Added: 2 years ago
From: TunesNorth
Views: 11,518
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (133)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Lake Supior better moarn for what she has done. R.I.P. to all 29 brave men.

  • My father lost his life on the Edmund Fitzgerald. I think your song is a very nice tribute to him & his fellow crewmates. Thank you for writing & singing your song in honor of them.

  • Brother Tom, thanks for this moving & wonderful tribute to the crew of The Edmund! I'm sorry that I missed this from your channel previously. Just a great job you've done in remembering these brave men! I've always found both the story itself and Gordon Lightfoot's classic song so very moving and haunting! RIP all the brave men who were lost 35 years ago! Semper Fi, Brother!

  • 11/10/ 2010 35 years ago today. R.I.P. all 29.

  • I don't use the word awesome, but....Awesome! Great tribute, Tom!

  • Brother Tom,this is a great tribute to the men of the Edmund F....Be proud of what you have done here...

    keep the faith Bro.

    Mike

  • NOBAMA !!!!! Where is Lee Harvey Oswald ....when we need him ?????

  • @eds1994fatboy That's an incredibly disrespectful and inappropriate comment, especially here.

    TunesNorth, another fine video. My mother's family comes from a tiny town in Michigan's UP, just a few miles from the shores of Gitche Gumee. I very much want to visit the Whitefish Bay Museum now next time I am out there.

  • 2:39 how every ship officer should salute. Good video.

  • Comment removed

  • Wow ! Some Vid. Great song of a tragic event. My Mom worked in a Charity (The Royal National Mission to Deep Sea Fishermen) a Christian Charity looking after fishermen's families in ports across Britain. Not one of the trendy charities but it does its best. Nice work. Andy

  • Nice cover pal

  • Tom, what a wonderful tribute you have left as an honor! Thank you!

    Dale

  • wonderful tom,,5 star work,,,,,brilliant,,

  • I love your voice in this one, it reminds me of when i was young.. awesome video dad. i love you.

  • Tom your vids are simply Awesome !! Keep up the GREAT WORK !! I gave this a High five thumbs up !! WOOOOOOO !! ~Sharky~

  • wonderful tribute tom, thumbs up , i enjoyed this one so much, ann

  • very good singing my friend..5 thumbs up again...awesome singing.

  • God bless the crew members and the shining great lakes.

    Very inspirational song Tom 5/5

  • Great video, great song. Good job.

  • GREAT tribute song !! 5*

  • Whew! I have tears in my eyes. Loved the video. Fair Winds and Following Seas from a Retired Sailor.

  • Great tribute

    May their souls rest in peace

  • Excellent video.

    Tom, I had not heard this before.

    I know the wreck of the Edmond Fitzgerald song, this is awesome!

    Thanks my friend :)

    Indy

  • Nice tribute Tom. I absolutely love the U.P., there are some VERY good people up there. I also have some family up there. Nice, simple, hardworking people. I love the U.P. can't say enough good about it.

  • Omg wow! this is great! You wrote this and sing too? A double thumbs up!

  • very nice song...and to add ....a great tribute! such a fateful nite that must have been.i wonder what it feels like to be alone out there on a night like that.i know ive been out on the gitchee after dark....and it is a lonely feeling.

  • Thank-you Tom for this song remebering those brave men of the Big Fitz.

  • Very well sang and arranged the bell toll was special, I feal the Men who lost their lives are at rest now. Great Work!

  • Very professional.

  • Tom, I think you did a great job i love the song. keep up the gd work nice video to.

  • really well done..thanks

  • A haunting yet very well done piece Tom. Completely fitting with the somber feeling surrounding not only the loss of the Fitzgerald, but all the sailors lost doing a hard job that has to be done.

  • Very well done - love the lyrics and the video. Nice touch with bell also.

    My hat's off to you Sir ......

  • nevermind tunes I pushed the plug in all the way on the headphones Dahhh sounds full now ...Cheers!!

  • good tune Tom . I plugged in the Bose headphones to get all the audio I could but It only came in on the left headphone so most of the audio was the vocals but yeah man very well put together. I travel for a living and will no doubt visit that museum when the time and place allows..Cheers!!

  • you sir are amazing and i am privaledged to hear this beautiful arrangement

  • wow am i glad you sent this to me

  • This is a poignant and very professionally done piece. I echo the sentiment of babbchuck, truly a labor of love. As to the vocals, I felt the emotion. It must be a one-of -a- kind feeling to live so close to history!! Also, how do you put together so excellently the choreography of the video? I will sub also!!

  • Well composed, it is a fitting honor to those who cannot speak for themselves. Also, thank you for passing your video to me, I like the usage of lake scenery and the way you blended the photographs into the time sequence of the film. 5 out of 5.

  • Nice job, Tom. Obviously a labor of love.

  • great song and video. *****

  • Thank you for sending this to me Tom - this is a very heartfelt song and I got chills listening to it. Thank you.

  • My Grandfather worked in the port there, he loaded up the Edmund the day that it sunk. So this is really nice to see. Thank you, sir!! I'm going to Sub you.

  • @mariahwhite1 wow I'd love to hear more of what you know about this...

  • Nicely done.

  • I must admit I know little about the ship but love the song by Gordon Lightfoot, this song is great Tom well done!!

  • It is so lovely, and the twenty-nine people may rest in peace now. I'm a writer, and this song, Lightfoot's song, and it all together has inspired me to write a book based off of it. Thank you, Tom.

  • well done Tom, very nice song. 5*****

  • good song..it captures the state of mind of sailors everywhere, never knowing what a gale would bring...not just the E F but all the wrecks since the Griffon

  • Thank you for sharing this with me. I don't know the story of this ship as I am not an American. However, I enjoyed your song and I could hear the passion in your vioce as you sang it.

  • Yeah, this is great! NICE job!

  • Hell of a job!!!You got a new sub!!!

  • Very heart felt TOM. Good job.

  • great vocals ;)

    you did a very good job

  • thank you for sharing this video with us, good song, and a tribute to our lost brothers.

  • GOOD JOB BROTHER

  • nice vid man 5/5 and god bless you

  • Hello Tom ,thanks for your kindly words ,on my profile, Yes i´m not an american citizen but i like your country , and i recognize the hard work from the US armed forces ,making a, safe and better world for living. great video i remeber this wreck because i saw it on a documental , thanks for sharing and invite me to be your friend. best wishes from a mexican living on Colombia

  • ?????????

  • Thanks for sharing this video with me god bless you and your family also all the soldiers and veterans peace be with you my friend TG out for now happy new year to you and your family. Happy 2010 PS 5 stars for your video

  • Wow thats a really nice video. Great singing and music. Im also grateful for your comment on my profile. May god bless you and your family and keep on making some more songs!

  • Awesome job on this video! Thank you for sharing this.

    Kathy Moffatt

  • May God Bless the soles of our Navy men.

  • Really enjoyed your video...and thanks for your service

  • Nice song, I'm sorry for your loss

  • if this is the one you sng thats pretty damn good sir

  • Reporting Aboard :)) ( Ironically, & gratefully..No bells will ring my arrivall back aboard.. as I have them in my quarters. shinning them up for the holidays !:)) Truth Tom, great tune !! Hampton.

  • Wow Tom, you have really done a great job on organizing this song. I really enjoyed it.

  • Great song, and a fitting tribute to lost sailors in an incident which is sadly all too common. The video is great as well, almost chilling. I might try to sing this myself once I figure out the chords.

    Thanks for posting, and greetings from a Scottish sailor.

  • This is a great song man!!

  • this is Mescaline American..JOE REYNA ..and i believe your song

    is a great addition to the story telling genre...I like the way you

    fused the bell with the song..it s a sonic light house for the soul....

  • awesome video tom do you have myspace or facebook if so tel me and ill add u by the way is that you at 00:59-1:02

  • Nice job on the musical tribute. Thanks for leaving a nice note about our version.

    James

    Cleveland, Ohio

  • Thank you so much for helping us remember those that were taken that day. Your video brought tears to my eyes as I remember all the times my family has visited the Museum.

    As with our freedom fighters, we must never forget. Thank you

  • The bell ringing gives me chills.

  • This is great! Love it!!! I'm from Minnesota so I grew up with the story of the wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald...so sad...This is a wonderful video!

  • This is an incredible video. With all my patriotic images I'm not sure I could really add to it, its so well done! Great job and a fitting tribute.

  • An AMAZING tribute--even not knowing much about the event, this beautifuly written and excellently sung song made my computer screen blurry. God Bless!

  • Great video, thanks. Being english i was never taught about things like this that didn't directly effect us, and this is a sad thing to happen.

    R.I.P to those people.

  • Thank you so much , you should join the support the troops conenction

  • This is my favorite Gordon Lightfoot song.

    Tom, you did an excellent cover of it.

    Thanks my friend.

    5*****

    Indy

  • Excellent Tribute! Thanks for posting 5*

  • How did the Edmund Fitzgerald sink? What exactly happened?

  • 535 feet? How much is it in meters?

  • nice one man

  • oh my goodness what a wonderful version .....this is so moving...so glad you dropped by ....;0) x

  • Nice job Tom!! I didn't know all those details about the story. Thanks for the comment on our version of Gordon's song. I have a T Shirt from the Whitefish Point Museum that was tossed to us by a then-shirtless guy who was listening to us playing "The Wreck" at a bar and grill in the mountains of New Mexico.... In fact...we were recording that night...it was at the same performance you commented on....Jeff

  • This Is So cool! seemed like when the bell woudl ring the paragraphs would come on the screen. cool!! your so great!

  • Tom, thank you for the link and the friend invite. Very well-written song you have here!

  • Very nice, 5*'s Not often you see a song that tells a good story and you told it very well

    Thanks for sharing,

    -Constantine

  • What you have created here is a masterpiece!! Great vid and great song!

    Such an admirable cause!

  • Great tribute.

  • Beautifull made video Tom, i read the story you wrote in the info, there's a little grey area between the reported difficulty's and the sinking i believe, sad story.

    Rest and Peace for all

  • Beautiful tribute to the 29 men lost on her, and all those lost on the great lakes. 5stars.

  • Sailors pray For fair winds and a following seaThe smell of salt in the air,

    The feel of their skin as it's touched by the spray An albatross soaring above,

    Dolphins in the ship's wake at play To witness a work of art that only God can create,The sunset at the end of dayAt night a million stars in the sky,

    Safe anchorage in an islands lee. When the time comes to die as for all it must,

    To awake in Sailors Heaven where nothing ever rusts.God bless and keep you Tom

    5 stars..Dave

  • Wow, you put a lot of time into this.

    It's fantastic! Great job! 5 STARS

  • a very nice tribute for these brave men.

  • Excellent effort Tom and great vid .............a great tribute to those who lost there lives on the Edmund Fitzgerald

    Bruce

  • Nice video; it had a homey feel to it. ^.^ The Shipwreck Museum reminds of a museum for the Nancy (another shipwreck) in Wasaga Beach, Ontario. You're a good musician and singer! Also, I find your respect for the dead admirable.

    RIP to the crew.

  • well done, keep it up

  • Thank you for your service.

    God bless you!

    Sam

    Eagle 1349

  • Very well done!

    The shot at 3:24 reminds me of that little State Park in Paradise. My family and I went on vacation there in August of '75, a couple of months before the sinking.

  • Exceptionally well done, moving. Very spiritual and a heart-felt tribute to honor these brave men.

  • excellent effort...awesome job...

  • This is good. You did a wonderful job.

  • That was awesome. Thank you for remembering those brave men. May the Edmund Fitgerald and her crew never be forgotten. May all the ones taken by the sea rest in peace and never be forgotten

  • Tom, I think you did a wonderful job both on the lyrics and on the video....a great tribute!!!!!

    Chrysie

  • Great job Tom! Well written and performed.

    Mark

  • Well done. Respectful and sincere. Beautiful location shots.

  • A very good and fitting tribute video and song. I remember hearing about it when it happened and have seen all the documentaries on the loss.

    The only thing I would say about the song is to truly make it a timeless song, you could change the words from '29 years ago' to 'all those years ago' or something similar. I understand you made it for that specific event but it could be for any othe the anniversaries.

  • A truly heartfelt song and video.Where would we be without our vets.Thank you

  • Excellent work! Loved it! Great tribute! 5 Stars!

  • The best way to honor the men who didn't come home is to simply remember the 10th of November and the tragedy that happened on that horrible night so long ago, and to remember all who have lost their lives to the Witch of November

  • Great video,Tom!,by a lot,I emphasize it for the emotion that caused in me.

    Thank you by your custom to Yield Tribute to all those people who in any manner they did/do Great to The United States,Country to the which all people

    around the world who we love the Freedom and the Democracy,we owe It so much.

    Just like another video of you,I´ll file it.

    I greet you,my friend,

    Eddie,

  • Nice job Tom sang with heart felt sarrow

    for the Captain and crew of the Edmund

    Fitzgerald may they Rest In Peace gone

    but not forgotten

  • You got it Thomas....keep doing what you are doing. Awesome song and video. May their names, memories and spirits live forever.

  • What an amazing dedication, my friend! Well sung - well-written - thank you for keeping the memory alive.

    Such a powerful, well-done vid. The images are memorable and poignant - burned into my consciousness. Hard to believe it all happened so long ago but still seems like yesterday. The winds and the waves of the Great Lakes lie at my door, and I, too, will always remember the great loss. *****

  • Powerful tribute! Well done. Thanks for sharing.

  • Great video and tribute. Very good.

  • nicely done

  • Excellent!

  • Excellent Video, So sad may they rest in Peace, Comeing from England it makes you think just how big the Great Lakes are, R.I.P.

  • Very good video.Well worked and the best is that it is very emotional I mean that when you see it you can actually feel the honor and the sorrow around it.(Sorry for the English)

  • This is beautiful.....well done!

  • Great video, nice footage and tune too

  • Cool! another great vid bro.

    Excellent footage and tune.

    5/5

  • 5/5 stars and a respectful salute to all hands and the loss of the Edmond Fitzgerald.

  • This reminds me of the 30s when the story of every tragedy was put to song by the singers of the time. 5 stars for sure. *****. Thanks for this gem.

    Marcus

  • This video is awesome. On Nov 10th I attended the ceremony, which was the 34th memorial anniversary - this video would have been very appropriate.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more