Very nice, my only comment is that in the opening either the flute is too fast, or the string accents are too slow, but it comes together as soon as everything else comes in :) very good though ^___^
This is pretty great, I think the attack of the strings kinda takes away from the bounce of it a little, almost makes it sound slightly out to be honest.
It's cool, but - if you want my opinion - I think it sounds a bit like you couldn't decide between playing it true to its modern, electronic style, or playing it as a symphonic piece of classical music.
Oh and I think you overdid it with the percussion.
This isn't to say that this isn't totally awesome, because it is totalyl awesome.
They should have used this as a template for Wii Version. Because, while not all of the redone music bugged me, I really didn't care for what they did to Grasstown.
Ahah, more content from that praised game that I never played. I really like this music though : it's relaxing and epic at the same time. Really catchy too! By judging from the song's title, I think the instrumentation is very appropriate and its quality is excellant.
Seeing the picture with the items, levels and all, is this an hybrid between platform, action and RPG? It looks really fun though, so that could be one more reason for me to play this game...
Oh man, I love this melody so much.
SantuXD6 2 months ago
The picture looks like its from cave story 3d :D
piplupwaitwa 6 months ago
@piplupwaitwa it's from the wiiware version
Lihyahm 6 months ago
Very nice, my only comment is that in the opening either the flute is too fast, or the string accents are too slow, but it comes together as soon as everything else comes in :) very good though ^___^
guymontag5 8 months ago
i wish they can play this at a highschool band
CinemaMinecraft500 10 months ago
amazing
CinemaMinecraft500 10 months ago
Totally Beautiful.............
Truearagon 1 year ago
This is pretty great, I think the attack of the strings kinda takes away from the bounce of it a little, almost makes it sound slightly out to be honest.
Still pretty great.
Pignoah 1 year ago
It's cool, but - if you want my opinion - I think it sounds a bit like you couldn't decide between playing it true to its modern, electronic style, or playing it as a symphonic piece of classical music.
Oh and I think you overdid it with the percussion.
This isn't to say that this isn't totally awesome, because it is totalyl awesome.
GalaxyGuy12 1 year ago
i like it because it has that sort of echoy quality that would be in a cave.
SceptileDude254 1 year ago
Can you upload the midi of this?please!
is awesome and i need the midi to play it on piano :D
FnyFb 1 year ago
sound like kirby music
AjourChannel 1 year ago
2 people are the Doctor and Ballos
KyubiStewie 1 year ago
They should have used this as a template for Wii Version. Because, while not all of the redone music bugged me, I really didn't care for what they did to Grasstown.
FrontDeskMatt 1 year ago
Dude..
1. I like your description
2. it's awesome. Perfect + no missing or false notes.
3. Do You have the absolute pitch? Or you simply checked the .ORG file of the song and copy/paste the notes? '_'
Actually i'm in research of absolute pitches like me lol. 8(
chiliman93 1 year ago
@chiliman93 it's not perfect - there's a number of notes i messed up while moving stuff around etc. that i'm aware of
i ripped a midi file using an org to midi converter (or something like that) but then i messed up the midi a bit
i don't have perfect pitch unfortunately but i'm getting better at figuring out stuff by ear though it takes forever
Lihyahm 1 year ago
@Lihyahm well what I meant by this is, you kept all the most important melodies and it's awesome man :) good job.
chiliman93 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Okay. This is midi file downloaded at VGMusic. Then he replaced those midi tracks with edirol orchestral instruments. He did not make this song.
you chose also bad instruments for it.
kololoilo 1 year ago
@kololoilo wrong
the midi i used wasn't from vgmusic - it was ripped from the game
i then moved the tracks around a bit and replaced the instruments etc.
i'm aware some of the choices could have been better and the percussion is rubbish but i still like it a bit
Lihyahm 1 year ago 7
@Lihyahm I would say it's like the music from the Wii version: good but not as good as the origonal. None the less, this is still good.
scoman91 1 year ago
could you plsplspls make an extended version? it sounds soooooo cool :D
DynaDyx 1 year ago
Wow this is pretty great! Nice work
AkagenoAdol 1 year ago
good good good goooood very good
AleeXDaaviiD1 1 year ago
:D my music favorite in cave story
AleeXDaaviiD1 1 year ago
Sounds like some Zelda game or the GBA pokemon versions.
dragon7x2k 1 year ago
Awesome, by the way, where did you get these samples? Or are they FL studio defaults?
savvn 2 years ago
It's the Edirol Orchestral VSTi
Lihyahm 2 years ago
Oh, awesome :P
savvn 2 years ago 5
I am in favour of all orchestrations.
htilden42 2 years ago
Very nice. I love the music from Cave Story. You should send this to Pixel, he'd probably enjoy it.
The music from the Wiiware game is... lacking from what little I've heard.
barghesteldark 2 years ago
Some tracks are inferior, some are better.
FF7ACJW 2 years ago
Is this Edirol Orchestral?
For future references, this is pretty good, but you might want to rewrite the drum parts to sound more, ya know, orchestral.
KingCheez 2 years ago
Yeah it's Edirol
I couldn't be bothered to play with the drums too much, as I was using the trial version and couldn't save project files
Lihyahm 2 years ago
Ahah, more content from that praised game that I never played. I really like this music though : it's relaxing and epic at the same time. Really catchy too! By judging from the song's title, I think the instrumentation is very appropriate and its quality is excellant.
Seeing the picture with the items, levels and all, is this an hybrid between platform, action and RPG? It looks really fun though, so that could be one more reason for me to play this game...
Anyway, nice version! + favorite
Fullnintendo 2 years ago
shooter/platformer hybrid similar to Metroid or Mega Man, with some RPG elements
Lihyahm 2 years ago
I love how everyone compares it to Metriod, and rightly so!I owned number three for the SNES and is my favorit game to date :D
WorstDoublesPartner 2 years ago
Aaaaahhh i love it.
This game was awesome.
Forbidden5 2 years ago
nice.... hey im a producer/rapper maybe you can checkout my tracks and if u like them then please subscribe and add me as a friend
hopefully ill be in contact with u soon
PhantomRecordss 2 years ago
Now if only it was gonna sound this good in the Wiiware version..
Hatchet2k4 2 years ago
That's what I'm hoping but from what I've heard the remixes aren't that great :/
Lihyahm 2 years ago
Heard the remix on the wii, definitely switching to the original, don't see why they could yours.
aluwart 2 years ago
Ive never played this game but this music makes me wanna play it XD
Z3R04NGEL 2 years ago
I should make something w/ FL studio
5/5
kitchenmaniac111 2 years ago
Nice job! Sounds just like the original!
ElectricPopTart18 2 years ago