Ashley - Vanessa - Colbie - Kiss The Girl

[slinkeemink1]

the 2nd version is not Vanessa. it's No Secrets.

[henry12014]

colbie is wwwwwwwaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyyyy better

[MajorGleeFanatic]

Colbie is totally the best

[qerenzu]

COLBIE BESTTTT :DDDDDD

[tubedude101]

ahley and vannessa are lesbian lovers

[Tsukaruu]

vanessa faild it to the power of EPIC, ashley is alright, and colbie is the best but nothing beats the original

[menlo76]

colby calliat i love you mami, you rock my heart big time , not like this bitches, who the fuck told them they can sing????????????????

[jcmahal]

Colbie, Ashley, and Vanessa in that order

[menlo76]

you suck!

[baamze]

@menlo76 Thank you x)

I like you.

[menlo76]

@baamze no disrespect but damn they fucked up such a nice song, hell, im 34 yrs and i love the music and lyrics of it but listening to this pisses me off

[lorejenny]

I prefer Ashley !!!

[giantbigfatbutwhosme]

i still like ashleys better i think i always will

[Dree12334]

Well i got used to the ashley's one . It reminds me kind of good memories i just heard colbiue's one for the first time a few minutes ago but i can't choose between colbie's version & ashleys .

BUT WHAT THE FUCK WAS THE VANESSA HUDGEN'S VERSION ?!!?!?! it's awful.

[madelt91]

ahhhh!! we always save the best for the last.

I'd only heard caillat's version before this video , but i guess i hadn't missed out on anything at all.

[lovelycharm04]

~ it doesnt sound like vanessa LOL :))

[spitxlexx]

I love Ashley's and Colbie's version best! ^^, can't pick from the two! hehehe ^^,

Vanessa's version though was the worst! I hate it!

[monskidudel]

the best is Sebastian's version :)

[lilpolarprincess]

Ashley's is more upbeat.

Vanessa's - it's not even Vanessa, people!

Colbie's is nearly the same as the original one.

[missycb34]

Colbie.

[Lynx790]

colbie is the best ashley is second and venessa is the worst

[blackrose31328]

it's like listening to crap then colbie sings and it's worht it to lisen to the beginning lol

[violetdreamz17]

Relaxing voice of Colbie.

[0oLenaaao0]

ashley is the best <3

[violetdreamz17]

Colbie really sings good...

[BaybiieJo]

ashley and vanessa dont really put effort into singging it so colbie is clearly better

[trendey1]

wow how is this even a compition clearly colbie is the best hers makes me remeber why i love the little mermaid ashleys i cant say sucked but com'on what is she 5 and that wasnt even vanessa that was videos made from other songs of hers and if it was her voice she needs to get that in check

[MysticGirl2458]

Ashley: Awsome

Nessa: That's actually Hilary Duff singing!

Colbie: meh, im not impressed! it's gd ye but i personally dont feel it

[angelusryu]

Is that really Ashely Tisdale? Wow, I guess it is true that without the makeup, most stars look like crap. I actually prefer the Colbie version of the song overall, though nothing can beat the original version - which, for those wondering, was actually performed by Samuel E. Wright.

[maichic123]

Vannessa sucks.. :(

[redmoonteeth121]

colbie is the best i think

[magita666]

i like colbie the best

[abrcrmbgrlify]

colbie for sure 100%

x

[12345susu]

colbie = best

vanessa is shit !!!

ashleys ok

[Summ3rs1]

Vanessa is lousy at singing. sorry -.o

[desirosalynwirawan]

yay colbie!! boo vanessa.. haha.. =)

[SilentwishX]

vanesA sucks!!

XD

[PlasteredHeart]

colbie :)

[MTV1996]

thats not vanessa thats no secrets

[ritathinkspink]

The best one is the original.

Then Ashley Tisdales one.

Then Colbie.

[MaiCecile]

Cooooooooolbie! This is one of my fave songs ever <3

[faireewingz1995]

omg colbies is ma fave by far. The music vid is really cool of hers xx

[323tinkerbell323]

i like colbie the best for sure than ashley than vanessa

[swimmingdolphin8393]

Colbie is the best by far! I love her other music too! <3

[laetitia877]

Colbie Caillat 's version is clearly better. I hate Vanessa Hudgens' v.

[KyleMLape]

OH GOD absolutly Colbie

[celtticnesses]

ashley is too "rock" ish and babyish.

the so called vanessa- too fast and sounds like a remix

colbie.. ahh nice peaceful mature perfect <3

[Marielu127]

If I could, I would give your comment 100 thumps up.

[ela0205]

ashley and colbie are good but vanessa is realy bad

[Mac5Productions]

yeah vanessa's is just bad. colbie's is relaxing

[californiaboy1990]

colbie is the best :)=

[PurestDelight]

colbie, easy!

[StIllaHeart]

ashley's then colbie's then vanessa's.

i dont think it's vanessa hudgens singing that though. it doesnt sound like her O_O

[frfr55clubpenguin]

thats her but she didnt do a music video it was disneys secret than disney relesed it on radio disney

[leonajonasx3]

its not vanesssa! stupppid :D

[maximumridegirl51]

its not vanessa. its a group called no secrets.

[kavieni]

Totally - Ashley sounds too pop star, Vanessa is far to fast, colbie is just nice :D

[mooniloverichielight]

exactamente !! i prefer colbie´s version !! :)

[Fopitaa]

volvete de donde te viniste vanesa!

[StupedSleepoverz]

Ashley's and Colbie's are great. Vanessa's is...well. Alright. I suppose.

[bluebaboosk]

i like colbie's, she sings so well!!

its not so preeteenie lol

[FallingAngelxx]

Ashely's then colbie's then vanessa's i think she changed the song to much it doesn't sound right.... thats just my opinion tho

[dreammaster495]

Ashely's is the best. Then Vanessa's.

[diegozcolombia]

Personally prefer the Colbie Caillant Version

[HildaaJonas]

WHERE IS THE PART OF VANESSA?

[inlovewithyouonly14]

ashley looks really bad in that picture

[Miley0XX5]

I perfer ashley :)

[xCBITWx]

that is deinitely No Secrets... -.-

[clubrent]

Again i like the vid but the one suposily made bii Vanssa is really made bii agroup called No Secrets. If u dont believe mii it is on Disney Manie 1. Btw im a girl usinq mii dad's account.

[florawinxcutegirl]

colbie's one is ok but i prefer ashley tisdale :)

[wateermeeloonn]

I agree!

[florawinxcutegirl]

thanks!

[milleniumcrystal]

yuuuuuhp!!!!

[florawinxcutegirl]

hehehehe

[ilolweizbhir]

i like colbie's version:) but ashley's version is nice too

[StarLightoO]

That isn't Vanessa?!

[cutehnin]

ya hu no her

[coffil]

Death to copy pasters

[MirandaDeleon]

fOo shut yo fucken azz up!

[Deemii13]

this isn't vanessa's voice

so i dont know?

[FroschLiii]

I find Ashley is the best and vanessa second because I like the quicker version!

Colbie is worst because I do not like her voice!

[12ock]

easy go lucky vanessa colbie relaxing ashley hmmph i dont know how to discribe its like seductive!!

[Mstar82]

Although Colbie's voice seems to be the best, she sings really great.

But I like more the girly version from Ashley as I said ^^

Uhm the other version of that girl from HSM (or isn't that she?) is really really bad THAT's what I would call really fucking up a classic, the other covers are decent.

I'd say:

1. Ashley (oh shes pretty :)) 2. Colbie 3. Vanessa (her version really don't deserve a rang actually..)

But ya Colbie got the most mature voice, but I fall more for the girly

[Mstar82]

I came randomly to the Ashley Tisdale version of Kiss The Girl and realized much later that it was a cover of the Disneys Little Mermaid song.

Well at first I didn't like Ashley Tisdale's version it was so annoying to me but then for some reason I had to listen to it again and again and now I kinda like it its really sweet.

Now I figured out that there are more covers.

I like Ashleys the most as she's really pretty in the music vid and it was the first I've ever heard so yeah.

[musicislovee13]

colbie's is the best. second only to the original haha

[mixtapes14]

i know!!!

[petewentz9998]

i likes colbies and the crabs!

[PaninyPictures]

ashley je nej pak vanessa a nakonec colbie

[Maria82599]

Colbie beats them to the top, ashley, Nice beat vanessa uggg!! she ruined the song

[ZlovesAxx]

I ABOSOLUTELY DISPISE vanessa's..

it really annoying and just TOO remixed.

& the talking irritates me..

[happybanana411]

1: Colbie 2:Ashely 3 :Vanessa

[vanessagha]

colbies voice is so peaceful.

i lovee itt!

and vanessas voice is reallyy

wineyy all the time. butt summtimes

its pretty.

and ashleys voice sounds like she

punching her nose. its flat!!!!

[MeThacha]

I just LOVE The Ashley Version! It's so cute and because it's cute it perfectly fits with the little mermaid!

[kiraryuu]

i like the voice of Colbie

the 3 versions have their type

[meaghan07039]

the one that is supposed to be vanessa hudgens sounds a lot like the version by no secrets, so I think it's by no secrets and not vanessa

[HarryBum95]

well, no secrets wrote the music, but she sings it

[knobylob]

colbie's definetly tops them all, then ashley comes next, she really can't sing but i like the beat, but vanessa's version is just pathetic

[pwinzexah]

sebastian's version is the best! hahaha !

[summermerina]

Ashley and Colbie are the best at singing that song but Vanessa no no

[12Taylorswiftfan12]

1. Colbie's voice suits that song perfectly

2.Ashley made it her own and did pretty well

3. Vanessa- unspeakably bad

[riles911]

Colbie is the best with Ashley coming it at a close second. Vanessa is just pathetic.

[selenathebest]

ashley is the best

[GirlyGirl1818]

colbies and ashleys are the best! but vanessa... she sounded gross! she ruined the song! lol!

[thirdeyeproductions9]

if this was a singing contest..

COLBIE is definitely the winner...

ashley's tingly voice does not suit the music..

vanessa made it worse! :))

[Chrisssi]

yeah but that wasn't vanessa that was a singing group called no secrets..

i should know it's one of my favorite

[l0vel0tz14]

i love colbie than ashley

[Ryanosorous]

colbie is deffinatly the best :D

[CoolCalmPeace]

is that vanessa?

[annafal2k8]

1. Ashley comes 1st the best version

2. Colbie 2nd very close

3. vanessa 3rd ... a disgrace .. =[

[stefnee15]

loveit..

[saltandpepper]

Colbie all the way!!

[ilovecloud26]

I think Colbie's is the best. Personally i think she has the best voice of all of them and she also happens to be very pretty

[utubeuzer15]

i luv colbie's version

[xxanimalluverxx]

vanessa's version is waaayyy too upbeat for me .-. ashley's is okay. i like her's best, because colbie's is a little slow for me xD

[cm2008sy]

achley's version is more rihem

i like her version the most but the other are verry good to !! xD

[cm2008sy]

i mean rithem * xD

[dorkmuch33]

lol thats not vanessa hudgens.

[pinkisnotawesome]

i think colbie's version is best. it seems the most like the original version than vanesa and ashley's typical pop stuff that are just mutilating the song.

[vanessamiley93]

vanessa is the best

[jenalexia]

ooo colbie's one sounds a bit reggae...lol

[hannahmica]

all three are good but ilike ashley's better

[doom1986]

Vanessa - Pure sucks!

Ashley - Looks like someone is squeezing her, it's freaking annoying to hear it, pure sucks!!

Colbie - Pure sex!! Rocks!!

[hannahmica]

shut up

[abaldugan]

I actually agree with you.

I like Colbie's version because its simple. Vanessa and Ashley's versions are too high pitched and fast.

[jellyfishluvr2]

vanessa's freaking sucked

i like ashleys and colbies

[getinjiggywidit]

colbie's way way way way way way way waaaaaaaaaaaaayyyy better!!!!!

[burntorangecow]

Colbie beats the pants off of the other two by far.

Not only is her version much more down to earth and easier on the ears, but it actually stays true to it's origins.

Gotta love Colbie! <3

[hannahmica]

no when she sings kiss the girl its kiss thee garllllllll! awful but good i like ashley 's better it still says the movie but colbie too different and vannessa to pop

[mysecretkiss]

i wasnt a fan of vanessa's, its really hurried and just doesnt sound right, and i'm not sure which is best between the other two, i think it depends if u want a chilled song or a more rock-ie song...both good i reckon though

[cocomo1294]

I liked Colbie the best, she sounds much more mature than the other two. oh well disney fans, go suck on a rock. Like charlie brown did in that one episode....

yea take that.

[hannahmica]

mature proppably she is 30 something and ashley is only 23 or 21 what colbie is in disney records hello ring a bell

[baamze]

Colbie is 23 years .___.

[hannahmica]

s o r r y for me for a mistake well she doesent look like 23

[baamze]

i know (;

[jeanieM15]

yeah and ash acts like a teen. she's an adult!

[hannahmica]

hey i like ashley not colbie but she is pretty and so what if ashley acts like a teen i like it

[mazajaria]

Colbie's voice really suits this song. :-)

[cocomo1294]

I know it just seems right.

[ZanessaandJoenessa]

Cute =]

[vanessamiley93]

vanessa is the best

[Girl4Music16]

It's Neither Vanessa Or Hilary. It's A Girl Band Called Vitimin C. How Do I Know? I Listen To All Disney Mania Albums And Vanessa Nor Hilary Has Ever Covered Kiss The Girl:)

[LhADyShaNah002]

vanessa rockxzxs...

ashley too.. but..

colbie sounds yuckk..

[Charliegirl101]

i disagree. colbie is amazing. =]

ashley's is really good too.

vanessa's is pretty good too, i'm just a bit unsure on the speed.

but they've all got really good voices. just different ways of singing the song. :)

[TheFlyingCaterpillar]

what? how can you say that? maybe vaneesas version is meant to be fast. hers is so the best. vanessa is changing it making it fit so she likes it. GIVE HER THE CREDIT, DAMN YOUZ. got that out my system :) COLBIE SUCKS. system now empty. colbie sounds && looks like a man anyways.

[mjwall12]

colbies the best. vanessa went way to fast and ashley tisdales voice is all computerized

[Sherabaroo]

Vanessa and Ashley sucks butt. I like Colbie the best, her voice is more soothing and authentic

[nony923]

hey people listen thats not venessa thats hillary Duff listen very well

[ArmeniaHsmLady]

who is Colbie????xD

ashley can sings that song perfect <3

(vanessa too.)

[hunnybunny23]

ew wtf she sounds like a rat drowning.

[RuthLorenzoisTheBest]

How do u not know Colbie she was the best one!

[cocomo1294]

thank you!!!!

[Zuzka129]

colbie by the way..roxx

[Picbaclushi]

ashley rox

[ClumsyStar]

1-Ashley Tisdale

2-Vanessa Hudgens

3- Colbie Vashley are the best!! Los que dicen que odian a Vanessa Son todos unos Estupidos , Tontos, Antipaticos, tarados. Nessa are so beauty Ash are so Pretty Colbie it's Ok bYe!

[nina951]

COLBIE IS DA BEST!! VANESSA SUCKS!! what in the HELL was that..omg

[nickJonasluv4ever]

wats up with vannesas songs always sounding like this

ugh

[tygrkcc]

Vanessa sounds really stupid. Colbie is the best. Definately. It's so more relaxing, and I personally think the mood to this song is more relaxing than Ashley's version...

[LuckyGirl1705]

Ashley's the best!

[ElizabethxD89338]

ew vanessa is gross that stupid slut

i like ashleys and cobies

[Picbaclushi]

I HATE VANESSA'S VOICE THIS TIME!!!

[Picbaclushi]

1.AsHlEy TiSdAlE

2.CoLbIe CaLlIaT

3.(THE LOSER!!!! HER VOICE IS HORRIBLE)VAneSSa(NOTE!: :P  )

[nony923]

1.Ashley

2.Colbie(she has a man voice)

3.Venessa(SUCKS)

[YeaaBoiix]

I Dont Thikn hats Vanesa. But Ashley's Version Is The BESTT!

[asiansakura109]

thats vannesssa minillo

[neoteddy275]

i don't think that's Vanessa

[misspretyoneonone]

it is vanessa

[limzining]

ashley's one is more for teenagers

colbie's is more serious(u can feel the emotion)

vanessa has a nice voice...but tis version is not working for me..

[hunnybunny23]

ASHLEY TISDALE IS A FUCKING RAT THAT IS DROWNED IN ACID.

thats how horrible her voice is.

and vanessa fuc,ade such a HORRIBLE cover.

colbie is the best.

she has real music not liek others.

[ashleytisdalecrazy03]

wow! vanessa's is a little..... no offense but its kinda weird..... anyway

1 ashley

2 that colbie girl

3 vanessa

[andreiyuh23]

colbie caillat is the BEST. the original.

ashley's is a cute version.

and who's the other one????

oh yeah..vanessa? (puking here!)

SUCKS