoredgum]

Eh, I don't quite understand the whole doe thing, even though I've read the 7th book twice and have asked for it to be expalined...

[HPobsessor92]

Ok, Snape was in love with Harry's mother, Lily. Lily was in love with James, Harry's father. James's animagus form was a Stag whose mate is a doe. Lily isn't an animagus, but she'd be the doe. Make sense? Probably not since I can't explain things well.

[ratflavoredgum]

Oh... thanks.

[Marinadellrae]

I LOOVVEEE IITTTTT

<3333

[MargotMeow]

The dude in the hood is cool.

[MelPuff]

lol depends on which one you're talking about, since it's two different people.

[akemi42]

It is really cool to see a vid that isn't movie footage. I love the stuffed deer.

[MargotMeow]

GREAT JOB!

I really like this!

Wrok is the best!

[potterfreak0515]

Haha! I still wear that Snape is Evil pin everyday!

[LoonyLoopyLuna]

Who is that guy playing Snape? lol Over 3000 views! Mel, you rock. My videos...well, they were made by me. Enough said:)

And the coolest part: it says that someone else is watching it at the same time I am. Doesn't that ever happen to the REALLY popular videos?

*huggles*

[LoonyLoopyLuna]

That was supposed to be only to the really famous ones...not ever...nm...

[brainmasala]

really really original

[SlytherinSistahs]

I liked the vid. It was very interesting. Good job.

[music42380]

the best one i have seen!!

keep it up

[MudbloodParselmouth]

AMAZING video, Melanie. Amazing. And I'm not just saying this because we're friends, because I loved this video before I even knew you made it. If you thank me, like my friend would say, "why are you thanking the truth?" It's a truly awesome video. You have talent. Amazing!

[Lalikaa]

This is really amazing. Very deep.

[xDeppObsessedx]

this vid so creative and i love this song. I LoVe Wrock!!!!

[camicastaing]

aaaaaaa son unos freaj super fans

[MelPuff]

Or maybe I am someone who wants to go into film for a living? lol.

[GryffindorPrincess13]

I cant get over how much I like this video .. I find it suits the song so well! Everyday I come on computer, this is the first video I listen to and sometimes I listen to it alot .. =P I got some of my friends singing it and they love it to!

Oh yeah .. good singing!

-GryffindorPrincess13 xo

[dionrosete]

Because the horcrux in harry is destroyed, can he still speak parseltongue or any other abilities voldemort has?

[MelPuff]

Harry wasn't a horcrux you silly goose.

[But honestly I have no idea...that's a question for Jo. I wouldn't think so personally.]

[snapesafriend]

i don't knoe it doesn't say

[janiegirly07]

no. everything that connected him to voldemort is gone. she said that in an interview somewhere...

[LilyEvansForHybrids]

Harry was a horcrux.

Read "King's Cross" over again.

[janiegirly07]

yes I know he was, I was answering to the original question. not these people who don't read close enough. I love Deathly Hallows.

[MelPuff]

lol I know. It's like an inside joke that he wasn't a horcrux.

[LilyEvansForHybrids]

Oh, okay good!

I was really worried for a second.

Someone seriously asked me if Voldemort and Harry were tethered by Lily's blood.....

[shanthenonbelivers]

Oh thats UR voice?!?! Cool!

[MelPuff]

yes embarassingly enough. I thought I got rid of that too.

[shanthenonbelivers]

Aw why?

[shanthenonbelivers]

i like your voice in the back! Its cool and makes it different then other ones!!!!

[BellatrixCrucioYou]

hey i love the song

[GryffindorPrincess13]

Oh my ... I love this song and this video .. good work!

[marst234]

cool kind of boring but interesting

[Samarachelle]

Wow... your singing voice sounds a lot like mine. =S Creeeepy.

Ha ha. Nice job! <3 I lurve this song.

[badlander2000]

I think this is one of the better ones. It's too bad that you didn't win. :/

[MelPuff]

If anyone wants to see the winner it's in the sidebar under related videos.

It's Ascendio by potterink.

[badlander2000]

I've seen that one, I don't like it quite as much as some others...

[xtremesnapefan]

whoops... i meant gay

[shanthenonbelivers]

Der!

[xtremesnapefan]

DID YOU KNOW DUMBLEDORE IS DEAD!?!

[shanthenonbelivers]

Der!

[shanthenonbelivers]

Just one thing tho...I hadn't read the sixth book when i saw this and my bro was acting like he was kiding about snape killing Dumbledore(or as i like to call him by what his name means Bumblebee)But don't worry! I thought he wasn't kidding any way...

[shanthenonbelivers]

Hey Melpuff did tey anoccuce the winners of the contest yet??? I hope you won!

[MelPuff]

lol no I didn't. They announced the winner a while ago.

[shanthenonbelivers]

aw that SMUCKS that you didnt win!

[shanthenonbelivers]

Whispers you should know what Smuck means!

[funkychicken010]

omg that was really good

[erbsoccer]

mel i love this video. i wish i could make stuff like this but i dont have the patience.

[hpiznxt2myheart]

great job! I love this song.

[killermis]

i just realized... Snape is a closet hufflepuff!!!! Great Vid Mel

[erbsoccer]

my favorite part is when mike kettel falls! yay

[shanthenonbelivers]

ROCK ON! :D! This is AWSOME! What song is this any way?!

[MelPuff]

It's called Snape Vs. Snape by ministry of magic. It's a harry potter band.

Is this Shannon from the beach by any chance? xD