Jimmy put it best that "when you look into a garden, you see lots of beautiful flowers", but unfortunately most people still won't get it, because they are not artists, they generally know nothing about the creative mind and creative process, and they have to be told who's the best by so-called "experts". Anyone can tell who is more proficient on a particular instrument, but past a certain point of technical ability and creativity, the only thing left is the listener's subjective opinion.
Wayne Shorter tells the story of 2 musicians discussing eary Coltranes sound. One musician argued that " I don't know man, he sounds like he's scambling eggs or something", to which the other musician said, "Yeah, but it's the "WAY" he's scrambing them eggs!!
@JazzVideoGuy I wish I could have the chance to meet Mr. Sonny Rollins. I've been to a few of his concerts... But I've never been able to see him.. How is it possible for him to do autographs e.c.t?
@vandoren59 He sometimes signs autographs after his concerts, for people who wait at the stage door. But not all the time, and usually not until at least 90 minutes after the concert.
@JazzVideoGuy Oh Ok. Well thank's so much for the advice Brett. Much appreciated. PLEASE DON'T EVER STOP MAKING YOUR WONDERFUL VIDEOS! They help me get through the day!! Thanks.
@vandoren59 im going to meet him at the barbrican back stage on the 20th of november. i got that cance because i went to a jam session and some people really liked my playing and the new sonny rollins! and the gave me free tickets and some backstage passes! so its just a case of looking
jazzvideoguy, please never take any of these videos off youtube, or stop putting them up. You actually make all these wonderful interviews available to the rest of us and i must thankyou so much!
@JazzVideoGuy Yes, yes, yes........thank you so much for these inside looks at our musical "heroes". I never get tired of listening to people like Sonny, Michael Brecker (R.I.P.), and SO many others. You, Bret, are as much a part of my influence(s) these past few years because of what you let me see and hear from my favorite jazz musicians here on YouTube. I hope I get the chance to meet you, shake your hand, and thank you in person someday. Thanks to YouTube, too! Can't wait to see more!
I've always liked jazz as a periphery musical idea, but I just recently began to understand it at 21 years old. I bought a vinyl Lp of love supreme and just sat and listened through it full. It blew my mind. Thank you or making and posting these videos. They add so much mythology to the music.
There is nothing like seeing the actual people talking about each other. There will never be again the likes of Sonny, Trane, Miles, Heath, on and on. We can only admire from our perspective and try to emulate.
Monk and Coltrane were his "comfortable to be with" guys..I love his comment about Miles always having a lot of stuff 'going on'. These interviews have tremendous value JVG, thank you, thank you, thank you.
at 1:38, I can ID Miles, but can anyone list who else is standing there? I was thnking Jackie McClean in the foreground, but he's holding a trombone -- Teegarden?
I just eat this stuff up. Legends talking about legends! As a younger musician I feel like they are almost mythological characters, but here they all are talking about them like buddy's. Sick.
Trane and Sonny were both extremely incredible innovators and we sax players are indebted to their vision and the possibilities that evolved out of these giants. We cannot say enough about their impact on the sax following another great master in Charlie Parker. The two respected each other tremendously.
There's a lot of talk of Sonny being scared into the woodshed by Coltrane, during the period leading up to "the Bridge", but to my ear Sonny outpaces Coltrane on Tenor Madness. Regardless they are both brilliant and divine
Jazz isn't a cutting competition. That being said, I am also of the opinion that Sonny "outpaces" Coltrane on that particular recording (he plays everything Coltrane played back at him and then more). Of course this is earlier trane (he sounds "unsure" sometimes in this recording imo). I'll stop rambling my irrelevant opinion now lol (b/c at the end of the day, they were both amazing on this recording and in general they were otherworldly).
Hello guys, quick question, what is the tune played at the very beginning of the video? I have a recording of it somewhere but not remembering the title I can't quite locate it.... thanks for your the help
a little problem... According to Alain Gerber, and I think he is right, John And Sonny were not really friends ! Rollins was jealous of Coltrane for a moment... And Coltrane considered sonny as a mentor AND as a musical "ennemy"...
AlainGerber is a French Critic who wrote a book about john coltrane "Le Cas Coltrane". Very intersesting and instructive.. Yes Sonny and Trane were great friends for a moment... But in the book there is a long chapter about Sonny/John relationship.. According to sonny when He played with his trio, he played in this kinda group because there was no pianist he would have liked to play with but Mc Coy Tyner... Coltrane had yet taken him... That's an example. Read the book if you wanna learn more.
I'll check it out, but I get my info directly from Sonny, who tells a somewhat different tale. It's been experience, over the years, that writers don't always have all the facks, though.
The actually quote on Pres' last 59'Paris int. about H.Evans is: "He loved HIS inst., & I loved mine TOO!... so? F* U, F* Me...boom"! "Newk" was another nickname 4 Sonny.Because he resembled Bklyn. Dodger's pitcher Don Newcomb. Real name: Theodore Walter Rollins. Listen to the "My Old flame" from the 58' session with Max,KD,Wynton & PC. Newl lays out a riff in his solo that a year later became the basis for Trane's compostion "Like Sonny"
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I've been listening to so much Jazz the last few days..that watching this..is like watching..they might as well be switching from one person playing an insturment to another..it's EVERYWHERE..I gotta take a BREAK!!!!!
great video!
bario579 2 months ago
does there always have to a better? why must it be a competition?
JazzVideoGuy 2 months ago
sooooooooo...who's better?
lesslove12 2 months ago
Jimmy put it best that "when you look into a garden, you see lots of beautiful flowers", but unfortunately most people still won't get it, because they are not artists, they generally know nothing about the creative mind and creative process, and they have to be told who's the best by so-called "experts". Anyone can tell who is more proficient on a particular instrument, but past a certain point of technical ability and creativity, the only thing left is the listener's subjective opinion.
saxjamin 3 months ago
Awesome, but is anyone else annoyed by the narrator's pronunciation of the word 'saxophonist'?
FoardenotFord 3 months ago
Sonny you are great!!
dreadtodred 11 months ago
worthy
chrisconwaypeters 1 year ago
jazzvideoguy you have the best collection of videos ive ever seen/heard of
stratovarius36 1 year ago 9
@stratovarius36 Many thanks for the kind words.
JazzVideoGuy 1 year ago
4 persons have brain damage.
MrPvenb 1 year ago 2
@MrPvenb
yup
annefrankisaho 10 months ago
Love & Appreciation:)
CCMusicianPerformer 1 year ago
trane practiced on the chords to gs for a year. if you need some time....don't be so hard on yourself....give it some time.
lmsypj 1 year ago
maybe, I don't know, sorry!
saxtom1 1 year ago
Dear lawd. FANTASTIC! Please, please keep posting these informative videos! THANK YOU SO MUCH!
hecbiz75 1 year ago
Wayne Shorter tells the story of 2 musicians discussing eary Coltranes sound. One musician argued that " I don't know man, he sounds like he's scambling eggs or something", to which the other musician said, "Yeah, but it's the "WAY" he's scrambing them eggs!!
mumbleora 1 year ago
i love sonny
0okhalilo0 1 year ago
I am crying of joy about this!
jazzuffe 1 year ago
I am crying of joy..
jazzuffe 1 year ago
and da brotha fine too....... jehosaphat.... ummmmmph
r59691 1 year ago
@JazzVideoGuy I wish I could have the chance to meet Mr. Sonny Rollins. I've been to a few of his concerts... But I've never been able to see him.. How is it possible for him to do autographs e.c.t?
vandoren59 1 year ago
@vandoren59 He sometimes signs autographs after his concerts, for people who wait at the stage door. But not all the time, and usually not until at least 90 minutes after the concert.
JazzVideoGuy 1 year ago
@JazzVideoGuy Oh Ok. Well thank's so much for the advice Brett. Much appreciated. PLEASE DON'T EVER STOP MAKING YOUR WONDERFUL VIDEOS! They help me get through the day!! Thanks.
vandoren59 1 year ago
@vandoren59 im going to meet him at the barbrican back stage on the 20th of november. i got that cance because i went to a jam session and some people really liked my playing and the new sonny rollins! and the gave me free tickets and some backstage passes! so its just a case of looking
moley97 1 year ago
@moley97 Yeah i'm going to that concert too. Is it possible to buy backstage passes on the barbican website?
vandoren59 1 year ago
is there diference between wooden and plastic reed, cause for me its much easier to use plastic one.
JanneFlinck1981 1 year ago
Thank you, Thank you, Thank you.......Jimmy Heath's remarks absolutely nail it !!!
studiocucamonga 1 year ago
Merci Bret Primack et cie
kaledoik 1 year ago
jazzvideoguy, please never take any of these videos off youtube, or stop putting them up. You actually make all these wonderful interviews available to the rest of us and i must thankyou so much!
scottspianist 1 year ago 5
@scottspianist Stay tuned, the best is yet to come.
JazzVideoGuy 1 year ago
@JazzVideoGuy Yes, yes, yes........thank you so much for these inside looks at our musical "heroes". I never get tired of listening to people like Sonny, Michael Brecker (R.I.P.), and SO many others. You, Bret, are as much a part of my influence(s) these past few years because of what you let me see and hear from my favorite jazz musicians here on YouTube. I hope I get the chance to meet you, shake your hand, and thank you in person someday. Thanks to YouTube, too! Can't wait to see more!
LEARNTOPLAYCRAPS 1 year ago
@LEARNTOPLAYCRAPS Appreciate the kind words. Stay tuned!
JazzVideoGuy 1 year ago
i love sonny
adelaxxx 1 year ago
nobody can fuck with coltrane
aaronamccoy 1 year ago
I've always liked jazz as a periphery musical idea, but I just recently began to understand it at 21 years old. I bought a vinyl Lp of love supreme and just sat and listened through it full. It blew my mind. Thank you or making and posting these videos. They add so much mythology to the music.
newwind07 1 year ago
These two players should have their portraits carved out of Mt. Rushmore.
clarkewi 1 year ago
80 years old!!!!!!!!
acx577 1 year ago
whats the music in the begginning?
godfather12m 2 years ago
@godfather12m trane's tune 'Like Sonny'
Mattytheman91 1 year ago
yeah!
Jazzsuperfan1 2 years ago
the way he says saxophone is weird..
theinvisiblelight 2 years ago
More gruff and louder, I guess
danielwerre 2 years ago
Wow, Sonny's voice does not sound as I imagined it.
danielwerre 2 years ago
How did you imagine it would sound?
JazzVideoGuy 2 years ago
@JazzVideoGuy lol like his sax o' course!! this is terrific
prvthampton 1 year ago
@JazzVideoGuy like a tenor sax! ;)
BeatBay 1 year ago
John Coltrain, Sonny Rollins, Sonny Stit, Michael Brecker....
Truelight0 2 years ago
Lester Young, Coleman Hawkins, Ben Webster, Johnny Hodges...
huskerspew 2 years ago
Hey huskerspew, Truelight0: You left out Kenny G LOL!!
mlredr 2 years ago
A must have for sax jazz buffs! Bravo!
paulostroff99 2 years ago
There is nothing like seeing the actual people talking about each other. There will never be again the likes of Sonny, Trane, Miles, Heath, on and on. We can only admire from our perspective and try to emulate.
busapp 2 years ago 13
@busapp
Ohhhiee, Newk, Trane, Pres, and Hawk!
helluvagun 2 years ago
@busapp What an amazingly perfect thing to say about people who study and play jazz. Well said
originallhamfist 1 year ago
I love it; this is rare footage!
jazzluvr4u 2 years ago
thanks for this....cheers
retsofnalanosaj 2 years ago
Monk and Coltrane were his "comfortable to be with" guys..I love his comment about Miles always having a lot of stuff 'going on'. These interviews have tremendous value JVG, thank you, thank you, thank you.
JazzmanJibilla 2 years ago 3
Touchy! I really watched it with tears in my eyes
Wyga23 2 years ago
giant
Phoen3 2 years ago
at 1:38, I can ID Miles, but can anyone list who else is standing there? I was thnking Jackie McClean in the foreground, but he's holding a trombone -- Teegarden?
whk1067 2 years ago
Kai Winding?? not sure
retsofnalanosaj 2 years ago
Fantastic!!!
guidomattina52 2 years ago
I just eat this stuff up. Legends talking about legends! As a younger musician I feel like they are almost mythological characters, but here they all are talking about them like buddy's. Sick.
nixli1980 2 years ago 2
I know the video focuses on Sonny and Coltrane, but I've always enjoyed hearing Jimmy Heath speak about the great players
BentGordonsen 2 years ago
what is the name of the beginning song?
dan1880712125847 2 years ago
"Like Sonny" by Coltrane.
swieca666 2 years ago 4
They rock the Chit Chit Chee beats!
nickwarhead 2 years ago
JVG: you're a bloody legend mate.....thanx
kevinherbert 2 years ago
While these two men are in the Bible of jazz tenor, we definitely MUST include WAYNE SHORTER!
ricisrock 2 years ago 16
definately!
but I'll add Joe Henderson whose playing and writing is on the same level as the 3 others imo
Fjord76 2 years ago 3
@ricisrock Yusef Lateef and Sam Rivers too! Hell James Moody as well!!
b133le 1 year ago
Sonny's style is more appealing to my ear.
SEXYMEXY4U 2 years ago
sonny Ilove you
dreadtodred 2 years ago
I haven't heard a saxophonist yet that can bring me to tears like COLTRANE. He is still the greatest (to me)!
peppersax 2 years ago 4
whats the name of the first tune when this video starts?... I have been looking for it forever but I don't now the title or album!
tbone926 2 years ago
John Coltrane - Like Sonny
JazzVideoGuy 2 years ago
@tbone926 from the great album 'Coltrane Jazz'
aartvanbergen 1 year ago
Trane and Sonny were both extremely incredible innovators and we sax players are indebted to their vision and the possibilities that evolved out of these giants. We cannot say enough about their impact on the sax following another great master in Charlie Parker. The two respected each other tremendously.
quickmajik1000 3 years ago 2
There's a lot of talk of Sonny being scared into the woodshed by Coltrane, during the period leading up to "the Bridge", but to my ear Sonny outpaces Coltrane on Tenor Madness. Regardless they are both brilliant and divine
jaikwillis 3 years ago
Jazz isn't a cutting competition. That being said, I am also of the opinion that Sonny "outpaces" Coltrane on that particular recording (he plays everything Coltrane played back at him and then more). Of course this is earlier trane (he sounds "unsure" sometimes in this recording imo). I'll stop rambling my irrelevant opinion now lol (b/c at the end of the day, they were both amazing on this recording and in general they were otherworldly).
saxoman1 2 years ago
It's the way the English pronounce it. I got it from Ronnie Scott in London.
JazzVideoGuy 3 years ago
you say saxophonist weird
JacobShulman 3 years ago
Hello guys, quick question, what is the tune played at the very beginning of the video? I have a recording of it somewhere but not remembering the title I can't quite locate it.... thanks for your the help
oznerolb 3 years ago 2
John Coltrane's "Like Sonny"
JazzVideoGuy 3 years ago
of course!! ;)
thank you JazzVideoGuy,
L
oznerolb 3 years ago
Sonny Rollins RULES man..nuff sayzd
SmokeingEars 3 years ago
great stuff
nubiantgirl 3 years ago
a little problem... According to Alain Gerber, and I think he is right, John And Sonny were not really friends ! Rollins was jealous of Coltrane for a moment... And Coltrane considered sonny as a mentor AND as a musical "ennemy"...
Nabzed 3 years ago
According to Sonny, they were friends. Very good friends.
who is Alain Gerber?
JazzVideoGuy 3 years ago
AlainGerber is a French Critic who wrote a book about john coltrane "Le Cas Coltrane". Very intersesting and instructive.. Yes Sonny and Trane were great friends for a moment... But in the book there is a long chapter about Sonny/John relationship.. According to sonny when He played with his trio, he played in this kinda group because there was no pianist he would have liked to play with but Mc Coy Tyner... Coltrane had yet taken him... That's an example. Read the book if you wanna learn more.
Nabzed 3 years ago
I'll check it out, but I get my info directly from Sonny, who tells a somewhat different tale. It's been experience, over the years, that writers don't always have all the facks, though.
JazzVideoGuy 3 years ago
What a great video, wonderful insight into 2 great tenor players. This is why I subscribe to JassVideoGuy. Keep up the great work!!
gsco82 3 years ago
The beauty of jazz is not one musician outplaying the other, but the gorgeous juice of sharing the music onstage!
Diva JC
divajc 3 years ago
The actually quote on Pres' last 59'Paris int. about H.Evans is: "He loved HIS inst., & I loved mine TOO!... so? F* U, F* Me...boom"! "Newk" was another nickname 4 Sonny.Because he resembled Bklyn. Dodger's pitcher Don Newcomb. Real name: Theodore Walter Rollins. Listen to the "My Old flame" from the 58' session with Max,KD,Wynton & PC. Newl lays out a riff in his solo that a year later became the basis for Trane's compostion "Like Sonny"
cemmi2 3 years ago
Tear of happiness =) May The Lord Bless Sonny and Trane.
Jazzadicto 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
тћіѕ іѕпт ƒаκє арраяєптℓч іƒ υ сорч раѕтє тћіѕ то тєп рєорℓє іп тћє тћє ηєχт тєп міпυтєѕ чоυ шіℓℓ ћаνє тћє вєѕт đач оƒ чоυя ℓіƒє томояяош чоυ шіℓℓ єітћєя gєт а κіѕѕ оя вє аѕκєđ оυт вυт іƒ чоυ вяєаκ тћіѕ сћаіп υ шіℓℓ ѕєє а ℓіттℓє đєаđ gіяℓ іп чоυя яоом топіgћт
kserkiller 3 years ago
nice vid son
fissure226 4 years ago 2
Looking forward to checking out Sonny's gig in Seoul come this May. Sonny is the man.
TampaRed 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I've been listening to so much Jazz the last few days..that watching this..is like watching..they might as well be switching from one person playing an insturment to another..it's EVERYWHERE..I gotta take a BREAK!!!!!
lsdlacedwatersupply 4 years ago
saxophonist (sax-off-ah-nist) = HA
Keep supporting live jazz!
ScanlonJazz 4 years ago
Great video
gtdist 4 years ago
great music... now if only that guy would quit talking over Coltrane...
gosax 4 years ago 2
Einfach wunderbar!
JazzVideoGuy hat die Knüller!
aselmerius 4 years ago
the footage of coltrane playing.. that's "So What" is it not?
dazedandconfucious 4 years ago
It is "So What" from a 1959 TV program Trane did with Miles.
JazzVideoGuy 4 years ago
yes. the full performance is on youtube somewhere, it's pretty great
ChimRichaldz 4 years ago 2
Man. Things like this make YouTube worth sorting through all the garbage!!!!
Toddo31 4 years ago 4
tv sucks now
osumb17 4 years ago
mil gracias por subir este video.
Capi de mardel, arg
crisssst 4 years ago
great music !
loweight 4 years ago
thanks for the great vid keep on doing what you are doing
bazookasax 4 years ago
i have the coltrane cd like sonny its awesome
scottbos68 4 years ago
same here :)
vincentgrit 4 years ago
This is why I watch YouTube instead of regular TV.
ChangitoMalo 4 years ago
Same here.
Extracelestial 4 years ago
Same here.
DanMcCaffrey 4 years ago