I'd say "Ancient Eye" is the second best track, next to "Hanging On". Has a wonderfully dark and fat synth backdrop that coincides perfectly with his vocals. "Johny Belinda" is also another good one you didn't even bother mentioning.
Can't say I agree with your review here, of all the tired indie music out there with poor singers who hide their lack of talent with excessive reverb, AC manages to stand out by not forcibly being different, but by just making good music and this album proves it.
I think the best songs on the album are "Hanging On," "Playing House," "High Priestess," and "Way Too Fast." I wasn't particularly in love with the opening title track, and, like the reviewer, I felt the end of the album was not as inspired as the rest. However, this is not to say I did not enjoy them!
Personally, I enjoy this album a bit more than you do, it seems, but I still seem to agree with some of your criticisms. For me, after High Priestess, the tracks admittedly lacked the previous inspiration. While my favorite tracks on this album aren't necessarily the admittedly brilliant R&B tunes, I find that they are those that fully embrace, and in my opinion, perfect, the haunting, ethereal, almost Classical in-nature sounds, contained within You Are All I See, and High Priestess.
Hey just wanted to leave two comments. First, this is a great album. Second, it's kind of annoying how this video is listed on the Active Child playlist. When most people click an artist's youtube mix they expect it to be uninterrupted material from the artist, not a review from somebody unassociated with the artist. Although I highly appreciate what you do, it just bugs me every time I want to listen to the playlist when your review comes up.
Run out of ideas? How can you not see that this album is amazing? This man is innovative as hell. He takes the orchestral power of gospel choir vocals, and makes them accessible and more humanistic through R&B delivery, which also raises the talent and symphonic's in R&B which is usually stale anywhere else. He basically takes the booming power of classical music styles, and then their pop equivalents and marries them perfectly. Every theme usual pop executes is realized through indie integrity.
I definitely think 'Hanging on' and 'High priestess' are the strongest on the album. I've listened through it a good five times now and those two are the ones I have to turn up and really get swept away by. 'Hanging on' is so love sick and beautiful--on the top of my plays this week.
Did anyone notice that When your love is safe opens with the lyrical tune almost exactly mimicking Gin Blossoms - Follow you down? Check it out. Scary similarities.
ANTHONY please don't review another perfect 10 "classic" album. That's for sellout review sites/mags. It's a waste of time. People should just listen to the albums you post on the wall.
Speaking of which, what the fuck is on your wall?
Hey theneedledrop):):):) Thanks for your support! :):):) Please share this with your viewers okay ! (JmTheMasterMinute) This is a "NEW" MUSIC video to FACE Childhood OBESITY called : I like the way you move by JM
I was totally thinking the same thing about "Way Too Fast" resembling James Blake. It's got the same minimalistic sound and the voice modulation is very similar. Overall, I really do feel the same way as you about this album. The beginning is awesome, but my interest kind of wanes by the end.
I'm am absolutely head over heels in love with this album. I've been obsessed with Active Child ever since I heard the track "Wilderness" off his Curtis Lane EP. This album was everything I could've wanted and more. It's a 10/10 for me.
Tony NeeDles, I think you should review the new Stephen Malkmus album. It's less self indulgent than his past few releases. It also seems to contain the lyric "God speaks through that albino... Hitler".
Hey Anthony, how about reviewing an album that you would rate 10/10? I don't think I've ever seen you give a perfect score before, which is fine, but if there's nothing that fits that rating, then the other ratings become sort of arbitrary. Clearly there's no objectively PERFECT album, but how about reviewing one that in your OPINION would score a perfect 10/10? I'd be really curious to know what you'd consider worthy of that.
If you'd stuck around long enough, you would know the answer to this. He HAS reviewed at least one thing with a perfect 10, that thing being a certain Wire album.
@goodbybluemonday i don't really give scores for "perfection." if something is a 10 to me, it's not perfect. i think you misunderstand what my numbers mean to me personally. i'm just rating my enjoyment. of course there are 10s out there to me, but they must reach a level of enjoyment i don't see being passable for me personally. 10 is basically the threshold for enjoyment for me. if and when a new album reaches that threshold, i'll tell ya.
LOVE IT... start to end
ByHookNorCrook 1 month ago
You're shit.
YouBoob112 2 months ago
8.5/10, saw them open for M83 in Seattle and was blown away !
Sektion9 3 months ago
Hanging on is clearly the best song in the album in my opinion...It's been a while since a song has hit me that emotionally and i'm a guy...
TheLewis121 3 months ago
I'd say "Ancient Eye" is the second best track, next to "Hanging On". Has a wonderfully dark and fat synth backdrop that coincides perfectly with his vocals. "Johny Belinda" is also another good one you didn't even bother mentioning.
Can't say I agree with your review here, of all the tired indie music out there with poor singers who hide their lack of talent with excessive reverb, AC manages to stand out by not forcibly being different, but by just making good music and this album proves it.
Smicallion 4 months ago
I think the best songs on the album are "Hanging On," "Playing House," "High Priestess," and "Way Too Fast." I wasn't particularly in love with the opening title track, and, like the reviewer, I felt the end of the album was not as inspired as the rest. However, this is not to say I did not enjoy them!
Nightbird87 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I just bought this album (the first album i've bought in like 5 years) because i found it SOOOOO amazing when i sampled it on the youtubes.
My favorite songs are Hanging on, Johnny Belinda, and High priestess.
I just find everything about this album super soothing and amazing to listen to. It's great to drive in my car to as well.
uggh...it's just so good.
cosmosman 4 months ago
I just bought this album (the first album i've bought in like 5 years) because i found it SOOOOO amazing when i sampled it on the youtubes.
My favorite songs are Hanging on, Johnny Belinda, and High priestess.
I just find everything about this album super soothing and amazing to listen to. It's great to drive in my car to as well.
uggh...it's just so good.
cosmosman 4 months ago
Personally, I enjoy this album a bit more than you do, it seems, but I still seem to agree with some of your criticisms. For me, after High Priestess, the tracks admittedly lacked the previous inspiration. While my favorite tracks on this album aren't necessarily the admittedly brilliant R&B tunes, I find that they are those that fully embrace, and in my opinion, perfect, the haunting, ethereal, almost Classical in-nature sounds, contained within You Are All I See, and High Priestess.
Apastronnn 4 months ago
I love some of the songs on You Are All I See. I think Active Child has the potential to make some incredible stuff.
WeEatBrainz 5 months ago
Hey just wanted to leave two comments. First, this is a great album. Second, it's kind of annoying how this video is listed on the Active Child playlist. When most people click an artist's youtube mix they expect it to be uninterrupted material from the artist, not a review from somebody unassociated with the artist. Although I highly appreciate what you do, it just bugs me every time I want to listen to the playlist when your review comes up.
BranfmanLawGroup 5 months ago
Comment removed
BranfmanLawGroup 5 months ago
Run out of ideas? How can you not see that this album is amazing? This man is innovative as hell. He takes the orchestral power of gospel choir vocals, and makes them accessible and more humanistic through R&B delivery, which also raises the talent and symphonic's in R&B which is usually stale anywhere else. He basically takes the booming power of classical music styles, and then their pop equivalents and marries them perfectly. Every theme usual pop executes is realized through indie integrity.
spawn22222 5 months ago
love this album.. "dreampopra"
briano1983 5 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Active Child
This has been flagged as spam show
Review Cleric - Regressions!
drumninmer34 5 months ago
I love Active Child <3
fordtaurusboy 5 months ago
>music critic
>sun ((o))
You've got to be fucking kidding me
zombiepanda6 5 months ago
0:18 HOLY FUCK!!! That effect scared me hahaha
LuketheJuke24 5 months ago
@goodbybluemonday Wire - Pink Flag
kakarooku 5 months ago
Hey fun fact my family's cherry tree was used in Bicentennial Man as a piece of driftwood
tomaterr20 5 months ago 4
@tomaterr20 nice.
theneedledrop 5 months ago
I definitely think 'Hanging on' and 'High priestess' are the strongest on the album. I've listened through it a good five times now and those two are the ones I have to turn up and really get swept away by. 'Hanging on' is so love sick and beautiful--on the top of my plays this week.
stellarkate 5 months ago 2
Did anyone notice that When your love is safe opens with the lyrical tune almost exactly mimicking Gin Blossoms - Follow you down? Check it out. Scary similarities.
hyperman5000 6 months ago
had a listen to this album and it's stunning
44jamica 6 months ago
I never heard it.
SapienApien 6 months ago
ANTHONY please don't review another perfect 10 "classic" album. That's for sellout review sites/mags. It's a waste of time. People should just listen to the albums you post on the wall.
Speaking of which, what the fuck is on your wall?
lukepleaseshutup 6 months ago
few requests please: stephen malkmus, i break horses, thundercat
thekingoflimbs1991 6 months ago
do tha carter IV pleaase, when it comes out
TXB14 6 months ago
LMAO! I listened to "Playing House". The guy sounds like Him from "The Powerpuff Girls" :D
0o0enileda0o0 6 months ago
Tha Carter IV. This will interest me.
TheCagedTiger 6 months ago 2
Anthony, you never named the two RB-ish tracks?
MultiContrarian 6 months ago
It sounds like I'm in heaven, chillin with jesus and stuff, but once in a while a cabrio drives by in slow-mo.
shinsouY 6 months ago
Comment removed
shinsouY 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey theneedledrop):):):) Thanks for your support! :):):) Please share this with your viewers okay ! (JmTheMasterMinute) This is a "NEW" MUSIC video to FACE Childhood OBESITY called : I like the way you move by JM
lakesriversoceans 6 months ago 2
why does this guy say "forever" after the name of the album at the end of every album review?? what is it supposed to mean? its quite irritating..
darthpigeon04 6 months ago
@darthpigeon04 your quite irritating
TheOriginalZero1 6 months ago
@TheOriginalZero1 Your use of the wrong you're irritates me.
maalbe987 6 months ago
@maalbe987 ooops my bad :P
TheOriginalZero1 6 months ago
@darthpigeon04 It's his sign-out phrase. It'll grow on you. Trust me.
lukepleaseshutup 6 months ago
Playing House is definitely one of my favorite songs of 2011 already
ManBag101 6 months ago
Not Sure im in that Neo-R&b Movement...Review Cities Aviv Anthony!
dipdipset 6 months ago
I was totally thinking the same thing about "Way Too Fast" resembling James Blake. It's got the same minimalistic sound and the voice modulation is very similar. Overall, I really do feel the same way as you about this album. The beginning is awesome, but my interest kind of wanes by the end.
ac8394 6 months ago
It was better than I thought it would be. But still not completely my thing. Great review, as always.
Nic33rd 6 months ago
in the beginning.. HUH!!!!
retroEddz 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Red Hot Chili Peppers - I'm With You please thanks
Brendadots 6 months ago
Thanks for reviewing this. Never heard of it, but fell instantly in love with it.
JasonsVinylObsession 6 months ago
Nice whale noise there. 0:20
Laura1123xox 6 months ago
@Laura1123xox LOL
ghassan112 6 months ago
I'm am absolutely head over heels in love with this album. I've been obsessed with Active Child ever since I heard the track "Wilderness" off his Curtis Lane EP. This album was everything I could've wanted and more. It's a 10/10 for me.
JohnWallaceMPLS 6 months ago
@theneedledrop New Mogwai EP 'Earth Division' review plz, be curious to see a Girls LP review as well.
theNomadz 6 months ago
Florence + the Machine - What the water gave me
Conceicawo 6 months ago
Anthony, How about reviewing Stephen Malkmus mirror traffic. One of the best albums of the year IMO. That and Thurston Moore's new one.
sweetmovie07 6 months ago
You should film squirrels more often
ssurgeon00 6 months ago
GAAAAAHHH
THE TREE-CAM MOVED!!!!!!
fimpson 6 months ago
Circle Takes The Square-Rites Of Initiation EP
rdarod 6 months ago 2
Game-the red album
kerrybtone 6 months ago
Cities Aviv - Digital Lows
RRS1009 6 months ago
Comment removed
RRS1009 6 months ago
Game - The R.E.D. Album
Cioffman 6 months ago
Phantogram - Eyelid Movies (kinda old but u should still check it out)
theshizzer05 6 months ago
Balam Acab - Wander / Wonder
CalChuchesta 6 months ago
Red Hot Chili Peppers - I'm With You
isaacADD 6 months ago
"dreamy pop opera" "delicate" "pile of pretty sounds"
you are a music criticism god. put my thoughts towards this cd in words.
charlestraws 6 months ago
Awesome. Best review ever. You're like the Gary Vaynerchuk of music.
TWBuddha 6 months ago
Tony NeeDles, I think you should review the new Stephen Malkmus album. It's less self indulgent than his past few releases. It also seems to contain the lyric "God speaks through that albino... Hitler".
Shnards 6 months ago
I no it's a little late, but a track review on Dungen's Jack White produced "Oga Nasa Mun"??
Smadden1194 6 months ago
RHCP - I'm With You! You can listen to the whole thing on iTunes i think.
flylo1227 6 months ago
Stephen Malkmus & The Jicks - Mirror Traffic.
ThirdWorldAstronaut 6 months ago
PLEASE review the new red hot chili peppers album "I'm With You"
atheistfreethinker17 6 months ago 2
@atheistfreethinker17 FUCK NO
Rabbitthateats 6 months ago
@Rabbitthateats red hot chili peppers ROCK!
atheistfreethinker17 6 months ago
Anthony Fantano, the internets busiest Bicentennial Man.
tehstick 6 months ago
I'd still love to hear your thoughts on And So I Watch You From Afar's Gangs!
theashcollins 6 months ago
Best. Intro. Ever.
TheAutumnMarch 6 months ago
/mu/ hates you now... I still love you!
TehBlitzSaysMeow 6 months ago
Yo...
Review some DOOM metal...
Please. :)
macleodponeage 6 months ago 2
The Game- The R.E.D. Album
ThePsychoticSmith 6 months ago
Nero - Welcome Reality
mrbloke11 6 months ago
They won't be out for a while but you should review the new albums by DT, Mastodon, and Opeth when they come out
BSMitchell1 6 months ago 2
Could you Review Flash Bang Grenada(Busdriver and Nocando)'s 10 haters album?
BigkKinny 6 months ago
@LeMrAtlas Thanks, haven't seen this one. Must be from before I became a regular.
goodbybluemonday 6 months ago
remember.
thefruitleather 6 months ago
Hey Anthony, how about reviewing an album that you would rate 10/10? I don't think I've ever seen you give a perfect score before, which is fine, but if there's nothing that fits that rating, then the other ratings become sort of arbitrary. Clearly there's no objectively PERFECT album, but how about reviewing one that in your OPINION would score a perfect 10/10? I'd be really curious to know what you'd consider worthy of that.
goodbybluemonday 6 months ago 115
@goodbybluemonday the wire - pink flag
im pretty sure he only reviewed that album so people would see what kind of album he would give a 10
AwesomeA1010 6 months ago
@goodbybluemonday Well that one is easy, just pick a random Soundgarden album and there you go :3
LidlFisken 6 months ago
@goodbybluemonday You can find his 10/10 ratings at his rateyourmusic page at collection/theneedledrop/r5.0
maxwellcale 6 months ago
@goodbybluemonday An example of a 10/10 review: watch?v=EBXwpNHHKtA
maxwellcale 6 months ago
@goodbybluemonday
You can't just pick a day when you want to review a 10/10 album... if one comes he probably will rate it thus
TheCagedTiger 6 months ago
@goodbybluemonday AGREED!
Justs0MEGUY11 6 months ago
@goodbybluemonday he gave pink flag - wire a 10/10
santashelpa 6 months ago
@goodbybluemonday
If you'd stuck around long enough, you would know the answer to this. He HAS reviewed at least one thing with a perfect 10, that thing being a certain Wire album.
And8But 6 months ago
@goodbybluemonday He gave Wire's Pink Flag a 10/10.
dgmcl3284 6 months ago
@goodbybluemonday He did once, he reviewed Pink Flag by Wire, go search the review up.
ian10898 6 months ago
@goodbybluemonday i don't really give scores for "perfection." if something is a 10 to me, it's not perfect. i think you misunderstand what my numbers mean to me personally. i'm just rating my enjoyment. of course there are 10s out there to me, but they must reach a level of enjoyment i don't see being passable for me personally. 10 is basically the threshold for enjoyment for me. if and when a new album reaches that threshold, i'll tell ya.
theneedledrop 5 months ago
The R.E.D. Album
GoLSU97 6 months ago 2
Eraas
MrHippiedude13 6 months ago
Edan - Beauty And The Beat
dynospectrum 6 months ago
Blu - NoYork!
Narkami 6 months ago 8
Mac Miller K.I.D.S
SORAFAN14ify 6 months ago
40 watt sun-The Inside Room
Movieboy777 6 months ago
Review
Curren$y - Verde Terrace
jet life
TheJeffMangum 6 months ago
ICS VORTEX - STORM SEEKER1!!11!11one!!!!1!
sentencedrush 6 months ago
hanging on. just dope
jakcha 6 months ago
GAME THE RED ALBUM!!!!!!
W0nderBreed 6 months ago
Gusgus - Arabian Horse
Have heard just a few tracks on it, but it sounds very interesting. I feel that it has a lot of more substance than their previous releases.
maxwellcale 6 months ago
"Active Child, you are all I see..." LOL
handsomerob48 6 months ago
Thundercat - The Golden Age of Apocalypse
tremulant2388 6 months ago
Stephen Malkmus, duuuuuuuude.
GrembyTheWalrus 6 months ago
Comment removed
GrembyTheWalrus 6 months ago
Comment removed
hysteriks 6 months ago
Gang Gang Dance - Eye Contact
JUST DO IT.
-Nike
scotricksen 6 months ago
How To Dress Well- Just Once EP plzzzzzz
Iwastman 6 months ago
Holy shit 0:22 made me laugh so fucking hard
skateNappreciate 6 months ago
mariachi el bronx - mariachi el bronx II
chr20b 6 months ago
Wax- Scrub Life
345XXL 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Girls - Father, Son, Holy Ghost
danicb3 6 months ago
Press 2 & 3. Forever.
juicehea 6 months ago
Mastodon - Curl Of The Burl
Psychotron72 6 months ago
I am forever.
theneedIedrop 6 months ago 2
ANTHONY FANTANO IM JIZZING EVERYWHERE HOW DO I STO-
PERSONIFICATIONOFYAY 6 months ago
You should review the new album Distance by Wume, please!
I've been digging on it a lot lately, and I think it might perk your ears.
williamweinstein11 6 months ago
Tom Waits- Bad As Me track review, please and thank you.
And, also, on October 25th, Tom Waits- Bad As Me album review, please and thank you.
EyeJustSkateboard 6 months ago 17
Are you gonna be reviewing the new Hella?
elmuffin2612 6 months ago
Male Bonding - Endless Now !
brobito 6 months ago
The soundcloud link is down.
ImmortalDestructor 6 months ago
"Honey flavoured vocals"
nzwwefan 6 months ago
Mind if I ask what that drawing is on your left?
Great review, as always!!!
SouthernPoint52 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
REVIEW DANNY BROWN'S XXX ALREADY
ThatNinjaBlack 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
REVIEW DANNY BROWN'S XXX ALREADY
ThatNinjaBlack 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
REVIEW DANNY BROWN'S XXX ALREADY
ThatNinjaBlack 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
REVIEW DANNY BROWN'S XXX ALREADY
ThatNinjaBlack 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
REVIEW DANNY BROWN'S XXX ALREADY
ThatNinjaBlack 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
REVIEW DANNY BROWN'S XXX ALREADY
ThatNinjaBlack 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
REVIEW DANNY BROWN'S XXX ALREADY
ThatNinjaBlack 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
REVIEW DANNY BROWN'S XXX ALREADY
ThatNinjaBlack 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
REVIEW DANNY BROWN'S XXX ALREADY
ThatNinjaBlack 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
REVIEW DANNY BROWN'S XXX ALREADY
ThatNinjaBlack 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
REVIEW DANNY BROWN'S XXX ALREADY
ThatNinjaBlack 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
REVIEW DANNY BROWN'S XXX ALREADY
ThatNinjaBlack 6 months ago
florence and the machine -- what the water gave me (track review)
thatdude5924 6 months ago
Bat for Lashes
15Zas 6 months ago 2
Review the new DIR EN GREY album: Dum Spiro Spero.
KakiharaxKyo 6 months ago
Mister Heavenly- Out of Love
auggie87 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Always watching the channel so it's time for a suggestion for all of you!
2 of my favorite comical (yet brutal) metal projects;
from the mad mind of Devin Townsend (Strapping Young Lad) comes "Ziltoid! The Omniscient!"
and from Jason Suecof (Capharnaum) comes Crotchduster with "Big Fat Box Of Shit"!
markWiechmann 6 months ago
Always watching the channel so it's time for a suggestion for all of you!
2 of my favorite comical (yet brutal) metal projects;
from the mad mind of Devin Townsend (Strapping Young Lad) comes "Ziltoid! The Omniscient!"
and from Jason Suecof (Capharnaum) comes Crotchduster with "Big Fat Box Of Shit"!
markWiechmann 6 months ago
Review the new Nero album please.
filipr700 6 months ago
Watching this before I'm going to immortally drunk. Aw ye.
Tyzz 6 months ago
GAME. R.E.D. ALBUM!
x1RED3x 6 months ago
APATHY - HONKEY KONG!!!
chaosinorderrr 6 months ago
anyone else expect a "Sad Robot" reference at 4:51?
slyfan64 6 months ago
Trophy Scars - Never Born, Never Dead wooo
badumed 6 months ago
@JozhBro yes, yes so muchh
badumed 6 months ago
The Game- The R.E.D Album
G1Main 6 months ago 27
@G1Main Made me lol.
rurounikenshin75 6 months ago
Kurt Vile - Smoke Ring for My Halo
RallizesDenudes 6 months ago 32
@RallizesDenudes Still Waiting...
vitality91 6 months ago
Fanthony Aantano
Mrburkey93 6 months ago
Game - R.E.D. Album
donekiltem 6 months ago
Shining: VII Född Förlorare
jesus h christ how hard can it be?
necrodawg 6 months ago
Fantano, do you dislike Antony and the Johnsons?
DandHgoogoo 6 months ago
DAS RACIST - MICHAEL JACKSON
DAS RACIST - MICHAEL JACKSON
DAS RACIST - MICHAEL JACKSON
VIKTORVOGHNDOOM 6 months ago
I BREAK HORSES - HEARTS
I BREAK HORSES - HEARTS
I BREAK HORSES - HEARTS
I BREAK HORSES - HEARTS!
Came out today, please and thank you. Enjoy your day.
Quirks100 6 months ago 3
AC-c-cTIVE NERD
gabrielgabriel2000 6 months ago
DANNY BROWN - XXX
DANNY BROWN - XXX
DANNY BROWN - XXX
MrInfiniteE 6 months ago
Hella - Tripper pretty please!
MrZombiejfk 6 months ago
balam acab
saccredtwin 6 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Track review Tom Waits' new single "Bad As Me."
undertheeaves6 6 months ago
Comment removed
undertheeaves6 6 months ago
REVIEW THE WEEKND MIXTAPE
names667 6 months ago
CIRCLE TAKES THE SQUARE - RITES OF INITIATION!!!!!!
NoPizzaProductions 6 months ago
It'd be neat if you reviewed Lonesome Ghost's debut EP
jca6125 6 months ago
Comment removed
jakhayter 6 months ago
I know you wanna review the new Big K.R.I.T. mixtape. I know you do.
MrSplatterPlatter 6 months ago
Balam Acab - Wander / Wonder
mattjcarney 6 months ago 5