Minerva McGonagall & Albus Dumbledore

[11adamlfc]

Thats anakin and padme 

[hoi88kal]

Why is there a scene of star wars in this? OMG XD

[kelliBswagiN]

Perhaps if you portrayed it as her gay best friend whom she possesed an unrequited love for....

[horseshoe270]

I love this video! Just perfect!

[Bella0and0Emma]

Except, ya know, that Dumbledore was gay... xP

[MutierterKeks]

@iluvicecream12

It is not in the book, but just imagination of the creator of this video

It is a very cute video, of course. But it´s a fact that the two were never in love with each other (J.K.Rowling said that in a video very insistently and besides this Dumbledore is/was gay)

[ceejayjan10]

i love you Maggie Smith!!!! ur awesome! xoxo

[SrDior]

Mis maestros favoritos , los extrañareee :/

[RyanMillar11]

a bit cheesy



[SusanBaudelaire]

Despite him being gay, I think they were secretly together.

[mer345]

i loved the star wars scenes

[andrewtwydell]

Isn't Dumbledore gay? LOL.

[kabascoolr]

Dumbledore is more than 30 years older than her. Dumbledore was a teacher in hogwarts when she was a student there. And, J.K Rowling says that Dumbledore is gay. That's why at one part of his life, he hated muggles, because of his love for Gellert Grindelwald, who was as dangerous as voldemort. He was a guy. But, Dumbledore changed his view on muggles and defeated Gellert Grindelwald.

[ekjasdevi]

I really thought they had a thing for each other until Jk Rowling said Dumbledore was gay.but oh well

[doublehanded]

Pity Albus' wand didn't bend that way...

[tdsrockz]

This makes me think that Dumbledore might not have been gay. Maybe he was bisexual. 'Cause I would love for Dumbledore and McGonagall to have had some passion between them.

[samgray75]

shame he was gay

[YiiForsyth]

Many of us were certainly thrilled that the new HP7 movie was already leaked. We all saw the entire thing via watchharrypotter.us

[BlackTunda007]

this might just be the most pathetic video ive ever seen

[rosebibbymiami]

I cannot believe the fact that HP and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 has been l.eaked this soon! My buddy and I found the movie at watchharrypotter.us!

[sharkey288]

Watching this I was all "aww" and then starwars came on... O_O

[WX0099]

that grate it almost made me cry

[jejrstans69]

I'm so glad you used Richard Harris as Dumbledore!! He is the only one. I like the idea of them having a romantic past. Great job.

[RobertoMoreno94]

Cute idea to make Anakin & Padmé the young Dumbledore and Minerva :)

[SusanBaudelaire]

I always wanted them to get together. I love this video!

[1john1992]

dumbledore was gay didn't you know?

[SEKTimPUNSCH]

great.

whats the name of the song ??

[LouiseCantor]

It's just a Fanvideo. In our fantasy everything is possible. I like this video very much, although i'm not a great harry potter fan. please excuse my bad english. ;) best wishes from germany.

[fiyourz]

@LouiseCantor how's viktor krum?

[masterype2]

dubledore is looking as gandaf 0-0

[lazer1235]

mcgongall is one horny motherfucker!!!

[artthefarter]

so what happend so mconigal? did she die? she could have helped harry

[TVCINEMA2010]

I think JK Rowling improved what that Dumbledore is gay, if not she would have said before

[StuntMcUtters101]

flashbacks of Harry Potter and Star wars, thats extremely epic, xD

[TheSophiee17]

This was adorable!!! Loved the lil flashbacks and the song fits perfectly! so sad at the end tho with the death thing =(

[TheSophiee17]

This was adorable!!! Loved the lil flashbacks and the song fits perfectly!

[miladynana]

Dumbledore and Minerva make the cutest couple

I got really mad when I foudn out he was gay, if JK wanted to make someone gay it should be Harry so he could be with Draco

[StuntMcUtters101]

@miladynana when I saw your comment I was WEAK! xD

[agibbs19]

this video made anyone who watched it stupid for life.

[11782m]

youve washed your hands clean albus

[maiii0608]

I also tried to creaty my own story about their past but I ended quiet frustrated^^ i mean it's easy to "forget" that dumbledore is gay, but as a matter of fact he is about 50 years oler than her, that's tooooo bad! =D Minerva is adorable, and so is Maggie :]

[ChristianBrinsxox]

Good video!

Just worked out though, there'd be a eighty years age difference between them! Weird!

McGonagall is epic!

[NathLloyd1]

@ChristianBrinsxox There's a 44 year age difference actually. Dumbledore was born sometime in the summer of 1881 and McGonagall was born on October 4th 1925.

[ChristianBrinsxox]

@NathLloyd1 Wow, is he only that young? I was just going by something JK said once about how Dumbledore was about 150 and McGonagall was 70. I thought it might not be right but I cba checking the lexicon. Didn't know I was that far off, lols.

[FamilyofMetal]

why have you got a video from star wars? blasphemy

[SimonTheSmartestOne]

He ain't gay... I refuse to believe it.

[Tsuta86]

@SimonTheSmartestOne

okay, be stupid *shrug*

[SimonTheSmartestOne]

@Tsuta86 I'm not stupid. I'm just believing what is right!

[MusicPhotolovr2011]

I've always thought of Albus D and Minerva McG as kinda like Harry's grandparents.

[hot00790]

this video is so adorable aw XD

[peacefulgirl09]

BUT he's gay..... so is Mcgonnagal supposed to be a guy...?

[Riss313]

Definite fav!

[smith4182]

i have an idea for a mcgonagall/dumbledore video but i am uncapable of preparing a video. If you are interested in making a video of them both for me, please! please! message me!

[tapdancer55]

this is my fav youtube video.. i watch it all the time.. i really thought that this happened before we found out tha dd was gay

[SophiaPatience]

I feel like a fish out of water... I didn't know that Dumbledore was gay... honestly.

[LunaIsMoi]

Dumbledore is gay

[83annak]

Well, the crossover is so cool: Star Wars and Harry Potter! I like both (Minerva and Dumbi) very much! Maybe Dumbi was ambisexual! ;-)

[bubbles24261]

WHAT! Dumbledore's GAY? I didnt know that dang it! Darn it to heck! LOL But seriously Y Y J.K Y. That sucks. NOOOOOOO I cant believe it y. (crying) y y y

[colmontana]

lmao star wars.

[457Gabriel]

Mcgonagall is my favorite character, but I know that Dumbledore was gay, so ...

[AnimalsInMyHeart]

Well, McGonagall is one year older than Tom Riddle, but I like to pretend she and Dumbledore are the same age...

[Connansvideos]

lmao starwars scene

[Blackrose6767]

AWESOME AWESOME!!! You did a good job.why does Dumbledore have to be gay anyway? His was cool when everybody believed he was straight. I love it!

Dumbledore+McGonagall ROCKS!!!

[aquagirl626]

OMG! its HARRY POTTER I LOVE THOSE MOVIES :) ps and star wars

[brokenagain89]

i cried i love this movie

[galanizer]

Dumbledore is gay and even if he wasn't he is WAY too old for Minerva

[MeepingDino]

Lol, true... Not about Dumbledore being gay, LOL, but like, McGonagall is like, 70, and Dumbledore is like, 115.

[ilikepints]

Why so serious?  It's like in The Simpsons comic nerds: 'in episode...'.

Nice job, Towarka.

[Cascas645]

i really like the harry potter part but why?

why stars wars?

i don't see the point?

[alluvermin]

I adore the two but the starwars part was corny lol

[shadowfox1119]

As much as I loved these two together (their witty banter, their close friendship), I just couldn't picture them in a romantic relationship. Even before poor Dumbledore was yanked out of the closet by the very author that created him. :/

Good video, any way, though. McGonagall was always one of my favorite characters. She's so accidentally badass, you just want to hug her. ^_^

[hogwarts09]

McGonagall and dumbledore would have been such a cute couple

[chilvari]

@hogwarts09 I agree

[24fans4life]

A great Dumbledore and McGonagall video! One of my favorites. They will always be together in my heart! :)

[SSSDZX]

Insane bit of info here, this is a fanvid so whether Dumbledore was gay or not it doesn't matter because he was never with McGonagall, this is clearly a fan based video, one that many people love, so well done Towarka. As for the start clips I'd say they represent young Albus/Minerva.

[Blackrose6767]

So the truth comes out,Dumbledore's was really a Jedi! [the crowd gasp in shock!] I knew it.

[marie2966]

on your video, it looks like Harry is their son :p

[mattyeverafter2]

dumble dore is gay, j.k rowling said he was

[pipinoktonos32]

dumbledore is not gay & why the hell u show us pics of star wars anakin & padmee?

[JWolps]

Oh no, he is.

[tomfeltonshunni]

what is this song called?????

[jaydizzle333]

"Hands clean" by Alanis Morrissette. Beautiful innit ^^

[livvi67]

lol, fast forward a few years later. They've both changed hair colour and look completely different ;P

[Holtza]

As someone who makes gay videos with characters who are obviously straight, I don't see the problem with doing the other way around. ^^ *points to all the "Albus is gay"-comments*

Yes, Dumbledore might be gay (and yes, I LOVE that), but you made an awesome job with this video. Yay for slash! ^__^

[Lozzeii]

HAHAHHA... Dumbledore is Gay.... J.K. Rowling, was on set when she told the Director that Dumbledore wouldn't say a certain line because he was gay... LOL

[MissCruciatus]

doesnt matter. its fan FICTION. you can make anything happen, thats the beauty of it :)

Anyways, i bet you wouldnt complain about dramione...they are sworn enemies. or drarry or ron harry...there all straight but its still fun to post vids edited of them together :)

To the maker of this vid, it was brilliant, actually gave me "warm fuzzies" lmaoo :) x

[karlz131]

whats the name of the song??

[TheLartenCrepsley]

pmsl HHAHHA

one catch though...dumbledores gay ;)

[allelsefailed06]

lol that one pic showing them when they where "younger" was star wars lol

[Fabienne9]

i really like this video... it's so touching... i love the thought of minerva and albus as a couple, they are made for each other... and i love the song, but i don't what the song is called... can someone please tell me what the song is call and who sang that :D

[Shitennou3]

something like `hands clean` by Alanis Morisette I think...

[Fabienne9]

oh thank you... know i finally know it... ;-)

[Shitennou3]

Was it right then?

Glad to have helped you ^^

[Fabienne9]

yes it was right and i am so happy... again thanks ;-)

[rulersmayersboy]

se supone que dumbledore es gay..... o al menos es lo que dice su creadora.. jejejeje

[koolchris05]

i miss the original dumbledore. it would have been very hard for the new one he had huge shoes to fill

[ffrancesccaaaa]

this is my all time favorite MMAD video (:

[NataliaMarie24]

Still in denial with the whole gay thing! They definately had a past,,,,,Great vid!

[funloverpeeps]

I thought this was really good. Albus Dumbledore and Minerva McGonagall have always had a secret past in my mind, that was before I found out that DUmbledore is gay. But, Rowling may have chosen to make him gay, but I prefer to think of the two of them as a couple with a hidden past.

[13sirius13snape]

@funloverpeeps Me too

[Descipledbyhim]

@funloverpeeps he was never gay

in story or real life

[funloverpeeps]

@Descipledbyhim 

[funloverpeeps]

@Descipledbyhim you didn't write the books so you don't know thats true

[sugar4585]

@Descipledbyhim J.K. Rowling herself said that Albus Dumbledore is gay. This isn't somethhing we're making up, the character is gay. It isn't relevant to the story and it doesn't change anything for me...

[funloverpeeps]

@Descipledbyhim again, are you the writer? Didnt think so. J.K. Rowling came out and said she intended him to be gay in the book.

[GOODBADGAMER]

@funloverpeeps you can still full in love with someone, of any gender, 'gay' is only a term of a gender liking the same gender. But love is different.

[imperailist99]

For the past decade people have been writing Snape/Hermione fiction, yet Dumbledore being gay bothers people?

What does it matter? It's Rowling's world, she can decide what she wants the characters to be - I always liked Minerva and Albus as a couple, but JK has decided Dumbledore should be gay. Doesn't mean we can't pretend otherwise as so many people do with other pairings. Get over it people.

[Racization]

I don't mind Dumby being gay. I mean, why SHOULDN'T he be gay? Is there any reason he can't be?

Now Snape/Hermione, that's just out of the blue (and in my opinion, creepy beyond words)

[NataliaMarie24]

oh yes, very creepy....

[duran3d]

There's no reference in the books about Dumbledore's love in any sense.

If JKR would have said that Dumbledore and McGonagall had a love story it would have had as much sense as saying he's gay, so stop criticizing.

Actually many people used to think there was something between these two, so this fiction is not that weird.

Nide video editing. Keep the good work.

[Doogner]

STAR WARS AND MCGONAGALL!!!!

[packets1]

There is nothing in the Half Blood prince about this, the OP is just being imaginative, but should change the description. Dumbledore was revealed by Rowling to be gay in a Q&A session, and that he was in love with Grindleward before their falling out, but she didn't say if his feeling where returned. It was not mentioned in the books, only subtly hinted at. She goes on to say that after Grindelward, he became more or less A-sexual after the the scarring experiences he had in that relationship

[AuslandCharlie]

What when was it meantioned that Dumbledore was gay? I never read that :S

Awesome video, I have always loved this ship. Great inclusion of the Star wars clips. It added more to the video

[NataliaMarie24]

it was in the Times magazine a while back

[AuslandCharlie]

okay thanks,

I tried to figure out which book it was in and it was driving me crazy :D

[missadorable7]

umm you know that he is GAY and that they DO NOT love each other??!! the vid is good but thee reason sux!! sorry but you shouldn't say spoiler if it isnt!

[DebbyMcGonagall]

Although Dumbledore is gay, I think this is an amazing video! Minerva and Albus would make a cute couple. Dumbledore shouldn't be gay -.-

[maiii0608]

Dumbledore is gay and more than 50 Years older.

But apart from that i like the motto "Everything you can imagine is real"

Soo...why not?! :D

[antjackson305]

he's gay..sooo...

[anjalukaseder]

The song is called

Alanis Morissette - Hands Clean

[anjalukaseder]

Albus and Minerva forever ♥ so cute.

[ChristianBrinsxox]

STAR WARS!  LOL! Too funny!

Cute video though.

[stevedacool]

I like this video.

But...it doesn't really make much sense seeing that Dumbledore is gay. But you probably made it before you knew that so it's ok then :)

[waterwind2266]

Wait...When was it ever said that Dumbledore was gay?

[stevedacool]

...

Are you kidding me? JKR said it in 2007! It caused a world wide news stint for a few days, probably up to a week or thereabouts. Just google it.

[ClarinetMadeofSteele]

Personally, I didn't get the context. I thought it was just a publicity stunt. I was shipping these two for years and they're my OTP. so whatevs!

[ItsJami]

She plays Mrs.Medlock in The Secret Garden.

[lastzamwesell]

i love professor mcgonagall

[lastzamwesell]

i love the song whats its name

[ceanL]

what is the tilte of the song??

[iElenaa]

Old people love!

[fashionjosiane]

Dumbledore is gay ...

[AnimalsInMyHeart]

So? We can ship Albus/Minerva if we want to.

[ProfessorAngieSnape]

soOoOoOo cut !.!.!

*sorry i´m crying*

it´s so wonderful !.!.!

[LeParaluieIrlandais]

PERFECT song

[CathWillowsCuddy]

I love it! I thought I was the only one who liked McGonagall with Dumbledore XD

* * *

[ihply0106]

I had thought they should be together when I saw them dance together at the ball in GOF.

[xxlcahill13xx]

who sings this song

?

[trina273]

alanis morissette

[CrowHeartedAngel]

SO CUTE!!

[Valkyrieness]

thank you margarita :)

[Valkyrieness]

what's the name of the film from which are taken the two lover's scenes?? it's so sweet.... :)

[MargaritaMahurin]

I think that it is star wars

[AnimalsInMyHeart]

It looks like star wars.

[tharubaba]

star wars

[musicgoddess618]

she's 44 years his junior. i think ... but i bend timelines. xD

[Pipsky12]

I loved it! The song is perfect for them, although i'm not a big fan of student/teacher ADMM. I liked the bits with Padme and Anikan in as well.

[hippogriffkeeper]

Oh goodness. I have a huge confession to make. I believe it was THIS vid that converted me to the MMAD ship two summers ago... Thank you so much for making this possible for me. Let the MMADness reign! =]

~Hippogriffkeeper

[musicgoddess618]

I think a lemony fic converted me ... but then I found some viddies a while ago and got right back!

[hippogriffkeeper]

Oh psssh! Is that woman BLIND?!! xD

[KatDeHermy]

Amazing! Albus/Minerva♥

[Avidfan19]

This is such a good video...i love this...they look so cute together....Whoooo!

love dumbledore forever!

[musicgoddess618]

I kust realized something. I have a weird mind and love StudentMinerva!Albus fics and this seems like a good song. Ahh!!! Me and my mind!

[hippogriffkeeper]

Oh my gosh, I thought the same thing with this song! You are not alone. xD

I don't really like those fics, but I have read one when Minerva fell in love with Albus when she was around 16 or so, and Albus didn't realize he loved her until much later... xD Silly Albus! xD

[musicgoddess618]

Yea...those are amzing! And I found out ... if you google JKR's email...apparently, you get it. Let's make a list of videos and send them to her. This and "Closer" deffly.

[hippogriffkeeper]

You know, she probably gets a million e-mails everyday still, and I'll bet it's not really her that answers them, because she 'doesn't believe in the internet'! xD

[musicgoddess618]

true ... but if she doesn;t believe in the internt than how can she critizie our random (and cute) pairing?

[hippogriffkeeper]

I honestly do not know. Perhaps she was *disgusted* by what we write, and therefore made Dumbledore *off-limits*. -rolls eyes-

Whatever. I'm still shipping MMAD, even if it kills me. xD

[musicgoddess618]

Me too. :)

[Theappels1100]

And??Where´s the problem??

[MissHarpoMarx]

She never recalled her love for Dumbledore...and i just finnished the book...although..i finnished it at like 2am and i was when they were in the cave and up till the end of the book..lol

[IMWEARINFEET]

well she kinda did but rowling made it like she was blaming herself for dumbledores death and i want to get in touch with rowling a ask her if mecgonagall evr had a thing with and for dumbledore

[musicgoddess618]

she didn't. jkr confirmed it. july 30th, 2007. even though i refuse to believe a word of it.

[musicgoddess618]

I wish she did ... it could be hidden in one of her lines. *contemplates on the world on dialogue*

[BonesBooth206]

Lovely video!!

What is the title of the song?

[musicgoddess618]

Hands Clean

[romans82]

I adore this song and I have never thought about this pairing with the song until you made this wonderful video. Great job! :)

[CatherineDeneuveFan]

wonderful!

[DumbledoresGirl4987]

this definatley isn't true but i kinda wish it was i always thought they should have a secret romance. but i guess that cant happen with dumbledore being gay. but oh well he's still one of my favorite characters

[notreallyhereIther]

His being gay has absolutely no relevance to the story. Just a fun fact, really.

[musicgoddess618]

Yeah ... a lot of people think she said it for publicity (and anger from the MM/AD fans...)

[1MusicManiac1]

And that includes me, I believe that too.

[126Samus169]

I have read all the books up to Deathly Hallows and this is so NOT true

[Minerva1928]

That's the point of...Nevermind.

[12Hinata246]

I know I'm not retarded you know like you. Bye I am a big Harry Potter fan you know. We have Harry Potter Day at my school and I really like it . I am a Slytherin .

[Minerva1928]

I never implied you were. In fact, I don't even recognize your screenname as the one I replied to. Sorry if you thought I did...

...I *was* McGonagall. I even had a FB group for MMAD shipping...

Sorry.

[12Hinata246]

i changed my screen name but ok i accept your apology and Go SLYTHERIN

[musicgoddess618]

...You DID??? Is it still there??? *looks*

[Minerva1928]

No...I'm in one now though. Just search for McGonagall.

[gothexperiments]

mcgonagall must be a lesbian..