Added: 4 years ago
From: jamessouth
Views: 2,060,966
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,589)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • wish i had a voice like that. brilliant!

  • Maravillosa..

  • fuck pink fuck her mother buT ! DONT TOUCH HER VOICE ! It's BRILIANT :))

  • I'm in my sixties and this song brings tears to my eyes. I suffered as a child and as a parent. Love you Pink!!!

  • this describes my life situation soooooo good.! divorces suck :[

  • omg the pianist is so good ahhhhhhhhh!!!

  • Amaziing!!

  • ND that man, the PIANIST... WOW!!

    such a strong talent!!!! wonderfull£!!!!

  • what i love the most is that everything is REAL!!!!

    her beauty, her voice, the words of her song... everything so REAL!!!

    

  • I miss you sis. I know we grew up in shamobles. Your brother loves you so very much. I miss you.

  • real music !!! love her

  • pink is amazing - i love her songs like hell

  • i wish i had a voice like her

  • the best song ever

  • Love this song from her life with divorced parents.. as many of us know! And the guy on the piano- wow- talented man!!!

  • i love everything about pink, her vioce , her hair , personality, not forgetting her laugh

    P!NK ROCKS!

  • That pianist thinks that he is the bomb..... 'CAUSE HE IS!!

  • pink has such a strong vioce

    she is such a true singer becuase she sounds excactly the same as when she is live , on a cd or in music video.

    I am her number 1 fan. seriously, i am.

  • I came from Bosnia to see her live at concert in Amsterdam,when i heard this begining of the song I felt like i was the only one there...thank you for thins song,thank you....

  • well this is the proof that everybody has family issues, even Pink!

  • i love this song ! And Pink? She´s the best :)

  • OMG, how amazing is P!NK here??? So much emotion and she has to be one of the best live "singers" around right now. Love her

  • amazing, my love song!!!! <3

  • damn.... :'( really sad!

  • nice....

  • Wow she is so into the song!! It's so emotional and she is a GREAT singer!!! She isn't fake that can only "sing" good in the studio... She is for real. And I love her!!

  • The story of my life. Just switch the mom and dad parts.

  • wow. the pianist is brilliant.

  • awsome voice! great artist!

  • Great piano solo ruined by Pink's filthy whoredoms on stage.

  • Amo esta canción

    

  • unbelievable, better live than on cd..... great, great song, an evergreen, you can listen to years!!!!

  • good song 

  • I LOVE the pianist!

  • Ah, this speaks to me so much. Surgeries, facial scars, divorce when I was five, a now absentee father who doesn't approve no matter what I do, and an extended family that can't seem to give two shits. My mom is my rock but this still speaks so deep to me. I played this to death in High School.

  • I hated my childhood. If that was one thing in my life i could erase i would definately do it..

    id never wanna go back to that. and i have many issues in my adult life....

  • "Remember that the night you left....you took my shining star" :'(

  • You're my hero P!KN! I love you!

  • the best....

  • she's perfect.

  • So Real.....

  • foarte frumos si real...

  • love it.<3

  • can we be a family?

  • Comment removed

  • we dont even have a family portrait..

  • Daddy don`t leave, daddy don`t leave! Can repeat it many times... It so hurts! I lost my farther recently...No, no cry. Enough. And PINK is CREAT!!! As always.

  • @9082809032 I am sorry for your lost. I lost my father 25 years ago and it still hurts. But I believe that if you had a father who loved you, his love will stay with you forever and help you through difficult moments. May be he is somwhere watching over you, who knows.

  • @nesiotivaj Thank you very much for your kindness.! I appreciate your warm words. And I`m sorry that it touched your memory.

  • @9082809032 Don't be sorry, I think of my father almost every day. And I believe that I was blessed with so much love and tenderness. Yes, it hurts I lost him so soon, but can you imagine how many people never had the blessing of having a father or mother who really loved them and cared for them... And our fathers may be gone from this world, but they will always stay in our hearts, in our thoughts, in the way we bring our own children. In a way they are always with us.

  • @nesiotivaj It is as you are taking my hurt away. Thank you a lot and best wishes! :)

  • @9082809032 Best wishes to you to! Be strong and don't  forget we are the richest people in the world for having recieved so much love from our fathers :) Nobody can take this away from us.

  • @nesiotivaj Yeah, that`s right.:)))

  • Daddy please don't leave me!!! no no no no!! no no no!! Daddy don't leave, don't turn around me.... Remember that the night you left... U took my shinning star.... I ll be nicer, I ll be so much better....

  • so emotional... :'(

  • awesome

  • the piano solo in the beginning is GREAT, but so wrong for this song. imo.

  • its so amazing..

  • literally , i cant even describe how i feel when i listen to this live

    its like NSU9329IPDWMLDMWNHKDHKDLK

    you can hear and feel the emotional , blenehw9oasjma

  • here we can see, that she can make nice song :)

  • you took my shining star

  • cool song pink rulz

  • p!nk is one of the only singers who doesn't do anything to her voice. respect!

  • love dis song

  • 63 dislikes?why?

    

  • @aidakiful F*** them

  • Amazing !

  • Comment removed

  • This is the story of my life... less hard, but still a part of my story.

  • @LamyaKR Same for me. I'm sad for everyone who has suffered from a dysfunctional family. don't let it ruin your future. start a new family if you can. don't let your kids to find silly ways to get rid of the pain. start all over again.

  • cry my eyes out:(

  • `Just like my story went... I love the women with power ! PINK (L)

  • <3 <3 <3

  • I just love this song..! every day i listen this song! is amazing!

  • I was in Drama in 6th grade and as a small project, we had to lip sync a song in front of the whole class. This was the song I chose. I was made fun of by everyone when it was my turn. I never knew why they were so cruel. Maybe they didn't know what it was like to grow up in a broken family.

  • She is so wonderful , I love her songs so much <3

  • i love the intro, its awesome :)

  • @Hawaii159357 - best intro ever! :D

  • first heard this song when I was 12. and I still remember each word.

  • Lady gaga+beyonce+britney = % 1 of PİNK

  • I love this woman. Best Singer in the world, most beautiful person in the earth.

  • sånn en dame skal være, :-)

  • i could just read the lyrics ... they mean soo much <3 love this gall soo much mich love :* <3 xxx

  • best performancr ever!! love pink this song talks bout everything im going thru..

    true inspiration too anyone who has went this

  • everything about this performance is magnificent. from the piano-improv to the singing!<3!

  • Comment removed

  • I Can Relate To This Sonq 100% And I Knw How She Felt.! Idk Y But This Sonq Jus Getz To Me Every Time I Hear It.!

  • This song melts me!

  • She's like incredible!! I LOVE YOU PINK!

  • A Real ARTIST !!! NO PLAYBACK LIKE THE OTHER!!! <3 <3 <3

  • Actually I don't even have FAMILY PORTRAIT :(

  • @usermie Makes 2 of us

  • 我非常喜欢。

  • hate and love this song at the same tme. love, because of the meaning, hate because of the meaning to me

  • Goose bumps! ;p PINK RULZ!

  • UGH, So mad that I saw this concert when I was in the 4th grade. And now I cant Remember ANYTHING about this concert.

  • She's just so fucking good. Honestly, if half the singers today on iTunes top 100 had Pink's talent, I would be a happy, happy person.

  • P1nK i§ N0T a Typ1cAL B1tch L1K3 th3 r3st, bUt sh3 1s s3xy.

  • Comment removed

  • This song relate to my family :( can't stop crying when listen to this song. I just want some happiness in my family

  • @usermie te la auguro con tutto il cuore.. davvero..

  • what a wonderful pianist! :D

  • such a great live performance <3

  • it makes me cry :(

  • Thank you very much P!NK =)

  • SHE SOUNDS EVEN MORE AMAZING LIVE THAN ON A CD !!!!!!!! LOVE THIS WOMAN

  • She has a gift.

    And she's giving it to us.

  • K thx

  • шикарное исполнение. мне даже больше оригинала понравилось. Пианист просто красавец. Подскажите где нибудь можно эту версию мп3 найти?

  • @JoramJozef it is it is on vevo

  • I like this video bud i hate that i cant find the official music video off this song

  • Pink great! We love here in russia

  • I wish this Pennsylvanian was a CALIFORNIAN

  • song was back in 2007 yet people in 2011 seem to still love it and listen to it=)

  • Comment removed

  • @MrsArielRane um no. The song was released in 2002 . This concert was in 2006 and the video was uploaded to youtube in 2007.

  • SHES SO AMAZING...I LOVE HER SONGS CUZ THEY HELP A lot of people., specially family portrait and fuckin perfect. LIKE IF U LOVE P!NK <3

  • i <3 you P!nk you help me get over a depression with you melody :X:*:*

  • @bbphnix thanks xxxxx

  • This song is amazing and hits home real hard. First time I heard it I cried so hard. And still every time I hear it it brings tears to my eyes because its my family. What an artist

  • Pink is amazing....her songs hit all of us in one way or another. I can remember my mother was going to leave my dad and she was packing our clothes and I was crying and unpacking them. So horrible for a young child. They made up and stayed devoted to each other until they passed. I cried and cried when I heard this for the first time. She tells stories with so much emotion and amazing talent.

  • this practicly describes my family xx

  • @shawtylillie u serios?

    man.... sorry to read that; hope things work out

  • das lied ist toll :D aber gibt es das auf you tube auch ganz normal...also nicht als karaoke oder live???

  • truly remarkable woman

  • now dont get me wrong i luv christina aguilera but y do peolple compare her 2 christina so what pink doesnt have the same voice but she sings amazingly and doesnt have 2 use auto tune so i still love christina tho they r my favorite singers but y compare them thumbs up if u agree

  • No me canso de ver este video!!! Me encanta!!!

  • i love this song so much, pink is a truely talented and passionate singer

  • this live version by far is the best quality

  • The piano man! Soul ! Amazing!

  • I love her voice!

  • Love this video

  • she's actually the most amazing thingggg!

  • PERFECT!!!

  • j'aime bien pink une vrai!!!!!!!!!

  • i love u P!nk, u are my idol !

  • how can you dislike this i like this sooo much<3

  • i love this song!! its so cool to sing it.

  • i love the piano in the beginning ! AND OFCOURSE A GREAT SONG !

  • Grande performance, grandi emozioni, grazie

  • All I know is that 54 people are complete DUMBASS idiots.

  • thanks :(

  • Love love love love this song..... Best ever!!!

  • Pink is so amazing and blessed. She's "strumming my pain with her fingers, singing my life with her words." Go Pink

  • nn commento.....io ascolto.....faccio solo questo........

  • this version makes me bawl out my eyes like crazy. times like these I thank god for pink <3

  • It's verygood, but I prefer this version iFcsuh8G6xE

  • she iz so fuken sexi!!!! :)

  • this song is amazing

  • Can you imagine how much more grand this intro would have been had it been on an actual piano?!! It's still awesome but just imagine the quality and tone that a baby grand piano or full size would have given it?!! IMO

  • pink's a mama now. wait til she pisses off her new daughter. what goes around, comes around.

  • @flyingfishsurf

    I don't argue with people on YouTube, so all I'm going to say is piss off.

  • WOW!!!!

  • WOW!!!!!!

  • Hey, see that red on bar with all the green on it?

    Me neither, because PINK IS TOO GOOD TO BE DISLIKED!

  • Pink is amazing 

  • Pik is the best

  • her lyrics are so beautiful :'( x

  • "I don't want love to destroy me like it has my family...." -/3

  • I LOVE PINK<3 the best female singer in the world and her lyrics are the meaning of life.

  • i love p!nk <3

  • lionel richie can play piano?

  • best singer ever <3

  • @jockaill no lol, I'm un great fan of Pink, but the best singer is Michael Jackson =) and Pink, egality <3

  • increible !!!!

  • "I don’t want love to destroy me like it has done my family..."

  • просто шедеврально!!!! обожаю Pink? Россия с тобой дорогая наша!!!

  • last weej i herd this song and cryed cuz my mom was out the house... my dad kiked her put and 2 days ago he came to her and said hes sorry..

    now i hear this song just becouse its so amazing and pink went through as much as i did..

  • never mind about that last comment

  • she chaged dad to god

  • @just6breathe

    this i a true story whats happend to pink.

    greetings from holland

  • she's so amazing.....you can tell she's actually feeling what she's singing love it!

  • couldn't get any better..

  • OMG, amazing pianoplayer'' :o