I really don't like Miley-I agree with @Cittykat27 that she's a bad roll model now. I actually think this boy version is kind of cool. I thought of doing a version of this with my band. Is that making fun of Miley too?
i agree with cittykat27 shes an immature little slag who wants attention all the time, her voice is sooo stingey and this is actually a good impression of her shes only famous because shes billy ray cyrus's daughter she took advantage of HIS fame and stole it from him shes such a bad influence on young girls.
you hate hannah montana are you too stupid even jealous of hannah montana because you are not a pop star and she is maybe you are a girl and you have a voice of boy or you are a boy and have a voice of girl and you cash in hannah that good now stupid girl or boy stupid stupid stupid stupid stupid stupid stupid stupid NOW THAT GOOD FOR ME SOU MUCH BYE STUPID
I'm not jealous or such of her, but I hate her. Does that make m voice a boy voice? No. Actually people like my voice.
People can hate her. I hate her because she is a horrible Role Model for young girls, such as my sister.
Get use to people hating her. I'm sure you hate some singers. Don't go psycho on someone. Seriously, you are not her, you are not her mother or father or whatever. It's not your business.
@Cittykat27 I believe. Most of the time when people hate celebrities is because they're successful. I PERSONALLY hate Miley because of her "dancing" and her attitude.
@Oceancida I don't hate on successfulness. I am happy they are living their dreams. I liked Miley before she started wearing clothes inappropriate for my sister to be looking at and even no clothes at all. To me, she'd be good, with an okay voice and such if she wasn't turning into a mini Britney Spears. I don't want my sister wearing short shorts and swinging on a stripper pole.
@Cittykat27 Oh, no. I think Miley is an exception to hating because of success. I'm not saying that's why you hate her, I'm just saying that with most celebrities, that's why but with Miley it's different :-)
@Oceancida Oh, yeah. I understand what you are saying. :] That's how a lot of people are. I just don't happen to be one of them haha. I don't get why people do though. Their lives aren't all that great sometimes. No privacy, lack of sleep and such. I sometimes pity some honestly.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Ahh alrightt! Playhouse Disney is there Hahah! If disney was the same as before it would have dropped 100%!!! Nobody would have been watching it Noww! They need more peoplee GOD! What has she done to you ayy?!
Ahahaha!!! Idiot!! What a word seriously!! People only hate her because of JEALOUSY!! Thats what caused all her bullying rom the start!! You have no ide what shes been throught when she was young!
Honestly, I couldn't care less about what she's been through when she was younger. This has NOTHING to do with jealousy. People hate her because of the effect she and her kind are having on Disney. Needing more people is no excuse for bastardizing the Disney name. And people WOULD be watching Disney Channel now if it was the same as before. Why? Because back then it actually had QUALITY programming. Not this "Oh look, I can sing! Let's have a tv show about me!" crap.
disney has been like this since world war II When They Had A Cartoon Of Donald Duck Training To Be A NATZI So You Really Cant Blame A 17 Year Old Girl On IT
I fail to see how you could call that short an example of bastardizing Disney. Not only was that short making fun of Nazi Germany, but Donald wakes up at the end to discover it was all a nightmare and is glad to be a US citizen. I think it's pretty patriotic and has a nice moral lesson that we should be thankful for all of the freedoms we have.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
WTH! Leave her alone! Shes an AMAZING singer! and NOT a "one hit wonder" as people call her! NEITHER is her father! So STOP making fun of amazing singers! I bet if you guys read her book you'd think of her in a different WAY! I bet YOU WOULD NOT like it if people made fun of your singing or acting! Put YOURSELF in her shoes!!! You should be ashamed of yourself whoever made this video including the people who laughed! SO LEAVE HER ALONE!!!!!!
Well, considering she, the Jonas Brothers, and HSM have effectively DESTROYED all that is Disney, it would only make sense that people would hate them. They represent this horrible era where we're hard-pressed to get a quality Disney animation outside of Pixar.
Where are the modern Sleeping Beauty's, The Lion King's, Beauty and the Beast's and The Emperor's New Groove's? Huh? Where the hell are they Disney? Heck, where's modern Mickey Mouse? Playhouse Disney? You've got to be kidding me!
what world do u life in 90% of americans hate her and the 10% that like r iether deaf or under the age of 5 plz i would never EVER waist my money on this chick
all he did was speak out. Chris brown kicked his girlfriends ass and no HUGE commotion there, Kayne comes on stage and SPEAKS his mind to a white blonde girl. He loses his spot from MTV. He did not slap her or shot her, he expressed his opinion, to a WHITE GIRL. There is still some racism these days.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
your just jealous because shes famous and your not, shes an amazing singer and you suck your moms dick and your dad needs to help cause its too big for your puny mouth
one day my pearents went out for dinner, then a babysitter came along with a clown, but the clown was a murderer, he kills relentless and he killed everyone and once the perents came home the male tried to defend but he failed he chainsawed his head off and the mom, well... shes history.
post it to 10 people or vids on you tube or the clown will be in your room at 3:30 am with a chain saw, oh and by the way dont scream nowone will hear you!!!it happened 2 me (sry to post it)
It's just a fun little remake! Stop getting all foolish! "oh go f*** yourself!" You guys have seriously got to get a life! miley cyrus rocks... and this is cool too! Do I have to choose a side?
one day my pearents went out for dinner, then a babysitter came along with a clown, but the clown was a murderer, he kills relentless and he killed everyone and once the perents came home the male tried to defend but he failed he chainsawed his head off and the mom, well... shes history.
post it to 10 people or vids on you tube or the clown will be in your room at 3:30 am with a chain saw, oh and by the way dont scream nowone will hear you!!!it happened 2 me (sry to post it)
And I actually think this was cool. SO you who says she's a whore. STFU! you aint any better self by writing it..
helenaMCRloverIMVU 6 months ago
you can only agreed to hate her or love her, i really dont care much for her, :D
PRETTY MUCH ,its just wat people say, and u cant change it so
lilaisha225123 6 months ago
cant get used to it cause im used to her voice but if i heard this and not hannah i might have liked it
urfoeishfriend 7 months ago
fucking bitch.
MrMeezyBoi 7 months ago
GAY BOY
TheGhettoCuzz 8 months ago
Comment removed
PeacepupWebkinz 10 months ago
@PeacepupWebkinz agree.
helenaMCRloverIMVU 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
paste to 2 other videos
go to your channel and see your commen
JUST DO IT IT'S SCARY!!
(omg I was SHOCKED when i saw my comment
thetruthishard1 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
oh yeah better than this slut
wayofthewolf 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
GO MILO CYRUS!! U ROCK MAAAANNNN!!!
amber6264 1 year ago
GO MILO CYRUS!!1 U ROCK MAAAANNNN!!!
amber6264 1 year ago
i knew she was a boy that nasty whore had it in for her.
SuperMysticButterfly 1 year ago
this is kind of awesome
keiyo12 1 year ago
Still sounds like a girl
mitwinx 1 year ago
Yes I can~! tanner Montana!
kamalii1000 1 year ago
it really sounds like jesse macartnie and like someone else but with a
msFuzzybutt 1 year ago
omg i hate u hannah lol u suck hannah this is the best yaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
gummybeargirl202 1 year ago
aint this her real voice : l
mealex6013 1 year ago
does anyone can think of a Male name that goes with Montana??
Fairytaleprincexy 1 year ago
@Fairytaleprincexy Ashton Montana. :)
BlacklitFloater 1 year ago
@BlacklitFloater THanks!! that is a good one!!!!
Fairytaleprincexy 1 year ago
This is wayyy better!!!
christoferdrew1025 1 year ago
this sounds 10 times better!
imaperson77 1 year ago
How is this making fun of Miley? Calm down!
I really don't like Miley-I agree with @Cittykat27 that she's a bad roll model now. I actually think this boy version is kind of cool. I thought of doing a version of this with my band. Is that making fun of Miley too?
AngelKaitsurinu 1 year ago
This is what she sounds like without computers
MintyFresh1999 1 year ago
i like this waaayyy better than the original
rainbowleggings 1 year ago 2
That's not good, but some fellas should really do a "male version" of this song!!
AshleyFan87 1 year ago
hate it your just making fun of miley!
christianloverful 1 year ago
@christianloverful .........screw it...youre no fun
kidal3x97 1 year ago
she sounds gay...*snicker* *muffled laughter*
EmoAngie85 1 year ago
@EmoAngie85 thats cuz she iz
elisa62976 1 year ago
I like the boy version better!
LadybugtheBeagle 1 year ago 4
whoa....
brookellebones1000 1 year ago
if this were her real voice then she would probably have more fans.
TheJrpenguin 1 year ago
sound just like my friend
funinator1 1 year ago
nope... i think it sounds like miley and her guy voice just like every other song lol
crazy4anime1 1 year ago
i agree with cittykat27 shes an immature little slag who wants attention all the time, her voice is sooo stingey and this is actually a good impression of her shes only famous because shes billy ray cyrus's daughter she took advantage of HIS fame and stole it from him shes such a bad influence on young girls.
AzzarClarKyy95 1 year ago
Lame!
KelKelsaidso89 1 year ago
This sounds better than her voice. She ain't on helium here.
Oceancida 1 year ago
@Oceancida hahaha good one!!! yeah she does sound like shes gulped a load of helium Lol
AzzarClarKyy95 1 year ago
this is miley not any other guy they just changed her voice level
antihitler14 1 year ago
Hannah much better
Coliukeluw 1 year ago
Hannah much better ;}
Coliukeluw 1 year ago
I love this <3
jillybean1231 1 year ago
WOW HES BETTER
kloveandcass10 1 year ago 2
sounds better than the original
sk8t3rchic94 1 year ago 3
wow this is almost better than her lol
Shaylakaymadden 2 years ago
haha yeah the voice is edited. the description box mentions the program :P
209129 2 years ago
I don´t hate Hannah Montana but the boy voice is great...isn´t it ?
SHoCK1team 2 years ago
who is singing this it sounds like her brother
moocow2843 2 years ago
@moocow2843 i know it does dosent it!?
I think they just made her voice lower, they didnt have a different person! x
xXxIpodGirlxXx 2 years ago
empress who
ariannaemmacp 2 years ago
wow. I like that. it's quite nice. I mean, I like miley, but this was a surprise. nice.
lilyevans2 2 years ago
you hate hannah montana are you too stupid even jealous of hannah montana because you are not a pop star and she is maybe you are a girl and you have a voice of boy or you are a boy and have a voice of girl and you cash in hannah that good now stupid girl or boy stupid stupid stupid stupid stupid stupid stupid stupid NOW THAT GOOD FOR ME SOU MUCH BYE STUPID
rithyism 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm not jealous or such of her, but I hate her. Does that make m voice a boy voice? No. Actually people like my voice.
People can hate her. I hate her because she is a horrible Role Model for young girls, such as my sister.
Get use to people hating her. I'm sure you hate some singers. Don't go psycho on someone. Seriously, you are not her, you are not her mother or father or whatever. It's not your business.
So shut up.
Kthxbai!
Cittykat27 2 years ago 31
@Cittykat27 I believe. Most of the time when people hate celebrities is because they're successful. I PERSONALLY hate Miley because of her "dancing" and her attitude.
We're allowed to, right?
Oceancida 1 year ago
@Oceancida I don't hate on successfulness. I am happy they are living their dreams. I liked Miley before she started wearing clothes inappropriate for my sister to be looking at and even no clothes at all. To me, she'd be good, with an okay voice and such if she wasn't turning into a mini Britney Spears. I don't want my sister wearing short shorts and swinging on a stripper pole.
Cittykat27 1 year ago
@Cittykat27 Oh, no. I think Miley is an exception to hating because of success. I'm not saying that's why you hate her, I'm just saying that with most celebrities, that's why but with Miley it's different :-)
Oceancida 1 year ago
@Oceancida Oh, yeah. I understand what you are saying. :] That's how a lot of people are. I just don't happen to be one of them haha. I don't get why people do though. Their lives aren't all that great sometimes. No privacy, lack of sleep and such. I sometimes pity some honestly.
Cittykat27 1 year ago
@Cittykat27 It's kind of the one thing that discourages me of trying to get famous...
Oceancida 1 year ago
Not deep enough.Gay picture.
Peace Out Loser!!!
taylorswiftfanzgirl 2 years ago
=) good
SHoCK1team 2 years ago
How cam people say "I HATE HER"? Do you even know her ? :))
LightLimoProduction 2 years ago 4
Some people are SAD!!
LightLimoProduction 2 years ago 3
WDF is up with people hating her god what has she dont you youu you fucking roumersbelivers
LightLimoProduction 2 years ago
(See my comment)
Blahblahblah3210 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Ahh alrightt! Playhouse Disney is there Hahah! If disney was the same as before it would have dropped 100%!!! Nobody would have been watching it Noww! They need more peoplee GOD! What has she done to you ayy?!
LightLimoProduction 2 years ago
You're an idiot for saying that. It's that kind of mentality that's screwing up television.
Blahblahblah3210 2 years ago
Ahahaha!!! Idiot!! What a word seriously!! People only hate her because of JEALOUSY!! Thats what caused all her bullying rom the start!! You have no ide what shes been throught when she was young!
LightLimoProduction 2 years ago
Honestly, I couldn't care less about what she's been through when she was younger. This has NOTHING to do with jealousy. People hate her because of the effect she and her kind are having on Disney. Needing more people is no excuse for bastardizing the Disney name. And people WOULD be watching Disney Channel now if it was the same as before. Why? Because back then it actually had QUALITY programming. Not this "Oh look, I can sing! Let's have a tv show about me!" crap.
Blahblahblah3210 2 years ago
@Blahblahblah3210 Im Reading Ur Comment About Bastardizing disney
disney has been like this since world war II When They Had A Cartoon Of Donald Duck Training To Be A NATZI So You Really Cant Blame A 17 Year Old Girl On IT
Just Saying
promnight95 2 years ago 2
*facepalm*
I fail to see how you could call that short an example of bastardizing Disney. Not only was that short making fun of Nazi Germany, but Donald wakes up at the end to discover it was all a nightmare and is glad to be a US citizen. I think it's pretty patriotic and has a nice moral lesson that we should be thankful for all of the freedoms we have.
See for yourself:
/watch?v=fZcs1SHVbz0
Blahblahblah3210 2 years ago
Hannah MANtanna
lordoftheflies2020 2 years ago
All her songs sound better as a boy TRanna Hanna
lordoftheflies2020 2 years ago
thats KINDA MEAN HOW CAN U DO THAT TO HER ITS JUST A GIRL WHY DO U HATE HER
MyDarline343 2 years ago
i hate her hanah montana i went to a york dukes game
abpokemon 2 years ago
hky7nujk h67uhy67yhjolnhy7l
XxXSasukeXxX453 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
WTH! Leave her alone! Shes an AMAZING singer! and NOT a "one hit wonder" as people call her! NEITHER is her father! So STOP making fun of amazing singers! I bet if you guys read her book you'd think of her in a different WAY! I bet YOU WOULD NOT like it if people made fun of your singing or acting! Put YOURSELF in her shoes!!! You should be ashamed of yourself whoever made this video including the people who laughed! SO LEAVE HER ALONE!!!!!!
CraazyKatie98 2 years ago
She is a good singer ^-^
Most people don't like her because they think she'll be the next Lindsey Lohann... ^-^;
they just put -4 karaoke on it lol
KeldricUsugi 2 years ago 2
Well, considering she, the Jonas Brothers, and HSM have effectively DESTROYED all that is Disney, it would only make sense that people would hate them. They represent this horrible era where we're hard-pressed to get a quality Disney animation outside of Pixar.
Where are the modern Sleeping Beauty's, The Lion King's, Beauty and the Beast's and The Emperor's New Groove's? Huh? Where the hell are they Disney? Heck, where's modern Mickey Mouse? Playhouse Disney? You've got to be kidding me!
Blahblahblah3210 2 years ago
Walt would be ashamed.
Blahblahblah3210 2 years ago
@Blahblahblah3210 Agreed.
KidsOfATown 2 years ago 7
what world do u life in 90% of americans hate her and the 10% that like r iether deaf or under the age of 5 plz i would never EVER waist my money on this chick
Preny4life 2 years ago
lol sometimes it sounds like kanye west lol I HATE HIM NOW THAT MEANIE DID U GUYS SEE WAHT HE DID TO TAYLOR?!?!?
Barkgirl22 2 years ago
all he did was speak out. Chris brown kicked his girlfriends ass and no HUGE commotion there, Kayne comes on stage and SPEAKS his mind to a white blonde girl. He loses his spot from MTV. He did not slap her or shot her, he expressed his opinion, to a WHITE GIRL. There is still some racism these days.
spartahog 2 years ago
yea lol i know but i still dot like him sory
Barkgirl22 2 years ago
it kinda sounds like zac effron at times
falloutjonas2 2 years ago
No comment
sonicxcharacters 2 years ago
nice vico
saea56love123 2 years ago
e.e i hate when ppl do this 1 star
MultiRainb0w 2 years ago
wow....thats all i can say
nkhoury51 2 years ago
so gay
babygirl27501 2 years ago
lol cool
bonasjonasill 2 years ago
awesomeee =)
KatieWillisx3 2 years ago
gah he sounds hoooot
shatimcat 2 years ago
nice picture lol
LiNoY12 2 years ago
...ummm kinda gay voice... but that's okay (:
EllenEmma09 2 years ago
to ellen emma its because its her voice but her voice is lowerd
zoey102319 2 years ago
I wish this was her real voice! lol (It might be akward when she talks, but it'll be so cool when she sings!)
bravoguy30 2 years ago
this is kinda gay, but I like it. Lol.
loveneo7788 2 years ago
if it was a boy I will totally when his cd
me1and1my 2 years ago
this is cool!
this voice sounds a little like Jesse McCartney
locomonkey90 2 years ago 26
I didn't hear it at first, but then I totally got it. ^_^ This is so funny.
NickJonasLoveStory 2 years ago
@locomonkey90 well not so mutch miley is miley!..What its a man voice?Oh well...xD
sladunkaAa 1 year ago
@locomonkey90 it does sound a little like Jesse McCartney.
MsTsuchikage 1 year ago
not bad ;)
LaVenezolanaKaterin 2 years ago
czemu ona jest skreślona i zmieniliście wykonawcę!!
dagnyyjuel 2 years ago
Cool =D
CzechMusicman 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
your just jealous because shes famous and your not, shes an amazing singer and you suck your moms dick and your dad needs to help cause its too big for your puny mouth
StuntMcUtters101 2 years ago
awsome xD
littleballofchaos 2 years ago
i love you which so ever guy sing this song would you like to be a gay because i want to be a gay
kevondias 2 years ago 2
then you should be gay (:
EllenEmma09 2 years ago
Really cool! I wish that was her real voice! Lmao
OMJiLoVeJB92 2 years ago 6
she sounds a bit hoarse !!!!!!!!!1 jkin..
chriskajsu 2 years ago
sounds like chris crocker version lol
snowangels100 2 years ago 7
The only way miley would sound better is if she was a boy. Much better ;D Where can I download this?
bravoguy30 2 years ago 2
is there anywhere i can download this version? this is so awesome! if miley sounded like this i would watch the show. :L
charmedp3pppp 2 years ago 3
Alot better than miley
deaniscute 2 years ago 5
The sad thing is that all her songs sound better as guy version. Seriously. Nice job.
MergGates1 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
one day my pearents went out for dinner, then a babysitter came along with a clown, but the clown was a murderer, he kills relentless and he killed everyone and once the perents came home the male tried to defend but he failed he chainsawed his head off and the mom, well... shes history.
post it to 10 people or vids on you tube or the clown will be in your room at 3:30 am with a chain saw, oh and by the way dont scream nowone will hear you!!!it happened 2 me (sry to post it)
Printer204 2 years ago
omgomgomg so hawt x]
elwenkitty 2 years ago
this sounds gay lower it a little more if u can
DeMan9870 2 years ago
lool now thats awesome !!
JellyBiscuitz 2 years ago 2
This sounds ALOT better than with Miley's voice
KairisLuckyCharm 2 years ago 2
thats really good
it actually sounds like a boy has rerecorded it haha
xkezxox 2 years ago 3
That's awesome!
cpandrs 2 years ago
this is miley.... voice lowered a lot. my mp4 can do this.
red0kawaii 3 years ago
Do You Know How Did I Do This
With Sony ACID FX Plugins
teentitanswwe 3 years ago
no. i do it with my mp4. and are you anti-miley? that rotten picture is so annoying.
red0kawaii 3 years ago
this is disturbing,...
shgdgrx 3 years ago
this is my favorite song and sound so hot as a boy...good job
Fairytaleprincexy 3 years ago
this is funny, but he sounds very gay....=]
GomezJonasLovatoLove 3 years ago 4
sounds like Zack singing this song
kevinralph12345 3 years ago
which one? zack from HSM or zack from the suite life?
hannahmileyfan08 3 years ago
Can u tell me how u changed the voice
gauravkasabwala67 3 years ago 2
okay im not a miley fan, and im not offending her, or anything, but this sounds better!!
lexuswoo 3 years ago
It's just a fun little remake! Stop getting all foolish! "oh go f*** yourself!" You guys have seriously got to get a life! miley cyrus rocks... and this is cool too! Do I have to choose a side?
smashcash4 3 years ago
it sounds really good and like i said before it kinda sounds like drew seely :]
falloutjonas2 3 years ago
fuck you, you wish you could be her gaywod. go to hell same with the other miley haters
geeversonrocks 3 years ago
maglio donna!
stellamontana 3 years ago
go fuck your face. Miley Rocks and she is awesome
jeniffer101 3 years ago
cough cough slut
TyValentine 3 years ago
yea i agree her voice is all good but this is better hey they should do this for the hannah montana 3 songs!
bathingapes112 3 years ago
thats a boy? it sound like a shim's voice!
get a life!
coldstone2yum 3 years ago
It's not her real voice. She doesn't sound this good on real. Her REAL voice sounds like a monkey from Nordway on crack.
MyChemicalBlack 3 years ago
Just Lower The Pitch.. It's Not hard :P
supermousesuper 3 years ago
it kinda sounds like drew seely
falloutjonas2 3 years ago
it may be a guy. but he is definately gay.
CampRock559 3 years ago
first of all you have not actually heard me "talk" because i am writing. 2nd of all dont tell me what to do.
you dumb fucking bitch.
WILDCATSBR 3 years ago
this is her real voice.
CUCProductions 3 years ago
FUNNY
SingerMarissa 3 years ago
girlish boy
themuppetpals101 3 years ago 2
you wouldnt have to mix her voice coz she sounds like a boy anwayz.
WILDCATSBR 3 years ago
you right
jasmen95 3 years ago
omg so true
hersheyslvr23 3 years ago
wtf that really sounds like a guy
spookyphantom122 3 years ago
You can obvieousley hear it is a mix of mileys voice but great touch anyways, but remember never to Take away mileys face
frikko7 3 years ago
lol that really sounds funny, but i love her still!!
rockchixdudes 3 years ago
funny who is that boy singing miley songs he sang 7 thing too
mileypopstar259 3 years ago
they mixed miley's voice
falloutjonas2 3 years ago
he sing good i love it
mileypopstar259 3 years ago
lol this is so funny
JesseShawnJBLSML 3 years ago
too bad this guy isnt real. he sounds gooood.
cluelessBrunette88 3 years ago
Um....I think he is real.
karateman856 3 years ago
Um...........I think he is real.
karateman856 3 years ago
i like it he sounds great if "he" was real lol
falloutjonas2 3 years ago
It's like a guy's voice with the little nuances of a girl's voice...
lendorama 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it sounds the same bahaha
hgihragus 3 years ago
haha! it does
jaclynjune14 3 years ago
itS a MAN
hippos008 3 years ago
wow! it sounds better in the guy voice in my opinion :)
elwenkitty 3 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
one day my pearents went out for dinner, then a babysitter came along with a clown, but the clown was a murderer, he kills relentless and he killed everyone and once the perents came home the male tried to defend but he failed he chainsawed his head off and the mom, well... shes history.
post it to 10 people or vids on you tube or the clown will be in your room at 3:30 am with a chain saw, oh and by the way dont scream nowone will hear you!!!it happened 2 me (sry to post it)
randomviewer1996 3 years ago
i love miley/hannah
and i love both versions(=
good job !
-rachiepoo97
MooMooChan 3 years ago
its dedly :) gud singer boy or girl :)
xXxNIKKI06xXx 3 years ago