Added: 5 years ago
From: joshie179
Views: 255,646
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,167)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I'm so torn between Christina, Celine, and Whitney for first. I don't really feel like Mariah and Barbra belong in the same category as those three

  • impossible, maria-celin-barbra-whitney are the best.

  • Barbara

    Celine

    Mariah/Christina

    Whitney

    Maybe thats more like it.

  • Barbara

    Celine

    Whitney

    Mariah/Christina 

  • Barbra,Whitney,Celine,Christin­a and Mariah

  • Mariah

    Celine

    Christina

    Barbara

    Whitney

  • I can't decide between Celine, Barbra or Mariah for #1 but then it's Christina and then Whitney. I love the first 3 too much and each are so amazing and no one, but no one sings the range that Mariah does. I love Whitney's "Do you hear what I hear". She's got that one hands down.

  • 1.Celine

    2.Mariah

    3.Whitney

    4.Christina

    5.Barbra

  • 1.Celine

    2.Mariah

    3.Christina

    4.Whitney

    5.Barbara

  • 1.whitney

    2.celine

    3.christina

    4.mariah

    5.barbra....and the best singer of all time now and always will be whitney and i have proof listen to the prince of egypt soundtrack when whitney sent mariah packing have a good day all lmmfao....

  • @wallyz89 im pretty sure she wouldnt be able to sing My Heart Will Go On (probably the hardest, vocal wise, song to sing) nobody hits the notes as precise as Celine does in that song

  • 1. Celine 2. Barbra 3. Whitney

  • 1 Mariah Carey - no need to comment, she can do anything

    2 barbra Streisand - wonderful voice, pure

    3 Witney Houston - great voice too

    4 Celine Dion - if she could stop to scream just for one minute

    5 Christina - amazing

  • 1.whitney

    2.celine

    3.mariah

    4.christina

    5.barbara

  • 1. Barbra, Celine & Charice haahaaha!

    2.Whitney and Mariah

    3.Christina but all great artist just my own rating hehe!mind all urs lol!!!

  • Not a fair race. Barbra and Celine are and always will be the best. I'm not sure their voices can ever be topped. Barbra tries to out do Celine but I'm afraid pure talent wins out. The others use volume to try and be as good, but it's no contest. As for Whitney.....She could have brought her talent to a really amazing level but gave up on her talent. To bad. That being said, I have loved songs by almost all of them.

  • 1-Celine

    2-X-Tina

    3-Mariah Carey

    4-Barbra

    5-Whitney Houston

    Celine and X-Tina are my idols. They have such amazing control over their belting. Mariah is 3rd for me because of her phenomenal head voice. I struggled about who to put as 3, as Barbra is also phenomenal. And then there is Whitney. I don't know what all the hype is about her. her voice just doesn't impress me as much.

  • 1-celine

    2-celine

    3-..

    .

    .

    the last and the best

    cellllllllllllllllllllllllllll­llllllllllllllllline

  • MARIAH SOUNDS LIKE SHES' CALLING DOGS WITH A WHISTLE...GET RID OF HER AND IT WOULD HAVE BEEN PERFECT...BURN THE BARELY COVERED NIPPLE DRESS, TOO! VERY INAPPROPRIATE FOR CHRISTMAS SONGS, BUT EXACTLY WHAT I WOULD EXPECT FROM HER IGNORANT UPBRINGING

  • 1. Barbra Streisand (Legendary)

    2. Celine Dion (The Aprentice)

    3. The others!

  • 1.mariah

    2.whitney

    3.celine

    4.chiristina

    5.barbra

  • 1.mariah

    2.celine

    3.babra

    4.christina

    5.whitney

  • 1. Barbra

    2. Whitney

    3. Celine

    4. Christina

    5. Mariah

    That was a hard question, they are my five favourite stars...:) (+ I have an other too: Lea Salonga...:-))

  • @borsika80 In ur face. MC is the best

  • All are incredible, but Mariah has the best control over her voice, she can go from high to low notes without problems.

  • 1.MARIAH

    2.WHITNEY

    3.CELINE

  • 1.) Celine: Such a nice voice even though she screams alot :)

    2.) Barbera: Very amazing voice, on the same page as Celine for me. She has a great Unique voice.

    3.)Whitney: Beautifull voice

    4.) Christina: Too much Riddles, but better than Mariah

    5.) Mariah: Too much Riddle

  • AT THEIR BEST "only"

    1. Mariah

    2. Whitney

    3. Barbra

    4. Celine

    Just speaking out the truth

  • @ChariceBillboard and as much as i like Xtina .. she aint going on my legendary list sorry

  • (cont.)

    #5: Christina Aguilera: Decent lower register, a gorgeous tone and a good falsetto. However, she has the worst technique here and her level of musicianship is almost as low as Celine's. She's the worst one here.

  • (cont.)

    #3: Whitney Houston - Great technique, wonderful mid-belt, the best head voice ever, the most beautiful tone, the most interpretive ability next to Streisand, and the most musicianship next to Mariah. Another legend.

    #4: Celine Dion - Decent technique, a good mid-belt, and great at holding notes. However, she has the least musicianship here.

  • If we're judging them as singers overall, the order goes,

    #1: Barbra Streisand - the best technique, a wonderful mid-belt, the most interpretive ability and the most versatile musically. A legend.

    #2: Mariah Carey - Best technique next to Streisand, the most musicianship, a fabulous lower register, equally fabulous upper belt, and the best whistle register ever. Also a legend.

  • We we set apart Barbra who is not just the greatest of them all but completely off competition (probably only with Judy Garland) then it is Whitney and Mariah. Then comes poor Celine who had the huge flaw in her making never to have been born a gay man in her previous lives :)

    The last one I dont know who she is.

  • barbra streisand is number one

  • You all forgot Donna Summer.......

  • Honestly people, how can you say about any of these singers that they can't sing? They are all completely amazing and most of nowadays wannabe performers can't compete.

    Really love them all :)

  • I agree!!

  • 1. Mariah

    2. Whitney

    3. Celine

  • 1.) MARIAH CAREY FOREVER THE BEST FEMALE SINGER IN HISTORY!!!!

  • 1) mariah carey

    2)whitney

    3)celine dion

    4) christina

    5) barbra

    mimi is the best

  • @Lakayllah haha whitney can't sing now...oops ... you should take your old self and get a life..

  • @Lakayllah haha whitney is just STRUGGLING..nah it's the other way around. u could have said mc is struggling and drug addict whitney is shitting and losing her voice oops FAIL

  • @Lakayllah haha bitch u r just hating on mariah..that's why u spend ur time around on youtube bitching on mc...loser BYE..i have to say haha

  • 1) Celine

    2) Whitney

    3) Mariah

    4)Barbra

    5Christina

  • 1. Christina

    2. Whitney

    3. Barbara

    4. Celine

    5. Mariah

  • I can't decide. They are all wonderful. Each in their own right. 

  • MOST ENJOYED...........(:

  • Mariah, Whitney, Celine, Barbra, Christina.. But I love them all lol

  • good singers

    1celine 100%

    2 mariah 88%

    3christina 65%

    4barbara 41%

    5whitney 24%

  • 1 celine (the voice) EXCELLENT CELINE THE BEST SINGER FOREVER!!!!

    2 mariah very very good excellet singer !!!!!!!

    3christina very good!!

    4 barbara

    5 whitney i dislike whitney

  • 1.Mariah (The Voice) and the best music out of the 5

    2.Christina The best voice of this generation

    3.Celine Great singer and vocal range but cant stand her or her music

    4.Barbara..Superior singer even though I'm not a fan of her music

    5.Whitney VERY Powerful voice and a personal fave.. also, great songs that puts her above everyone except MC. Unfortunately, she does not match these ladie's ranges.

  • 1)Whitney (The Voice) <3

    2)Celine

    3)Mariah

    4)Barbara

    5)Christina

    This Coment is The BEST.

  • in order of talent....whitney, mariah, barbara, celine, christina... but I still prefer celine to barbara... and aguilera to celine... :D well, aguilera to celine I'm not sure, I just love the soul that comes from x-tina... she's very special...

  • For me it would be Whitney Houston, Celine Dion, Christina Aguilera, Mariah Carey then Barbra Streisand.

  • I worship each of these ladies!!!!!!! But, In order of talent and respect, Barbra comes first. Whitney next. Celine. Mariah and then Xtina. Whitney, unfortunately, didn't make her launch pad of BRILLIANCE into nearly 50 years, like Barbra has. Barbra can still hit her high notes, Whitney is struggling. Celine cant have a movie career because she cant shake that Fr-Can accent, Mariah is box-office poison, and her best asset is some mega-high whistling falsetto we're all sick of anyways.....

  • BUT ONLY MARIAH HAS THE REAL WHISTLE!

  • celine whitney & barbra tied,,,, mariah great octaves but in this economy shes got too much PRIMA DONNA DIVE XTINA YES even before mariah

  • Did someone actually include Beyonce in the list? I am not a Christina fan, but she can outsing Beyonce any day of the week. I have no idea how Beyonce became successful. She is the least talented of the Destiny's Child singers, and her mother makes the ugliest clothes I have ever seen. Beyonce sux.

  • @baybaygotgroove

    soooooooooooooorrry BUT beyonce is a genious!

  • why christinafit in there? :( she's so young

  • 1)>whitney houston

    2)>mariah carey

    3)>barbra streisand

    4)>celine dion

    5)>beyonce knowles .....

  • Mariah's right tit is struggling to stay in that gown.

  • 1) BARBRA!!!

    2) Celine (at a very close second)

    3) Whitney

    and I honestly can't stand the other two and refuse to put them on the same list as Barbra Streisand.

  • 1º MARIAH CAREY

    2º MARIAH

    3º MIMI

    4º MC

    5º MARIAH CAREY

    they´ll never be MC, baby don´t you don´t you forget about this

    MARIAH IS THE BEST SINGER, SONG WRITER IN THE WORLD

  • @bconsitt "If you want jazzy style it's Christina"- Or not LOL!

  • if you want sheer voice power and and high notes it's Celine, if you want huskiness, whispering and airy light voice it's Mariah, if you want to dance and groove with effective soul touches it's Whitney. If you want jazzy style it's Christina.

  • Mariah Carey ALL THE WAY!, she is the best!

  • celine

    whitney

    barbara

    christina

    mariah- idont like her she always whislting unlike the other they ca hit high note w/o whisle

  • Its a hard pick with Celine, Barbara and Whitney as top 3 and Mariah and Christina after, cant pick order though, but all are incredible, love them all

  • Celine is the best

    Barbra and whitney are the second

    now is big hole and than mariah and christina (i dont like them)

    PS: great female singers: Ruthie Henshall, Elaine Paige, ...

  • 1. mariah

    2. mariah

    3. mariah

    4. mariah

    5. t. whitney, christina, barbara, celine

  • ofcourse CELINE DION!

  • WHITNEY HOUSTON!!!

  • Celine

    Barbra

    Whitney

    Mariah

    Christina

  • Duelale a quien le duela,,, pero Barbra Streisand es un Monstruo Sagrado, las demas gritan cuando ella en tono pausado canta como los angeles y da notas mucho mas altas, imaginense cuando grite... las demas tambien son muy buenas....

  • Duela a quien le duela. Mariah por siempre fue, es y seguirá siendo la mejor cantante de todos los tiempos. Cantante, compositora, arreglista y productora musical con una trayectoria en la industria de la música que "muchas" quisieran. Más de 200 millones de discos vendidos en el mundo y con 18 singles número 1, es simplemente THE BEST FEMALE SINGER OF ALL TIME! MARIAH ALWAYS THE BEST.

  • 1. Whitney 2. Barbra 3. Mariah 4. Celine 5. Cristina

    Whitney in her day had the best voice with depth, emotion, versatility, and range.  Number 2 would be Barbra. Mariah had beautiful songs and killer range. The reason Celine is 4 is because she is sooo nasal and technical. I can't listen to that voice for very long (it's a poor mans Barbra). Cristina is throaty & pushy with her vocals. She has a smaller voice than the rest. This singer named Robin is almost as good as Whitney & Barbra.

  • based on voice and range

    1. celine

    2.whitney

    3.christina

    4.barbara

    5.mariah (love her but her range is not as clear as the others ones)

  • 1- Whitney (in the past)

    2- Celine

    3- Mariah (in the past)

    4- Barbra

    5- Christina

  • @vitorvog Mariah is almost equate to Celine, dude. she's still good as Celine or liped well as Celine...ha ha.... but I agree with you to whitney...tdo sad...

  • Whitney Houston No. 1 PERIOD!!!!!!!!

  • whitney is still the best! whitney i love you with all my heart....

  • this battle is the battle between the greatest....

    and I prefer most is Ms. Celine because she is expressive at the same time impressive...

    and second is Mariah Carey but unfortunately, she is more impressive rather than expressive...

  • 1.Mariah - Unique voice. Rich Beautiful tone that has the ability to change which is obvious with her different sounds on every album. Range and WRITES HER OWN MUSIC and whitsle register. 18 #1's most successful of them all and still around today along w/ christina

    2.Whitney - Amazing. Always will be respected. typical BLACK powerhouse church voice

    3.Celine - Angelic voice. Sometimes screams to much for me though

    4.Barbra

    5.Christina - nice voice but oversings ALOT

  • It's hard to go past Celine & barbra

  • Celine > Barbra > Christina > Whitney > Mariah

  • 1.) celine

    2.)mariah

    3.)christina

    4.)barbra

    5.)whitney

  • celine is best

  • mariah carey the first

  • 1. Kokia

    2. Celine

    3. Whitney

    ... Others

  • 1. CELINE DION!

  • WHITNEY HOUSTONN!!!!!!!!!!!!! NUMBER ONE!!!

  • 1)CELINE :)

    2)Whitney

    3)Barbara

    4)Christina

    and if you have to give it a number 5) mariah

  • Barbra's voice has endured time much better than Mariah or Whitney's. Celine is still good and we'll see what Christina's voice is like in 10 years lol

  • 1 Mariah

    2 Celine

    3 Christina

    4 Barbara

    5 Whitney

    This is based on who has the best career in t he music industry today whered the all go besides mariah and christina Gone whitney somewhere on crack celine i guess is getting to old for the job

  • BARBRA WON; NO HANDS DOWN!!!!

  • i'm way better than them hahaha joke!:)

  • all of these women are great singers but for me in order.

    1. Mariah-Has incredible voice amazing range and a great artist and songwriter and a sweet person all around and she can still sing and doesnt lip.

    2. Whitney- well she lost alot of her voice but she was amazing and still has a great voice and will always be loved and respected.

    3. Barbara-Great singer and the first real great pop singer.

    4. celine- Great singer but oversings alot.

    5 Christina-incredible voice but also oversings.

  • 1-celine dion

    2-barbra streisand

    3-christina

    4-whitnery houstan

    5-mariah carey

  • 1st = celine

    2nd = barbara

    3rd = mariah

    4th = whitney

    5th = chrisrina

  • CERY GOOD

  • 1) whitney, I know she has lost a lot of her legendary voice, but nobody will ever repeat the wonderful interpretation of I will always love you,

    2) Barbra, magnific voice, sweet, powerful, melancolic

    3) Celine Dion, as one of the guys here said, I can only tolerate her voice, not her singing live

    4) Christine Aguilera, powerfui, but I coincide with her screaming a lot

    5) MAriah Carey, Good voice, but her horrible ego makes her not that wonderful

  • 1. Barbra

    2. Celine

    and the others.

  • Christina has a lot of potential to be the top here. She needs to learn control her over the top riffs and vocal acrobatics. She's good at that but true excellence needs control and precision.

    ^^

  • Oh! Mariah is the Best! Love Her!

  • 1) Whitney LOVE her :)

    2) Celiene really nice voice :)

    3) Christina amazing vocals :)

    4) Barbra love somewhere :)

    5) Mariah i just dont like lip sincers or screcechers but thats my opinion :)

  • i love them all <3 but i really wish celiene didnt try a meatloaf song her voice is more pop not rock but i still <3 her!!

  • @lilloz2k8 Haha! I think Celine did amazing on this song. Meatloaf also took her a song, «Is Nothing Sacred Anymore», was first written for Celine and sang by her, but she never released it, sadly.... Then Meatloaf took it back like 2 years later:P

  • 1) Barbra. Few top Barbra.... Rich tones, clear, powerful...and so funny

    2) Celine (in voice only..I can't stand watching her sing)

    3) Mariah (again..in voice only..too much ego for my liking and her voice is too much all over the place...my opinion)

    4) Christina...Great voice but not in Barbra's league

    5) Whitney..Great voice but I lost interest in Whitney long ago

    Barbras talent doesn't stop at singing...which is where the others fall short for me

  • 1.) Celine

    2.) Barbera

    3.) Christina

    4.) Mariah

    5.) Whitney

  • @STREISOUND

    My real point here is that Aguilera has something none of them have and that is natural beauty.

    Aguilera is acknowledged not only for her voice but for her beauty. Houston is mostly seen as a drug addict and always in fights with Brown.

    Dion is pretty but not close to Aguilera in looks.

    Streisand is not pretty at all.

    Carey is okay.

    People here can't seem to respect opinions.

    Sign off...

  • @wonone100 Celine and aguilera is the prettiest. the rest are siliconized

  • Celine and Barbra are the best here...with their clear and sharp voices in full chest voice belt....they can control their voice beautifully...

  • 1.babs

    2.Mariah

    3.celine & Whitney

    4.xtina

  • mariah

  • My favorites are Celine and Whitney, Barbra is also amazing but I`m not a big fan... Mariah is a great vocalist but I don't like her style much, and about Christina she`s very powerful, but she sounds like she`s screaming quite oftenXD

  • How is Barbar singing a chistmas song and she is jewish?

  • it goes 1)Celine ♥

    2)whitney

    3)Barbara

    4)Mariah

    5)Chrisrina

  • Remember production value and the time sang... Barbra wins; hands down. She can sing w/o back up.

  • @andyinshermanoaks I agree. Barbra has no equal. The other singers here can fight over second place! Celine is alright but lacks the rich tone that Barbra has. The others aren't even worth commenting about. LOL

  • which song is that Barbra perform?

  • Its clearly, Whitney, Celine , Barbra, Mariah , Christina. I will also want to add , Leona Lewis. Remember shes an upcoming star who will remain in history.

  • I gotta agree completly... Celine and Whitney are the two best voices ever, and about Leona, you're right she`s gonna become a legend fast enough:)

  • Barbra forever , forever

  • In my opinion: Mariah, Celine, Christina, Barbra, Whitney. They all hae amazing voices and have been given a gift.

  • Everyone talks about Barbra Streisand's tone, the one that inspired all those comparisons to the world's smoothest condiment. They also speak of her range, which mirrors the distance between the depths of the Grand Canyon and the peaks of Everest. Her lung power invites equal comment; Small wonder since, at full bore, it can flatten a town.

  • wow i love that larreisand!

  • mariah carey the best!!!!

  • Oh and I forgot...My opinion is it's a)Celine, b)Mariah, c)Barbra, d)Whitney, e)Christina

  • wow look at all the comments below...This is not a fight between "celine barbra mariah christina whitney"....It turns out it's Chimier VS wonone100....

  • Celine wins me all the way..

    I prefer her voice skills and tone.

  • MARIAH RULES!!!!!!!!!!

  • Celine

  • incomparable and very individual...I like everyone of them

  • Barbra Streisand

  • For me number one will always be Whitney Houston.

  • Voices in order of beauty and power in my opinion?

    1. Celine Dion

    2.Christina Aguilera

    3. Barbra Streisand

    4.Mariah Carey

    5. Whitney Houston

  • Vocal power is not subjective. Whitney has the most of out of all these ladies, then it's Mariah and Barbra. Celine is next, Christina is last.

    And while preference of timbre is subjective, Whitney has the most beautiful tone.

  • Barbra forever...

  • In terms of talent:

    1. Whitney

    2. Barbara

    3. Celine

    4. Mariah

    By far last: Christina (It is a joke that she is even mentioned in this group. She is such a wannabe.)

  • Aguilera possesses a God given voice of the 7 octave and that is pretty darn rare and unique.

    Not a wannabe but a true talent and that is why she is rich and famous;her voice and beauty took her there.

  • Xtina's biggest hits are "Genie in a Bottle" and "What a Girl Wants." They are cute, but, seriously, they are a far cry from "I Will Always Love You," the Titanic song, "We Belong Together" or all of Babs classics. Babs and Whitney are legends. Mariah and Celine are superstars. Christina is a rising star.

  • @baybaygotgroove

    Aguilera is very young whereas Streisand is in her sixties and Dion is in her forties I think. Houston, in my opinion does not sing, she only makes noise.

    Carey is a great singer but she also is older than Aguilera.

    Aguilera is a success because of her voice and her beauty.

  • @wonone100 Your points are all valid except that Whitney only makes noise. In her prime, she was amazing. And her voice is slowly improving now.

  • Whitney only makes noise? You are certainly mixing her up Christina. Whitney makes music. Christina randonly yells over the harmonic progressions and is out the meter. Nothing she does is music, just bad, offkey vocalizing and oversinging.

  • I'm mixing up nothing! It is MY opinion that Christian sings and Whitney doesn't.

    I have rights! I have the right to NOT like Whitney or her voice!

    Christian IN MY OPINION is more talented than Houston.

    I DO NOT like Houston ok? Get over it!

  • Christina Aguilera is better than all of them in every way.

    That is my opinion! I do not like Houston and in truth do not like anything about her!

  • I never said you should like Whitney, but if you knew even the slightest about music, you wouldn't be saying such bullshit like "Whitney makes noise". Preference for a singer is subjective. Vocal ability is not and Whitney has 100x the vocal ability Christina does. Christina is the worst here.

  • I'm a singer myself so I do know a little about music. I do know what people SOUND like and in my opinion Houston cannot even sing.

    Aguilar is better than Houston IN my opinion and I oh how I hope you can understand this!

    Leave me alone already!

  • @wonone100 says in her opinion Houston cannot sing.

    That is MY opinion and my like and my preference.

    I prefer Aguilar to Houston PERSONALLY!

  • @wonone100 If you knew anything about music, you'd know that singing ability is not subjective. Preference for a singer is.

    Anyway, I don't really care who you like. Ms. Piggy could be your favorite singer.

  • Go look up the word "opinion" in the dictionary and you will understand what it means when I say I do NOT like Houston. In my opinion she cannot sing.

    Why can't you understand this?

    Now leave me alone!

  • @wonone100 You may have an opinion, but not enough knowledge to make the right one. Oh well, that's an you. As I said, I don't care.

  • Think what you w ant I still cannot stand Houston's voice.

  • @wonone100 Don't care.

  • @wonone100 "Houston cannot sing"- HAHAHA! You're funny.

    You certainly don't know what singing is.

  • I know I do NOT like Houston's voice. I also don't like Cher's or Beyonce's or many others.

    It is called OPINION or PREFERENCE.

    I prefer Dion to Streisand. Please leave me alone.

    Please quit embarrassing me because I do not like Houston.

  • @wonone100 I don't care who you like. I already said preference of a singer is subjective. Vocal ability is not.

    NEXT!

  • Then leave me alone!!!

  • @wonone100 Then stop commenting dumbass!

  • I see you c all others by your own name.

    I'm reporting you to to You tube.

  • @wonone100 You do that.

  • Christina has a FOUR octave range, not a seven octave range. For her to have a seven octave range, the difference between her highest note and her lowest note must be 7 octaves. It's not, so she doesn't.

  • @wonone100 Christina Aguilera don't have a 7 octave range....her range spans about 4 octaves....maybe 4 and a half at the most, but definitely not 7 octaves.

    There's no need to lie to make your favorite look good....especially when she's Christina Aguilara. A true talent indeed, I'd even go so far to say she's the voice of her generation.

  • 1. Barbara

    2. Celine

    3. Whitney

    4. Mariah

    5. Christina

  • 1 - barbara

    2 - mariah

    3 - whitney

    4 - celein

    5 - christinia

  • 1. Barbra Streisand

    2. Whitney Houston

    3. Céline Dion

    4. Christina Aguleira

    5. Mariah Carey

  • Mariah!!!

  • Celine N 1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Mariah Carey N 1 )))

  • christina number 1 (L)