CBS-NY: Ron Paul Offers Giuliani A Reading List

[Davidsternsucks]

I think it's funny how Rudy blasted Ron Paul over talking about blowback. Why doesn't Rudy own up to his own failures as mayor of NYC?

[Revolution66334]

this seems to be a better recording /watch?v=DAt6Pf7jZjA

[lmtlsss]

Ghouliani was in it right up to his eyeballs.

[MMAExpertKnower]

haha~ Giuliani got owned here! It's probably the biggest insult to tell someone to read a book and understand policies.. But clearly this guys needs to do a lot of reading! Good job Ron Paul!

[dreamingWisdom]

I'm thinking he should give the other Republican candidates a reading list as well.

[kardentyrell]

Wait Rudy Giuliani was dealing with the terrorist attacks? No...he was dealing with the after effects of the attack, not the cause

[ifuyivara]

I just tweeted this to clown boy Santorum.

[kaldonius12345]

@ifuyivara lolol

[EagleTalonZ]

Looks like Rick Santorum needs this reading list now. Ron Paul has been right consistently.

[blanchfield137]

Ron Paul 2012! Dr. Paul has my vote.

[bschou]

Giuliani's incompetence got hundreds of firemen killed on 9/11. He put the command center in the WTC tower against his adviser's wishes and refused to give them working radios. All the 9/11 firemen hate... and I mean HATE his guts. Ghouliani is pure scum and uses propaganda and fear to fool people.

Ron Paul is a genuine statesmen. It's a travesty that a war profiteer like Ghouliani can stand on the same stage as Paul and have the audacity to diss Paul as well.

[mit26chell]

It doesn't matter what Rudy's uneducated, inn-informed staff person responded with - Paul brought along the CIA's HEAD of the Bin Laden Unit who backed up his claims word for word - enough said. Paul wins, hands down. Anyone who can't see this needs to look into the matter a little more, or shut up.

[Gamabyu]

That was fucking awesome lmao Ron Paul 2012

[thisafrikan]

i love these guys.

[Gioxtream]

outrageous statement from Gulliani...totally unacceptable. Ron Paul you educated me.And.Millions of Americans too.You got my vote.

[tomheryai]

Fine Asian wife lushfmlk.info

[PresidentRich]

OWNAGE

[dulouz2001]

9/11 is an inside job. Ghouliani should be tried for treason along with accessory-after-the-fact O'bomb-a and the rest of the traitors to the Constitution.

992 architects & engineers demand a real 9/11 investigation.

ae911truth [dot] org

[jaaycee]

it's obvious that giuliani is ignorant and his argument was purely emotional with no evidential support.

but let's focus on maria comella for a second. she has to be even more naive/ignorant to say..

"and to further declare rudy giuliani needs to be educated on September 11th when millions of people around the world saw him dealing with these terrorist attacks firsthand is just as absurd"

that argument gets shot down in a second.

what the hell is a deputy communications director anyway

[bodisatva75]

Gulliani shipped all the evidence of 911 steel to china for scrap b4 it was investigated?

was that not illegal?

yeah choose him

[gmachala404]

Gulliani was responsible for all the FDNY deaths on 911 because he knew their radios were inadequate. FDNY complained and begged for better radios but the mayors office (Guiliani) wouldn't listen. He is a traitor to his city and our nation.

[azaquihel]

he was an stupid mayor ...so if a tsunami hit new york the mayor is gonna turn out to be a geologist ??

[faanunu]

Is it just me or does Ghoulani answer seem to be the reason they attacked... maybe he should listen to himself speak.

[Stimuli2000]

This video is hilarious in stating that Giuliani knows about 9/11 simply because he was walking through the street while on camera during the event. I live in NYC and can say that Giuliani did not "deal" with any attack or situation, he was just seen on TV with dust on his shirt. Giuliani has no clue in regards to most political issues, especially the economy or foreign policy. Ron Paul was right in attempting to educate Giuliani. Ron Paul is the red pill. He is the truth. A true American.

[Stimuli2000]

Rudy got PWNED!! XD

[soicuw]

Wow-owned...

[LemonAndYoghurt]

That Juliani or whatever he is called. says ron paul made a ridiculous comment? how could julidude say ron is ansurd while what he said was the absurdest and dumbest thing i ever heard? What he sais clearly states he doesnt know what he is talking about. And he gets an applause?

Americans are scary!

[bluemagicsmurf]

how can we get ron paul to win? I know he would get the popular vote if people ha dthe chance to hear him

something the elite is scared of...yes they are terrified of RON PAUL !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[bodisatva75]

He will never win as long as the Federal reserve (a private bank) is allowed to corrupt the presidency, the Rep/Dem magic show is all manipulated by the same group!!

[brendoncrawford]

Common sense and rationality prevail, yet again. Score one, Ron Paul.

[DAQUEEN718]

fuck rudy gulliani hes a ignorant bastard!!

[lrice6488]

In an election that has managed to both raise my hopes to their highest point whilst simultaneously making me ashamed to be an American we can retain at least a shred of national pride in one thing: Giuliani didnt even come close to obtaining the republican nomination.

With all the lowering-of-the-bar that's gone on, at least that ignorant self absorbed excuse for a human being got exactly what he deserved. To be so unapologetic in ignorance is astounding. I hope this is the last we see of him

[Dakej]

America's Mayor? Fair and balanced my ass.

[Dakej]

Agh it's CBS, I just saw the Fox logo and made an assumption.

[gnuspeak]

Barack Obama/Ron Paul

Uniting for CHANGE in 2008

[edmundohillary]

How can you not love this guy?

[INFOWARforYourMind]

Ron Paul Revolution

Legalize the Constitution

[passwordthisasspart2]

Ron Paul actually speaks his own mind and not the corporate spin that McCain and Hillary spew upon us !

[chewbaca1989]

Classic, I wonder if Rudy ever got around to the books.

[dj3902]

I still can't believe ppl casted votes for Rudy that cross dressing wife hopper.

[swanseaboy]

What's ubsurd to me is that Giuliani really expects people to believe that he is right on count of ignorance.

What he said was complete rubbish and made him look a fool and the people who clapped him are IDIOTS!

All he did was laugh when Ron Paul spoke, which is such a childish and pathetic thing to do. It is not the way to debate at all, and he is NOT a 9/11 hero, he is a fraud.

[kiddwee]

That's ALL you got "SCUMBAG," "LIAR" So the CIA and the 9/11 commissions report are also SCUMBAG and LIARS? He will NEVER say that 9/11 was in INside job. Even IF he did believe that, he cares too much for his life. BUT he repudiates that. He AGAINST Corporatism, WAR, he's NOT bought by BANKERS, CORPORATE AMERICAN, or the MEDIA. Lobbyists pass his office in Washington. GET a GRIP.

[Leen234]

you're absolutely right!

his positions, his voting history, all those facts prove he can't be corrupt.

[swanseaboy]

He isn't a scumbag or a liar. If you know politics at all, saying that you believe in something such as 9/11 inside job would RUIN your politics career straight away!

[JonnyRingo84]

conspiracy theorists should shampoo my crotch. look up the term "confirmation bias" and you will know the basis for your beleifs.

[LemonAndYoghurt]

you keep on playing Dumb asshole! The dumness of most Americans scares the shit out of me, because America has so much saying everywhere in the whole wide world. And you're supporting such Nazis.. Screw you, I get sick to stomach just thinking about how dumb you dimbwitts are!!

[mooc1]

Giuliani was wrong and knows it...but why would he admit it? Doesn't matter anyway, Ron Paul has more votes then he has. It doesn't surprise me that no one likes Rudy...he has no idea what he is talking about and his puppet strings are quite visable.

[munqui]

Doesn't make any difference now. He's suckin hind tit,and John McCain's ass.He's history, and you know how fast we forget history.

[munqui]

Rudy,that is. not Dr. Paul

[Philosophobia]

Yay!!! Ron Paul!!! If you don't vote Ron Paul in 2008, you're not an American!!!

[lucasllama]

I support Ron Paul, and your statement is the dumbest thing I've ever heard.

[Philosophobia]

Okay? Why? You think any other candidate is a proper representative for America?

[lucasllama]

I support Ron Paul just like you, but I say your statement ("If you don't vote Ron Paul in 2008, you're not an American") is the dumbest thing I've ever heard because when you say that, you sound just like the neo-conservatives who bash Ron Paul. Calling non-Ron Paul supporters non-American is against everything Ron Paul stands for and it's embarrassing to all the Ron Paul supporters that have a brain.

[Philosophobia]

So, defending the constitution isn't American?

Promoting the founding fathers and peace isn't American?

Wanting American's to be free, keep our sovereignty, keep our money, and not police the world isn't American?

Ron Paul IS the embodiment of America, and that's why I say what I say. Anyone who doesn't vote for Ron Paul doesn't support America, the constitution, or the economy, Go fuck yourself, prick.

[lucasllama]

I like how you're bashing me for AGREEING with your political beliefs. Calling people Un-American for disagreeing with your beliefs is Un-American, that's what makes this country great is that we have the right to disagree. So keep on embarrassing yourself bashing people that not only disagree with you, but agree with you as well! Go Ron Paul!

[Philosophobia]

You attacked me first, lol. You called me dumb, and said I didn't have a brain, you're such a deluded twat, and you say I'M the embarrassment? And I don't care if you agree with me politically or not, a prick's a prick no matter who they support.

[dhchemistry]

He was just pointing out that it's unfair to call someone un-American for voting for a candidate other than Paul. Given that Paul is a great representative of American principles, it is unfair to call someone un-American simply because they have different political preferences than you. That is un-American.

[Philosophobia]

I'm not attacking freedom of choice. I'm attacking choosing anyone who doesn't stand for the constitution, not policing the world, fixing the economy, or giving you your freedom IS un-American.

The other Republicans want to stay in Iraq, send even MORE Americans to Iraq, and send the country even deeper into debt by funding it, and the dollar will go further in the toilet, fighting a war you can't win and never should've fought in the first place. Those are really true Americans right there!!!

[Jermybug]

What's absurd is that Giulianni thinks just because he may have handled 911 well (and that is open to debate), he thinks he's an expert on foreign policy.

[STRINGMAGICK]

Dr Ron Paul has my vote!

[ronpaul2016]

Blowback by Chalmers Johnson??? Chalmers Johnson is the standard Berkeley educated leftist.

He has made a career out of bashing America. Even if things "changed" to the way he viewed them, he'd have to find something wrong to keep cashing checks to keep up his lifestyle.

I'm disappointed in you, Ron Paul. I'm sure most Ron Paul supporters could give less than a rat's ass, but isn't he supposed to win the republican primaries? That ain't gonna happen.

[Katyousha]

giuliani is a pro Israeli jew. If you want this schmuck to bring America to war and hand over the US to the jewish lobby then make him US president.

[arznodoubt]

"to suggest that Giuliani needs to be educated on 9/11 when millions of people saw him dealing with these attacks firsthand is absurd"

WTF does being a mayor on 9/11 have to do with the foreign policy issues involving terrorism!!???

Rudy and his people are the master of the straw man argument on these issues.

[dbillesbach]

Funny...Millions of people shouldn't have seen him if he was doing his job instead of schmoozin the cameras! Once the gold was gone he was out and ordered the NYFD to stop lookling for dead brothers. Due to his lack of responsibilty to assure NYFD's, they're still finding firefighter's remains in the CITY DUMPS!!! NYFD does NOT like Rudy! That's our problem...People are stupid when it comes to the facts!

[chere7up]

call your county precinct and start attending your precinct meetings, you will notice not very many people are involved..asked if you can host..that makes you a state delegate. Go in offer to help, and you can be undecided and then once you learn about RP you can be in an powerful position for getting our man elected for primary & President..Become delegates..URGENT..

[RonPaulCentral]

Help Rudy learn to read:

RudysReadingList dot com

[mlystew]

Wow, this guy is BOLD!! LOVED IT!! Like biden said, giuliani only says, "noun, verb, 9/11" yet he hasn't read the 9/11 commission! Ron Paul 2008

[Ahtahs]

It is 100% inexcusable that Giuliani never read the 9/11 commission report.

[dleemm]

Veterans for Paul Go Ron Go !!

[tplayer73]

I just see DISHONESTY written all over Giuliani's face (and the faces of so many other candidates). Isn't it obvious??? WAKE UP PEOPLE!!! The only candidates that I sense honesty, sincerity from are Mike Gravel & Ron Paul. But as it stands, I'm voting for Ron Paul!

[onelove51]

Rudy is too blinded by his emotions leading to infantile tunnel vision. Not his fault, but please don't put him in office.

[gregc12345]

Ghouliani is an idiot. Ron Paul 2008!

[ghosttwo2]

"America's Mayor" my achin' ass.

[RageAgainstTheMach]

That tool Ghouliani got owned hard by Dr. Paul! Maybe he should read the 9/11 commission report and study up on some foreign policy before he tries to stand toe to toe with Ron Paul. All he has to run on is poor sound bites, and fear tactics.

Ron Paul 2008!!! The peoples choice

[TainaAtheist1]

Giuliani is absurd for thinking that the terrorists had no basis in reason to attack. Clearly, Giuliani is a bad listener or he would have heard Bin Laden say it was done because of U.S. occupation overseas, just like I heard it.

[hoorock]

So by the Giuliani camp's logic, because he happened to be the mayor of New York while it was attacked, he's now a foreign policy expert. How does living through the 9-11 attack make him an expert on the 50 years of history of US-Middle Eastern relations? That's the most absurd thing I've ever heard. How can he possibly chastise a guy for citing the CIA document on 9-11? He's an unabashed idiot. Ron Paul in 2008!

[JonnyRingo84]

your right that is absurd. but shallowly, it SOUNDS so good. shallow people who vote off of slogans alone will love guliani's response. "well hell yea he was THERE...what can ron paul teach him about it?!" sheep.

[GinsingSullivan]

The People want Ron Paul in 2008!

[genYprogressive]

Thank you Ron Paul!!!

[paulyd0021]

stupid news, i guess they have to protect their own asses by reporting what people want to hear "Giuliani, the WAR HERO" . Well let me tell you he didnt do sh**. Had ANYONE ELSE been the mayor of NY at the time, I'd swear on my life they would have done a better job post and pre 911. Hundereds of our fireman died because he never supplied them with updated equipment such as radio contact incase of an emergency. He is no hero, and if anything he's closest to a criminal.

[bajaw55]

this was classic. i wonder how stupid guiliani would actually feel if he did the reading assignment. he would probably cry himself to sleep if he realized how ignorant he really is..

[Raisinjeff]

Rudy Giuliani did not deal with the terrorist attacks firsthand. If he did, he'd be patrolling Afghanistan in fatigues.

[edbrown100]

This is an absolute riot - suggesting a reading list. Forget arguments. How about some good, old fashioned education? Love it. Condoleezza Rice gave Bush a reading assignment, too - 'Crime & Punishment'. ...seriously. Giuliani and 'big, bad' stance is watered down by his whoredom for the powers that be.... that and his lisp, of course. ;-)

[311Transistor311]

Haven't heard about Bin Ladin lately...hmmmmmmmm...figures!!

[morris0n2]

$ paul!

[JChibiabos]

Both Giuliani and his mouth piece, Cormella are in desperate need of education. Perhaps the best place for them to start would be kindergarten. Neither of them appear to have a clue about the real world.

[greatbroad]

NATIONALISM'S POSTERBOY: Rudy Guliani

A REAL PATRIOT: Ron Paul

[LEATSLAN]

Naw, JulieAnnie needs to be educated about foreign policy... only a brainless dolt would really believe we were attacked "for our freedoms" or "they hate us for our freedom"... that's just bullshit

[infokemp]

Ron Paul again uses reason and logic.

Ghooliani acted like a child and so he's Getting A Hard Truth Lesson.

Ron Pauls 2008!

[TexasRounder]

Bahahaha, keep sticking to your guns Guiliani. After all you must be the expert your were the Mayor of the city that got attacked.

[imhuami]

youtube-com/watch?v=-jUWRAB_e0­c

The International Association of Firefighters held their Presidential Forum and Rudy "America's Mayor" Giuliani was MIA. President of the Association Harold Schaitberger appeared on Hardball last night and had some extremely harsh words for Rudy and his ;egregious acts; against the FDNY in the days and weeks after 9/11.

[imhuami]

Your in delusionville kellie and your insinuation RP is left is absolute idiocy. Turn off faux newz and put down the crack pipe. Might I suggest reading also. kelliekv (2 minutes ago) marked as spam

the fringe left...you guys crack me up. You guys call propaganda facts. The real facts seems to go right over your head.

[kelliekv]

the fringe left...you guys crack me up. You guys call propaganda facts. The real facts seems to go right over your head. How sad. Youtube is filled with pure HATE. HATE from the left. You want the truth, you listen to Rudy. You want to hear a crackpot nut job with conspiracy theories, you listen to Paul.

[Liberty0rDie]

"They hate us for our freedom." - Rudy Giuliani

"Freedom is Authority" - Rudy Giuliani

"We're being attacked for what we do in the Islamic world, not for who we are or what we believe in or how we live" - Michael Scheuer, chief of the CIA's Osama Bin Laden task force

"They identify with the Palestinian problem, they identify with people who oppose repressive regimes" - FBI Special Agent James Fitzgerald

Who is spitting propaganda? Please, tell us what is the "Truth" Rudy speaks?

[gearzone2611]

You get it from the 9-11 Commission Report?

[rapsody]

fringe left? lol that the only argument you people have isn't it? anytime ANYONE disagrees with you on any issue, LEFTIE!! crackpot!! nutjob!! (place name call here)!!

[DoctorFist]

You have no actual defense for your claims, do you kelliekv? Feel free to post more so that it becomes even more obvious that you actually know nothing. Try responding to 'Libertyordie'; stop fervently labelling everyone on the left a crackpot, it only makes you sound childish and less credible (you should know this??)

[deceivedone]

Watch Zeitgeist and research Walter Burien

Ron Paul 2008!

[johnnyappleseedism]

@kelliekv fringe is fringe, doesn't matter if left or right. some of the investigators of 9/11 say they were obstructed and a new investigation is needed. but if you say rudy is the man to listen to, i guess you're right. everyone run for your lives! the commies are coming to kills us! ooops, i mean the terrorists are coming to kill us! but just keep that defense budget huge and we'll protect you. guess no one watches mafia movies.

[pumaman1]

Ha!ha!

Rudy just "walked" into that one ... Reel 'm in Ron!

lol

[johannesgrimm]

Dr. Paul NEVER said (or implied) that the US "invited the attacks".

[billbacon]

YEAH!!! That's really funny!

[eracer34]

RonPaul2008dotcom

RonPaulites Stand Up!!!

[flugplug5]

Don't het me wrong .. there are terrorists . but Rudy saying crap like "they're gonna follow us home" that's just pure scare tactics for votes.

[flugplug5]

ROFL . a reading assignment! There little smear tactic didn't accomplish anything .. you should hear the news now.. it rings of Ron's statements when talking about the iraq issue. i.e.-Edwards: "The war on terror is nothing more than a bumper sticker"

[d991]

Um, has anyone asked Rudy where exactly he is getting the "they hate us for our freedom" bit? Paul seems to have some factual evidence. Even if Rudy doesn't believe Paul's facts are valid, at least Paul has some facts....

[radiofriendly]

When's the Rudy/Ron Paul Debate? Rudy you are a joke!

[djbAnks]

pwnd

rudy is no president and he is not my mayor! he is however a parasite politician. straw man arguments do not fool the good Dr Paul. Get real jewels.

[vieboheme]

Lol, Rudy got owned.

God bless Ron Paul, he's wise and has guts !

[ZRASEC]

Rudy = Gay ( sorry for offending the gays)

[kevin29chev]

Rudy,Rudy,Rudy, your done!

[bossobass]

Mr. Giuliani...Reading Is Fundamental

[jeremydmccann]

Rudy, give it up man. You are completely unfit to lead this country. The good Dr. owned you!

[cujothekitten]

LOL, Ok Rudy you go ahead and keep on thinking that.

[onetimeswine]

By Rudys logic, stomping in a pile of poop makes one an expert on fecal matter.

Hey Rude, another reading assignment for ya: Google "Operation Ajax" then ask your "terror expert" self if just maybe that upset a few people. The corporate media liars never mention US debacles like Operation Ajax, Rudy is counting on ignorance.